Vision doesn't happen in a vacuum. It happens within the wider cultural context of the organisation. A technical lead, a project lead, a manager - they are all affected by the environment they are in. If you spend all your time fighting politics and trying to shore up demoralised engineers, you are not going to waste your time dreaming about ponies and rainbows.
If you want an analogy, you can take the world's greatest general, but if you drop him in a WW-I trench, he is just cannon fodder.
I think that's a fair point. Good reply.
The article started with stack ranking, but clearly there were much bigger issues looming.
>“He didn’t like the user interface, because it didn’t look like Windows,” a programmer involved in the project recalls... “Windows was the god—everything had to work with Windows,” Stone tells Eichenwald. “Ideas about mobile computing with a user experience that was cleaner than with a P.C. were deemed unimportant by a few powerful people in that division, and they managed to kill the effort.”
They could have been years ahead on phones, tablets, and e-readers. But instead they had a culture that tried to shoehorn a standard Windows experience into every device (I imagine for marketing reasons). They are only now getting over it a decade later, though it's probably more accurate to say they have the same philosophy but in reverse: shoehorn a mobile experience into the desktop in Windows 8.
What difference does it make if you have the greatest engineers in the world but management is blocking them at every turn?
I actually laughed out loud when I read that--it's true!
That statement is false in many ways. As a developer, you keep seeing substandard products from Microsoft. Have you looked at the architecture of SharePoint? compare SqlServer CE to SQLite, not to mention the horrible tutorials and source code which Microsoft keeps putting out.
C#/.NET is an excellent platform/language but Microsoft keeps putting out horrible sub standard code/tutorials
My impression of Microsoft (entirely from the outside) is that they have this same problem.
Engineers always think that companies are engineering driven, when in fact mostly they are sales driven. If SharePoint sells well, then its not substandard, even if you don't like its architecture.
But really? Is that why Microsoft has fallen by the wayside (realtively)? Because they don't have good enough engineers?
I disagree. I think they have a wealth of talented engineers.
What they need(ed) are people with vision, a deep understanding of the future of consumer electronics and computing, and a way to execute on that vision. They need to deliver short, medium and long-term products that feed their vision. They need to show people the future of the industry instead of lagging behind it.
Engineering is a crucial component in that, but it's only part of the story IMHO.