News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New iMac with M4 by simonw on Monday October 28, 2024 @12:16PM (#41972805)
Yeah, that's my biggest complaint with iMacs: I want to be 100% certain I can repurpose them as monitors later in their lives.

I have a ten year old iMac at the moment that would make an amazing second monitor... but it doesn't quite have the features I need to use it like that. An HDMI input would be great.

Re:New iMac with M4 by lisper on Monday October 28, 2024 @12:24PM (#41972934)
> An HDMI input would be great.

There is a reason that is difficult to do: the licensing terms for HDMI require manufacturers to put DRM in place to make it impossible (or at least not straightforward) to record from an HDMI source. It's nearly impossible to meet that requirement on a computer.

Re:New iMac with M4 by kmeisthax on Monday October 28, 2024 @03:20PM (#41974993)
You're thinking of HDCP, not HDMI. HDMI recorders exist (Elgato built an entire brand off selling them for console game streaming) but they are not allowed to speak HDCP because gestures vaguely at DMCA 1201.

In the specific case of the iMac:

- USB-C video outputs are all either DisplayPort[0]. HDMI Forum was promoting an HDMI USB-C altmode but it was never implemented. USB-C HDMI adapters are all DisplayPort adapters that additionally tunnel DVI traffic (because HDMI 1.x is actually single-link DVI with a funny connector and extra bits).

- Apple used to support Target Display Mode for video input until the Retina iMac a decade ago. They dropped Target Display Mode because their 5K display panels were using eight lanes of DisplayPort, a configuration that doesn't exist[1] outside of Apple's custom display controllers. Every other 5K display (and even some 4K ones) were instead using multiple cables, with some extra (poorly-supported) metadata to tell the graphics card to treat both halves of the display as one.

Why Apple hasn't brought TDM back now that we have enough bandwidth for 4.5K over standard cables is beyond me.

[0] Or MyDP, aka "the funny Nintendo Switch altmode"

[1] Think of it like a "32-lane PCIe port". It's technically possible but no host or device silicon supports a link that wide.

Re:New iMac with M4 by lisper on Monday October 28, 2024 @03:30PM (#41975132)
Yes, that's right. Thanks for pointing that out.

https://www.makeuseof.com/hdcp-vs-hdmi-whats-the-difference/

Re:New iMac with M4 by wtallis on Monday October 28, 2024 @10:12PM (#41978685)
> USB-C HDMI adapters are all DisplayPort adapters that additionally tunnel DVI traffic

Not tunnel, convert: these are active adapters that take in a DisplayPort signal from the computer and re-encode it as a DVI/HDMI output signal. The computer doesn't need to know or care that there's HDMI happening downstream, because it's still just outputting DisplayPort signal. It's not like Thunderbolt where DisplayPort traffic is tunneled inside a different signalling mode that the host machine supports.

This is why USB-C to HDMI adapters are unidirectional (at least, all the mainstream commodity ones). You'd need a different converter chip to do the conversion in the other direction.

Re:New iMac with M4 by buccal on Monday October 28, 2024 @12:33PM (#41973068)
Re:New iMac with M4 by lisper on Monday October 28, 2024 @12:37PM (#41973119)
It's not impossible, but it has to be a completely separate signal chain that bypasses the PC. (Well, OK, it's theoretically possible to do it other ways, but it would be really hard.)
Re:New iMac with M4 by tcoff91 on Monday October 28, 2024 @12:27PM (#41972999)
DisplayPort doesn't have that same restriction, right?
Re:New iMac with M4 by lisper on Monday October 28, 2024 @12:40PM (#41973161)
I don't know, but probably not. It's a legal requirement for HDMI, not a technical one. It's actually not hard to build an HDMI recorder, you just can't legally sell one. But bootleg recorders are easy to find.
Re:New iMac with M4 by sleepybrett on Monday October 28, 2024 @12:58PM (#41973388)
They could design it in such a way that the hdmi input port bypasses the whole 'computer' and goes straight into the display board. If it's plugged in the 'computer' could either not boot or just run headless, i'd prefer the former (just to save on energy costs).
Re:New iMac with M4 by fwip on Monday October 28, 2024 @12:39PM (#41973151)
Couldn't you "just" wire the HDMI port to the panel control logic? That is, the HDMI-in doesn't connect to the computer part of the iMac, just to the display circuitry.

Edit: nevermind, I see you addressed this in another comment.

Re:New iMac with M4 by hultner on Monday October 28, 2024 @12:34PM (#41973084)
You probably know this but it’s possible to buy a controller card for the panel on Ali Express and retro-fit into the case and use as a monitor if you are ready to retire the computer itself.

I’m contemplating doing this myself at some point but my maxed out 2019 iMac upgraded to 128GB ram and extra SSD is still plenty fast for me, actually feels subjectively quicker than my M2 Pro MacBook Pro with significantly less ram feel. I was a bit surprised as I had read all the hype of the responsiveness of the Apple M-machines.

Re:New iMac with M4 by eastbound on Monday October 28, 2024 @02:00PM (#41974110)
If they could be used as monitors, then my iMac 2018 would still be worth 1700€ (the price of the Apple monitor)!

Instead, the 2018 iMac is incredibly slow, and can be thrown away.