Out of curiosity, last year, I purchased some test strips to test my drinking water. The strips showed typical contaminates: arsenic, lead, copper etc. they all registered in the "acceptable range". In the test, there was a test strip for QUATs (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quaternary_ammonium_cation), which caught my attention. It wasn't something that I would have thought to test for, but my water tested positive. I was curious, so I started testing other local water sources including bottled water from various brands; to my surprise they all tested positive for QUATs. The only local water I could find that didn't contain QUATs was distilled.
I thought maybe it was just in my area, so I started taking the test strips with me when I traveled. In the last year, I've tested the drinking water in multiple states and countries, and only one source has tested negative for QUATs. It was the water from a drinking fountain in the San Francisco Airport, interesting enough.
My suspicion is that QUATs are often flushed down the drain, and the molecules must be too small to be filtered out in the water treatment process.
I haven't found much research on the impact of QUATs on the human body, but I can help but think our mitochondria would be susceptible to damage.
We all know the solution: Organic vegetables, lean protein, and lots of exercise.
It might be that they are already exposed to enough processed food and pesticides that simply getting those things out of their diet is not sufficient, but I think it's clear that there's more going on here than a simple answer.
And, I think, most damningly, there are many people who maintain a healthy weight with no active efforts to maintain that weight, including a lack of exercise and consumption of processed food. It might be that a significant fraction of people are resistant to this effect or might just not enjoy the taste of processed food so naturally gain the benefits of avoidance.
There isn't anything even remotely close to a scientific consensus on any of those.
There are plenty of scientists who tell you to stop exercising when you want to lose weight, because the exercise leads you to eat more than you would otherwise, and is ultimately self-defeating -- to focus entirely on eating less, and then only add exercise back in once you've reached you target weight. And "processed food" is a highly non-scientific category that is way, way too disparate to be useful at all.
Organic vegetables might be nice, but there's zero evidence that organic vegetables are better at weight loss than non-organic. Also zero evidence regarding lean protein as opposed to fatty -- there's a big argument that fatty meat is better for weight loss, because the fat satiates so you wind up eating less calories overall.
The person holding the gun is mental issues. Mental issues cause people to eat unhealthily.
A lizard whose bite makes its prey eat less is crazy but it exists.
A lizard whose bite makes its prey eat more is also crazy, but maybe it exists?
The first lizard is literal, the second lizard is a stand-in for whatever mystery force I am postulating the existence of.
When you look at the historic literature on diet and nutrition from the first half of the century it's like looking into another universe. People are obsessed with getting people to eat more to prevent malnutrition even when food is freely available. Something changed.
Mass production and consumerism of food created perverse incentives that resulted in drastic changes to diets - different macronutrient profiles, new ingredients (emulsifiers, artificial sweeteners), and new manufacturing byproducts (residual solvents, pfas, plastic). You can still opt-out of mass produced food and move to the bush to live a subsistence life, and you'll still be ingesting plastic and pfas.
Part of the reason this is so hard to grapple with is that (in the USA) almost no one alive was an adult before the food industry industrialized. I'm 40 and my parents and grandparents rode the initial waves of processed garbage.
Someone joked on twitter that you can save a lot of money if you just eat the same amount of food that you would eat if you were on ozempic, because you'd see the same weight loss.
My only point is that it is not absurd to think that just as ozempic causes you to eat less, it is not ridiculous to speculate that other agents that can cause you to eat more.
How mammals ingest, process, store and burn energy has been well understood for a very long time.
You know why some domestic dogs and cats are overweight? Is it ADHD or microplastics? Of course not, it’s because they’ve been eating more energy thaN they have been burning for a while.
Ozempic only stops you wanting to eat more, which perfectly proves the point. The boogeyman you are searching for is eating more energy than you burn.
Research especially into people with healthy body weight seems to indicate that there is something going on that is causing widespread obesity. That is, there's some sort of environmental "GLP-1 Turbocharger".
Maybe it relates to processed food, maybe it relates to microplastic contamination, maybe it's in the cheese, maybe it's an innocuous viral agent, maybe it's gut biome, maybe it's ADHD drugs, maybe it's SSRIs.
I suspect that Ozempic is helping us get back to a baseline level of exposure by counteracting this. And in the future if we're lucky we'll figure out what it is and try to correct it at the source.