News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Forest Service Is Losing 2,400 Jobs–Including Most of... by ninetyninenine on Tuesday October 22, 2024 @09:13PM (#41920587)
People who don't hike or use nature recreationally tend to view it as completely useless.

They do have a bit of a point. The asset isn't really being maintained. It's being maintained for human use as recreation. Overall you don't need to really maintain wilderness to preserve it. Overall you just leave it untouched.

You would actually do a better job if you locked down the entire area and just spent the money on keeping everyone out as my own self fish usage of nature as recreation harms it more then it helps it.

Re:The Forest Service Is Losing 2,400 Jobs–Including Most of... by whatshisface on Tuesday October 22, 2024 @09:40PM (#41920802)
>You would actually do a better job if you locked down the entire area and just spent the money on keeping everyone out as my own self fish usage of nature as recreation harms it more then it helps it.

That would work until a mining company wanted to extract oxygen from Yellowstone Quartz and met with zero public opposition to making use of "empty land."

Re:The Forest Service Is Losing 2,400 Jobs–Including Most of... by ninetyninenine on Wednesday October 23, 2024 @02:23AM (#41922353)
oh good point. Public opposition is what stops it from happening not the word of law.
Re:The Forest Service Is Losing 2,400 Jobs–Including Most of... by exabrial on Tuesday October 22, 2024 @10:20PM (#41921111)
This is even more short term thinking and a bit of ignorance. Where do you think all of the ‘stuff’ around you came from? Everything starts as raw materials, most of them organic.

And besides how selfish would it be to preserve nothing for the future generations.

Re:The Forest Service Is Losing 2,400 Jobs–Including Most of... by ninetyninenine on Wednesday October 23, 2024 @02:20AM (#41922337)
I'm literally saying preserve it by keeping everyone out.
Re:The Forest Service Is Losing 2,400 Jobs–Including Most of... by amanaplanacanal on Wednesday October 23, 2024 @03:07AM (#41922589)
It's a political problem. If people can't actually use the wilderness, you will lose public support for keeping the wilderness. It will all end up being sold to the highest bidder and destroyed.
Re:The Forest Service Is Losing 2,400 Jobs–Including Most of... by exabrial on Wednesday October 23, 2024 @08:25AM (#41924296)
This is exact opposite of preservation, forests don’t preserve themselves since humans arrived! This line of thinking has lead to crazy intense wildfires. Even grasslands require regular maintenance.

Invasive species are the biggest problem. Fuel buildup is another. Ignoring the problem is the third.

Re:The Forest Service Is Losing 2,400 Jobs–Including Most of... by ninetyninenine on Wednesday October 23, 2024 @09:53AM (#41925073)
Your claims are inconsistent. First you say I’m selfish then I prove to you I’m not by emphasizing my original claim was anything but selfish.

Now your claim is forests don’t preserve themselves since humans arrived?

First off my solution is to reverse the arrival of humans. Second your claims are inconsistent as they’ve changed.

I don’t think you’re maintaining a clear and consistent thought process you’re just attacking me from every possible angle. We should be having a discussion here, don’t get defensive.

Re:The Forest Service Is Losing 2,400 Jobs–Including Most of... by jjulius on Wednesday October 23, 2024 @01:18AM (#41922048)