News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US Navy X-47B Robot Fighter Jet Completes First Phase Of ... by droithomme on Saturday June 30, 2012 @12:48PM (#4182075)
These sorts of weapons move the balance of power to where the only reasonable defenses against the US are nuclear and bioweapons, and therefore that is where you should start investing your research efforts in if you are not an ally.
Re:US Navy X-47B Robot Fighter Jet Completes First Phase Of ... by protomyth on Saturday June 30, 2012 @01:18PM (#4182180)
The US Navy has a massive superiority over every other navy in the world for a good many years. This is just the next step.

The recently release radar information (tracking raindrops) was probably a bit of a warning telling others that their new generation of missiles was not going to work as well as they think. Probably much like NASA showing people underground rivers was designed to tell others hiding ICBMs was a waste.

Re:US Navy X-47B Robot Fighter Jet Completes First Phase Of ... by samstave on Saturday June 30, 2012 @02:48PM (#4182455)
What is the underground rivers thing you mention?
Re:US Navy X-47B Robot Fighter Jet Completes First Phase Of ... by protomyth on Saturday June 30, 2012 @03:25PM (#4182570)
I remember an old story about NASA giving a detailed map of the underground parts of some river system via ground penetrating radar to a country thus telling the USSR that building large underground facilities was not really going to hide them.

I thought it was the Nile and Egypt, but I am probably wrong on that. It was in one of the history books I was reading in the 90's and they are in a storage garage about 400miles away.

Re:US Navy X-47B Robot Fighter Jet Completes First Phase Of ... by antidoh on Saturday June 30, 2012 @05:12PM (#4182841)
"It was in one of the history books I was reading in the 90's and they are in a storage garage about 400miles away."

As much as I hate ereaders, there's an excellent example of why ebooks are a good thing.

Re:US Navy X-47B Robot Fighter Jet Completes First Phase Of ... by protomyth on Saturday June 30, 2012 @06:05PM (#4182957)
e-readers are great, re-buying all the books is not so great.
Re:US Navy X-47B Robot Fighter Jet Completes First Phase Of ... by aerique on Saturday June 30, 2012 @07:41PM (#4183177)
Since you already own them, why not torrent them?
Re:US Navy X-47B Robot Fighter Jet Completes First Phase Of ... by protomyth on Sunday July 01, 2012 @12:12PM (#4185156)
Because I made a personal decision that I wouldn't torrent anything but open source stuff. If I'm going to format shift, I will buy the item. The author deserves the money for continuing their efforts.
Re:US Navy X-47B Robot Fighter Jet Completes First Phase Of ... by antidoh on Sunday July 01, 2012 @12:47PM (#4185277)
I don't disagree with your decision to not torrent, but whether the author gets any money from format shifting is determined by each author's contract for each work.
Re:US Navy X-47B Robot Fighter Jet Completes First Phase Of ... by protomyth on Sunday July 01, 2012 @01:59PM (#4185555)
Yep, and since I don't have access to the contracts, I will take the safe route.
Re:US Navy X-47B Robot Fighter Jet Completes First Phase Of ... by mixmax on Saturday June 30, 2012 @01:27PM (#4182210)
actually with the adversaries the US is currently engaged with the most reasonable defense (from the point of the adversaries) is terrorism.

It's cheap and effective, and arguably no more unfair than bombing civilians that don't stand a fighting chance against a drone controlled by an operator thousand of miles away.

This is the major downside of modern American one-sided warfare.

Re:US Navy X-47B Robot Fighter Jet Completes First Phase Of ... by vibrunazo on Saturday June 30, 2012 @02:58PM (#4182484)
The most efficient military defense countries are engaging in is developing economic relationships. The number one reason why the US start a military war against China in the foreseeable future. Is not because of their super advanced autonomous airships. But because doing so would be shooting their own foot. As both US and China are highly dependent on one another.

Plenty of small countries around the world have very little military but are completely safe from US attacks because of economic relationships. Modern economics are the most powerful weapon for peace. Not autonomous vehicles nor terrorism.

Re:US Navy X-47B Robot Fighter Jet Completes First Phase Of ... by droithomme on Saturday June 30, 2012 @03:12PM (#4182534)
China has a gigantic arsenal of functioning nuclear warheads sitting atop of maintained and ready ICBMs that are pretargetted at key american targets.

Military action against China by the US is simply not possible.

The US doesn't bully China. It bullies people who don't have working nukes and ICBMs.

One of the main arguments against the US building a network of "star wars" missile defense stations capable of stopping mass ICBM attacks is it would dangerously shift the balance of power with China, requiring them to pursue other means of preventing the US from attacking them. The Chinese are extremely smart so targetted bioweapons that only infect people with smallpox who don't have asian ancestry are not out of the question as a reasonable project to look into next. It would be better for all of us if they do not pursue this line of research. Not having a missile defense system maintains the usefulness of their nuclear arsenal. It is therefore better than having a missile defense system which makes their nuclear arsenal useless.

Re:US Navy X-47B Robot Fighter Jet Completes First Phase Of ... by arethuza on Saturday June 30, 2012 @05:15PM (#4182853)
According to Wikipedia China has "66 land-based ICBMs and 24 submarine-based JL-2 SLBMs" - compared to the US or even Russia that is hardly "gigantic".
Re:US Navy X-47B Robot Fighter Jet Completes First Phase Of ... by droithomme on Saturday June 30, 2012 @06:35PM (#4183021)
If bringing in submarines, we should also bring in all the "fishing boats" that have short range nukes as well which sit off US coasts. There's also the long range bombers, though those are not really effective since the above mentioned robot planes will make quick work of them.

But forget the fishing boats, it's not relevant. Let's just talk the submarines and the ICBMs, some which carry multiple nuclear warheads, each warhead capable of destroying a large metro area.

You don't think it is gigantic, really? Let's launch them all at their primary programmed targets. What happens next? If you're in the US do you feel safe because you feel the arsenal is not as gigantic as I think it is? What is the difference in result between whatever level you personally feel qualifies as a gigantic number of nuclear armed missiles, and the number that somebody typed into Wikipedia?

It's completely astonishing to me that anyone thinks the Chinese don't have a gigantic number of nuclear missiles.

The current number is more than sufficient to permanently end 90% of human life in north america. Why is that not enough to qualify? How many more do they need before it's enough to be a gigantic number of ICBMs carrying nukes?

Let's just think about this for a moment. The US launches a full blown robot attack fighter strike against China, for which there is no defense. What's China's response? To give up? No. China has a defense. A last resort defense. Because they have this defense, the US will not attack China. That's just how it is. Attacking China is suicide because of China's nuclear capabilities. Countries without these capabilities are sitting ducks for american corporate imperialists to toy with as they fancy with their shiny robot death weapons. These countries can resign themselves to be the US's plaything, or they can develop a defense strategy. A defense strategy involving an airforce, an army, or anything resembling conventional warfare is not going to work against the US. So now what? Unconventional warfare, that's what. Nothing surprising in the least that more and more countries will be pushed into this corner if they don't want to be bullied by the US. Right now, as well as last week, as well as next week and the week after that, this is the conversation that is going on throughout the world in every country that has natural resources the US might want, that doesn't price oil they sell in US dollars, or that doesn't feel like being controlled by a corporate plutocracy aligned with a phony protestant religious veneer used to get the rubes on board with the looting scheme under the guise of god and patriotism.

Re:US Navy X-47B Robot Fighter Jet Completes First Phase Of ... by hexagonal on Saturday June 30, 2012 @06:56PM (#4183079)

  No. China has a defense. A last resort defense. Because 
  they have this defense, the US will not attack China. 
  That's just how it is. Attacking China is suicide because 
  of China's nuclear capabilities.
Technically, China's agreed to never use their nukes in a first-strike scenario. They're supposed to only be used in response to nuclear attack.

That agreement's laughably unenforceable in a full-bird US/China shooting war; but it's there.

Re:US Navy X-47B Robot Fighter Jet Completes First Phase Of ... by hexagonal on Saturday June 30, 2012 @06:54PM (#4183073)
China hasn't agreed to any arms inspections, so the size of their nuclear arsenal is pretty vague. (Inspections are typically the result of bilateral arms reductions-- China doesn't have enough nukes to require reducing them, so there's no reason for them to let foreigners into their ICBM silos)
Re:US Navy X-47B Robot Fighter Jet Completes First Phase Of ... by seanmcdirmid on Saturday June 30, 2012 @10:13PM (#4183553)
These are only estimates from our intelligence community, but they are considered relatively reliable. China hasn't built up a massive nuke stockpile yet, and its probably not within their best interests to do so (expensive, increased tensions). They could not hope to match the US or Russia today, so why bother trying?

China will continue to build up its conventional forces to project power in the region, that is probably more of a worry for the US than anything else.

Re:US Navy X-47B Robot Fighter Jet Completes First Phase Of ... by mindslight on Saturday June 30, 2012 @02:38PM (#4182428)
Not only from the point of the adversaries, but to anyone who's thought about the actual role each "side" is playing. But don't worry fellow Americans, just keep supporting the intractable and autonomous government.
Re:US Navy X-47B Robot Fighter Jet Completes First Phase Of ... by forgotusername on Saturday June 30, 2012 @01:17PM (#4182178)
These are still vulnerable to electronic countermeasures, not to mention plain old missile attacks on their requisite communications infrastructure (satellites presumably).

I imagine if any modern power got into a real fight with the US, the first volley of missiles would be headed for space.

Re:US Navy X-47B Robot Fighter Jet Completes First Phase Of ... by ghostfish on Saturday June 30, 2012 @01:10PM (#4182151)
How does this type of aircraft shift the balance of power? It doesn't appear to do anything "better" than a manned aircraft aside from not having a pilot to lose onboard.
Re:US Navy X-47B Robot Fighter Jet Completes First Phase Of ... by mbenjaminsmith on Saturday June 30, 2012 @02:41PM (#4182435)
1. With in-air refueling, a greatly increased time in the air vs manned aircraft.

2. Ability to outmaneuver any manned aircraft by exceeding the human g limit.

3. Greatly lowered cost in both manufacture and pilot training (or lack of).

4. When fully realized, AI that is superior to human pilots -- increasing overall combat effectiveness and reducing error.

Re:US Navy X-47B Robot Fighter Jet Completes First Phase Of ... by velodrome on Saturday June 30, 2012 @05:02PM (#4182811)
5. Reconnaissance

6. Stealth

7. Autonomy

8. Cost of pilot death (human loss)

9. Reduced training time

Re:US Navy X-47B Robot Fighter Jet Completes First Phase Of ... by antidoh on Saturday June 30, 2012 @05:16PM (#4182854)
0. No risk of losing a human, which makes it easier to decide to attack or go to war, and so you look more bad ass in the balance of power.

The increased willingness and ability to attack is a bad thing.

Re:US Navy X-47B Robot Fighter Jet Completes First Phase Of ... by kiba on Saturday June 30, 2012 @06:25PM (#4183002)
1. With in-air refueling, a greatly increased time in the air vs manned aircraft.

Not unique to unmanned aircrafts. On the other hand, pilots need to go to the restroom, get hungry, and tired.

2. Ability to outmaneuver any manned aircraft by exceeding the human g limit.

Only useful if human pilot have low latency access to aircraft, or if AI is good enough to fight. Otherwise, you're good as owned.

3. Greatly lowered cost in both manufacture and pilot training (or lack of).

Useful, when nobody is trying to shoot down your drone.

4. When fully realized, AI that is superior to human pilots -- increasing overall combat effectiveness and reducing error.

In 30 years, maybe.

Re:US Navy X-47B Robot Fighter Jet Completes First Phase Of ... by Dove on Saturday June 30, 2012 @01:58PM (#4182316)
You can attempt a lot more of the type of mission in which both your target and your aircraft are destroyed.

I've heard folks who work on drones say that once you've fired all your munitions, you have one munition left.

Re:US Navy X-47B Robot Fighter Jet Completes First Phase Of ... by breidh on Saturday June 30, 2012 @01:15PM (#4182171)
It can ostensibly disable an adversary's satellite.
Re:US Navy X-47B Robot Fighter Jet Completes First Phase Of ... by protomyth on Saturday June 30, 2012 @01:19PM (#4182185)
Uhm, I might be off, but are you thinking of the X-37B?

The US has had satellite shoot down capability for a while.

Re:US Navy X-47B Robot Fighter Jet Completes First Phase Of ... by breidh on Saturday June 30, 2012 @05:44PM (#4182916)
Sorry, you're right. I was thinking of the x-37.

However, I wasn't aware there was air-to-low-earth-orbit shoot down capability. Only ground launch capability.

Re:US Navy X-47B Robot Fighter Jet Completes First Phase Of ... by protomyth on Saturday June 30, 2012 @06:02PM (#4182951)
Re:US Navy X-47B Robot Fighter Jet Completes First Phase Of ... by velodrome on Saturday June 30, 2012 @04:55PM (#4182799)
However, disabling (or altering) the satellite without the adversary knowing about it is an even greater advantage.
Re:US Navy X-47B Robot Fighter Jet Completes First Phase Of ... by mkaltenecker on Saturday June 30, 2012 @01:31PM (#4182223)
The only consequences I can think of are that the cost for the military is potentially decreased and that advocating war gets easier.

The first one is a maybe. I’m willing to bet that you still need a lot of people to make those things fly, they are also potentially more complicated machines and I’m not sure how the cost of pilots (and replacing them if one is killed) figures into this.

The second one seems significant to me. It seems that drones already make it pretty sure you are nowhere safe if the US don’t like you – even if you are a relatively low priority. Presidents (especially Obama) have become extremely willing to use them for just about anything.

Re:US Navy X-47B Robot Fighter Jet Completes First Phase Of ... by Gustomaximus on Saturday June 30, 2012 @01:56PM (#4182306)
I would think this is going to increase the push into cyber warfare. In the same way we saw a done being hijacked recently through GPS I would think taking more complete control of your enemies drones, or at the least disabling their sensors and ability to operate will become a big military push.
Re:US Navy X-47B Robot Fighter Jet Completes First Phase Of ... by sien on Saturday June 30, 2012 @07:46PM (#4183187)
No, the reasonable defense against the US is already working.

Debt.

Re:US Navy X-47B Robot Fighter Jet Completes First Phase Of ... by mikeash on Saturday June 30, 2012 @01:23PM (#4182197)
WMD or insurgency has been the only realistic way to militarily oppose the US for a long, long time now. That's nothing new.
Re:US Navy X-47B Robot Fighter Jet Completes First Phase Of ... by molmalo on Saturday June 30, 2012 @07:08PM (#4183095)
Actually, in conventional war, as Millennium Challenge 2002 clearly showed [1], using smart tactics a technologically inferior army can effectively defeat the US military.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Millennium_Challenge_2002

Re:US Navy X-47B Robot Fighter Jet Completes First Phase Of ... by adventureful on Saturday June 30, 2012 @07:54PM (#4183204)
No, that only works if the US can't keep coming at you. In that case, you have to be able to sustain massive damage to your economy and military and keep fighting indefinitely (which then guarantees a shift to guerrilla tactics).
Re:US Navy X-47B Robot Fighter Jet Completes First Phase Of ... by molmalo on Saturday June 30, 2012 @10:39PM (#4183611)
This is not 1945.

This is what I think would happen if the events of MC2002 were real:

If an entire fleet and more than 20000 people were killed in a single day of combat, I bet that the US would have a significant political turmoil, much worse than that of Vietnam, and massive protests. Moving an entire fleet to replace the one lost, could take months, hundreds of billions of taxpayer dollars, loss of morale in troops, and an economic disaster (the markets would simply tank to the lowest).

And of course, moving a fleet to replace the one lost, would mean that you have to lower your guard in another front, which itself introduces new kind of problems. Just as an example, moving the 7th fleet would pave the way for China to invade Taiwan. At the same time, China or Russia would be selling more equipment to the other party.

Right-wing groups would ask for a full retaliation, or more possibly, asking for allies to get involved, but that could rapidly escalate to a regional or global conflict, as other countries would try to support the one playing "David" here.

At that point, with the markets falling apart and clamoring for heads to roll, it would simply be unfeasible to continue.

There's even the possibility that some allied economies (Germany?, France?) would probably refuse to help, as the balance of economy tips in their favor, while US markets tank.

Wars are not only resolved with bullets today.

Re:US Navy X-47B Robot Fighter Jet Completes First Phase Of ... by gmrple on Saturday June 30, 2012 @02:26PM (#4182399)
Least ways not in an offensive manner. Though that could be a faulty assumption, we (the US) haven't had any real military attacks on our soil in a while.