The less cynical answer: they have a business relationship with Uber. They looked at Uber’s logo as they were ordering. Uber took their money. Uber is who appears in their bank statement. They had no control over which driver drives them, Uber did. They had no information about the driver except what little Uber provided them with. If not for Uber they would have never been able to connect with the driver. Uber’s reputation is why they trusted the driver.
> They use minimal vetting on those drivers, and they often look the other way when accounts are rented out illicitly, swapped-in vehicles go unreported, and other hijinks on the driver's end.
Sounds like very good reasons why Uber is liable then?
> How could they possibly even be aware of issues which would affect a driver behind the wheel, or the vehicle on the road?
It also sounds like your very own comment answers this question. By vetting the drivers. By checking the cars. By not looking the other way when accounts are rented illicitly, and so on and so on.
https://www.uber.com/us/en/safety/#
There’s auto insurance to help protect you Leading auto insurance providers help protect riders and drivers on the Uber app. Uber maintains commercial auto insurance in case of a covered accident, including at least $1 million in liability insurance on behalf of drivers and delivery people once a ride is accepted.
https://www.uber.com/us/en/safety/#
“ There’s auto insurance to help protect you Leading auto insurance providers help protect riders and drivers on the Uber app. Uber maintains commercial auto insurance in case of a covered accident, including at least $1 million in liability insurance on behalf of drivers and delivery people once a ride is accepted.”
They not only wrote the app, but they host the service and charge the end customer - you aren't paying the driver, you pay uber, who clip the ticket and then pay the remainder on (less taxes) to the driver.
This is like saying "So if an employee of a hotel booked through Booking.com steals your laptop, Booking.com should be responsible?", where the answer is no. When you book on Booking.com or Airbnb you are freely choosing where you stay, and using the platform only as a marketplace.
However, in Uber's case, you are supposedly insured by uber, and you hire them to provide a service, which is then assigned to a driver. You can't choose the driver you get, or the car or whatever, so it's not a marketplace.
A case like Airbnb would also be any flight booking app like Expedia or Skyscanner, where you can see what multiple airlines offer and choose from them, and then book with the airline. If something happens, you file a claim or lawsuit against the airline.
Edit: I'm not talking about factual law, IANAL and I'm not in the US so there's that. I'm talking about what it _should_ be and what _would_ be fair.
Is there an allegation of negligence on Uber's part? For example, did the driver have a history of accidents? If so, I could see liability extending to them.
Maybe (probably) the driver is at fault but as a customer, you only did business with Uber so you should sue Uber and get their money and then Uber should sue the driver and get their money (or their insurance money).
So they are liable to some extent.
If the ill-fated ride was properly insured, why is this family so destitute from it? Didn't it pay out enough?
Some protection, up to the limits of policy? Yes.
If I incur $200K in medical bills because of your negligence in an accident, and you're insured for $100K? I'm taking that $100K from your insurer, and filing suit against you for the other $100K.
(Whether or not I'll get it, and how quickly, etc., is a separate matter, but you don't get to say "Oh, no, I was insured, and they paid you, so I am indemnified now, regardless of how well that payment reflected what you were entitled to.")
This is about the terms of use.
> I honestly don't understand, at all, what sort of liability would be in Uber's camp.
> Uber ... do their damndest to pretend that the drivers do not work for Uber.
If I am in a vehicle accident and hit by a commercial vehicle (and in fact I have been, though not an Uber, vehicle totaled and I was injured), the insurance policy is held by the employer, and generally I would also sue the employer, not the individual driver (and if I did, I would expect that the employer or their insurer would come between us).
The whole "pretending they don't work for Uber" is a free pass to all sorts of shenanigans. You're right, "how could they be possibly be aware?" - but that's the point, they're doing these things to try not to be aware, for exactly these reasons (as well as the employment benefits and local regulation crap).
You can, as you say, blame the driver. It's not clear from my reading the article who is at fault here for the accident. But there's a broader liability issue: does Uber engage in practices that make such an accident more likely? Do they do so knowing this?
Example: imagine Uber lets a driver continually take rides for 30 hours straight. At some point the driver is fatigued and is more likely to crash. This is a foreseeable issue so, if it were true (and I'm not saying it is; this is just an example), Uber could still be liable.
The Uber ToS of course seek to limit liability by forfeiting rights and submitting to binding arbitration. This state court has upheld the enforceability of the Uber ToS. That's not binding on any other state so this has a long way to go before becoming a useful legal precedent.
This is an illusion they have been keen to promote in many places, but one which has been shattered in various courts. Drivers are considered workers or even employees in some countries[1].
> They use minimal vetting on those drivers, and they often look the other way when accounts are rented out illicitly, swapped-in vehicles go unreported, and other hijinks on the driver's end. How could they possibly even be aware of issues which would affect a driver behind the wheel, or the vehicle on the road?
Indeed, and this is a major problem, companies should not be able to run with such poor practices and such little accountability.
[1] https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2021/feb/19/uber-driv...
Uber is a tech company that basically writes an app and maintains servers. They do their damndest to pretend that the drivers do not work for Uber. They use minimal vetting on those drivers, and they often look the other way when accounts are rented out illicitly, swapped-in vehicles go unreported, and other hijinks on the driver's end. How could they possibly even be aware of issues which would affect a driver behind the wheel, or the vehicle on the road?
Since all that Uber does is write an app, then this family should be targeting the sole person who may bear any responsibility or liability: the driver themselves. It's the driver's personal vehicle: it's not a fleet model, and Uber neither provides these, nor even inspects them! It's all on the driver and the driver's insurance, so let the drivers be sued.
Article says nothing about whether they've pursued this avenue, but just attempts to garner outrage over Uber's perceived invulnerability here.