News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The IPv6 Transition by Dylan16807 on Sunday October 20, 2024 @03:15AM (#41893541)
NAT is mostly okay, but carrier grade NAT where you can't forward a port causes real problems.

IPv4 exhaustion is a real problem, it's just not enough to motivate people much.

Re:The IPv6 Transition by saurik on Sunday October 20, 2024 @03:20AM (#41893570)
Have you tried using PCP to forward the port? I was under the (maybe-incorrect, and if so I would really like to learn) impression that most major CG-NAT setups supported it.
Re:The IPv6 Transition by Dylan16807 on Sunday October 20, 2024 @03:32AM (#41893628)
I suppose I can try that some time. I can find absolutely zero mentions of that for the ISP, just the option of buying a static IP.
Re:The IPv6 Transition by kortilla on Sunday October 20, 2024 @03:38PM (#41897924)
Nah, many carriers don’t support it. I’ve always had to resort to STUN
Re:The IPv6 Transition by matrix2003 on Monday October 21, 2024 @12:50AM (#41900773)
STUN also isn’t guaranteed if the router is strict. IPv6 removes a lot of these unknown and strange ways that IPv4 infrastructure can break things.
Re:The IPv6 Transition by kortilla on Thursday October 24, 2024 @12:35AM (#41931937)
Yep, my point was just that STUN works far more frequently than explicit port forwarding protocols. Part of the reason (for better or worse) is that most major console networks (Xbox live, PSN, etc) will grade your connection poorly if STUN doesn’t work. Customers who otherwise don’t know about networking do complain to ISPs about this sort of thing.
Re:The IPv6 Transition by orangeboats on Monday October 21, 2024 @06:06AM (#41902496)
PCP is not widely deployed in South East Asia at the very least. Relying on it is not feasible.
Re:The IPv6 Transition by kijin on Sunday October 20, 2024 @03:21AM (#41893584)
If it was a real problem, market pricing would reflect the increasing severity of that problem.

The truth is that people who care about port forwarding are such a small minority -- especially now that P2P file sharing has lost its hype -- that they don't make a visible dent in the rate of IPv4 exhaustion.

Re:The IPv6 Transition by Dylan16807 on Sunday October 20, 2024 @03:28AM (#41893614)
The market price is only something like 5 or 10 dollars a month, but anyone having to pay that to be accessible is an embarrassing failure of the system. It doesn't matter whether it's a big dent in the number of IPs or not.
Re:The IPv6 Transition by kijin on Sunday October 20, 2024 @03:42AM (#41893673)
There are billions of people out there who can access the internet, and make themselves accessible through the internet the way they want, just fine without a dedicated IP address.

Maybe you have a definition of "access" that is different from the usual one. That's fine, but let's be honest, it's not the usual definition.

Re:The IPv6 Transition by Dylan16807 on Sunday October 20, 2024 @02:32PM (#41897465)
Someone being able to connect to their device is the definition I use. What's your definition?

Being able to relay through a third party is a different thing.

Re:The IPv6 Transition by minitoar on Sunday October 20, 2024 @11:51PM (#41900525)
Most people are totally fine relaying everything through a third party. A vanishingly small number of email users host it themselves.
Re:The IPv6 Transition by IcePic on Monday October 21, 2024 @02:49AM (#41901361)
But is it "well off people not having a problem paying a buck or two directly or indirectly to an american corporation to be able to bounce traffic" which you refer to as "most people"? I can see how a few billion other people would have problems with that concept for many reasons apart from the obvious financial one.

And for everyone that does pay this "internet tax", it only strengthens the position of said corporations to be able to buy up even more of the available routable ips. It's not hard to see that the end result is very much not in the consumers favor, regardless of how unnecessary it feels for customers currently to have a real ip when all they want is kitten animations on social media.

Re:The IPv6 Transition by immibis on Monday October 21, 2024 @04:02AM (#41901756)
This is a problem.
Re:The IPv6 Transition by GoblinSlayer on Monday October 21, 2024 @07:25AM (#41902958)
But this third party isn't free service even if it runs on ip6.
Re:The IPv6 Transition by minitoar on Monday October 21, 2024 @11:59AM (#41905506)
What? I don’t write a check to Google to use their email. It’s free.
Re:The IPv6 Transition by tptacek on Sunday October 20, 2024 @07:09PM (#41899262)
Almost nobody (far, far less than 1% of users overall) do pay this; the system is in this regard smashingly successful by econometric standards.
Re:The IPv6 Transition by Dylan16807 on Sunday October 20, 2024 @10:53PM (#41900271)
The IP consolidation is reasonably successful, but it doesn't have to break port forwarding, that's laziness and negligence.
Re:The IPv6 Transition by AStonesThrow on Sunday October 20, 2024 @03:44AM (#41893682)
The truth is that major cloud providers such as Amazon AWS have begun to charge [more] for static, routed IPv4 addresses.

Last I checked (a few years ago, I suppose), AWS APIs were incapable of using IPv6 internally, so a VPC still needed to dual-stack it in order to use AWS cloud features. That may have changed by now.

Re:The IPv6 Transition by kijin on Sunday October 20, 2024 @04:07AM (#41893774)
IPv4 prices peaked during the Covid pandemic, presumably because of sudden high demand. Amazon took this as an opportunity to increase prices.

Now IPv4 prices are returning to pre-Covid long-term trends. But of course Amazon won't reflect that in their pricing table.

Re:The IPv6 Transition by throw0101c on Sunday October 20, 2024 @04:17PM (#41898189)
> Amazon took this as an opportunity to increase prices.

IPv4 prices peaked in early 2022; AWS started charging for public IPv4 in 2024 (announced in 2023):

* https://aws.amazon.com/blogs/aws/new-aws-public-ipv4-address...

If they had increased prices in 2022 (or at least announced in 2022), then I could see some kind of correlation, but give it was 1.5-2 years after, I doubt there is a connection.

Re:The IPv6 Transition by bluGill on Monday October 21, 2024 @06:33AM (#41902651)
i would expect aws needs a year or two from when they decide to charge for something new just to work out the details
Re:The IPv6 Transition by throw0101c on Monday October 21, 2024 @06:55AM (#41902788)
> i would expect aws needs a year or two from when they decide to charge for something new just to work out the details

The price had already dropped, and was continuing to fall, when they announced the change, so if rising acquisition cost was the primary reason for adding the IPv4 charge, it had already went away.

I think AWS has looked at a utilization graph and sees a time their current pool is get used up at current rates and doesn't want to go through the hassle of acquiring more IPv4 addresses, regardless of cost (even if it is "cheap").

I also think that they have statistic for their www.Amazon.com storefront, and maybe are seeing a good proportion from IPv6 and so figure that there's a 'critical mass' (especially mobile).

Re:The IPv6 Transition by bluGill on Monday October 21, 2024 @07:33AM (#41903004)
There is a lot of lag in decisions like this so price falling isn't enough to say anything.
Re:The IPv6 Transition by ta1243 on Monday October 21, 2024 @09:41AM (#41904078)
AWS is seeing growth rates reduce and needs to pump up their revenue.

They're moving onto the "squeeze" part of the cycle.

Re:The IPv6 Transition by thayne on Sunday October 20, 2024 @05:23PM (#41898591)
Yep, lots of AWS apis don't work over ipv6, and many require making requests outside the VPC, so you need to have at least one ipv4 address for a NAT.
Re:The IPv6 Transition by cyberax on Monday October 21, 2024 @01:05PM (#41906107)
You can use NAT64, it works with all the AWS services. Although it's pretty stupid that services like ECR don't have IPv6.
Re:The IPv6 Transition by thayne on Monday October 21, 2024 @02:18PM (#41906812)
NAT64 requires you to have a NAT with a public ipv4 address. Or possibly pay to use someone elses NAT.
Re:The IPv6 Transition by cyberax on Monday October 21, 2024 @02:47PM (#41907123)
AWS supports NAT64 automatically if you have an Internet gateway attached, you just need to set it up in the VPC settings.
Re:The IPv6 Transition by thayne on Monday October 21, 2024 @04:00PM (#41907924)
https://docs.aws.amazon.com/vpc/latest/userguide/nat-gateway...

Says you need to have an AWS NAT for that to work. And AFAIK, setting up a NAT requires an ipv4 elastic ip.

And it makes since that AWS would want customers to have their own IP for NAT64, so that if one customer does something to get the ip address blocklisted it doesn't impact other customers.

Re:The IPv6 Transition by cyberax on Monday October 21, 2024 @09:30PM (#41910308)
Yes, you're correct.

Though I don't think AWS cares too much about IP blocklist, you can always just get another elastic IP at any moment.

Re:The IPv6 Transition by Hamuko on Sunday October 20, 2024 @03:29AM (#41893621)
Doesn't CGNAT also mess up things like Nintendo Switch online multiplayer?
Re:The IPv6 Transition by electronbeam on Sunday October 20, 2024 @05:31PM (#41898649)
Nintendo should really enable IPv6 on the Switch to help with this
Re:The IPv6 Transition by pmarreck on Monday October 21, 2024 @08:21AM (#41903376)
The network experience on Nintendo devices always seemed janky and home-grown. I feel like they built everything from scratch at corp HQ complete with wonky edge cases.
Re:The IPv6 Transition by lucw on Sunday October 20, 2024 @10:50PM (#41900260)
In practice the tech giants such as Google, Apple and Microsoft will dictate adoption of technology. When Chrome starts mandating or heavily recommending IPv6, adoption will reach 99% overnight. That's what happened with https: https://www.znetlive.com/blog/google-chrome-68-mandates-http...
Re:The IPv6 Transition by pmarreck on Monday October 21, 2024 @08:17AM (#41903337)
One can only hope.

Either this or a "killer app" use-case that requires IPv6 will push it forward significantly, IMHO.

Re:The IPv6 Transition by immibis on Monday October 21, 2024 @09:03AM (#41903725)
Like high-quality video calling for free?

Companies will relay your video calls for free. For now. Basically undercutting. The only way to prevent undercutting is by the government regulation.

Re:The IPv6 Transition by efitz on Monday October 21, 2024 @05:33AM (#41902262)
Why was this downvoted? It’s exactly right.

The reason that IPv6 is so lightly used is that it’s cheaper to use IPv4 + workarounds.

I’m not saying this is a good thing or a bad thing, or making any value judgment about IPv4 vs IPv6.

People and businesses don’t spend money on technology upgrades where the benefit is not measurably better than what they already have.

This is just common sense; no one wants to throw away money.

If you want people to use IPv6, then IPv4 has to fail first. As long as people keep making it work then the benefits of changing will never outweigh the costs.

BTW this is exactly the same situation as clean energy vs fossil fuel, etc. In that situation governments are actively putting their thumb on the economic scales in all sorts of ways. Again, I’m not offering a value judgment, just an observation.

Re:The IPv6 Transition by pmarreck on Monday October 21, 2024 @08:18AM (#41903346)
> The reason that IPv6 is so lightly used is that it’s cheaper to use IPv4 + workarounds

Cheaper? Hetzner and other hosts give IPv6 addresses out for free and charge extra for IPv4 addresses.

Re:The IPv6 Transition by immibis on Monday October 21, 2024 @09:04AM (#41903736)
And if you want PI addresses, they exist for IPv6 only.
Re:The IPv6 Transition by efitz on Monday October 21, 2024 @04:57PM (#41908461)
Most people don’t need a public IPv4 address and can live with CGNAT.

For the relatively small number of people who do need public addresses, renting them from a cloud provider or buying blocks at auction are still economically viable, in comparison to the capital costs of upgrading everything that needs upgrading to support IPv6-only.

Re:The IPv6 Transition by James_K on Monday October 21, 2024 @07:26PM (#41909616)
This isn't necessarily true. The scarcity of IPv4 addresses could very well induce a lack of demand and decrease the price. You wouldn't dream of developing a technology that requires people to have an individual IP address, so you don't. This massively reduces the demand for v4 addresses. It's not as if there are users out there who will demand the features you can't implement, and it's not as if you could fund the entire IPv6 network by yourself to bring about those features. Then ISPs have no reason to support v6 because no customers demand it. Instead of increased price, the cost is paid through decreased service. Think of a congested road network. It could be well worth it to build some more roads and ease congestion, but if there is no one in the system willing to pay for it, everyone will suffer.
Re:The IPv6 Transition by arp242 on Sunday October 20, 2024 @08:16PM (#41899608)
The main problem I had when I was on CGNAT was not so much port forwarding (annoying, but solvable), but with being banned from all sorts of stuff. The address is shared with so many people and one person did something stupid or whatnot. Sometimes you don't even know if you're banned or not.

For better or worse, IP blocks are still very common. It's easy to complain about this, but there aren't really any good methods to deal with persistent abuse.

Re:The IPv6 Transition by GoblinSlayer on Monday October 21, 2024 @06:55AM (#41902787)
CGNAT is a small tor.
Re:The IPv6 Transition by Arnt on Tuesday October 22, 2024 @06:43AM (#41912999)
Ah… that makes it sound as if we've reached a phase where IPv6 has no significant problems and saves a little bother compared to IPv4. Switch to v6 ⇒ escape false alarms from tools like fail2ban.
Re:The IPv6 Transition by josephg on Monday October 21, 2024 @01:19AM (#41900893)
> IPv4 exhaustion is a real problem, it's just not enough to motivate people much.

Well, its only really a problem if you're poor. Rich people don't care - IPs are still cheap enough when you live in a wealthy country & have a decent job.

The people affected by IP address exhaustion are largely the exact set of people who can't do anything about it.

Re:The IPv6 Transition by nlitened on Monday October 21, 2024 @03:51AM (#41901711)
What country is that where poor people can’t afford an IP address? Is it a real place?
Re:The IPv6 Transition by josephg on Monday October 21, 2024 @05:07AM (#41902104)
From the article, IPv4 only has 3.03 billion unique, routable addresses. The world population is 8.2 billion. So there's only enough IPv4 addresses for 1 unique address per 3 people on the planet. But of course, in reality, huge swathes of the IP address range are held by big companies (like amazon), universities and the US military.

Its very common for whole streets or neighbourhoods to collectively share a single IPv4 address. Its required, as a result of simple math.

You'll even see this in some parts of the US and UK.

Re:The IPv6 Transition by otabdeveloper4 on Monday October 21, 2024 @08:45AM (#41903571)
In reality an IP address costs about $2 a month at market rates.
Re:The IPv6 Transition by ta1243 on Monday October 21, 2024 @09:39AM (#41904061)
Because of two technologies

1) CG-NAT

2) IPv6

You literally can not have one unique IPv4 address per mobile phone.

Re:The IPv6 Transition by josephg on Monday October 21, 2024 @09:38AM (#41904052)
So? Is your argument that it’s so cheap that everyone should get an IP? That would be mathematically impossible.

If more people wanted an IP, the price would just rise. The same percentage of people (less than 1/3) would have one. They would just pay more.

It’s like buying land in a city like SF. Demand can change the price, but the supply remains the same.

Re:The IPv6 Transition by otabdeveloper4 on Monday October 21, 2024 @10:10AM (#41904366)
The argument is that migrating to IPv6 isn't worth anyone's time. (Except for maybe CG-NAT operators.)
Re:The IPv6 Transition by Dylan16807 on Monday October 21, 2024 @02:17PM (#41906798)
The number of people behind CGNAT is huge and rising. It's collectively worth it. And really not that much effort. (If your internal business network is sufficiently entrenched you don't have to change it.)
Re:The IPv6 Transition by nlitened on Monday October 21, 2024 @10:57AM (#41904896)
What you're saying is similar to "there's limited amount of SWIFT codes", not enough for each person on earth, so each person cannot have their own bank to receive money transfers.

True, but each person does not need to have their own bank to send or receive money, they can have an account within a bank of their preference, and use that extra information to route money transfers precisely.

"But they can't route money directly" — most people will never need to.

Re:The IPv6 Transition by josephg on Monday October 21, 2024 @08:09PM (#41909878)
Yeah I hear the argument that CG-NAT is fine for most people. It’s true, but kinda sad. It means most people won’t be able to run home servers, or learn to be the server for a multiplayer video game, or all sorts of other things I took for granted when learning the craft. It kinda locks in, technically, the consumer and producer relationship between computers on the internet. And for no good technical reason - just a quirk of history. CGNAT is usable; but it’s sad.
Re:The IPv6 Transition by nlitened on Wednesday October 23, 2024 @02:06AM (#41922265)
I agree that it’s diverging from what was envisioned for the internet originally, so the thing doesn’t reach its technical potential.

On the other hand, I find it beautiful that network routing architecture and network security architecture naturally converged on NATs — I think because they are easier to understand for people, and more closely reflect what’s actually happening, without some hidden magic.

Re:The IPv6 Transition by selcuka on Monday October 21, 2024 @08:12PM (#41909895)
Remember rich people wants to sell stuff to poor people, so if it's a problem for poor people then it's also a problem for the rich.
Re:The IPv6 Transition by josephg on Tuesday October 22, 2024 @02:08AM (#41911630)
True. But CG-NAT is mostly fine for disempowered consumers.
Re:The IPv6 Transition by ozim on Monday October 21, 2024 @06:02AM (#41902480)
It is enough for Amazon/Google/FB/Netflix - they start to choke on IPv4 and they also don't want to pay up insane amounts for holding IPv4 ranges. When they switch to IPv6 they have more cheaper addressing. Once they force it down by making faster services via IPv6 all the ISPs will follow right away because everyone will want to have their Netflix/YT streams load faster.