And articles like this have been popping up for years (I think about the exact same two students even), and each time I have to decide whether to downplay the scale of their achievement so high school students don't lose hope about achieving something similar, or praise them with the qualifier for high school students because they couldn't be expected to have enough mathematical background to push the boundaries of one of the oldest and most extensively researched parts of modern mathematics.
I can't help but feel that each additional article is just further entrenching the stereotype that you're either a genius at mathematics or not, and is demotivating the students in question, because how on earth are they ever going to top this?
it's cyclotopic, a term they coined. I suggest the intro section juxtaposing trigonometry vs 'circular' approaches might best be read as guidance as to how interested high school students (their past selves?) might think about the topic rather than a necessary preface for their paper.
I also very much enjoyed: "In this section, we verify that our proofs aren’t circular."
Didn't have the motivation? So what? They did.
The things they did seem obvious? Yes, I bet they do in hindsight. Touch screens on cell phones seem obvious today too.
I don't try to discredit this stuff, and probably couldn't come up with similar proof myself since I'm not that interested in mathematics in general, but I am personally getting kinda tired of all these "child discovers x" stories where x turns out to either be something this is already well known or it turns out that they've just restated something that was well known in a somewhat trivial way. I'm not saying that's what happened in this case, but it is what happens in most of these sorts of stories that get published anytime it's a slow news day.
If anything, "trigonometric" is the word they should have avoided, since, even though the word is etymologocally closely associated with triangles as they said, it is also commonly used to refer to exactly the thing they are trying to avoid -- dependency on the Pythagorian theorem, which was the spource of all the confusion and fuss and terrible media reporting when they first published their proof and referred to an ill-defined statement in a 100 year old textbook.
There are hundreds of old proofs of Pythagorean Theorem. I'm sure you can find one that satisfies you. For those of us who enjoy new ideas that push back the intellectual frontier, this paper is very nice.
However, I just cannot get excited about an article with proofs that:
(1) give a different name for methods that use sin(90)=1 vs only working with sine of an acute angle ("cyclometric" vs "trigonometric", ugh)
(2) use "high-powered" methods like convergence of infinite geometric series to prove the Pythagorean theorem
(3) apply the law of sines several times to produce the Pythagorean theorem
I just couldn't give it a chance. Give me a good old fashioned proof by a dissection diagram any day.