News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:London saw a surprising benefit to ultra-low emissions zo... by naming_the_user on Sunday September 22, 2024 @10:24PM (#41621876)
My 2c as a local: a significant issue with any discussion of this is that people don't really have a good handle on the actual statistics of who drives in London.

It cuts across every demographic. Under 25k household income - a good 40-50% of households have a car. Housing estates - tons of cars. Well off - almost everyone.

https://content.tfl.gov.uk/technical-note-12-how-many-cars-a...

It mostly comes down to whether someone has a need (e.g. has children, fairly mobile in their job, has family outside of town, enjoys going on road trips etc) and actually wants to pay for it rather than anything else.

In addition to that, a bunch of stuff happened basically at the same time. We got ULEZ, we got a ton of low traffic neighbourhoods (e.g. streets where cars are not allowed at certain times of day regardless of emissions), we had COVID meaning that habits and demographics changed, we had Brexit which probably had some minor effect, etc. All of that happened within about 5 years and I don't think you can isolate any of them.

I don't really find most discussions about it interesting as a result of all of the above - it usually just ends up with someone trying to find evidence for their pre-existing position rather than anything that feels actually scientific, unfortunately.

Re:London saw a surprising benefit to ultra-low emissions zo... by fecal_henge on Monday September 23, 2024 @12:42AM (#41622436)
I had a chat with some older people who told me distainfully that the only consequence of ULEZ was that they were not going to drive as much.

I just hope it gains enough inertia so that a theoretical future populist Mayor cant just sweep it aside.

Re:London saw a surprising benefit to ultra-low emissions zo... by boesboes on Monday September 23, 2024 @02:46AM (#41623017)
Sounds like a good thing
Re:London saw a surprising benefit to ultra-low emissions zo... by walthamstow on Monday September 23, 2024 @11:09AM (#41627012)
Yep. 60+ have their free public transport subsidised by working people anyway.
Re:London saw a surprising benefit to ultra-low emissions zo... by zik on Monday September 23, 2024 @01:58AM (#41622713)
> ...told me distainfully that the only consequence of ULEZ was that they were not going to drive as much.

Did they not realise that's literally the whole point?

Re:London saw a surprising benefit to ultra-low emissions zo... by iamacyborg on Monday September 23, 2024 @02:17AM (#41622812)
The point isn’t to stop folks from driving. The point was to stop them using highly polluting cars.
Re:London saw a surprising benefit to ultra-low emissions zo... by chgs on Monday September 23, 2024 @03:20AM (#41623267)
My 20 year old car I bought 18 months ago for £1100 is ulez compliant. I struggle to work out what isn’t to be honest.

It’s not a barrier to driving.

Re:London saw a surprising benefit to ultra-low emissions zo... by chippiewill on Monday September 23, 2024 @04:17AM (#41623644)
The ULEZ rules were quite easy for petrol engines to be compliant, but I think diesels had to be very new
Re:London saw a surprising benefit to ultra-low emissions zo... by Lio on Monday September 23, 2024 @03:31AM (#41623345)
My 10 year old diesel isn’t compliant.

I don’t live in London though and generally don’t drive much either. When I visit people In London I either take the train or drive and pay the charge.

It is more expensive but for the amount I have to drive in London it’s fine for now.

Re:London saw a surprising benefit to ultra-low emissions zo... by djd20 on Monday September 23, 2024 @03:28AM (#41623323)
Presumably this car is a small and light one - not a large truck that takes a lot of space and pollutes a lot...
Re:London saw a surprising benefit to ultra-low emissions zo... by chgs on Monday September 23, 2024 @04:10AM (#41623590)
Sure. Wouldn’t drive an enormous car. I live in the county, would struggle on the narrow lanes with one of those Chelsea tractors. Big cars are only needed in the city.
Re:London saw a surprising benefit to ultra-low emissions zo... by gpderetta on Monday September 23, 2024 @06:05AM (#41624324)
> Big cars are only needed in the city.

my sarcasm detector is malfunctioning today, but surely that was in jest.

Re:London saw a surprising benefit to ultra-low emissions zo... by chgs on Tuesday September 24, 2024 @04:35AM (#41634441)
Well they’re certain no good here - scratches, verges, and you want as narrow a car as possible.
Re:London saw a surprising benefit to ultra-low emissions zo... by Fradow on Monday September 23, 2024 @04:44AM (#41623844)
ULEZ and similar scheme are not about vehicle size. They are about Euro-spec of the engine.

There is a very vocal opposition against those: big recent SUVs are compliant, but small old cars are not, which goes against how people perceive their respective emissions.

In general: - any EV or hybrid is OK - petrol cars are OK if they're not too old (depending on Euro rating of the engine, I also have a 22 yo compliant petrol car, though a car from the same year could be non-compliant if the engine has a lower Euro rating) - diesel cars need to be recent (in general equipped with DPF and other emission-control equipment that's become mandatory to pass more recent Euro-specs)

Re:London saw a surprising benefit to ultra-low emissions zo... by LightBug1 on Monday September 23, 2024 @05:35AM (#41624144)
Yeah, the whole "I can't afford to drive due to the ULEZ" argument really used to annoy me ... I have a 2005 Toyota (my first car, which I can't emotionally get rid of it), and it's ULEZ compliant, and it's value is probably £500 ... no excuses in my books, especially as second hand car prices are plumetting (where I am anyway).

If you can't afford a £500 car, you probably shouldn't be driving anyway.

Re:London saw a surprising benefit to ultra-low emissions zo... by b800h on Monday September 23, 2024 @05:57AM (#41624279)
Oof, steady there. Poor people shouldn't drive?

"If you're not driving by the age of thirty, you've failed in life" was a quote I believe was attributed to Thatcher. She did some great stuff, but I'm not sure I agree with that one.

Re:London saw a surprising benefit to ultra-low emissions zo... by LightBug1 on Monday September 23, 2024 @09:12AM (#41625694)
You might want to re-read what I've wrote. You've entirely misconstrued it ... (and I'm in the 'pull down the Thatcher statues and dump them in the ocean' brigade).
Re:London saw a surprising benefit to ultra-low emissions zo... by Tade0 on Monday September 23, 2024 @08:41AM (#41625428)
All the diesel cars bought in the mid aughts when the fuel was still considered environmentally friendly thanks to its lower CO2 emissions.

Then again it's not like there are no buyers for the vehicles - my relative recently bought a 2012 diesel VW Golf from, apparently, a Londoner or someone who drives there frequently and didn't get that huge of a discount on it.

Sell the diesel, buy gasoline and enjoy not paying as much as you lost on the sale, only every year.

Re:London saw a surprising benefit to ultra-low emissions zo... by bdjsiqoocwk on Monday September 23, 2024 @02:28AM (#41622893)
The point is to stop them using highly polluting cars OR stop driving altogether OR something in the middle. So the person you're responding to is right. The "older people" were saying in a roundabout away that they'd rather stop driving than playing along by getting less polluting car. And the correct answer to that is indeed: "you've made your choice, that was the entire point".
Re:London saw a surprising benefit to ultra-low emissions zo... by Earw0rm on Monday September 23, 2024 @03:26AM (#41623314)
Or just.. use it less, and pay the appropriate fee when they do.

£10 a couple of times a week seems a pretty good deal if you're used to getting place by overground train & bus.

Re:London saw a surprising benefit to ultra-low emissions zo... by nzjrs on Monday September 23, 2024 @03:03AM (#41623146)
Now do LTNs
Re:London saw a surprising benefit to ultra-low emissions zo... by iamacyborg on Monday September 23, 2024 @04:22AM (#41623683)
Stop ubers and white vans taking shortcuts down residential streets that are being made unsafe by high amounts of traffic.
Re:London saw a surprising benefit to ultra-low emissions zo... by nzjrs on Monday September 23, 2024 @07:33AM (#41624953)
I'm not british either, but I understand the culture here is to disparage and discriminate against poor people in a slightly more polite and indirect way.
Re:London saw a surprising benefit to ultra-low emissions zo... by bdjsiqoocwk on Monday September 23, 2024 @08:04AM (#41625184)
Fines are discrimination against poor people, got it. They don't have those in wherever you're from?
Re:London saw a surprising benefit to ultra-low emissions zo... by iamacyborg on Monday September 23, 2024 @09:42AM (#41625997)
LTN's are mostly in poor neighbourhoods, this is preventing high amounts of traffic in them.

https://www.theguardian.com/world/ng-interactive/2021/mar/02...

Re:London saw a surprising benefit to ultra-low emissions zo... by throwawayffffas on Monday September 23, 2024 @06:53AM (#41624637)
> The point is to stop them using highly polluting cars OR stop driving altogether OR something in the middle.

You can get a compliant car for as little as 1000 pounds. Virtually all gasoline powered cars after 2010 are compliant. It's not about stopping people driving altogether.

Re:London saw a surprising benefit to ultra-low emissions zo... by reedf1 on Monday September 23, 2024 @04:16AM (#41623630)
My 2c as a local: I live in zone 2 and at least anecdotally I am in disagreement with your point here. So I looked it up: from TfL - "There are 2.56m cars licensed in London. This equates to an average of 0.3 cars per adult. In total, 46 per cent of households do not have a car, 40 per cent have one car and 12 per cent have two or more cars, with very few households owning more than two cars."

This is the same as your stated numbers, but framed in a substantially different way, in addition I suspect this is dominated by the outer boroughs. Maybe one or two of my 20+ coworkers who live in zones 1-3 have a car, it's more once you get z4+.

Re:London saw a surprising benefit to ultra-low emissions zo... by philipwhiuk on Monday September 23, 2024 @04:39AM (#41623800)
By Zone 5 you're basically almost back to the world of infrequent bus services and out-of-town supermarkets so it's a lot more understandable why you need a car.
Re:London saw a surprising benefit to ultra-low emissions zo... by short_sells_poo on Monday September 23, 2024 @06:43AM (#41624556)
Anecdotal sample from my village just outside Zone 6 (but inside M25): every single one of my neighbours has 2 cars, some have 3 (or 4). Basically every adult or young-adult member of the household who has to go somewhere on their own has a car. You could argue that they don't need that many, but take it this way: the reliability of the UK train network has become absolutely disgraceful. They are either on strike, or if they are not striking, then they are doing engineering works, and if neither of those are happening, then there is a major disruption. This means that in the last 6 months, I think there have been 2-3 weeks perhaps where the connection into London was reliable.

Unless you have a car, you are completely hosed.

Re:London saw a surprising benefit to ultra-low emissions zo... by reedf1 on Monday September 23, 2024 @06:48AM (#41624595)
Yes, that tracks with my experience too. I've found some evidence to back up our anecdotal experience here: https://centreforlondon.org/blog/car-ownership-census/
Re:London saw a surprising benefit to ultra-low emissions zo... by gadders on Monday September 23, 2024 @07:29AM (#41624921)
Not to mentioned the cost of using the train vs driving.
Re:London saw a surprising benefit to ultra-low emissions zo... by short_sells_poo on Monday September 23, 2024 @08:27AM (#41625340)
I skipped over this issue, but it's absolutely right. Train tickets are ridiculously expensive - to the degree that it's cheaper to drive into town and then pay the parking. And for this price you get absolutely abysmal service.

I don't know where public transport has gone wrong in the UK, but it is truly catastrophic even compared to the post-soviet bloc countries in Europe. In fact, those tend to have much better public transport these days.

Re:London saw a surprising benefit to ultra-low emissions zo... by reedf1 on Monday September 23, 2024 @08:55AM (#41625551)
I have some privately collected analysis that there is large scale fraud of their already poor performance metrics. It's an open scandal.
Re:London saw a surprising benefit to ultra-low emissions zo... by twen_ty on Monday September 23, 2024 @07:23AM (#41624869)
Exactly. Came here to say the same thing. I live in zone 2 and I'd say that majority of the households don't own a car because they don't need one. We only got a car after we had kids and used to Uber around when we needed a car, a lot cheaper than full time car ownership.
Re:London saw a surprising benefit to ultra-low emissions zo... by PaulRobinson on Monday September 23, 2024 @05:49AM (#41624230)
What annoys me about this is the assumption that ULEZ means people can't drive any more.

Every single person with a car today can continue to drive under ULEZ without paying the ULEZ fee.

They just need to have a car that isn't high emissions. They can pay to drive a non-compliant car, or they can change car to something that is compliant, and don't pay the charge. That's it.

To facilitate that, the taxpayer through the ULEZ scrappage scheme offered £2,000 even if the car was not worth anything close to that value. I've seen people get £2k for vehicles that frankly weren't worth half that.

There are plenty of vehicles available for not much more money that are ULEZ-compliant.

I think the fact this happened at a similar time when we were exposed to chatter of "government interference" from Europe (Brexit), or Whitehall (Covid lockdowns), didn't help, but the language I hear some people using is insane - we're paying for the same level of personal protection for the Mayor as for the PM because of the number of death threats he gets.

I definite;y agree very little of the debate feels scientific.