News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The "Everyone gets the source code, donations get you bin... by justincormack on Friday June 29, 2012 @06:39PM (#4179502)
This is not allowed under the GPL, which he is using.
Re:The "Everyone gets the source code, donations get you bin... by A1kmm on Friday June 29, 2012 @06:55PM (#4179569)
If the author owns copyright on every line of code used to make the binary, they can do what they like with it without need for a license.

However, if there is other GPLd software in there, and they are relying on the GPL to be able to distribute it, then you are right, they need to comply with the GPL requirement to distribute everything needed to build it (Makefiles etc...).

Disclaimer: IANAL, this is not legal advice.

Re:The "Everyone gets the source code, donations get you bin... by nothacker on Friday June 29, 2012 @11:43PM (#4180443)
Even though this is incorrect, I agree that this seems to totally violate the spirit of GPL which is meant to be used with free software. It's one thing to open source your code and have people donate to get support and fund development. It's quite another to charge for binaries. Others can just redistribute your binaries instead of you, so what is the point? Also, you are open sourcing and GPL'ing it, and yet you won't follow through and actually provide the built code- that's just shooting yourself in both feet. But, you have to appreciate the fact that he did open source it and that he is trying to make money off of it.
Re:The "Everyone gets the source code, donations get you bin... by jules on Friday June 29, 2012 @07:12PM (#4179643)
Sure it is. Under the GPL you are not allowed to distribute a binary without also distributing the source and dependencies. But it is fine to distribute the source code without bundled dependencies.
Re:The "Everyone gets the source code, donations get you bin... by koenigdavidmj on Friday June 29, 2012 @09:33PM (#4180108)
The problem is that you also need to supply the dependencies that you used to build it (makefiles and such).
Re:The "Everyone gets the source code, donations get you bin... by jules on Friday June 29, 2012 @10:04PM (#4180175)
Certainly. I'm not saying it's a viable business model. As I mentioned elsewhere in this thread, one person could even buy the pre-built binaries and freely redistribute them. The GPL allows this. However the parent is still factually wrong.
Re:The "Everyone gets the source code, donations get you bin... by zem on Friday June 29, 2012 @10:37PM (#4180259)
not to people to whom he's not distributing a binary
Re:The "Everyone gets the source code, donations get you bin... by georgemcbay on Saturday June 30, 2012 @05:55PM (#4182934)
But once he distributes them to one person who gets the binary that person can distribute them freely to everyone else.
Re:The "Everyone gets the source code, donations get you bin... by zem on Sunday July 01, 2012 @10:12PM (#4186936)
and he's perfectly fine with that
Re:The "Everyone gets the source code, donations get you bin... by simonbrown on Friday June 29, 2012 @07:06PM (#4179615)
Is it? From my understanding, he only needs to give the full source (with a GPL license) to people he's distributing the binaries to.
Re:The "Everyone gets the source code, donations get you bin... by jasonlotito on Friday June 29, 2012 @07:19PM (#4179668)
Only if the binaries are released under the GPL.
Re:The "Everyone gets the source code, donations get you bin... by jason_slack on Friday June 29, 2012 @06:42PM (#4179514)
good point. I wasn't trying to imply this was allowed, just another possible model depending upon circumstance.