Seems right.
If you export/download games from lichess, they use the .pgn (Portable Game Notation) format, which is a standard plain-text format circa 1993, used by pretty much everyone for describing a chess game.
Lichess follows the specification to the letter, and as it only technically allows one-second accuracy, lichess only record moves with one-second accuracy. It seems insane, but that's how they do it.
Chess.com also exports PGN files, but they add a decimal place, allowing subsecond accuracy. No one has a problem with this. There is no software which cannot handle this. But Lichess refuses to "break" the spec.
lichess PGN export example:
> 1. d3 { [%eval -0.15] [%clk 0:01:00] } 1... g6 { [%eval 0.04] [%clk 0:01:00] }
Chess.com PGN export example:
> 1. d4 {[%clk 0:02:58.6]} 1... b6 {[%clk 0:02:59.2]}
According to this blog post, this doesn't appear to be the case since at least 2017:
https://lichess.org/@/lichess/blog/a-better-game-clock-histo...
"Move times are now stored and displayed with a precision of one tenth of a second. The precision even goes up to one hundredth of a second, for positions where the player had less than 10 seconds left on their clock."
TBH this is what I expected for all online chess. How else to reconcile the two players' differing clocks and also prevent client-side cheating?
I do recognize that fps games utilize predictive algorithms and planning to estimate future player positions but still, turn based networking with 100ms accuracy should be a solved problem
TCP, although I like to imagine FPS games where shooting someone sends "DELETE /players/n00b HTTP/1.1" to the server.
Yes, it's easy to cheat with this, but it's very easy to cheat with chess anyway.
You can read about what became timeseal here. https://eprint.iacr.org/2004/203.pdf
on lichess it does have an impact. lichess has a thing they call lag compensation where the server can add time to a player's clock after the server receives their move.
The goal is to make it fair for someone with high lag playing someone with low lag.
I don't know the exact cheating method used. I'll have a guess, though. What if someone spent a few seconds looking at the board before making their move, and then adding (edit: oops, subtracting) a few seconds to their clock in their response packet. The server would see the client made their move instantly based on the time in the response packet, but it took a few seconds for the server to receive the packet. i.e. lag. So it might add time to compensate for the perceived lag.
Lag compensation cheating is a frequent topic on the lichess forums.
Is there a point in preventing cheating, really? I can just make a bot...
Carlsen, Nakamura and chess.com itself have participated in the Niemann witch hunt. No evidence of over-the-board cheating has ever been provided.
None of the accusers is banned.
Kramnik did the same as they did (by indeed going too far).
It is actually perfectly fine to not ban people doing something wrong one or two times while banning people doing that exact thing for fifth time.
The former is always excused, presumably because people's ancient group instincts kick in. The latter is a single heretic that must be destroyed.
The group does much more damage than the individual. Everyone already thought that Kramnik's pseudo-mathematical evidence was garbage, so why the ban? The answer is that he mentioned well connected people like Nakamura, so the rogue nail needed to be hammered in.
Groups are never punished, and 95% of Internet commenters always excuse the group.
Niemann was already an admitted cheater who had been previously sanctioned for his activities. Carlsen’s accusations against him may have been unfounded for the specific game in question but Niemann’s reputation was already blemished. Niemann’s lawsuit was inexcusable though, as it was essentially a SLAPP [1] designed to hinder everyone’s efforts to get cheating out of chess. Thankfully the lawsuit was unsuccessful and Niemann continues to play chess.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strategic_lawsuit_against_publ...
chess.com confirmed the issue.
It's super annoying and the reason I only play blitz+ on chesscom.
[1]https://www.chess.com/forum/view/help-support/mate-in-one-qu...
This is one of the many, many things but imo it's the most telling. They can't even add a clock counting down the 6 minutes to their web client.
>>I think I heard a streamer say it was for kicking out the cheaters
I can't see how it can possibly help. Maybe he meant something else?
Regardless, one thing I find maddening about chess.com is the time architecture of the game. I haven't seen the underlying code, but it feels like the SERVER is tracking the time. This completely neglects transport time & latency meaning that 1s to move isn't really a second. Playing on the mobile client is an exercise in frustration if you are playing timed games and down to the wire. Even when you aren't, your clock will jump on normal moves and it is most obvious during the opening.
This could also be due to general poor network code as well. The number of errors I get during puzzles is also frustrating. Do they really not retry a send automatically?? <breath>
Chess.com has the brand and the names... but dang, the tech feels SO rough to me.