[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alfred_Noble_Prize
EDIT: typos
https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=John_Hopfield&dif...
[citation needed]
I suppose some might argue that being awarded the Nobel Prize in Physics is enough to call yourself a physicist.
…it does have the unfortunate implication, however, that nominations need not be restricted to physicists at all since any winner becomes a physicist upon receipt of the prize.
It’s sort of like the No True Scotsman but inverted, and with physicists instead of Scotsmen.
Or semiconductor manufacturers.
All the math and CS needed for AI can fit on a napkin, and had been known for 200+ years. It's the extreme scaling enabled by semiconductor science that really makes the difference.
(When the required math was invented is a different question, but I doubt all of it was known 200 years ago.)
There were also plenty of "hacks" involved to make the networks scale such as dropout regularization, batch normalization, semi-linear activation functions (e.g. ReLU) and adaptive stochastic gradient descent methods.
The maths for basic NNs is really simple but the practice of them is really messy.
[1] https://scholar.google.com/citations?view_op=view_citation&h...
This isn't really true. If you read a physics textbook from the early 1900s, they didn't really have multivariate calculus and linear algebra expressed as concisely as we do now. It would take several napkins. Plus, statistical mechanics was quite rudimentary, which is important for probability theory.
This is completely incorrect.
Computer science wasn’t even a thing 100 years ago.
If Newton had the machinery to fit large models to data, he would have done so. No doubt.
Again, I’m unsure that calculus existed at sufficient level 200 years ago — it didn’t appear in modern form from either Leibniz or Newton.
Which category fits better?
Also arguing that NN is used in physics so we can argue nobel prize is okay is like asking for Stephan Wolfram to be awarded Nobel prize for Mathematica which is much more used in physics as a tool. And he is a physicist and had contributions to the field of numerical relativity (The reason he created Mathematica in the first place).
The royal science academy fucked up so much with this choice.