News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Flesh and Blood (2021) by delichon on Monday September 23, 2024 @12:55PM (#41628102)
> Private property first appeared as a concept in sacred contexts

I can't watch a couple of dogs fighting over a bone and believe that the concept of private property is a recent or human or even mammalian invention.

Re:Flesh and Blood (2021) by snapcaster on Monday September 23, 2024 @04:13PM (#41629982)
I feel like this is an instance of "common senseism" for lack of a better term. You're not really engaging with the concepts presented (legally enshrined concepts of private property in a capitalist system) and dismissing it with some folksy sounding idea. Like others on the thread mentioned, you could pick a different arbitrary animal and come up with the complete opposite "conclusion"
Re:Flesh and Blood (2021) by Agentus on Monday September 23, 2024 @01:10PM (#41628285)
from a quick glance at the text i think he means legally institutionalized private property or equivalent.

but he as an anthropologist has argued in other venues to revise historical origins of various concepts like currency and debt based on available evidence rather than academic myth.

which is an earliest known origins argument based on available archaeological evidence rather than true earliest origins or mythologized origins for propagandized explainability. Of course this isnt relevant to your dog point, but just to contextualize a reoccurring theme of Graeber.

Re:Flesh and Blood (2021) by wahnfrieden on Monday September 23, 2024 @02:32PM (#41629134)
also worth noting they published papers together with wengrow being an archaeologist and taking that perspective. he is friendly on twitter if you want to talk to him...
Re:Flesh and Blood (2021) by whb101 on Monday September 23, 2024 @01:03PM (#41628195)
"this is my cheeseburger"

is different from

"all 100 people in my village need a cheeseburger very badly; this piece of paper says that if any of them lay a finger on it, they get carted off to jail"

they're more referring to the latter

Re:Flesh and Blood (2021) by AndrewKemendo on Monday September 23, 2024 @01:00PM (#41628155)
Are you a dog?

What of the cooperation an ant colony?

People love finding examples that reinforce their biases

Re:Flesh and Blood (2021) by mecsred on Monday September 23, 2024 @03:28PM (#41629617)
You ever seen two ant colonies fight?
Re:Flesh and Blood (2021) by AndrewKemendo on Monday September 23, 2024 @04:05PM (#41629913)
Moving the goal posts…it was proposed that two agents (dogs fighting over a bone) is proof of something I can only assume is the position of cooperation being “unnatural” when in fact it’s not.

This then moves the goal posts to the claim that multi-agent internally cooperative affinity groups can’t coexist. Dogs don’t fight if there are plenty of bones to go around. Plenty of ant groups coexist in the literature.

So, you’re most likely infected with the myth that there’s scarce resources.

This idea of the humans are inextricably and unambiguously violent or in a state where we must compete for scarce resources, is a trope that is both wrong and a threat to long term peace

Re:Flesh and Blood (2021) by shortrounddev2 on Monday September 23, 2024 @01:12PM (#41628312)
Leftists (Graeber was an Anarchist) distinguish personal property from private property. Personal property are your personal effects. Your clothes, your car, your desk, your pen. Private property is the ownership of land and, later, industrial means of production. Things which have been historically used in an allegedly communal context, or worked on by communities of people, but their product is privatized for the person who provided the capital for the land or industrial tools.

I don't agree with this view of economics, but this is generally the line of thought among leftist thinkers

Re:Flesh and Blood (2021) by wahnfrieden on Monday September 23, 2024 @02:26PM (#41629067)
At least in the book this link summarizes, it looks beyond anarchism and isn't written through that lens specifically

There's a new film out I just saw at TIFF by Tsangari who produced DOGTOOTH by Yorgos Lanthimos called HARVEST with Caleb Landry Jones, anyhow it's a telling of the early days of the Inclosure Act, an interesting period of transition, performed w anachronistic timelessness

Re:Flesh and Blood (2021) by queuebert on Monday September 23, 2024 @01:08PM (#41628264)
Maybe the dogs should write their own history books.
Re:Flesh and Blood (2021) by pydry on Monday September 23, 2024 @01:04PM (#41628201)
Private property is a legal designation for the ownership of property by non-governmental legal entities.

I think maybe you're referring to personal property.

Re:Flesh and Blood (2021) by lukan on Monday September 23, 2024 @12:58PM (#41628132)
This so very much.

But of course you could argue that dogs were badly influenced by humans .. but also most other wild animals know the concept of territory and fight over it.

But I think was meant with the quote is formalized property. Ownership tied to a piece of paper eventually - and this is indeed something different at some point.

Re:Flesh and Blood (2021) by pilastr on Monday September 23, 2024 @01:08PM (#41628254)
Sounds like someone could stand to put down the mouse and go read a book.
Re:Flesh and Blood (2021) by tonyedgecombe on Monday September 23, 2024 @01:08PM (#41628252)
It varies. Cats are more territorial than dogs for instance.
Re:Flesh and Blood (2021) by lukan on Monday September 23, 2024 @01:28PM (#41628453)
Surely it does. Also dogs, like wolves are pack animals. So not the single dog, but rather the pack has a territory. (And dogs include humans as their pack).
Re:Flesh and Blood (2021) by analog31 on Monday September 23, 2024 @06:18PM (#41631185)
One thing I learned from "the dawn of everything" is that societies have had diverse approaches to property over the millennia. And I've seen that it varies by country and region, even today.

Anecdote: My family went on a walking holiday in England. The entire country is crisscrossed by a network of walking paths. Many go through private farms. The same thing is rare, or even nonexistent, in the US. We were told that although we're allowed to use the land, there are certain stipulations, such as taking care not to damage the crops or disturb the livestock.

Here in the states, my family "owns" the land that our house is on, but with a variety of limitations.

Re:Flesh and Blood (2021) by chairmansteve on Monday September 23, 2024 @09:01PM (#41632133)
One difference is that a single dog can't claim to own all the bones in the country.