News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:TCAS averts possible head-on collision in Austin by olliej on Friday October 18, 2024 @08:51PM (#41884766)
I’m sorry, but in what world is it acceptable for an aircraft flying in an airport’s atc controlled airspace to not be coordinating with ATC?

I thought that was literally the entire reason we have controlled airspace rules?

Re:TCAS averts possible head-on collision in Austin by buildsjets on Friday October 18, 2024 @09:11PM (#41884846)
The Class C airspace at that location starts at 2,100 feet. The Cessna was at 1,300 feet. The airliner was at 1,700 feet. The Cessna did not have to be coordinating with ATC because they were NOT in controlled airspace that requires radio communication with ATC, but it is optional and recommended.

The real question here is, why does Austin Approach Control have airliners driving around lower than the ceiling of the Class C protected airspace, where EVERY pilot knows that there are little putt-putt planes pottering about down there?

Re:TCAS averts possible head-on collision in Austin by noirbot on Friday October 18, 2024 @09:35PM (#41884958)
That's essentially the approach for the landing to the airport. I'd assume the AA flight was on its way in for landing.

It definitely strikes me as a place that wouldn't be a great idea to fly your plane past if you're not planning to be on comms with ATC.

Re:TCAS averts possible head-on collision in Austin by buildsjets on Friday October 18, 2024 @10:16PM (#41885136)
No, that's essentially underneath the landing path to the airport. Aircraft operate in three dimensions, and the airspace is sized and configured in three dimensions to support all the navigation needs and users in the area.

Did you know that there is a "tunnel" of uncontrolled airspace directly about Los Angeles International, between 3500 feet and 4500 feet, and you can fly through with commercial airliners whizzing about, talking to absolutely no radar services or ATC controllers? Called the LAX SFRA.

https://www.aopa.org/advocacy/advocacy-briefs/air-traffic-se...

Re:TCAS averts possible head-on collision in Austin by amluto on Friday October 18, 2024 @10:14PM (#41885130)
Seems like maybe the airspace used for the approach should be class C?

How does one find a map?

Re:TCAS averts possible head-on collision in Austin by buildsjets on Friday October 18, 2024 @10:16PM (#41885138)
skyvector.com
Re:TCAS averts possible head-on collision in Austin by olliej on Friday October 18, 2024 @10:03PM (#41885073)
Ah, so the actual issue is that the approach path is inexplicably not controlled airspace? That seems like a different version of bad :-/
Re:TCAS averts possible head-on collision in Austin by buildsjets on Friday October 18, 2024 @10:09PM (#41885100)
The Class C airspace is sized to contain the approach paths, including a buffer above and to the sides, as controlled airspace. But underneath the approach path and Class C airspace is generally uncontrolled airspace, untill you are very close, within a few miles, of the airport. (Technically it is called Class E or Class G airpspace depending on the area and altitude) Think of the controlled airspace as shaped like an upside-down wedding cake. Oh look, the FAA has a graphic for that:

https://www.faa.gov/air_traffic/publications/atpubs/aim_html...

Re:TCAS averts possible head-on collision in Austin by ryandrake on Saturday October 19, 2024 @12:16AM (#41885599)
Also, don’t forget that Class E airspace is controlled airspace, as IFR aircraft must operate with an ATC clearance. Airliners operate in Class E all the time. 1. ATC must vector them around VFR aircraft, and 2. VFR aircraft must see and avoid.
Re:TCAS averts possible head-on collision in Austin by buildsjets on Saturday October 19, 2024 @03:46PM (#41890211)
Yes, I intentionally did not include that fact, as it it is confusing for a layperson, than an airspace is called "controlled" even though it is only controlled for participating IFR aircraft. For the understanding of a layperson, Class E and G airspace do not require radio communication, radar contact, or permission to enter for little Cessna drivers in nice weather. Heck, you do not even need to have a radio installed, or even an electrical system, if you do not want one.

Respectfully, you are incorrect, and if you are a pilot, this is a dangerous misunderstanding. ATC does NOT provide radar separation services between VFR and IFR aircraft in Class E airspace. Reference the AIM, section 3-2-6-(f). Only separation between IFR aircraft is provided, and you may or may not get advisories and vectors for VFR traffic. How could it be otherwise, technically? The VFR aircraft may not even be equipped with a transponder, one is not required if you are more than 30 miles away from one of the 30 major Class-B airports in the country, and it might be made of bamboo and cloth with negligible radar cross section, so ATC may not even be aware of it's existence.

Separation between IFR and VFR aircraft in Class E airspace requires see-and-avoid by both the IFR aircraft and the VFR aircraft, and it is the responsibility of both pilots in command to ensure this happens. That's why we have the visibility and speed limitations that we have in Class E airspace, to provide enough time and distance for see-and-avoid to occur. But it requires at least one person in each flight deck to have their eyes out the window, not face down looking at the fishfinder.

There has grown a culture of complacency at the major airlines when it comes to integrating with parts of national airspace system that are outside of being directed by a controller - witness the recent Southwest debacle where they took off from a closed runway with personnel working because they did not understand, did not know, or ignored the standard dispatch procedures for operating before a control tower opens.

Re:TCAS averts possible head-on collision in Austin by ryandrake on Saturday October 19, 2024 @08:39PM (#41891972)
You are absolutely right about separation between VFR and IFR aircraft. I stand corrected.
Re:TCAS averts possible head-on collision in Austin by willidiots on Saturday October 19, 2024 @12:35AM (#41885668)
Looking at the charts, the Cessna brushed right up against the ground-4500 class C space. Not the smartest place to be off-frequency, in what sounded like mixed viz conditions. At the same time yeah, Austin Approach screwed up - "that traffic's through your final", when obviously it wasn't.
Re:TCAS averts possible head-on collision in Austin by cameldrv on Saturday October 19, 2024 @02:43AM (#41886103)
But this is also why you have a layered system of safety. Here, there are three layers:

1. Uncontrolled aircraft stay in uncontrolled airspace, airliners generally stay in controlled airspace (speaking generally, I know class E is controlled, but it's not positive control, and I know that the class C doesn't extend up to the class A) (successful)

2. The airliner had TCAS, as required, and the small plane had a working transponder, as required. As long as the airliner followed the RA, they would remain safe (successful)

3. The controller was supposed to provide separation on a workload permitting basis (not fully successful, the goal is more separation than was provided).

The ultimate result though was that the two planes missed each other by a fairly comfortable margin. The great thing is that the system doesn't depend on everyone being perfect to have a safe outcome, and it's been many years since an airliner has hit another plane in the U.S.

Re:TCAS averts possible head-on collision in Austin by bee_rider on Friday October 18, 2024 @09:03PM (#41884815)
The site seems to be very focused on what happened in the air, I assume the site summarizes air traffic control or FAA reports for hobbyists, or that sort of thing, right? So we don’t know what happened when the pilot of the Cessna got on the ground. Without knowing much about the rules of this sort of stuff, I assume they got a pretty stern talking to…
Re:TCAS averts possible head-on collision in Austin by noirbot on Friday October 18, 2024 @08:52PM (#41884774)
It's F1 weekend in Austin, so I'd assume that's part of the reason someone may think they don't need to care where they fly their private jet.
Re:TCAS averts possible head-on collision in Austin by dfc on Friday October 18, 2024 @09:12PM (#41884854)
Are you referring to the 45 year old Cessna when you say private jet? It looks like that plane flies a lot around Louisiana and Texas. Weird to jump to a conclusion about F1 money and an entitled pilot.
Re:TCAS averts possible head-on collision in Austin by noirbot on Friday October 18, 2024 @09:29PM (#41884931)
I mean, I'm just guessing, but AUS becomes one of the busiest airports for non-commercial planes this weekend every year. Even an old Cessna is literally a private jet, and they clearly weren't listing to ATC, so it's either entitlement or some sort of minor disaster that almost became a major disaster.

It's a choice to fly your airplane across the land/takeoff trajectory for a major airport. They also essentially flew by the F1 track on the way.

Re:TCAS averts possible head-on collision in Austin by ceejayoz on Friday October 18, 2024 @09:31PM (#41884942)
> Even an old Cessna is literally a private jet...

No, it isn't. It's a small non-jet aircraft. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cessna_182_Skylane

> they clearly weren't listing to ATC

They are not required to in that airspace at that altitude.

Re:TCAS averts possible head-on collision in Austin by noirbot on Friday October 18, 2024 @09:36PM (#41884970)
Private plane then. The point is the same. If you're flying a couple miles away from a commercial airport and across the path of the runways, maybe you're not required to be listening to ATC, but that's definitely a choice you're making to risk it.
Re:TCAS averts possible head-on collision in Austin by ceejayoz on Friday October 18, 2024 @09:40PM (#41884982)
> Private plane then. The point is the same.

No, it isn't. You can get a Cessna for less than a Cybertruck. You cannot get a private jet that cheap.

> If you're flying a couple miles away from a commercial airport and across the path of the runways, maybe you're not required to be listening to ATC, but that's definitely a choice you're making to risk it.

There's an explicit system of controlled airspace around airports.

See the picture illustrations in https://aviation.stackexchange.com/questions/97110/why-do-ai...

The Cessna was operating in airspace it had the legal right to be in and no need for ATC coordination. Near some of the busiest airports, etiquitte requires you try not to make a nuisance of yourself as a GA pilot to ATC.

Re:TCAS averts possible head-on collision in Austin by noirbot on Friday October 18, 2024 @11:03PM (#41885331)
You clearly know this more than I do, and I'm probably wrong in general, as it seems. I guess I find it hard to believe ATC is just flagrantly flying planes full of people in airspace they shouldn't be, but maybe that's normal.
Re:TCAS averts possible head-on collision in Austin by ryandrake on Saturday October 19, 2024 @12:11AM (#41885578)
You’d be surprised! For example, when I take off from Palo Alto in the Bay Area and fly northeast over, say, Fremont, staying under 4000 feet, I am in what’s called Class E airspace where I am not required to transmit on the radio. I regularly see arrivals into Oakland in front of me at my altitude and below. It is technically considered controlled airspace, as IFR aircraft must operate on an ATC clearance, but my VFR ass can legally barrel right through without talking to anyone! Obviously that’s not the smartest or safest practice but it’s legal.
Re:TCAS averts possible head-on collision in Austin by ceejayoz on Friday October 18, 2024 @09:30PM (#41884934)
A Cessna 182 isn't a private jet.
Re:TCAS averts possible head-on collision in Austin by noirbot on Friday October 18, 2024 @09:41PM (#41884991)
Ok, I used imprecise language in using the colloquial term. I'm not a pilot. I don't work in ATC. The exact nature of the plane doesn't seem too relevant to whether they should have been flying across the path of an airport runway without listening to ATC.

It's not as if the lack of literal jet engines makes it less of a problem or less of a rich person's toy.

Re:TCAS averts possible head-on collision in Austin by ceejayoz on Friday October 18, 2024 @09:46PM (#41885007)
> The exact nature of the plane doesn't seem too relevant to whether they should have been flying across the path of an airport runway without listening to ATC.

ATC had this controlled aircraft outside the airport's standard controlled airspace.

The fact that TCAS occurred at all means the Cessna was properly (legal requirement) broadcasting its altitude, airspeed, and GPS position to all around it.

The blame here likely lies with ATC, not the Cessna pilot.

edit: Flight tracks and ATC comms at https://x.com/flightradar24/status/1847148742882857191. This was ATC's problem.

Re:TCAS averts possible head-on collision in Austin by AceyMan on Friday October 18, 2024 @09:54PM (#41885042)
Well, imprecise language really is key here - because a pilot with a turbojet rating is, de facto, a better pilot than one who's flying a single engine piston plane.

Words matter.

Re:TCAS averts possible head-on collision in Austin by noirbot on Friday October 18, 2024 @11:05PM (#41885343)
Honest question, why would they de facto be better? Is it harder to fly a jet-engine plane? Especially when we're talking about generally flying safely in terms of "in airspace you're allowed to be in and being aware of other planes"? I could see a more complex plane being literally harder to fly, but is there a reason a Cessna isn't easier to fly safely?
Re:TCAS averts possible head-on collision in Austin by K0balt on Saturday October 19, 2024 @01:50AM (#41885896)
In general, a jet is much more likely to be coordinating with ATC even if they aren’t required to under the specific circumstances. But still, this was a failure of ATC to provide adequate separation from an aircraft that they knew was operating under Visual Flight Rules, and was not under ATC control.

The Cessna pilot is under no obligation to maintain contact with ATC in this airspace, and it is the job of ATC to route the aircraft under its guidance around this kind of airspace, and if penetration of uncontrolled airspace is required, then to advise about and route around any known traffic.

The Cessna was probably communicating with the relevant CTAF or tower frequency for the airport it was setting up an approach for, or monitoring Unicom for traffic avoidance for other small VFR aircraft.

A single pilot can’t fly, navigate, and maintain traffic separation in a plane and communicate on all frequencies at once simultaneously, and ATC does not have the resources to control all random manoeuvres of small aircraft.

This is why there are places where small aircraft operate, mostly under “see and avoid” VFR rules, and places where all operations are done under strict ATC controls.

In this case, the heavy aircraft was directed to fly through one of these uncontrolled areas, and the controller failed to maintain adequate separation from uncontrolled operations.

Re:TCAS averts possible head-on collision in Austin by AceyMan on Saturday October 19, 2024 @05:50PM (#41891022)
It's a next level certification - to achieve that rating you have to prove mastery of techniques and skills not examined in the requirements for a Private Pilot license.
Re:TCAS averts possible head-on collision in Austin by K0balt on Saturday October 19, 2024 @01:33AM (#41885846)
Cheaper than a cybertruck, but rich is a matter of perspective.