News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by knodi123 on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @09:02AM (#41646995)
There's plenty of evidence. He confessed to his girlfriend, and a cellmate. He pawned the victim's possessions. He was seen disposing of bloody clothes. He already had 15 felony convictions in addition to offenses related to Ms. Gayle's murder: robbery (2), armed criminal action (2), assault (2), burglary (4), stealing (3), stealing a motor vehicle, and unlawful use of a weapon.

Now, as to whether this evidence is solid enough for a death penalty conviction, that's tougher to say. But there's plenty of evidence.

Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by diogenes_atx on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @11:38AM (#41648606)
As stated in the article written by the legal scholars at the Innocence Project:

> "There is no reliable evidence proving that Marcellus Williams committed the crime for which he is scheduled to be executed on Sept. 24. The State destroyed or corrupted the evidence that could conclusively prove his innocence and the available DNA and other forensic crime-scene evidence does not match him."

DNA evidence is based on proven science, and the DNA evidence that was not destroyed by the state is exculpatory.

Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by makomk on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @01:54PM (#41650023)
As far as I can tell, this isn't actually true: "the DNA evidence that was not destroyed by the state is exculpatory". The Innocence Project are being very careful with their wording here. Initially, they relied on trace DNA on the knife that didn't match the accused murderer, but that ended up being from someone in the prosecutor's office handling it after it had been processed for forensic evidence. Then they tried to argue that this showed the state had destroyed evidence which would've proved his innocence, but the courts didn't buy it because all available evidence suggests the killer's DNA was simply never on the knife. (Which isn't that surprising - DNA evidence isn't perfect and gloves exist.) The other "forensic crime scene evidence" seems to be hothingburgers like a few non-matching hairs in a house that'd had a large number of people going in and out in the recent past.
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by rysertio on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @04:34PM (#41651581)
DNA evidence is where it's hard to get a false negative then false positive.
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by CSMastermind on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @06:29PM (#41652559)
It's sad to me that the Innocence Project, instead of being a neutral third party investigating and then pushing back against wrongful convictions, have just become an all out 'stop the death penalty' advocacy group.

Ultimately I think this undermines their cause and hurts their ability to save truly innocent people.

Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by bombcar on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @08:19PM (#41653219)
This is the real issue. Either the death penalty is wrong in all cases, even when it’s brutally obvious that the person is guilty of heinous crimes, or it is simply a matter of taste when it should be applied, like seasoning. The argument against executing someone should stem from the first not the second, even though the second is much easier to play in the media.
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by remarkEon on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @08:47PM (#41653375)
The Innocence Project has been like this for a while. They are not a neutral third party, they are activists. In this particular case, this man was plainly and obviously guilty of a heinous murder. They’re using weasel words and a disingenuous reading of DNA evidence to argue that there’s reasonable doubt when there is not. If their issue is with the death penalty then just argue that issue.
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by seadan83 on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @10:15PM (#41653856)
Do you have reason to also claim that any of the points raised in the article are incorrect? If not, that would seem to contradict your claim that they are just a stop-the-death-penalfy advocacy group.
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by xyzzyz on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @10:30PM (#41653940)
They have always been such.
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by WillPostForFood on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @11:03PM (#41654123)
There cause is to sow distrust and spread misinformation to discredit the death penalty so it will be abolished. They are doing a fair job.
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by anon291 on Thursday September 26, 2024 @12:50PM (#41660602)
DNA evidence is notoriously faulty. Let's not pretend it's 100% accurate. If I understand correctly, the innocence project has -- in the past -- used the fact that it's not accurate as a way to cast doubt on convictions.
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by JeremyNT on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @10:02AM (#41647657)
> There's plenty of evidence. He confessed to his girlfriend, and a cellmate.

Be careful, this is hearsay and not evidence. Those people claim that he confessed to them, but there is a lot more context. Here is what the linked story says about the "he confessed" part:

> The investigation had gone cold until a jail inmate named Henry Cole, a man with a lengthy record, claimed that Mr. Williams confessed to him that he committed the murder while they were both locked up in jail. Cole directed police to Laura Asaro, a woman who had briefly dated Mr. Williams and had an extensive record of her own.

> Both of these individuals were known fabricators; neither revealed any information that was not either included in media accounts about the case or already known to the police. Their statements were inconsistent with their own prior statements, with each other’s accounts, and with the crime scene evidence, and none of the information they provided could be independently verified.

Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by whamlastxmas on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @10:40AM (#41648068)
Someone who is incarcerated snitching on someone who’s in there with them just screams “give me your cupcake or I’m gonna tell the cops you confessed to me”. Williams was also a person who was black and Muslim so prejudice alone could have been a motivation
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by kergonath on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @10:59AM (#41648273)
People say stupid things all the time as well. It’s not inconceivable to brag about something that’s not true either as an act of defiance or for social reasons such as to get some respect, look important, or to be left alone.
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by EasyMark on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @12:26PM (#41649111)
Right, these types of hearsay are only useful if they can lead investigators to more evidence that is actually supported by a solid source/chain-of-legitimacy. So it can be valuable but probably shouldn’t be submersible to court or at least the defense should really be able to lay into and tell the jury it is -highly- suspect.
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by amoorah on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @07:24PM (#41652927)
He did not convert to Islam until he was in prison.
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by qingcharles on Thursday September 26, 2024 @12:40AM (#41654610)
As someone who has personally known jailhouse snitches, I don't think this is accurate. The biggest problem with becoming a snitch is that you are then forever more labeled as a snitch, and while (unlike the movies) this is unlikely to result in violence, you will certainly be shunned for the rest of your prison life.
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by knodi123 on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @12:36PM (#41649210)
> Both of these individuals were known fabricators

Careful- it we're considering their history, then Mr Williams has a history of over a dozen counts of armed violence, burglary, robbery, and assault.

> this is hearsay and not evidence

Conflicting reports say that Asano provided verified information that had not been publicized. And Asano refused a cash reward for relaying the confessions she had heard. Regardless,

https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/3501

> Nothing contained in this section shall bar the admission in evidence of any confession made or given voluntarily by any person to any other person without interrogation by anyone, or at any time at which the person who made or gave such confession was not under arrest or other detention

Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by atmavatar on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @01:16PM (#41649621)
I would think the far more compelling detail is the one you overlooked:

> Their statements were inconsistent with their own prior statements, with each other’s accounts, and with the crime scene evidence, and none of the information they provided could be independently verified.

Not only were the two known liars, but their accounts could not be verified, and they conflict with each other as well as the existing evidence. That seems enough reason to me to call their testimony into question.

Also, I'm a little curious about your assertion:

> Conflicting reports say that Asano provided verified information that had not been publicized

When TFA specifically included the following:

> neither revealed any information that was not either included in media accounts about the case or already known to the police.

That, coupled with the fact that apparently none of the evidence at the scene was linked to Marcellus Williams makes me wonder how he was ever convicted in the first place. If we can take TFA at its word, the whole thing smells wrong.

Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by knodi123 on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @01:28PM (#41649751)
TFA is published by The Innocence Project, which obviously only presents one side of the story.

I was also using a statement from the governor,

https://governor.mo.gov/press-releases/archive/state-carry-o...

who makes some assertions which contradict the innocence project's.

Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by jasonlotito on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @08:43PM (#41653367)
Did they explain why they convened a board to research the topic to get to the bottom of this and then disbanded the board before they finished? Seems kind of shady when the government says "We are not sure, we need to do more research before we do this" and then never actually do that research and just kill someone?

Either you trust the government, and agree that they should have waited.

Or you don't trust the government, in which case you really can't trust them to kill someone.

So which is it?

Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by awb on Thursday September 26, 2024 @03:49AM (#41655639)
The previous governor stayed the execution and created the commission to investigate which lasted 6 years until the new governor was elected. The new governor disbanded the commission. They were from different political parties and probably had different views on the death penalty / the use of state resources.
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by jasonlotito on Thursday September 26, 2024 @09:16AM (#41658046)
So you agree they should have waited.

Gotcha. Thanks!

Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by randallsquared on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @05:52PM (#41652254)
The quote

> neither revealed any information that was not either included in media accounts about the case or already known to the police.

from The Innocence Project seems carefully worded to imply that they didn't say anything that mattered, while still leaving open that they provided information that the police had, but which had not be publicly released.

Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by boomboomsubban on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @07:57PM (#41653101)
It's worded that way as if one side of the interview knows something, it can easily leak to the other side intentionally or accidentally.
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by awb on Thursday September 26, 2024 @03:51AM (#41655652)
Whereas the Governor’s statement does say that information provided to the police by one witness was not known publicly.
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by pjfin123 on Thursday September 26, 2024 @11:47AM (#41659788)
> When speaking with law enforcement, the jailhouse informant provided information about the crime that was not publicly available, yet consistent with crime scene evidence and Williams’ involvement.

This is hard to fake and seems like pretty compelling evidence that the informant is telling the truth.

https://governor.mo.gov/press-releases/archive/state-carry-o...

Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by klyrs on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @05:48PM (#41652214)
> Careful- it we're considering their history, then Mr Williams has a history of over a dozen counts of armed violence, burglary, robbery, and assault.

This is all superfluous to the question of the credibility of the two witnesses. It isn't about being "fair" and treating Williams and the two witnesses the same -- one is on trial, the others are not.

Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by soerxpso on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @01:15PM (#41649602)
> Be careful, this is hearsay and not evidence.

You're mistaken. There are many exceptions to the evidentiary rules against hearsay in the US, and one of the more common exceptions is a statement made by the opposing party (i.e. while the prosecution is questioning a witness, a statement made by the defendant to that witness) (Rule 801(d)(2)). It's evidence.

Your issues with the credibility of those witnesses are valid, and the defense had the opportunity to bring those issues up at trial (that's why we have jury trials and why you have a right to defend yourself at your jury trial). They certainly weren't the only pieces of evidence against him (there's a lot), and I'm sure the jury considered that.

Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by pcthrowaway on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @01:34PM (#41649824)
There was also a $10,000 reward for information which easily could have incentivized them to provide false testimony
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by knodi123 on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @03:46PM (#41651127)
According to the governor,

> The girlfriend never requested the reward for information about Ms. Gayle’s murder, despite claims that she was only interested in money.

Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by amatecha on Thursday September 26, 2024 @03:11AM (#41655378)
except..

> The woman at first denied having information about the crime, prosecutors’ motion states. But after meeting with police several times – and being promised charges she was facing would be dropped and told she would be eligible for the reward – Asaro eventually cooperated, telling police she had indeed seen Williams on the afternoon of the murder, the motion states.

https://www.cnn.com/2024/08/21/us/marcellus-williams-missour...

Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by truetraveller on Thursday September 26, 2024 @10:34PM (#41665718)
Wow...that is amazing dishonesty on the part of the governor if this is true. Incredible how hard people are trying to hide facts.
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by pcthrowaway on Friday September 27, 2024 @01:20PM (#41673186)
There should be criminal penalties for prosecution or people involved with the chain of evidence for criminal trials failing to mention details that might sway the jury towards defense
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by xboxnolifes on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @02:49PM (#41650653)
It's not hearsay to go to the witness stand and say the defendant told you something. That defendant is there in court and is able to defend themselves.
[dead]
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by jkhdigital on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @06:06PM (#41652373)
…did you read the link you just posted? If the person whose words are being presented as evidence is available for cross-examination then (legally) it’s not hearsay. The defendant in a criminal case is always available, so any statement they make out of court is never hearsay.
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by tzs on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @08:36PM (#41653330)
That's not quite correct. An out of court statement offered to prove the truth of the matter asserted therein is always hearsay. The exceptions given in that Wikipedia article are not exceptions to it being hearsay. They are exceptions to the rule that hearsay is not admissible.

> The defendant in a criminal case is always available, so any statement they make out of court is never hearsay.

That's also not quite correct. A declarant is considered to be unavailable for example if they refuse to testify about the subject matter despite the court ordering them to. They are also considered to be unavailable if they testify that they cannot remember the subject matter. See rule 804(a) of the Federal Rules of Evidence for the criteria for being unavailable.

(I'm using FRE because that seems to be what others are using. Really though we should be using Missouri's rules of evidence. I think most state's rules of evidence are fairly close to the FRE so that's probably reasonable).

Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by lazy_moderator1 on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @06:14PM (#41652435)
from the article :)

> if Susan is unavailable for cross-examination, the answer is hearsay

Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by tzs on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @08:58PM (#41653446)
Correction: it is in fact hearsay but it is admissible under one of numerous exceptions to the rule that hearsay is not admissible.

Laws are generally clearer if you write them as general definitions and general rules and if those cover too much carve out exceptions in the rules rather than the definitions. It would work to make the exceptions to the definitions instead, or to both the definitions and rules, but that is usually going to be more complicated and less clear.

For hearsay the general definition is "an out of court statement offered to prove the truth of what the statement asserts" and the general rule is "hearsay is not admissible", and that is narrowed by a bunch of exceptions to the "hearsay is not admissible" rule. As far as I remember pretty much everyone has left the definition untouched.

Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by mjan22640 on Thursday September 26, 2024 @05:00AM (#41656134)
> Laws are generally clearer if you write them as general definitions and general rules and if those cover too much carve out exceptions in the rules rather than the definitions.

Similar motivation as exceptions for error handling

Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by TZubiri on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @06:09PM (#41652392)
>Be careful, this is hearsay and not evidence.

I think you are out of your element. To my understanding hearsay refers to a claim made by someone not in court. In this case the girlfriend and jailmate were called as witnesses and gave testimony in court.

Witnesses are evidence and they are one of the oldest forms of evidence, your view that evidence is only material is a gross misunderstanding of trial procedures.

Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by twojacobtwo on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @07:22PM (#41652913)
Here's a more thorough definition:

> Evidence that is not within the personal knowledge of a witness, such as testimony regarding statements made by someone other than the witness, and that therefore may be inadmissible to establish the truth of a particular contention because the accuracy of the evidence cannot be verified through cross-examination.

Tying the two together, basically it would be anything that can't be verified (in court) by the one who the witness is 'quoting'.

Regarding witness testimony, I don't think the tradition of it makes it any more iron clad. We used to have a lot more testimony of sorcery and such as well that got people killed. Further, we have only recently begun to study it scientifically. From what I gather, from my very limited knowledge of the studies thus far, it doesn't look good for eye-witness accuracy in general.

Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by TZubiri on Thursday September 26, 2024 @03:42AM (#41655588)
That's a take, but it's far from reality. Witnesses are a central evidence in most cases.

When the parties are present for cross examination it's not hearsay.

Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by twojacobtwo on Thursday September 26, 2024 @11:43AM (#41659732)
> When the parties are present for cross examination it's not hearsay.

That's exactly what I just said.

Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by concordDance on Thursday September 26, 2024 @03:41AM (#41655575)
> Be careful, this is hearsay and not evidence.

Note that it's possible the person you are replying to was using the everyday "observation increases relative likelihood of theory" definition of evidence rather than the legal one.

Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by aguaviva on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @05:51PM (#41652237)
But there's plenty of evidence.

Perhaps so. I'm not familiar with the details of the case.

But this I do know: prior felony convictions are manifestly not evidence.

Presenting them as such causes me to seriously doubt the broader argument you are trying to make here.

Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by virissimo on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @06:37PM (#41652608)
Prior convictions are evidence in the broad sense (because they provide information that could update one's belief about a defendant's character or likelihood of committing a crime), but not legally admissible evidence (in many jurisdictions).
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by sam1r on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @05:57PM (#41652298)
>>> He already had 15 felony convictions in addition to offenses

I wish this would be the top snippet on the comments. After reading this, there is no more left for me to read on this topic.

Thank you.

Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by karaterobot on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @08:04PM (#41653149)
I don't think it follows. If someone is convicted of 15 counts of felony tax evasion, that doesn't mean they're guilty of any other crime they're accused of (including a 16th count of tax evasion—but set that aside). Especially not murder. You need more information other than their rap sheet to conclude someone is guilty.
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by frostburg on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @07:28PM (#41652947)
This is an abuse of statistics, because you're not considering the likelyhood that a random 15-time felon killed someone, but the likelyhood that a specific 15-time felon that was accused of killing a specific person actually did it.

If you were trying to pick a realistic scapegoat he would have been a great candidate.

Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by ljsprague on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @08:14PM (#41653197)
>If you were trying to pick a realistic scapegoat he would have been a great candidate.

It also helps if the scapegoat had the victims property in his car.

Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by frostburg on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @08:27PM (#41653270)
I have not reviewed the details of the case and have no opinion on actual guilt, I was commenting on a specific line of reasoning.
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by seadan83 on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @10:19PM (#41653870)
Reasonable implication, find someone with many prior convictions, accuse them of any crime, present past convictions, and then they are guilty? This seems to defy the very concept of innocent until proven guilty.