News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Naming of America (2001) by meiraleal on Sunday October 06, 2024 @05:01PM (#41760275)
Intersting. In Brazil we argue that the US isn't America. Great to know that Brazil was first called America, not the US :)
Re:The Naming of America (2001) by philwelch on Sunday October 06, 2024 @08:17PM (#41761566)
Brazil? Do you mean the Federative Republic?
Re:The Naming of America (2001) by jecel on Monday October 07, 2024 @04:35PM (#41770741)
Note that the country's full name has been "República Federativa do Brasil" only since 1968. Between 1889 and 1967 it was "Estados Unidos do Brasil".

https://pt.wikipedia.org/wiki/Estados_Unidos_do_Brasil

Re:The Naming of America (2001) by samatman on Sunday October 06, 2024 @07:05PM (#41761137)
The USA, you mean?
Re:The Naming of America (2001) by meiraleal on Sunday October 06, 2024 @08:05PM (#41761484)
Yeah by US ("Estados Unidos") we mean the USA. Nobody would be taken seriously calling the US "America" in South America.
Re:The Naming of America (2001) by bentley on Sunday October 06, 2024 @08:51PM (#41761737)
The source of this terminology difference is that continents have no universal definition, only societal convention. Romance language–speaking countries tend to teach the six‐continent model with a single America, whereas Anglophone countries like the UK, Australia, and USA teach the seven‐continent model with North and South America. Neither side is wrong, since there’s no universally agreed upon idea of what the continents are, only convention (and neither convention matches the current geological consensus either). The equivalent term to Spanish “America” in English is “the Americas,” not “America.” My Brazilian friends consider themselves “American,” but I’ve never met a Canadian who did.
Re:The Naming of America (2001) by gerdesj on Sunday October 06, 2024 @09:31PM (#41761927)
That's fine. You have your terminology and others have theirs.

It might (not) surprise you to learn that what I call Cyprus is called "Zypern" by Germans and there are a lot more copper related names for the place.

Closer to my home, what I call London is Londres in France and London in German. The city in question was named by a bunch of what would become Italians (Romans) - Londinium was named by a murderous bunch of colonial invaders.

I have insinuated an awful lot from your comment and "replied" to those insinuations as best I can.

I am somebody and I use the term America routinely to describe the USA and the term Americas for the entire continent. North America is US + CA and Southern America is Brazil, Argentina, Peru, Paraguay, Chile, Uruguay and ... oh there are rather a lot more. There is also Central America which is the countries that join the north to the south.

I get that you have an axe to grind about which America is which and who owns which name. I have some sympathy for Brazil getting pissed off about Amazon (the company) too.

I try to understand all points of view - its quite interesting.

Re:The Naming of America (2001) by yulker on Sunday October 06, 2024 @11:18PM (#41762469)
Mexico is part of North America, interesting you left it out.
Re:The Naming of America (2001) by throaway89 on Monday October 07, 2024 @06:11PM (#41771616)
as is Greenland
Re:The Naming of America (2001) by reshlo on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @03:55AM (#41785534)
Along with the Caribbean, Bermuda, and Saint Pierre and Miquelon.
Re:The Naming of America (2001) by throaway89 on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @06:54PM (#41793677)
true but a lot of people understandably assume those are part of Central America
Re:The Naming of America (2001) by meiraleal on Sunday October 06, 2024 @10:06PM (#41762124)
> I have some sympathy for Brazil getting pissed off about Amazon (the company) too.

I never met a Brazilian that cares about it tho. There was a big national uproar a few decades ago when some Japanese company tried to patent the use of the Açaí fruit and trademark.

now about America and Americans. South Americans and North Americans are as much "Americans" as Northern and Southern Europeans are Europeans. Calling themselves THE Americans and the rest latinos (what do they call Canadians? I guess just Canadians) lowers our history and culture. North-Americans or US-Americans or whatever-Americans shouldn't be the ones defining who is American, who is Latino-American, who is Native-American, Afro-American. Not surprising, there isn't a Euro-American tag.

Re:The Naming of America (2001) by shiroiushi on Sunday October 06, 2024 @10:45PM (#41762326)
>Calling themselves THE Americans and the rest latinos

"Latinos" are what Spanish and (to a much lesser extent) Portuguese-speaking people living in the USA call themselves (and their relatives still living in other Latin-American countries). They seem to prefer it to "Hispanics". And the term only applies to people speaking Latin-derived languages (i.e., Spanish and Portuguese). So the people living in Belize, for instance, are not "Latinos" at all.

Similarly, African-Americans were named that way by themselves, to distinguish themselves from the majority white Americans, since they had a very different and unique culture and history. It wasn't some kind of pejorative they were stuck with by outsiders; they came up with it on their own because they were tired of being called "negroes", "colored", or much worse.

You seem to have a very warped perception of who thinks what, and as the other poster said, you obviously have an ax to grind.

People in the USA are called "Americans" because it's (part of) the name of their country, and there's no other convenient and pronounceable demonym to describe them, and there's no other country in the world that has the word "America" in it.

Re:The Naming of America (2001) by jaimebuelta on Monday October 07, 2024 @02:20PM (#41769184)
According to surveys, most people in the US prefer to refer themselves as “Hispanic”, though there’s a generational change

https://www.pewresearch.org/race-and-ethnicity/2024/09/12/u-...

Re:The Naming of America (2001) by SllX on Monday October 07, 2024 @06:39PM (#41771867)
They generally prefer to be called what they are: Mexicans, Salvadorans, Cubans, etc. The ones born here in the US of A even often just prefer Americans sometimes, although that differs from person to person.

Pan-ethnic terms are the creatures of demographers, political scientists and others of the social sciences. We don’t really need that crap and it’s just there to make their jobs easier.

Re:The Naming of America (2001) by fuzztester on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @02:55AM (#41774455)
>People in the USA are called "Americans" because it's (part of) the name of their country, and there's no other convenient and pronounceable demonym to describe them

There is another demonym, although much less used:

USian.

It's quite convenient and pronounceable. Some HNers use it:

>https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&qu...

Also see the Wikipedia definition of the word you used - demonym:

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demonym

The first two sentences at the above link:

>A demonym (/ˈdɛmənɪm/; from Ancient Greek δῆμος (dêmos) 'people, tribe' and ὄνυμα (ónuma) 'name') or gentilic (from Latin gentilis 'of a clan, or gens')[1] is a word that identifies a group of people (inhabitants, residents, natives) in relation to a particular place.[2] Demonyms are usually derived from the name of the place (hamlet, village, town, city, region, province, state, country, and continent).

Re:The Naming of America (2001) by meiraleal on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @07:45AM (#41776263)
I'm going with this one for now on. Thanks!

Thanks also to all USians that commented. As a fellow American, I think we should be more United! :)

Re:The Naming of America (2001) by fuzztester on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @10:49PM (#41795005)
The fact that my sibling comment (by me), about HNerds using racist and derogatory terms like Asian sweatshop, got flagged within seconds after I wote it, shows clearly that it is true, and that racist discrimination exists on HN, despite the vaunted claims by the mods of keeping it as a clean and nice community.

Hah!

Re:The Naming of America (2001) by fuzztester on Saturday October 12, 2024 @09:35PM (#41824430)
All you guys put together, i.e. all countries in both the American continents (North and South), need an American national anthem (not a USian one), to put you on the right track to continental and then world solidarity.
Re:The Naming of America (2001) by meiraleal on Sunday October 20, 2024 @07:44AM (#41894705)
Unfortunately, what's needed is that the USians stop putting themselves as the main character and everyone else supporting. What's more interesting about this American identity is that the US and all other American countries have an almost identical history, the US is only the most prosperous ex-colony. But almost all countries in America were built in a similar manner. It is a continental identity as much as being European, Asian or African.
Re:The Naming of America (2001) by PaulDavisThe1st on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @12:34PM (#41779149)
> "Latinos" are what Spanish and (to a much lesser extent) Portuguese-speaking people living in the USA call themselves (and their relatives still living in other Latin-American countries). They seem to prefer it to "Hispanics".

In my part of the world (Santa Fe, New Mexico), people of "direct" Spanish descent prefer the term "Hispano" to differentiate themselves from both Hispanics (n-th cousins who might still arrive here, but did so after several generations south of Mexico City), and Latinos which is broadly equivalent to Hispanic.

Re:The Naming of America (2001) by jaimebuelta on Monday October 07, 2024 @02:13PM (#41769108)
Interestingly, there’s a word in Spanish for people from the USA that’s “Estadounidense”, literally “Unitedstatian” which is widely used (at least in Spain)

I find it a fascinating word and a way of precisely naming to keep the “American” word to be more broadly applicable, at least in theory

Re:The Naming of America (2001) by bentley on Monday October 07, 2024 @03:07PM (#41769748)
Do people of Estados Unidos Mexicanos count as estadounidense?
Re:The Naming of America (2001) by jolmg on Monday October 07, 2024 @08:59PM (#41772787)
Re:The Naming of America (2001) by adastra22 on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @12:54AM (#41773957)
It is both less specific (there are many countries named “United States of …”) and unpronounceable in English.
Re:The Naming of America (2001) by returningfory2 on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @10:59AM (#41778071)
IMO a better English translation of Estadounidense is United Stateser (like people in Maine are Mainers).
Re:The Naming of America (2001) by adastra22 on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @12:53AM (#41773955)
Americans don’t refer, in English, to the inhabitants of countries south of them as “latinos.” You are simply incorrect on this.

Among Spanish speakers the word is used, but it is a cultural not geographic term. There are ISA and Canadian Latinos too.

Re:The Naming of America (2001) by marcosdumay on Monday October 07, 2024 @06:37PM (#41771851)
> I have some sympathy for Brazil getting pissed off about Amazon (the company) too.

I have never seen anybody pissed about that one. But then, I have never seen anybody insisting that "Amazon" means the company and the geographic region better shut-up and forfeit its name.

Re:The Naming of America (2001) by samatman on Monday October 07, 2024 @12:04AM (#41762698)
The name of our country is the United States of America. Sometimes we call it the US, or United States, sometimes we call it America.

Much as yours is called la República Federativa do Brasil, which you call Brasil for short. Do you ever call it the RF I wonder? Real question, I have no idea.

Whatever you call America, the country, in your language, that's up to you. The Chinese call us 美國, the few of us aware of that are not even slightly bothered by it. Your language, your rules.

You have no right, and no ability, to dictate to Americans how we refer to ourselves and our nation, in our main (but not official) language. We do not care what your name for us is, and we do not care at all what you think about how we refer to ourselves.

For the record, in America we do not think of the Americas as one continent, but rather, two. So Brazilians, as we style you, are South American. Canadians, Mexicans, and Americans, are North Americans. If we need for some reason to refer to the people of both continents we might say "people of the Americas" but this doesn't come up much, just as we might say "Old Worlders" to refer to the megacontinent of Europe, Asia, and Africa.

The chip you carry around on your shoulder does you no credit at all. The notion that because we use a word in the name of our nation to refer to ourselves in some way denigrates the other inhabitants of the two continents, North and South America, which happen to share that word with the name of our nation...

That is 100% a you problem, not an us problem, and not a US problem. Get over it. Or don't.

Re:The Naming of America (2001) by jandrewrogers on Sunday October 06, 2024 @08:33PM (#41761632)
"America" is the only name the country has. Other countries are also called "United States of $FOO", so the USA does not own title to "United States" in the same way no one owns "Democratic Republic" as the name of their country.

Regardless, in most languages and countries, it is just "America" so that ship has sailed. Either way, America or United States, everyone knows which country is being referenced.

Re:The Naming of America (2001) by jltsiren on Sunday October 06, 2024 @09:20PM (#41761866)
The name of the country seems to be the equivalent of either "United States" or "United States of America" in pretty much every language I can read. "America" is an informal name people usually understand, much in the same way they understand when you call the UK "England".
Re:The Naming of America (2001) by yulker on Sunday October 06, 2024 @11:16PM (#41762456)
England is not the UK.
Re:The Naming of America (2001) by arethuza on Monday October 07, 2024 @04:07AM (#41763778)
I think that's the point?
Re:The Naming of America (2001) by dleary on Monday October 07, 2024 @05:04AM (#41764090)
Calling the UK “England” is a different class of error, though. England is a part of the UK.

Analogous would be calling the USA “Texas”.

Calling the UK “Britain” is a much more direct comparison.

United States of America -> America

United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland -> Britain

Re:The Naming of America (2001) by rgblambda on Monday October 07, 2024 @05:46AM (#41764350)
It's not helped when England, Britain and United Kingdom have been viewed as interchangeable terms by UK politicians, famous writers and the general public.

Boris Johnson: "If I am ever asked on the streets of London, or in any other venue, public or private, to produce my ID card as evidence that I am who I say I am, when I have done nothing wrong and am simply ambling along and breathing God’s fresh air like any other freeborn Englishman..."

Rupert Brooke: "If I should die, think only this of me: That there's some corner of a foreign field That is for ever England."

Re:The Naming of America (2001) by graemep on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @03:31AM (#41774623)
No, they are not used interchangeably, even in your examples.

Johnson is giving London as an example of a place in the UK. It is a very apposite example because it is where any power the police are given would be used most heavily (as stop and search is). He is using the the phrase "freeborn Englishman" to evoke associations with the use of the phrase that is far older than the UK. The phrase in its literal sense also excludes women and serfs and I do not think Johnson is aiming for that.

Brooke was writing a poem. He was evoking an effect and a particular sense of place and identify. "England" evokes different associations and and a different emotional response to "the united Kingdom". It is more local, and cosy, and has visual associations (the "English countryside" vs "the Scottish countryside" for example).

Re:The Naming of America (2001) by RugnirViking on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @05:00AM (#41775194)
Both of these simply use the word england, they are not incorrect. Yes, some people are from a place called england, just like some people are from texas, and may write poetry or wax lyrical about how they like being from texas and what it means to them
Re:The Naming of America (2001) by HarHarVeryFunny on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @11:48AM (#41778677)
[Great] Britain is an island

England is a country (part of Britain, together with Wales & Scotland)

The United Kingdom [of Great Britain and Northern Ireland], is an alliance of countries.

I'd hope that most citizens of the UK wouldn't regard these as interchangeable, and just because an Englishman waxes poetic about England doesn't mean he's unaware that it's part of the UK, etc.

Re:The Naming of America (2001) by meiraleal on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @07:41AM (#41786777)
> The United Kingdom [of Great Britain and Northern Ireland], is an alliance of countries.

No, it is not. The UK is ONE sovereign state/country, the rest are states/provinces/whatever, even tho some people living in this country might disagree and wish to separate themselves to become a full sovereign state.

Re:The Naming of America (2001) by HarHarVeryFunny on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @09:47PM (#41794710)
You're right, of course about the UK. It seems that maybe the most accurate (and/or historically appropriate) label for England, Wales, Scotland, and I suppose Northern Ireland, are "non-sovereign countries", or more sloppily I guess the UK and England can both be called countries ("a country within a country") with the distinction implied.
Re:The Naming of America (2001) by standardUser on Monday October 07, 2024 @02:05PM (#41768979)
No individual US state has anywhere near the economic, historic, political or social hegemony over the rest of the nation state as is seen with England in the UK. In a lot of contexts outside of the UK, saying "England" is completely comprehensible as meaning the UK, regardless of correctness. No one is going to say "England invaded Iraq" and be confused.
Re:The Naming of America (2001) by chihuahua on Monday October 07, 2024 @02:18PM (#41769166)
Let's be logical about this:

(United States of) America -> America

(Federal Republic of) Germany -> Germany

(United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern) Ireland -> Ireland

Re:The Naming of America (2001) by throaway89 on Monday October 07, 2024 @06:09PM (#41771595)
England annexed Wales and Ireland and would have annexed Scotland if it didn't use marriage instead.
Re:The Naming of America (2001) by thoroughburro on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @08:22AM (#41776541)
> would have annexed Scotland if it didn't use marriage instead

Would have tried, perhaps.

Re:The Naming of America (2001) by throaway89 on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @07:09PM (#41782728)
Im sure the Scots would have fought to the last Scotsman, but I think they would lose in the end.
Re:The Naming of America (2001) by Yeul on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @12:38PM (#41779188)
The Netherlands is often called "Holland" which technically doesn't even exist anymore.

But of course Dutch people don't really care what foreigners call the country, they can use whatever name they come up with it doesn't matter. Although it's nice that Germany gets it right. These kind of arguments speak to the fragile ego of some nations.

Re:The Naming of America (2001) by meiraleal on Sunday October 06, 2024 @09:58PM (#41762074)
America being the name of the country isn't a problem, the problem is the people from this country calling Americans "latinos". Or Native-Americans, or Whatever-Americans because the only Americans are themselves.
Re:The Naming of America (2001) by gotoeleven on Sunday October 06, 2024 @10:31PM (#41762261)
The main reason people call themselves $HYPHENATION-americans is because they want some free stuff from the government for their particular $HYPHENATION
Re:The Naming of America (2001) by blovescoffee on Monday October 07, 2024 @04:36AM (#41763928)
What free stuff do Jewish Americans, Italian Americans, Asian Americans, get?
Re:The Naming of America (2001) by rgblambda on Monday October 07, 2024 @05:50AM (#41764372)
Spare a thought for the poor Scots-Irish who didn't think to add American to their hyphenated identity. I'm sure they're missing out on so much free stuff.
Re:The Naming of America (2001) by pessimizer on Monday October 07, 2024 @09:51PM (#41773064)
This is absolutely the reason. Except in the case of black people, for which it was something imposed by white people during the Clinton administration as a sort of twisted apology for destroying the Rainbow Coalition (who popularized "African-American.")

Once people saw that slaves and their descendants might be compensated in some way, or treated in a special way by government in lieu of compensation, they all wanted to become black. So after 1965 (the end of legal segregation in the US) they started hyphenating their ethnicities, or in the case of "hispanic," making up new ethnicities from whole cloth.

Compensation for slavery isn't "free stuff." You should give up your inheritance.

Re:The Naming of America (2001) by allknowingfrog on Monday October 07, 2024 @06:14PM (#41771648)
There was a time when "Black" was considered offensive and "African-American" was the generally-approved nomenclature. You seem to be implying that the "-American" pattern emerged as some sort of white conspiracy to paint everyone else as less American, but my understanding is that the opposite is true. Language and social preferences evolve over time, and that one has simply come and gone as the "correct" option of the day.

As a generally "white" person (of roughly western European descent), I will happily use any set of labels that keeps people from glaring at me. I feel pretty strongly that unpleasant language is a symptom of prejudice, not a cause. If changing words could change hearts and minds, I think we would have seen it happen by now.

Re:The Naming of America (2001) by JohnMakin on Monday October 07, 2024 @06:24PM (#41771741)
> There was a time when "Black" was considered offensive and "African-American" was the generally-approved nomenclature.

Eh, this is a little inaccurate - I don't think anyone but white people worked themselves up about this, and the distinction between "black" and "african american" was made because Americans with slave ancestry are not the only people who have dark skin color. It's also still in use and hasn't gone anywhere. AFAIK you've always been able to refer to a black person as black without offense, but of course, people have used that as a mild slur or with insulting connotations.

Re:The Naming of America (2001) by Izkata on Monday October 07, 2024 @07:56PM (#41772399)
Whether or not it was mainly white people who did this, I do remember when I was a kid (late 90s/early 2000s) there was a hard push to just swap "black" for "African-American" no matter how little sense it made, because "black" was considered offensive. It's how we got one particular addition to the "ignorant American" meme videos, where people would go on vacation to Europe or Africa and call a black person born and living there "African-American". It's also why Elon Musk generally isn't considered African-American, even though he has a better claim to the label than most.
Re:The Naming of America (2001) by JohnMakin on Monday October 07, 2024 @08:30PM (#41772609)
These narratives were not driven by black people. I know what you are referring to. It was never considered an offensive term by anyone who had any stake in it, it was purely contrived and performative nonsense for being “aware” when it was signaling only that they absolutely were not. Just my 2c as a PoC
Re:The Naming of America (2001) by adastra22 on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @12:44AM (#41773916)
Same goes for Indian vs Native American, which this thread started off with. Few Indians are offended by the phrase “Native American”, but it is cumbersome and not used to describe themselves. They’re perfectly fine with the term “Indian” and prefer it, even if it is etymologically wrong (sorry to the South Asians out there).

It’s an outsider combining in and saying “no, people can’t call you black” [or “Indian”] that is weirdly controlling and oppressive.

Re:The Naming of America (2001) by graemep on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @03:41AM (#41774678)
I wondered about how the majority of people belonging to those two groups felt about it.

I am quite surprised that "Indian" is still acceptable in a country as sensitive about vocabulary as the US - its very much a colonial term. Then again "America" is, if named after Vespucci, is named after a slave owner and trader which does not seem to bother anyone (which is odd in an age when other things are being renamed).

I prefer "Native American" because, as British Sri Lankan (lived in both countries) Indian just has a different meaning to me.

> It’s an outsider combining in and saying “no, people can’t call you black” [or “Indian”] that is weirdly controlling and oppressive.

Yes, and we have that problem in the UK too. I find it very amusing that South Asians (particularly those actually in South Asia who are not much subject to western influence) will use phrases about themselves (e.g. "coloured") that would shock westerners.

We are also getting a lot more policing of language in the UK. It is actually quite oppressive, and disadvantages recent immigrants (and people from the wrong background) who do not know the right vocabulary.

Re:The Naming of America (2001) by adastra22 on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @04:25AM (#41774963)
> I prefer "Native American" because, as British Sri Lankan (lived in both countries) Indian just has a different meaning to me.

Well that's the thing, you're not indigenous American, so you don't really get a say. Neither am I, btw. We're getting into moral discussions here, but if anyone should be granted one thing, it's the right to choose for themselves what group name they prefer. There wasn't, generally speaking, a common name in the indigenous American languages for the people of the americas, separate and distinct from the word for "people" which would have included the invading conquistadors from Europe. So “Indian” was as good as any, even though it was already the name of a people halfway around the world. [Although to be pedantic, it was meant to refer to the people of modern-day Indonesia, Malaysia, and South-East Asia, not the Indian subcontinent. He thought at first he'd landed in Indonesia. Then he thought maybe Japan or China. He was a confused dude.]

It is right and proper that people should be able to decide for themselves what they want others to call them, and the indigenous people of the United States prefer to be called "Indians." The clunky term "Native American" was repurposed from a very different meaning to apply to Indians during the civil rights era, not by Indians themselves but by misguided activists and civil rights fighters who patronizingly thought they were doing tribes a favor by decolonizing their language. Ironically, the very act of mandating what terms they should use to describe themselves is peak colonialism.

If you go to tribal land and talk to the people living there--and I've had some wonderful conversations with people on the Hopi and Navajo reservations--they'll tell you that they prefer that you use their specific tribal name to identify them, but if you must group multiple tribes together then they prefer the term Indian, they've always referred to themselves as Indian, and they have no desire to change that, thank you very much.

Re:The Naming of America (2001) by PaulDavisThe1st on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @12:27PM (#41779089)
> “We were enslaved as American Indians, we were colonized as American Indians, and we will gain our freedom as American Indians and then we can call ourselves anything we damn please,”

- Russell Means, a Lakota activist, wrote in his 1998 essay, “I Am An American Indian, Not a Native American!” https://compusci.com/indian/

See also: https://www.fair360.com/medialib/uploads/2020/11/Native-Amer...

Re:The Naming of America (2001) by vundercind on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @09:42AM (#41777280)
Mann’s introduction to (I think it was) 1491 has a section on his settling on “Indian” as his term in the book for (most of the—there’s some nuance) indigenous Americans and their decedents, and he doesn’t go into great detail, but it reads like he kept using “Native American” around… well, Indians, with whom he was speaking to learn more about topics for the book, and they consistently rolled their eyes and told him to just say “Indian”, so after a great deal of this he finally relented and settled on that as the most-OK term to use. I recall it because I found the passage amusing.
Re:The Naming of America (2001) by pessimizer on Monday October 07, 2024 @09:40PM (#41773001)
> here was a hard push to just swap "black" for "African-American" no matter how little sense it made, because "black" was considered offensive.

This was a hard push from white people toward other white people, about being offended on the behalf of black people. Black people have never liked the term African-American, and most don't use it. The reasons why white people on either side of the "debate" wouldn't notice this or would operate as if this weren't true are left as an exercise for the reader.

-----

1991: Poll Says Most Blacks Prefer 'Black' to 'African-American' https://www.nytimes.com/1991/01/29/us/poll-says-most-blacks-...

2021: New Poll Shows Black People Prefer to be Called Simply ‘Black’ Over ‘African American,’ Hispanics Aren’t Keen to Newly-Formed Label ‘LatinX’ https://atlantablackstar.com/2021/08/11/new-poll-shows-black...

Here's a stupid article pretending that black people who still call themselves black in 2012 are space aliens or Amish, when there was never a point when black people didn't call themselves black: Some blacks insist: 'I'm not African-American' https://www.nbcnews.com/id/wbna46264191

Re:The Naming of America (2001) by Izkata on Monday October 07, 2024 @10:06PM (#41773153)
> This was a hard push from white people toward other white people, about being offended on the behalf of black people. Black people have never liked the term African-American, and most don't use it.

Doesn't matter because that's not the point of my comment. The person I was responding to said:

> and the distinction between "black" and "african american" was made because Americans with slave ancestry are not the only people who have dark skin color.

My point is there was no distinction. At the time, in the US, those two terms referred to the same group of people. The push was to replace "black" with "African-American", not to use whichever term was more appropriate.

Re:The Naming of America (2001) by kitd on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @10:18AM (#41777647)
> There was a time when "Black" was considered offensive and "African-American" was the generally-approved nomenclature.

This culminated in an epic television moment when an American interviewer asked Kris Akabusi, a black British 400m runner, what his victory meant "as a British African-American".

Re:The Naming of America (2001) by dghughes on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @12:06PM (#41778899)
Here in Canada at least my generation it was The States, The US, even The Boston States but never America.

I also now hear America now from younger people (< age 30) and people now also use the "word" y'all too.

Even US football which never got a second look even Canadian football was mocked (two of nine total teams had the same name) now people have Superbowl parties.

Culture creep is causing USization more rapidly in Canada.

Re:The Naming of America (2001) by cyberax on Monday October 07, 2024 @01:38PM (#41768638)
There are two countries with the words "United States" in the name: the USA and Mexico. There is only one country with the word "America" in it. So "America" as an informal name for the USA is appropriate.
Re:The Naming of America (2001) by sbassi on Monday October 07, 2024 @06:23PM (#41771726)
it is not appropriate for non-US people since the name "America" clash with how they name the continent (America), so they believe that Americans are "stealing" the name of the continent for themselves. While Americans don't think so because they don't even think there is such a continent, there are 2 continents for them.
Re:The Naming of America (2001) by SllX on Monday October 07, 2024 @08:00PM (#41772421)
As an American, I believe continents are a useless fiction that don’t properly account for how land is actually divided on the crust of the Earth and disregards small continental areas which ought to be accounted for if we’re to believe Europe and Asia are different continents. There are also two different six continent models taught in the world in addition to the seven continent model I was taught: Europe and Asia as Eurasia and North and South America as the Americas.

Personally I don’t care what you call us in other languages, but in English it’s just “Americans”.

Re:The Naming of America (2001) by Izkata on Monday October 07, 2024 @08:00PM (#41772423)
> since the name "America" clash with how they name the continent (America)

There are two continents, "North America" and "South America". To refer to the whole, you pluralize it as "the Americas".

Re:The Naming of America (2001) by mkl on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @02:59AM (#41774464)
The number of continents and their names vary between cultures and languages. In Latin America, the Americas are considered a single continent called America: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Continent#Number
Re:The Naming of America (2001) by graemep on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @03:44AM (#41774696)
I assume someone from one of those cultures would not call it America.

Major places (and IMO it is a mark of the importance of a place) have different names in different languages. London does, Germany does, Japan does,....

Re:The Naming of America (2001) by jjtheblunt on Monday October 07, 2024 @02:15PM (#41769129)
i'm from the united states of america, mid 50s, and i always thought it's pretty random "america" implies the united states too.
Re:The Naming of America (2001) by adastra22 on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @12:47AM (#41773932)
Literally the only country with “America” in its name tho.
Re:The Naming of America (2001) by jjtheblunt on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @01:55PM (#41779971)
good point