News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The web I want vs. the one we have by tolerance on Monday October 14, 2024 @09:51PM (#41844149)
These Web elegies are starting to become a real drag to read. And I don't mean to come across as flippant in saying this. I feel a sort of concern for the spirit of the authors of these kind of pieces, which are becoming more and more commonplace.
Re:The web I want vs. the one we have by adriand on Monday October 14, 2024 @10:07PM (#41844231)
Agreed. I don’t even know what this elegy is for. “what was wonderful about the web, was that here was a machine for finding people with similar interests and experience, anywhere in the world. That’s the web I want back.” Is that no longer the web? It seems pretty easy to find communities these days.

The web I want back is the one powered by real people making real things. But rather than complain about it I think I’d rather be one of the people who is still here, making things.

Re:The web I want vs. the one we have by Chathamization on Monday October 14, 2024 @11:41PM (#41844702)
> Is that no longer the web?

From what I've seen, a lot - I'd say most - of the communities that existed outside of the major platforms have dried up or ended (the famous/infamous bodybuilding forum apparently just went down). Web forum communities, mailing list communities, communities built around an individuals website (it sounds strange to say now, but this was pretty common a couple of decades ago). Even the offline meeting sites like Couchsurfing and Meetup are a shadow of what they were in their heyday (about 15 years or so ago).

The actual number of people actively using the internet is much higher, yet the number of people outside of a few small social media silos are much lower. So I can only surmise that these social media silos are giving the vast majority - almost everyone - what they want (those gratifying instant hits). It's just sad to know that there's apparently only a tiny sliver of humanity interested in venturing off the main path and interacting with people outside of these silos.

Re:The web I want vs. the one we have by dartos on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @01:11AM (#41845149)
You may be pleased to hear that those kinds of communities are actually alive and well, they just live on places like discord now.

Places that largely can’t be indexed by google.

My hope is that eventually these groups migrate to matrix, but we’ll see.

Re:The web I want vs. the one we have by treyd on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @02:23AM (#41845520)
That's exactly the issue the parent poster is talking about. It's not the web in the strict sense, it's the siloification.
Re:The web I want vs. the one we have by dartos on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @08:22AM (#41847802)
> It's not the web in the strict sense

It kind of is though. Maybe not with discord specifically, because it’s a closed platform. but communities on open ones like matrix are just as much part of the web as any forum.

It’s not a big platform with all users in one space. There are dedicated communities with passionate people talking, sharing ideas, helping each other out.

Would you’ve considered IRC chat rooms on freenode part of the web?

Re:The web I want vs. the one we have by treyd on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @10:41PM (#41855095)
> but communities on open ones like matrix are just as much part of the web as any forum. [...] Would you’ve considered IRC chat rooms on freenode part of the web?

For IRC, absolutely not. IRC (1988) even predates the web (1989). Freenode offered a web-based gateway that ran on their servers, that doesn't make IRC a web protocol.

As for the rest it's slightly fuzzier since in practice they rely on HTTP, but you can't just use a normal web browser to interface with them. You have to run a specialized client that understands the protocol to interact with them. The practicality of the firstparty clients for these platforms/protocols (or in Discord's case the only one you're officially allowed to use) being shipped in a web browser doesn't make the systems "part of the web". The server doesn't give you HTML that you can see in any browser, you make API requests for JSON in a non-W3C-standardized format and interpret it with specialized software. You can't send someone a URL to a message and have them be able to open it in any web browser without additional software.

Re:The web I want vs. the one we have by dartos on Thursday October 17, 2024 @02:26PM (#41872275)
> You can't send someone a URL to a message and have them be able to open it in any web browser without additional software

You actually can with discord and with certain matrix clients as well.

The clients for those protocols are built on top of web technologies, even if the protocols may not be.

That would discount IRC from being part of the web though.

Re:The web I want vs. the one we have by treyd on Saturday October 19, 2024 @11:57AM (#41888541)
I am well aware that it's possible to have a link to a discord/matrix message, but it only works if you're already a member of the group and you download the custom software client.
Re:The web I want vs. the one we have by jjav on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @08:44PM (#41854580)
> You may be pleased to hear that those kinds of communities are actually alive and well, they just live on places like discord now.

But that is exactly what it wasn't. Discord is a proprietary walled-garden like too many others today. I tried to access a forum there once and it demanded both registration and a phone number. No thanks. That's not the open Internet.

The open communities were defined by the openness. Using standard protocols like SMTP, NNTP, HTTP (on public websites, not walled gardens).

Re:The web I want vs. the one we have by 256_ on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @03:06AM (#41845740)
> (the famous/infamous bodybuilding forum apparently just went down)

What forum? Was it the one where they couldn't figure out how many days there were in a week?

Re:The web I want vs. the one we have by prmoustache on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @03:28AM (#41845851)
> From what I've seen, a lot - I'd say most - of the communities that existed outside of the major platforms have dried up or ended (the famous/infamous bodybuilding forum apparently just went down). Web forum communities, mailing list communities, communities built around an individuals website (it sounds strange to say now, but this was pretty common a couple of decades ago).

I would say that is simply because bodybuilding sucks and everyone with half a brain has moved to other activities like crossfit or similar that allows you to have a nice body that you can actually do something with instead of a useless one :)

More seriously this is not my experience. Two of the websites I visit the most in 2024 are the "traditionnal participative type", ie, privately owned, not social medias but with membership and comments and stuff. One is using a custom cms based on rails and has been launched in 1998, the other one is only 15y old but is running vbulletin.

And I still encounter many websites like this. Last time I had an issue with my Piaggio motorbike, I found a vespa dedicated web forum that was really helpful and active.

I think there are lots of people deep in social medias, reddit and discord and some who are fed up by this stuff and stay out of it. The issue is that privately owned websites cost money to run usually or are very stripped of customization/features/storage and moderation is a burden so you need very motivated people to keep the light on compared to say, a discord or reddit community that can stay online for months/years while the initial admins/founders aren't even connecting to it anymore.

Re:The web I want vs. the one we have by Centigonal on Monday October 14, 2024 @10:36PM (#41844390)
I'm looking forward to reading an aging GenZ-er's elegy of the web that looks fondly back on the age of TikTok and algorithmic feeds, back when people actually made things.
Re:The web I want vs. the one we have by gonzo41 on Monday October 14, 2024 @11:37PM (#41844670)
Lets be honest, they won't have the concentration to be able to write more than a tweet about it.
Re:The web I want vs. the one we have by whatshisface on Monday October 14, 2024 @10:59PM (#41844494)
I can write it for you:

"I miss when the internet was an international gathering place, not a carefully guarded forum for communicating misinformation-free messaging about foreign policy and corporate life in the United States of America, England and Wales. I had a friend from China."

Re:The web I want vs. the one we have by jamiek88 on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @03:20AM (#41845815)
How when the Chinese won’t let people from China use it?
Re:The web I want vs. the one we have by stackghost on Monday October 14, 2024 @10:40PM (#41844415)
>Is that no longer the web?

I don't think so

>It seems pretty easy to find communities these days.

Outside of HN and a few niche subreddits, I can't think of many. Most good communities I'm part of are off the web on things like Discord which isn't addressable by search engines.

Re:The web I want vs. the one we have by shiroiushi on Monday October 14, 2024 @11:42PM (#41844715)
Discord is honestly one of the worst things to happen to the internet, and I'd blame Gen-Z for most of its popularity since they seem to have no idea why the internet was created in the first place.
Re:The web I want vs. the one we have by hmcq6 on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @02:20AM (#41845486)
In my opinion, you're shooting the messenger.

Why does Gen-Z like Discord? No advertising, no enshittification, just a simple solution to a common problem.

It's just modern AIM, but AIM wasn't blamed for "killing" forums. AIM and forums coexisted because they serve different purposes.

Re:The web I want vs. the one we have by shiroiushi on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @02:33AM (#41845582)
>AIM and forums coexisted because they serve different purposes.

That's the problem with Discord. As an AIM replacement, it's fine, because no one cares about being able to access other peoples' ephemeral private chats. But when large communities discuss things, it's very useful for that information to be publicly available and accessible from a search engine, and Discord prevents that, locking it all away from any outsiders. If your group really wants to be secret and private for some reason, I guess that's fine, but if you're a group discussing, for instance, bicycle maintenance tips, why do you want to keep others from seeing this helpful info? And why do you want to keep others out? Specialty subreddits don't have this problem.

Re:The web I want vs. the one we have by hmcq6 on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @02:51AM (#41845670)
So where do you suggest people post that is zero cost and advertisement free?

These communities were pushed onto discord because there isn't a better place for them.

The regional live music discord I'm in would be much better served by being on a web forum but running a forum costs money. Or they could use facebook but not everyone in the community has/wants a facebook account. Not everyone uses reddit/twitter/insert your favorite social media.

> why do you want to keep others from seeing this helpful info?

How paranoid would one have to be to think people are moving to discord to be malicious? The garden doesn't have walls to keep you out, the walls are to keep the advertisers/bots out.

Re:The web I want vs. the one we have by shiroiushi on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @03:00AM (#41845717)
>So where do you suggest people post that is zero cost and advertisement free?

These days, Reddit seems to be the best option available (unfortunately).

Back during better days, we had lots of independent forums running software like PhpBB, which served this purpose well. For some reason that I don't really understand, back then (when computers were less powerful and efficient than now) that worked well enough, but now everyone's screaming about hosting costs and how expensive it is to run even a single bulletin board on the internet so they turn to Discord when they don't like Reddit. Why hosting costs apparently weren't such a big deal 15-20 years ago with crappier hardware and much less storage space, I honestly don't know.

Re:The web I want vs. the one we have by xnorswap on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @04:13AM (#41846170)
Part of the problem is that 20 years ago they weren't being scraped 24/7.
Re:The web I want vs. the one we have by n_ary on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @08:18AM (#41847788)
> Why hosting costs apparently weren't such a big deal 15-20 years ago with crappier hardware and much less storage space, I honestly don't know.

Back in the so called "golden days", I actually hosted a forum with a friend. His uncle offered his old office PC(bought at a bargain) and internet with fixed IP for us to tinker with. Our tiny forum has local kids and some "supervising adults" doing moderation. Many of our international members were mostly on dialup, so even if we didn't have lovely CDN, the slowness was accepted as normal thing. We did not face much spamming, grifting and any trouble makers were policed out immediately by moderators.

In present days, I am very afraid to put something online, because if the moderators are not vigilant, I could very well expect a police letter by a week or two asking about certain type fo contents and my infra provider banning or null routing my forum. It was easy back in days, now the risks are too high and trouble makers have more resources than well intent folks.

Re:The web I want vs. the one we have by shiroiushi on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @08:19PM (#41854428)
I see, this really sheds a lot of light on things. Thanks!
Re:The web I want vs. the one we have by hmcq6 on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @02:15AM (#41856101)
I said 0 cost and ad free but your answer does not satisfy those requirements, because your interest are at odds with the interests of these various communities.

Communities generally don't need their content to be indexable. People in the community can use Discords search feature. Indexable content is only a benefit to people outside the community.

So why should these communities move away from discord to help you? Especially given that you do not respect their interests.

Do you get what I'm saying?

> Why hosting costs apparently weren't such a big deal 15-20 years ago?

It's not that hosting costs are so much higher now. In the 2020s I ran a forum for ~10$ a year but then I realized exposing my home IP was a bad idea. Then I ran the forum for $50 a year and... no one but me used it.

Recently one of my friends paid $500 to set up a forum using a dedicated provider /w a support plan. Fingers crossed it sees more activity than mine did.

So you can still host a forum pretty cheap but it requires trading in your personal time or paying $500 and given most Americans don't have $500 liquid you would need donations/organization (which requires more of your personal time).

It's not impossible but it's not super easy either.

Re:The web I want vs. the one we have by shiroiushi on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @03:01AM (#41856322)
>So why should these communities move away from discord to help you? Especially given that you do not respect their interests.

>Do you get what I'm saying?

No, I don't. I guess these "communities" don't want any new members, because if I can't find them with a search, I'll likely never know about them.

Re:The web I want vs. the one we have by hmcq6 on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @03:11AM (#41856381)
You're just repeatedly asking that these communities deal with advertising to make things easier for you personally because you think they need your participation to survive. But what if they don't need you?

P.s. not every community recruits primarily through the internet.

Re:The web I want vs. the one we have by shiroiushi on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @07:57PM (#41865117)
I never asked for advertising: you're putting words in my mouth and arguing in bad faith. I only asked for openness.
Re:The web I want vs. the one we have by GuB-42 on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @07:41AM (#41847489)
> No advertising, no enshittification

It is starting to change, for me, Discord has being going downhill for a couple of years.

Client updates are becoming more common and more buggy, as if we were on a beta channel. Marketing for Nitro is becoming more agressive, and now, there are "Quests", which are essentially ad banners for games.

Re:The web I want vs. the one we have by n_ary on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @08:03AM (#41847653)
If my memories are not too deteriorated, I find the Discord communities akin to IRC communities, except with more memes and emojis.
Re:The web I want vs. the one we have by shiroiushi on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @08:05PM (#41854337)
I think this sounds accurate. And, on the surface, there's nothing wrong with a modernized, glorified IRC network, but it should be obvious to anyone here that this is utterly useless as a store of useful information that can be archived and indexed and searched by others later. It's like two guys sitting next to each other at a bar and striking up a conversation, and one tells the other a great tip he figured out for how to fix a very particular issue with his car. That's nice, but the other guy just got lucky he met someone with this knowledge, and all the other people with that same issue are out of luck and won't learn this valuable nugget of info because there's no record of it anywhere.
Re:The web I want vs. the one we have by jjav on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @08:46PM (#41854588)
IRC wasn't run by a proprietary company that demanded your phone number to read the channels. So discord is basically the exact opposite of IRC (and everything else in the open Internet).
Re:The web I want vs. the one we have by bonoboTP on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @09:22AM (#41848312)
There has to be a barrier, a kept gate. Back "then", simply access to the internet was enough of a filter to get a good signal-to-noise ratio.

Today it's something else, such as knowing discords through word of mouth, knowing groups on other platforms, etc. If you're not getting through this knowledge filter, you need to try harder or accept not being in there.

HN can remain public and high quality due to strong moderation and an "ugly", text-only, imageless, emojiless UI that scares away "noise"-people.

Re:The web I want vs. the one we have by dwoldrich on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @10:00AM (#41848694)
This comment was very well-written. And, it stirs up thoughts about what works and what doesn't. "What abouts" like that one battle royale game (that failed) that coupled advancement to being a good sport and respectful to others, and it kindof worked. Could that kind of "good sport" thing be engineered into public forums somehow.

But in the end, all my feeble "what if's" collapse, and I end up agreeing with you.

Re:The web I want vs. the one we have by echelon on Monday October 14, 2024 @11:04PM (#41844514)
I still remember the screen names of folks I interacted with in and on IRC, AIM, ezboard, IGN boards, forums, etc.

I only remember a handful of HN usernames and absolutely zero handles from elsewhere.

Forums used to have large avatars and signatures you could customize and communities were much more tightly-knit. I imagine that's what Discord and VRChat do now.

Re:The web I want vs. the one we have by Chathamization on Monday October 14, 2024 @11:51PM (#41844774)
> I still remember the screen names of folks I interacted with in and on IRC, AIM, ezboard, IGN boards, forums, etc.

> I only remember a handful of HN usernames and absolutely zero handles from elsewhere.

Same. It's strange that in terms of interpersonal communication, we appear to be worse off than where were 25 years ago with AIM and e-mail. Back then it was common to carry on pretty deep conversations and relationships with people from all over the world. Part of my nightly routine was going over the day with my friends (both near and far). I would send long e-mail to my distant friends on their birthday, talking about all the things that had happened in my life, and they would do the same. I'd even keep in contact for years with pen pals I had met all over the world.

There's no reason this couldn't be done today, but I suppose most people prefer the much shallower interactions we have now.

Re:The web I want vs. the one we have by klibertp on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @06:32AM (#41847079)
> I only remember a handful of HN usernames

That's a feature. HN is expressly built to encourage high-quality content in the comments - by removing or discouraging things that tend to bring poor content with them. Not showing up/down-votes counts, not allowing avatars and discouraging lengthy signatures, not showing previews of images linked, not allowing to reply immediately to comments (and the length of "immediately" getting longer the deeper the thread) - the HN is coded this way to encourage sticking to guidelines and making thoughtful comments focused on informative, interesting content.

It does make HN a worse place for building interpersonal relations, no question about it - but it also eliminates or blocks many of the enshitiffication vectors. Not all of them, and we do see changes over time in what's acceptable, going in the direction that some will dislike, but I think the fact that HN still existing in relatively constant form almost 20 years later shows that the strategy works, to an extent.

Re:The web I want vs. the one we have by moi2388 on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @02:07AM (#41845413)
The irony of posting this on hackernews..
Re:The web I want vs. the one we have by turnsout on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @06:33AM (#41847089)
100%. I've been writing HTML since 94, and there truly was no golden age. There have been (get ready for this) good and bad things about each era.

It has always been possible to create communities, or break away and do something different. I really like ActivityPub, but it does not really change the dynamic.

With all of that said, sometimes getting a fancy new notebook makes you more likely to draw/write, which seems to be essentially what Dave is experiencing. Nothing wrong with that!

Re:The web I want vs. the one we have by wormius on Monday October 14, 2024 @11:59PM (#41844817)
Don't worry in about 5 years they'll come to the conclusion I did about 5 years ago (because I was like that in 2014) - that is to say, they're realize it's futile and liberate themselves from the angst of it all and just accept the world is shit and the internet is shit and there's no going back and you will be free from such horrific lust for the dead remains of an archaic past. You will be glad when new potential "solutions" come up, but be sad to see the loss of expansion of said places and ultimately learn to accept that it's "creative destruction" on a smaller level, and the only people who care are the old heads who are a dying generation. We're like hippies at a dead show, with a few young hangers on who love to hear the glory of the old days, But they'll soon be dead too. Freedom in acceptance. Freedom in serenity. Free at last, thank god almighty, they will be free of such mental strife at last.
Re:The web I want vs. the one we have by malfist on Monday October 14, 2024 @11:32PM (#41844641)
It's always the start of eternal September for someone
Re:The web I want vs. the one we have by hu3 on Monday October 14, 2024 @11:13PM (#41844556)
This is controversial and perhaps rude but I've started to copy-paste these articles into ChatGPT to summarize into a single paragraph to help me decide if it is worth reading or not, for me.

Again, I mean no offense but humans only have 2,207,520,000 seconds on average. You can be goddamn right I'll take all the help I can allocating this precious resource called time.

Example output from this article:

> The author reflects on their early experiences in Silicon Valley, feeling at home among peers in the tech world but later realizing that many influential figures, including gatekeepers and executives, lacked a deep understanding of software. This disconnect was disheartening, as key decision-makers often misunderstood the potential and intricacies of the technology they were overseeing. Despite this, the author celebrates the web for its ability to connect people globally with shared interests and expertise, yearning for a return to a time when the internet was a space for meaningful connections and innovation. They also express enthusiasm for their current blogging on platforms like WordPress and Mastodon, envisioning future improvements and business potential.

(it's worth reading for me so I'll read)

Re:The web I want vs. the one we have by LVB on Monday October 14, 2024 @11:53PM (#41844786)
Learn skimming? I say this as a old person who actually had "skimming" and "scanning" (different things!) as part of my elementary reading curriculum. We even had to practice skimming the whole (printed) NYT in 5 minutes. This piece is seven short paragraphs. I can get the gist and tone in a few seconds. Quicker, in fact, than reading the chatgpt snoozefest.

I'll happily dump an 80 page patent or court ruling into chatgpt for a summary. But if an actual human wrote a few hundred word personal blog post, I'd rather read it.

Re:The web I want vs. the one we have by hu3 on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @12:04AM (#41844834)
Fair enough that's what I did previously.

But I'd rather delegate mundane cognitive effort and prioritize spending it on more important uses.

Come to think of it, I'll write a bookmark or Tampermonkey script to summarize pages according to my prompt.

Re:The web I want vs. the one we have by rangedbarbarian on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @03:37AM (#41845881)
If you think that human mind works like this, then you'll find out that those precious ideas and things you want to think about come once in a blue moon if ever. ChatGPT is going to make you even dumber than you already sound like.
Re:The web I want vs. the one we have by croisillon on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @03:08AM (#41845758)
wow i never knew that was a skill, and that it could be taught in school! TIL
Re:The web I want vs. the one we have by ajkjk on Monday October 14, 2024 @11:17PM (#41844576)
Not so much rude as.. silly. What's your goal here? Optimal resource consumption? Can't relate. It's not like absorbing more information faster makes me smarter or more capable. Or happier. If anything it's the opposite.
Re:The web I want vs. the one we have by hu3 on Monday October 14, 2024 @11:34PM (#41844654)
No. It's about determining if the structure and conclusion of the article is pertinent to my interests.

Just like Abstract section in scientific articles. I wouldn't call those silly.

Re:The web I want vs. the one we have by Sn0wCoder on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @01:20AM (#41845198)
Hate to admit this but reading the comments will give a person way more knowledge than any given submission and if the comments are good the article is required reading before adding your own comment. Not sure ChatGPT is worth the effort here. By the time you cut and paste then read the gibberish one could have already read the top few comments (you can use the minus to minimize them and read the next thread). Like the time spent leaving this comment would be better used any where else, but yet here it is (all 300 seconds or if you like 300,000 ms)
Re:The web I want vs. the one we have by 0xEF on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @04:57AM (#41846483)
The original reply was looking for a summary of the article which ChatGPT can supply, not more info, which is typically more where one might go to the comments and join the discussion. Two different streets on my map.

Just be aware that comments on HN are subject to all sorts of opinions skewed by bias and sycophantism, the same way Reddit or Mastodon silos tend to be. I think a lot of users think HN has some sort of immunity to that, so the tribalism tends to be strong and stubborn.

Re:The web I want vs. the one we have by Sn0wCoder on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @06:23PM (#41853748)
Agree 100% with everything you said and the comment I left was very low quality. It would be interesting to see a ChatGPT summary for each submission to HN and the comments to give you an overview of the content that was auto generated. The main point was the time it takes to cut, and paste is not zero. Personally, spending that time reading the top comments seems more useful (to me) than reading a ChatGPT summary of the article, but like you say two different streets.
Re:The web I want vs. the one we have by kristianc on Tuesday October 15, 2024 @07:05AM (#41847287)
Winer in particular often writes in a style that approaches technology with the attitude that even the most obvious ideas weren't truly finished until he's had a hand in them.