News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wiki inventor Ward Cunningham develops federated wiki by nicholassmith on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @10:34AM (#4199551)
I think this could lead to a lot of interesting possibilities but I'll focus on one.

Lets say you're on Wikipedia and for example want to know about the assassination of J.F.K, the Wiki article contains most of the stock facts and so on, but lets say you want to know about the really crazy and out there conspiracy theories of Hoover and aliens and so on, a federated system would allow people to set their own page up and you can continue through to it. The sort of content that sends most Wikipedia moderators into catatonic seizures indexed and available.

There's plenty of other uses out there, I just think it's an interesting point that it'll allow anyone with enough time on their hands to create an archive of what they think is relevant as a counterpoint to what someone else thinks is relevant. Don't like the standard descriptor? Normally you'd have to fit a wiki mod, fork it off and have it as a counter point.

Re:Wiki inventor Ward Cunningham develops federated wiki by tokenadult on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @11:33AM (#4199747)
Lets say you're on Wikipedia and . . . you want to know about the really crazy

I am a Wikipedian. I edit sporadically these days, after being really active when I first started editing. Before I began editing, I read whole books about the history of Wikipedia and its internal processes. Because of the anarchy of how Wikipedia started out, with the typical Wikipedian having NIL research and editing experience (not even the research and editing experience implied by getting an undergraduate degree at a research university), you can find plenty of crazy on Wikipedia already.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Lamest_edit_wars

And of course blatantly false assertions about the assassination of President John F. Kennedy have already stood on Wikipedia for a long time.

http://www.nytimes.com/2005/12/04/weekinreview/04seelye.html...

http://www.usatoday.com/tech/news/2005-12-11-wikipedia-apolo...

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia_biography_controversy...

The Deletionpedia experiment,

http://deletionpedia.dbatley.com/w/index.php?title=Main_Page

which seems to have fizzled out, was an archive of pages deleted from Wikipedia, in an attempt to make volunteer Wikipedia editors ("Wikipedians") more accountable for deleting articles. The result of the Deletionpedia experiment was to show that most content that is deleted from Wikipedia well deserves to be deleted, and probably doesn't serve any reader in any useful way anywhere on the Internet.

The Internet is already flooded with counterpoints. It's bad enough that in important subjects (for example, medical research) most of the best published literature is not available on the Internet (it is still behind publisher paywalls), while a lot of scam artists flood the Internet with websites that exist only to sell something that cheats consumers.

I do look forward to seeing how Ward Cunningham's experiment develops. MeatballWiki introduced some thoughtful discussion of online communities to the broader online world,

http://meatballwiki.org/wiki/OnlineCommunity

and that was enabled by the innovation of wiki sites, that any user could edit a webpage already posted on the site. There is a place for wikis, and some wikis are very helpful,

http://www.artofproblemsolving.com/Wiki/index.php/Main_Page

but the last thing the world needs is more content forks for crazy points of view that get edited off of Wikipedia.

Re:Wiki inventor Ward Cunningham develops federated wiki by morsch on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @08:02PM (#4201215)
I don't think any of what you say particularly supports your final point. The internet is flooded in counterpoints, but few of them are on Wikipedia, or in Wikis. And none of them are as visible as Wikipedia's take on things. I think people are increasingly relying on Wikipedia to provide The Truth(tm) -- mostly because it's gotten so damn good at delivering it, the JFK examples notwithstanding.

Counterpoints seem to survive in ideological communities that have their own closed world view and their own knowledge databases which are considered to be definitive.

Re:Wiki inventor Ward Cunningham develops federated wiki by nfg on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @04:43PM (#4200792)
I've always found you can learn a surprising amount about a subject by reading it's wikipedia 'Talk' page.
Re:Wiki inventor Ward Cunningham develops federated wiki by derleth on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @11:11AM (#4199681)
> The sort of content that sends most Wikipedia moderators into catatonic seizures indexed and available.

The reason it is anathema to the Wikipedia concept is because Wikipedia wants its name on good content, not Alex Jones JOOZ-DID-IT (Oh, and Aliens-Big-Pharma-Bilderberger-USPS-Did-9/11 Too) bullshit, unless such bullshit is clearly marked as coming from a specific minority viewpoint.

I think that's a great reason to keep the crap on the current version of Wikipedia to a minimum: The world is confusing, especially when there are people like Alex Jones out there trying to make it more confusing to sell more videos. Having something where you have a good chance of getting the Sane People Version of controversial (or only-controversial-because-of-the-crazies) topics is invaluable if you want somewhere to start. Especially if it's a topic that books aren't really written about, like specific health scams.

So the Federated Wiki universe will need some way to mark specific forks of articles as being from a given group of people, so people aren't mislead into thinking that the sane editors approve of the version of reality Alex Jones is selling the gullible.

Re:Wiki inventor Ward Cunningham develops federated wiki by nicholassmith on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @11:24AM (#4199726)
Exactly, the mods are there to keep the crazy out but occasionally you need to reference some of the more outlandish things for various reasons and letting people for things off into tinfoilhatswiki.net would be good for the mods sanity and useful for people who need to reference the over the top stuff. Not sure how the link direction would work, but I'm sure there's a way.
Re:Wiki inventor Ward Cunningham develops federated wiki by klint on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @12:33PM (#4199968)
I agree that some way to remove links to forks that are spam or that you find reprehensible is a good idea, but the whole point of forking instead of editing is that the forks aren't approved.

As I said elsewhere, I (nor the people I quoted) meant to represent this as an alternative to Wikipedia itself. I'd see it more as some that a wiki farm like Wikia could use to allow editors to put more of their own perspective into an article (that's my opinion, not the Smallest Federated Wiki developers' opinion).

Re:Wiki inventor Ward Cunningham develops federated wiki by derleth on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @12:41PM (#4199996)
> the forks aren't approved.

I get this. My whole point is that it needs to be very obvious where a fork comes from and what else the people responsible for it are responsible for.