News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:As Florida Storms Worsen, Some in Tampa Bay Wonder: Is Li... by irrational on Saturday September 28, 2024 @12:15PM (#41681156)
I'm fine with them living there as long as the rest of us don't have to pay anything to bail them out when the inevitable hurricane or tornado comes through. These aren't like earthquakes and volcanoes that are relatively rare. They literally have a hurricane season. Imagine if we had a volcano season.
Re:As Florida Storms Worsen, Some in Tampa Bay Wonder: Is Li... by bbqfog on Saturday September 28, 2024 @12:25PM (#41681227)
For second homes, mansions on the beach... totally. There are a lot of impoverished people in the area that won't be able to move though. I have no idea what will happen, but short of some sort of assisted mass-relocation, it doesn't look good.
Re:As Florida Storms Worsen, Some in Tampa Bay Wonder: Is Li... by JumpCrisscross on Saturday September 28, 2024 @01:25PM (#41681634)
> a lot of impoverished people in the area that won't be able to move

Instead of providing assistance to rebuild, if the property is in a fucked place, provide money to move.

Re:As Florida Storms Worsen, Some in Tampa Bay Wonder: Is Li... by threatofrain on Saturday September 28, 2024 @12:46PM (#41681379)
IMO it is wrong to sell this land to people. It is debt-laden land that will crush most people. It's like I sold you cheap land and you later find out you're going to get cancer there and insurance won't cover you.

How is this any different from selling people exploitive loans to desperate people?

Re:As Florida Storms Worsen, Some in Tampa Bay Wonder: Is Li... by willidiots on Saturday September 28, 2024 @12:30PM (#41681261)
How about the rest of the eastern US? Billion dollar climate disasters are hitting everything, not just coastal cities in Florida and WUI towns in California. There was just massive flooding in Tennessee due to Hurricane Helene - are they at fault for living in "hurricane country"?

Climate related disasters are intensifying everywhere. What's now "inevitable" may have been unthinkable when some of these folks moved there.

Re:As Florida Storms Worsen, Some in Tampa Bay Wonder: Is Li... by yababa_y on Saturday September 28, 2024 @12:36PM (#41681310)
Tennessee? The one with the famous river valley that used to catastrophically flood pretty regularly?
Re:As Florida Storms Worsen, Some in Tampa Bay Wonder: Is Li... by thunky on Saturday September 28, 2024 @10:53PM (#41684489)
How about Asheville NC then
Re:As Florida Storms Worsen, Some in Tampa Bay Wonder: Is Li... by Der_Einzige on Saturday September 28, 2024 @12:51PM (#41681418)
Californias only serious risk is the big one earthquake, but that could hit anywhere on the west coast.

West coast best coast.

Re:As Florida Storms Worsen, Some in Tampa Bay Wonder: Is Li... by ghaff on Saturday September 28, 2024 @12:56PM (#41681458)
And wildfires in many areas.
Re:As Florida Storms Worsen, Some in Tampa Bay Wonder: Is Li... by ineedaj0b on Saturday September 28, 2024 @01:36PM (#41681707)
the wildfires could be mitigated by controlled burns but knowing the gov in California, it'll never happen.

eventually seismic activity will pick up too.

Re:As Florida Storms Worsen, Some in Tampa Bay Wonder: Is Li... by deepfriedchokes on Saturday September 28, 2024 @03:18PM (#41682384)
The other problem is the government can’t force controlled burns on private property. And there’s a lot of private property.

I almost lost my fire insurance last year because my neighbor doesn’t keep his property up, for decades. The agent initially rejected my renewal due to pictures taken from an inspection they did that showed a ton of downed trees but they were across my property line.

Re:As Florida Storms Worsen, Some in Tampa Bay Wonder: Is Li... by Ekaros on Saturday September 28, 2024 @12:30PM (#41681264)
And well for both earthquakes and volcanoes the effected areas are now well known. It could be set that simply any new building moving forwards is not covered. There is plenty enough space in areas with lower risks, so people should be directed towards there. Eventually this will naturally empty the risk prone areas.
Re:As Florida Storms Worsen, Some in Tampa Bay Wonder: Is Li... by paradox460 on Saturday September 28, 2024 @12:32PM (#41681278)
Should we extend this logic to charging California climate tax every summer, when their inevitable wildfire pollutes the air for two states over?
Re:As Florida Storms Worsen, Some in Tampa Bay Wonder: Is Li... by threatofrain on Saturday September 28, 2024 @12:51PM (#41681419)
There are wildfires that happen in Oregon as well, why shouldn't there be a special cooperation between the western states to divvy up burden? But that should be a cooperation between just those states and not a federal matter.

Also, federal assistance programs largely transfers wealth from "blue" states to "red" states. Proposing less federal assistance or some kind of "fairer" tax program isn't going to persuade in the direction you think. It's just going to mean more money for blue states to handle their own internal matters.

Re:As Florida Storms Worsen, Some in Tampa Bay Wonder: Is Li... by biftek on Saturday September 28, 2024 @12:34PM (#41681292)
Unironically yes
Re:As Florida Storms Worsen, Some in Tampa Bay Wonder: Is Li... by freedomben on Saturday September 28, 2024 @12:45PM (#41681369)
As a resident of Idaho and former resident of Utah who has spent years having to suffer from the smoke, I have a similar tendency to take this suggestion seriously. Not as a punishment, but as an incentive to improve things. California has neglected things like electrical grid repairs (PG&E anyone?) and controlled burns for many, many years, and now others who had nothing to do with it are paying for it with our health. I know people who are sensitive to the smoke and are essentially trapped in their houses during those times, and have to spend hundreds of dollars on air cleaners.

So, it's an interesting idea to change the choice from: either "don't spend the money" or "spend the money on prevention and fixing our shit"

To: from "the money is spent either way, might as well fix our shit."

If there's also one state that has demonstrated a willingness to use economics to encourage "correct" choices/behavior in consumers, it's California, so they should be real sympathetic to this idea :-)

I don't know if I'd support such a proposal or not. That would require some serious analysis and consideration of the details, but I don't think we should just dismiss the whole idea.

Re:As Florida Storms Worsen, Some in Tampa Bay Wonder: Is Li... by Dr_Birdbrain on Saturday September 28, 2024 @12:39PM (#41681334)
But even if everybody moved out of California, there would still be wildfires that blow smoke two states over.
Re:As Florida Storms Worsen, Some in Tampa Bay Wonder: Is Li... by freedomben on Saturday September 28, 2024 @12:46PM (#41681387)
For the fully natural wildfires, yes of course. It definitely happens.

But there are plenty of things that can be done to reduce the number of wildfires. Remember the fires caused by old and poorly maintained PG&E lines?

Re:As Florida Storms Worsen, Some in Tampa Bay Wonder: Is Li... by scruple on Saturday September 28, 2024 @03:34PM (#41682473)
We don't even have to go that far back.

The Airport Fire that just burned in Orange and Riverside counties was started by some county public works employees pushing boulders around with a bulldozer (to build a barricade preventing motorcyclists from going into the canyons and starting a wildfire) on a red flag day, literally at the peak of the heat hottest day of the entire year.

This sort of shit should see whoever sent them out there fired for gross misconduct and potentially charged. I certainly wouldn't keep my job if I fucked up that badly.

Re:As Florida Storms Worsen, Some in Tampa Bay Wonder: Is Li... by JumpCrisscross on Saturday September 28, 2024 @12:59PM (#41681481)
Honestly yes, particularly if the source is human, e.g. arson or PG&E. There is also a negligence factor in Sacramento avoiding controlled burns because they sold building permits up against every forest.
Re:As Florida Storms Worsen, Some in Tampa Bay Wonder: Is Li... by s1artibartfast on Saturday September 28, 2024 @01:20PM (#41681606)
RE housing, I think it makes sense to price in some of the real risk factors tied to location. I have a friend whos is a wildfire behavior analyst and occasionally is paid to speak with mountain communities.

They are under strict orders not to say the blunt truth as they put it "you have one exit and in the middle of an unstoppable fuel load. in case of fire,you are all fucked and will die".

Instead they have to say something along the lines of that they should do everything within their economic power to reduce their fire risk.

On the part of pollution from wildfires, I'm much more ambivalent. A smoke filled West Coast was the norm in fall prior to California fire suppression.

Re:As Florida Storms Worsen, Some in Tampa Bay Wonder: Is Li... by JumpCrisscross on Saturday September 28, 2024 @01:24PM (#41681628)
> smoke filled West Coast was the norm in fall prior to California fire suppression

Genuinely curious for the evidence on this, if you have it.

Re:As Florida Storms Worsen, Some in Tampa Bay Wonder: Is Li... by s1artibartfast on Saturday September 28, 2024 @03:39PM (#41682501)
Sure. There is a large body of literature looking at fire occurrence intervals prior to suppression. It is based of tree rings as well as other data sources.

It has been estimated that 5 to 12 million acres burned in California per year prior to 1850 [1], [2]. As a comparison, California’s 2000–2020 average burned acreage is 0.79 million acres per year [2]. 2020 was the largest wildfire year in California's recorded history, with nearly 4.5 million acres burned, which is on the low end for the historical average.

Last time I went down this rabbit hole I found several archival records and letters from settlers and surveyors describing California smoke and haze from the 1800's, but unfortunately I cant produce them for you. They described how the Sierra Nevada would be blanketed with smoke in the fall, and that it would linger in the central valley as a dim haze. If by chance you come across these, please let me know.

There is also ample biological evidence in the fire adapted ecology of California, where many plants require fire to reproduce and spread. This comports with the burn studies that estimates the burn interval for most California biomes to be between 3 and 20 years, with 3 years being typical for grasslands and steppes, 10 being typical for redwood forests, and 20 being more common for the pines forests.

Of course there is more to wildfire and smoke than simple acreage, and the quantity of fuel and hardwoods currently being burnt is greater as a result of our 150 year hiatus from wildfire. That said, the pre-1850 average was literally an order of magnitude greater than post 2000, which goes a long way in bridging this difference.

Here is a paper on Wildfire acreage:

[1] https://www.sierraforestlegacy.org/Resources/Conservation/Fi...

[2] https://ww2.arb.ca.gov/sites/default/files/classic/cc/SB901_...

here is some information historic fire intervals:

https://fireecology.springeropen.com/articles/10.4996/fireec...

https://www.researchgate.net/publication/228116866_Historic_...

Re:As Florida Storms Worsen, Some in Tampa Bay Wonder: Is Li... by Dr_Birdbrain on Saturday September 28, 2024 @12:38PM (#41681318)
In California, we have a fire season.
Re:As Florida Storms Worsen, Some in Tampa Bay Wonder: Is Li... by Molitor5901 on Saturday September 28, 2024 @12:43PM (#41681355)
What if we just federalize assistance and help everyone, regardless of where they live and what disasters they must contend with?
Re:As Florida Storms Worsen, Some in Tampa Bay Wonder: Is Li... by JumpCrisscross on Saturday September 28, 2024 @12:48PM (#41681402)
> What if we just federalize assistance and help everyone, regardless of where they live and what disasters they must contend with?

We get this mess. Local governments selling building permits in flood and wildfire zones because they get cash in the short term while others pay in the long.

We’re seeing in Florida, for example, a recapitulation of the financial crisis, down to bogus ratings of undercapitalised insurers allowing risky mortgages to be passed along to banks, Fannie and Freddie [1].

[1] https://www.hbs.edu/ris/Publication%20Files/24-051_f1329bc3-...

Re:As Florida Storms Worsen, Some in Tampa Bay Wonder: Is Li... by randcraw on Saturday September 28, 2024 @01:35PM (#41681700)
The right question is, what should the role of federal vs state vs local government be in natural disasters, especially those that occur often in an high-risk area?

Personal insurance must cover 100% of personal property loss, not governments (at any level) which are obliged to serve the population fairly and uniformly. Local government alone is responsible for rebuilding lost local infrastructure -- roads, power, sewer, and schools. Presumably state government would marshal emergency response from outlying communities, and perhaps coordinate financial resources to rebuild.

Federalizing recovery will pass along the cost of disaster recovery to everyone, not just those who build homes in the paths of hurricanes or in low lying areas which flood frequently. That is the role of personal property insurance. The companies who insure against flood, fire, and wind damage are a far better source of indemnifying the risk incurred by each home and neighborhood than is any government. Then the homeowner can choose to insure or not. But no government should pass along the costs of higher risk by some to others who chose a lower risk. That would clearly be unjust.

Re:As Florida Storms Worsen, Some in Tampa Bay Wonder: Is Li... by standardUser on Saturday September 28, 2024 @12:46PM (#41681386)
If anything, we should spend that money to help people willingly relocate, not encourage more people to move to increasingly dangerous areas. Hurricanes are getting worse and will continue to get worse for the foreseeable future.

What you are suggesting is subsidizing people to live in economically impractical regions, specifically regions we know will get worse and more costly. I don't see the logic there at all.

Re:As Florida Storms Worsen, Some in Tampa Bay Wonder: Is Li... by EasyMark on Saturday September 28, 2024 @09:58PM (#41684253)
That’s a really bad use of resources. It may sound cruel, but don’t build somewhere that constant, every 5-10 years, a natural disaster is going to come through and wipe out your house.
Re:As Florida Storms Worsen, Some in Tampa Bay Wonder: Is Li... by EasyMark on Saturday September 28, 2024 @09:56PM (#41684239)
This is why I say let the free market decide what insurance will pay. There is no reason someone should have to subsidize someone’s choice to live on the coast just because the state government demands it. I can understand socializing costs within reason; when a house is gonna get razed every 5-10 years by a hurricane or other natural disaster I’d say that ridiculous and shouldn’t get subsidized or regulated and market conditions will fix it in a decade or two.