It's interesting that you mention Theo, since apparently the reason OpenBSD exists is because he couldn't get along with the other core NetBSD developers.
What it shows is that the characteristic of being a good "benevolent dictator" isn't the same as "getting along" with your peers. Theo was a poor collaborator in a larger project. Linus probably would be too.
Theo's collected e-mail from that time: http://www.theos.com/deraadt/coremail.html
are there any significant projects other than debian that have elections?
For some value of significant, Squeak. The turn out has been down for the last few elections, with the last one getting around a hundred votes, with around 450 people authorized to vote.
Some of the decline is probably linked to the Pharo fork http://www.pharo-project.org/home
The FreeBSD Project has elections, and is in short order going to announce a new Core Team.
Gentoo developers elect its Council, and the Foundation members (large overlap with the developers set) elect the Trustees.
Fedora.
It might be interesting to see how effective (if such a thing could even be measured) communities with benevolent dictators perform as compared to those that operate by consensus/voting.