News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Captive Portal IPv6 Support by arjvik on Tuesday October 22, 2024 @08:53PM (#41920439)
As much as we need infrastructure to move us all the way to IPv6 (no more CGNAT please!), I'm not sure I want more captive portals in the world. I'd much rather an addition to the WiFi standard to support interactive login, though I suppose that would be hard pressed to come by now.
Re:Captive Portal IPv6 Support by zamadatix on Tuesday October 22, 2024 @10:20PM (#41921110)
Interactive auth sounds attractive at first but it's really the wrong place for an answer once you look at all of the ways captive portals are used (i.e. more than just "check this agreement box"). You really need the power of the browser to display a custom form behind the solution or you end up with n+1 solutions instead of replacing captive portals.

Something like a DHCP option or NDP option ends up being a lot more natural: "Hey, here's your IP along with the information needed to access the network" is already a function of that layer. Some devices (e.g. macOS/iOS/iPadOS, Windows, Android) take a similar approach in the reverse by probing for a specific test url. That's also a bit hacky and unreliable (e.g. it can falsely trigger) but some minor standardization of it to e.g. a well known DNS name could be another good option.

Re:Captive Portal IPv6 Support by 0xbadcafebee on Tuesday October 22, 2024 @11:30PM (#41921514)
A DHCP option would be the correct way to specify a captive portal on a LAN. We have DHCP options for tons of things: IP phones, TFTP servers, cable boxes. One more option for a captive portal authentication URL would properly inform clients that there is a captive portal and how to access it. (It being a URL means it can also specify the protocol, so you aren't even locked into web browsers)

My assumption is this wasn't adopted because operators want the option of placing the captive portal upstream of the local network DHCP server. DNS spoofing works great over multiple network hops, but DHCP doesn't. (I'm not sure if that's a valid argument, but I'm sure somebody insisted on it)

Re:Captive Portal IPv6 Support by gavinsyancey on Wednesday October 23, 2024 @01:58AM (#41922225)
There is a DHCP option for a captive portal URL. It isn't very well supported and nobody uses it.

https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/html/rfc7710

Re:Captive Portal IPv6 Support by gavinsyancey on Wednesday October 23, 2024 @02:29AM (#41922383)
Re:Captive Portal IPv6 Support by 0xbadcafebee on Wednesday October 23, 2024 @10:08AM (#41925205)
If they got the top 5 wifi router vendors to support it, for sure you'd see other clients support it too, because the whole point of captive portal support in browsers is to react to what those routers are doing for captive portaling.

Since those vendors largely use open source tools, if you patched open source DHCP servers with that option, it would get adopted quicker by them.

- KEA DHCPD supports it as option 114: https://gitlab.isc.org/isc-projects/kea/-/blob/master/src/li...

- ISC DHCPD is officially ended (whoa!), but it looks like it supports option 114: https://gitlab.isc.org/isc-projects/dhcp/-/blob/master/commo...

- Dnsmasq author says they added the option (https://www.mail-archive.com/[email protected]...) but I don't see it in their latest release

- Udhcpd doesn't seem to support it, so somebody could send them a patch, looks trivial to add

Re:Captive Portal IPv6 Support by willidiots on Tuesday October 22, 2024 @10:44PM (#41921254)
There already was! It was called Passpoint R2 Online Sign-Up, but it never got traction on the phone side of things, so it's now being deprecated by the Wi-Fi alliance.

It's really a business problem. IMO you shouldn't have to solve this just because you've gone indoors – you already pay a carrier for connectivity – but many carriers don't want to own that responsibility.

Re:Captive Portal IPv6 Support by coretx on Tuesday October 22, 2024 @09:41PM (#41920814)
CGNAT is ok for IPV4 because it provides us some level of protection against state ( sponsored ) actors.
Re:Captive Portal IPv6 Support by apearson on Tuesday October 22, 2024 @09:57PM (#41920935)
You’re going to have to explain that one.

I don’t see how CGNAT does anything but allow easier access to attacks (using private ip space outside of the local network)

Re:Captive Portal IPv6 Support by coretx on Tuesday October 22, 2024 @09:58PM (#41920946)
All the details can be found in the EUROPOL publications begging for it to be banned.
Re:Captive Portal IPv6 Support by zamadatix on Tuesday October 22, 2024 @10:10PM (#41921043)
IIRC there was some hullabaloo made with RIPE in ~2017. Half of it was "go to IPv6 and it isn't a problem" and the other half was "or also log the source ports so we can complete the identification through CG-NAT".

It's nearly 8 years later, we haven't moved to IPv6, and they stopped making noise so I'm left to assume they either got more source port logging or found some other method?

Re:Captive Portal IPv6 Support by sulandor on Wednesday October 23, 2024 @02:35AM (#41922416)
politics still clinging to the idea of identifying ppl by obvious traffic meta-data
Re:Captive Portal IPv6 Support by coretx on Tuesday October 29, 2024 @04:03PM (#41988712)
There is people using chef/kitchen knifes for murder too. That doesn't mean we should regulate them for army use and monitor all cooks. Yet this is what many but certainly not all decision makers are doing. Good, fundamental, stuff is happening too, such as RPKI for example. Some "politics" is definitely not happy about that, but its good for the internet.
Re:Captive Portal IPv6 Support by apearson on Tuesday October 22, 2024 @10:04PM (#41920996)
Ah, allows hiding behind a massively shared single address with less traceability.
Re:Captive Portal IPv6 Support by gruez on Tuesday October 22, 2024 @09:28PM (#41920724)
Is there even an alternative to captive portals?
Re:Captive Portal IPv6 Support by snvzz on Tuesday October 22, 2024 @09:33PM (#41920759)
Just give internet access directly.

Or do not offer internet access at all. People carry their own already-connected devices anyway.

Re:Captive Portal IPv6 Support by gruez on Tuesday October 22, 2024 @09:58PM (#41920957)
What if legal wants to show a TOS page, or you want finer grained authentication than a shared key?

>Or do not offer internet access at all. People carry their own already-connected devices anyway.

Travelers don't typically have gigabytes of bandwidth to spare. I for one like having unmetered internet access even when there's theoretically internet access available through roaming (absurdly expensive) or esims (expensive)

Re:Captive Portal IPv6 Support by snvzz on Tuesday October 22, 2024 @10:43PM (#41921250)
>What if legal wants to show a TOS page?

The reality is that nobody wants to bother with any of that.

Either just connect me to the internet without extra steps, or don't at all. Don't waste my time.

Re:Captive Portal IPv6 Support by gruez on Tuesday October 22, 2024 @11:01PM (#41921343)
>The reality is that nobody wants to bother with any of that.

I don't either, but for IT departments in large organizations, ignoring the legal department isn't an option.

Re:Captive Portal IPv6 Support by immibis on Wednesday October 23, 2024 @03:18AM (#41922642)
Gues they just won't provide access then. Oh, what's that? There's a reason they need to provide access? Well, too bad the IT standards people invented a way to make sure we didn't interfere!
Re:Captive Portal IPv6 Support by notpushkin on Tuesday October 22, 2024 @11:07PM (#41921377)
I appreciate the sentiment, but having a shitty Wi-Fi is better than none at all IMO.
Re:Captive Portal IPv6 Support by stephenr on Tuesday October 22, 2024 @10:51PM (#41921288)
> or you want finer grained authentication than a shared key?

Configure your access points to use RADIUS or SAML for auth?

Re:Captive Portal IPv6 Support by gruez on Tuesday October 22, 2024 @11:05PM (#41921363)
Is WPA enterprise authentication still a dumpster fire? Last time I set it up it was still a hassle because you had to import CAs and manually choose the authentication protocol. Definitely not a good experience for someone who's stopping by a cafe for 30min and wants wifi.
Re:Captive Portal IPv6 Support by stephenr on Tuesday October 22, 2024 @11:29PM (#41921505)
In your coffee shop-like scenario, what benefit does a captive portal on anonymous Wifi offer to either the customer or the coffee shop, over regular Wifi authentication, and a sign on the wall that says "wifi username/passowrd is..."

As for importing a private CA. Use a certificate trusted by a public CA and you won't have this problem?

Re:Captive Portal IPv6 Support by gruez on Tuesday October 22, 2024 @11:53PM (#41921653)
>In your coffee shop-like scenario, what benefit does a captive portal on anonymous Wifi offer to either the customer or the coffee shop, over regular Wifi authentication, and a sign on the wall that says "wifi username/passowrd is..."

From an access control perspective, it probably doesn't matter much for a coffee shop, but matters more for something for a hotel where you want to limit to certain guests only (eg. ones with room or loyalty program members)

From a legal perspective, having an interstitial might provide cover for when a baddie uses the connection to order drugs or whatever. IANAL and I'm not sure whether it's actually needed or not, but most companies rather not risk it. Moreover it's unlikely that no jurisdictions require it, so you'd still support for it.

>As for importing a private CA. Use a certificate trusted by a public CA and you won't have this problem?

No idea. Last time I had to use WPA enterprise, the organization providing the connection isn't exactly small and couldn't afford a certificate, but still required me to import a CA. That makes me think it might be an inherent issue with WPA enterprise.

Re:Captive Portal IPv6 Support by stephenr on Tuesday October 22, 2024 @11:59PM (#41921681)
> Legal cover for when a baddie uses the connection to order drugs or whatever.

.... Is this meant to be a joke?

> still required me to import a CA

It's reasonably likely that they wanted it to only work on known devices with their private CA cert installed; but either way, and regardless of the technology in question, I wouldn't suggest it's particularly meaningful to use one organisation's setup as the basis for how things inherently work.

Re:Captive Portal IPv6 Support by gruez on Wednesday October 23, 2024 @12:03AM (#41921697)
>.... Is this meant to be a joke?

Are you a lawyer? I wasn't making a definitive statement, but if you have stronger evidence to the contrary please present them rather than making shallow dismissals.

>It's reasonably likely that they wanted it to only work on known devices with their private CA cert installed

It's an organization where BYOD is very common.

Re:Captive Portal IPv6 Support by chikere232 on Wednesday October 23, 2024 @03:50AM (#41922797)
If someone makes you import a CA, you have to assume they intend to eavesdrop on ssl encrypted communications. Enterprise WPA doesn't require it.

The right flavour of incompetence might get you there without bad intentions but really if you give someone the capability of eavesdropping you have to behave as if they're intending to use it

Re:Captive Portal IPv6 Support by gruez on Wednesday October 23, 2024 @04:11AM (#41922908)
Doesn't seem like it. For instance the WPA enterprise setup dialog has a field specifically for a CA certificate[1]. Other OSes have something similar [2]. Presumably that's only used for WPA authentication purposes rather than being added as a sytem CA.

[1] https://askubuntu.com/questions/1317320/how-can-i-automatica...

[2] https://documentation.meraki.com/MR/Encryption_and_Authentic...

Re:Captive Portal IPv6 Support by leptons on Wednesday October 23, 2024 @01:25AM (#41922077)
Captive portals are used for many, many things that aren't just internet access gateways. Many IoT devices use them to enter wifi credentials so the device can connect to the wifi router. One of my projects is an IoT device with a custom web interface that can be used from a cellphone when there are no nearby wifi routers for the IoT device and phone to connect to - the phone connects directly to the IoT device and gets the custom device control interface.
Re:Captive Portal IPv6 Support by somerandomqaguy on Wednesday October 23, 2024 @01:36AM (#41922124)
16% of Canadians in 2022 didn't have a data plan on their phone, according to Statistics Canada. Roughly 6 million Canadians or so.

So not everyone. Actually a decent number of people that don't.

Re:Captive Portal IPv6 Support by sulandor on Wednesday October 23, 2024 @02:30AM (#41922388)
seems easy to confuse % of plans with % of ppl. probably a lot of obscure use-cases in there
Re:Captive Portal IPv6 Support by Gud on Wednesday October 23, 2024 @04:49AM (#41923129)
Hotels absolutely don’t want to provide open access to all for obvious reasons. Although I have a “global unlimited” business SIM, I find it rarely works all that great. Getting a local SIM is not always an option.
Re:Captive Portal IPv6 Support by stephenr on Tuesday October 22, 2024 @09:43PM (#41920831)
... use regular authenticated wifi?