Re:With Kickstarter, Who Needs the National Endowment for th...
by ef4 on Tuesday July 03, 2012 @12:11PM
(#4194692)
Your distinction is an important one, but I think it amounts to the same effect in the end.
Back then, you couldn't make money by selling many copies of your art because making copies was too difficult.
Now, you can't make money by selling copies of your art because making copies is too easy.
But in both cases, the effect on the artist is the same: he cannot sell many copies, so he must find other ways. Like concerts and patronage.
Re:With Kickstarter, Who Needs the National Endowment for th...
by jonhendry on Tuesday July 03, 2012 @01:03PM
(#4194997)
Cervantes had to deal with a ripoff of Don Quixote while he was writing the second part of Don Quixote, after publishing part I. It even makes up part of the plot of part II.
Another author published what they claimed to be part II.
It's a different form of IP infringement than simple unauthorized duplication of a work, but it's been around for a long time.
If you wanted to hear a Beethoven symphony, you had to find an orchestra that was playing, and travel to see it.
Even duplicating printed work was much more work, since the type would have to be reset by hand.
While the funding model was certainly different, the era was much more different. Using the romantic era or earlier as proof that (in modern society) culture could flourish without copyright is ludicrous.