News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Brazil Supreme Court unfreezes X, Starlink's bank account... by blackeyeblitzar on Saturday September 14, 2024 @01:12AM (#41537623)
Censorship of speech / bans of politicians’ social media accounts, done with secret gag orders outside of the public’s view, will always be morally wrong. In this case I don’t understand how this was ever allowed even legally (setting aside moral and ethical problems) given that Article 5 of the Brasil constitution guarantees a right to free speech without censorship. Glad to see Twitter/X stand up for basic civil liberties.

As for freezing accounts and taking money out of them - let’s call this what it is, theft by a court that has usurped powers it was never granted by law. Illegal censorship orders followed by illegal seizure. Not to mention the freezing of the personal assets of Twitter’s legal representative.

Re:Brazil Supreme Court unfreezes X, Starlink's bank account... by JumpCrisscross on Saturday September 14, 2024 @01:17AM (#41537641)
> secret gag orders

We can debate principles and even the legality of these actions. But they weren't done in secret. (EDIT: I may be mistaken in this claim.)

> Article 5 of the Brasil constitution guarantees a right to free speech without censorship

Would this also ban spam filters? Fraud convictions? If not then there are obviously caveats to when and how one can censor. (No right can be absolute. If it were, it would merit infinite sacrifice to uphold.)

Also, why isn’t Article 220 ¶ 5 the relevant one [1]? Article 5 has 74 sections. Genuine question, I have no knowledge of Brazilian law.

> taking money out of them - let’s call this what it is, theft

A court that can’t find people in contempt isn’t a court.

Again, we can debate the principles. But these are straw men.

[1] https://www.oas.org/es/sla/ddi/docs/acceso_informacion_base_...

Re:Brazil Supreme Court unfreezes X, Starlink's bank account... by inemesitaffia on Saturday September 14, 2024 @01:48AM (#41537741)
They were secret orders. Think superinjunctions.

Why do people still repeat this?

Re:Brazil Supreme Court unfreezes X, Starlink's bank account... by ekianjo on Saturday September 14, 2024 @02:29AM (#41537905)
this could be LLM bots parroting opinions these days.
Re:Brazil Supreme Court unfreezes X, Starlink's bank account... by inemesitaffia on Saturday September 14, 2024 @02:34AM (#41537919)
Could be.

People miss the fact the judge gave orders to suppress his personal misdeeds and that the orders to Twitter asked them to take down accounts and posts without revealing it was a judicial order. Or even the reason for the ban.

Imagine getting banned from social media, the operator tells you it's for a TOS violation or tells you nothing. You don't realize it's from a court. That's what's this is about.

Re:Brazil Supreme Court unfreezes X, Starlink's bank account... by Natsu on Saturday September 14, 2024 @02:11AM (#41537822)
> We can debate principles and even the legality of these actions. But they weren't done in secret.

The gag orders were only released by X, not by the court. The only reason we know what they contain at all is because of X. You can read them here: https://nitter.poast.org/AlexandreFiles

They gave X just hours to censor a sitting Brazilian senator and censored entire accounts without identifying any specific posts alleged to violate the law. It's interesting that the current version of this news article does not appear to mention the actual orders at all, instead linking to some secondary reporting by a Brazilian outlet.

Re:Brazil Supreme Court unfreezes X, Starlink's bank account... by JumpCrisscross on Saturday September 14, 2024 @02:50AM (#41537982)
> gag orders were only released by X, not by the court

Thank you. Was X prohibited from releasing them by the orders?

Re:Brazil Supreme Court unfreezes X, Starlink's bank account... by Natsu on Saturday September 14, 2024 @02:00PM (#41541557)
> Was X prohibited from releasing them by the orders?

Yes, you can see the CONFIDENTIAL stamps on them in the lower left corner of the orders. For example, look at the bottom left of this image:

https://nitter.poast.org/pic/orig/media%2FGWzpltMWQAAosr3.pn...

Note that Brazilian Portuguese uses exactly the same word we do in English, though it's pronounced slightly differently, the end of the word sounding like see-al.

I can confirm this due to having a native speaker of Brazilian Portuguese right next to me at this very second, who also confirmed to me that yes, the CONFIDENTIAL stamp on the order really does mean that X was not permitted to release this order.

Re:Brazil Supreme Court unfreezes X, Starlink's bank account... by blackeyeblitzar on Saturday September 14, 2024 @02:19AM (#41537857)
> We can debate principles and even the legality of these actions. But they weren't done in secret.

They were literally in secret - as in, the orders tell Twitter to comply and to do so in secret. See the actual order for yourself:

https://x.com/AlexandreFiles/status/1829979981130416479

> Would this also ban spam filters? Fraud convictions? If not then there are obviously caveats to when and how one can censor.

It would ban a government spam filter yes. I am not sure how fraud matters here, but I am guessing you’re saying that speech that constitutes fraud can be censored. But this is a lot more basic - the banning of currently sitting elected officials from social media.

> Also, why isn’t Article 220 ¶ 5 the relevant one [1]? Article 5 has 74 sections. Genuine question, I have no knowledge of Brazilian law.

Brazil’s constitution isn’t as well written as some other countries like the US. It is really long and there are many redundant and conflicting sections. Article 220 is in Title 8 (social order). Article 5 is in Title 2 (fundamental rights) and is more important. In article 5, look at 9 or 37 as examples that the actions of Alexandre de Moraes violates.

Re:Brazil Supreme Court unfreezes X, Starlink's bank account... by JumpCrisscross on Saturday September 14, 2024 @02:45AM (#41537965)
> See the actual order for yourself

Is the first image the actual order? Seems weird for it to say “including that of a sitting Brazilian senator.”

Re:Brazil Supreme Court unfreezes X, Starlink's bank account... by zerocrates on Saturday September 14, 2024 @03:02AM (#41538034)
The actual orders are in a following tweet, it seems: https://x.com/AlexandreFiles/status/1829980105567059997

One of those oddities of the current experience there is that you can't see that there's another message in the thread if you're viewing it while not logged in.

Re:Brazil Supreme Court unfreezes X, Starlink's bank account... by JumpCrisscross on Saturday September 14, 2024 @03:10AM (#41538059)
I see sigoloso at the top. Would this have been permanently secret? Or is it like a warrant, where it's sealed for a period of time?
Re:Brazil Supreme Court unfreezes X, Starlink's bank account... by piva00 on Saturday September 14, 2024 @05:58AM (#41538712)
It's sealed for a period of time, not a state secret like Top Secret, etc.
Re:Brazil Supreme Court unfreezes X, Starlink's bank account... by wwtrv on Saturday September 14, 2024 @02:00AM (#41537785)
You did include both of these in the same comment, though:

> Would this also ban spam filters? Fraud convictions? > But these are straw men

Anyway, at least in the US (but I also assume similar provisions in other countries as well) the 5th amendment generally only applies to the government, not companies and private individuals (in a way you deciding to "censor" someone is an expression of your free speech).

Re:Brazil Supreme Court unfreezes X, Starlink's bank account... by inemesitaffia on Saturday September 14, 2024 @02:35AM (#41537928)
You're making a terrible mistake here
Re:Brazil Supreme Court unfreezes X, Starlink's bank account... by wakawaka28 on Saturday September 14, 2024 @02:53AM (#41537989)
Multiple mistakes in fact, lol
Re:Brazil Supreme Court unfreezes X, Starlink's bank account... by wwtrv on Tuesday September 17, 2024 @06:41PM (#41573649)
Care to explain? Besides the accidental 5 of course.
Re:Brazil Supreme Court unfreezes X, Starlink's bank account... by icehawk on Saturday September 14, 2024 @02:15AM (#41537837)
Kinda weird take on this. I mean, none of this is a secret. The fact that we know about it precludes this.

Not to mention they did post court documents on twitter and tagged musk himself

https://twitter.com/STF_oficial/status/1828932387117392265

Re:Brazil Supreme Court unfreezes X, Starlink's bank account... by blackeyeblitzar on Saturday September 14, 2024 @02:21AM (#41537867)
What you linked isn’t the censorship order but a subsequent public order to X after X went public with its non compliance and complaints. Here’s an example censorship order to X that literally instructs them to perform the censorship in secret - this is the official Twitter account where they’re exposing the censorship scheme they were subject to from this one judge:

https://x.com/AlexandreFiles/status/1829979981130416479

Re:Brazil Supreme Court unfreezes X, Starlink's bank account... by icehawk on Saturday September 14, 2024 @02:31AM (#41537911)
Oh well i can see it on twitter! Still not secret!
Re:Brazil Supreme Court unfreezes X, Starlink's bank account... by TeaBrain on Saturday September 14, 2024 @03:45AM (#41538194)
You are being incredibly obtuse here. Imagine if a top secret document was published. The fact of the document being published does not mean that the document is no longer classified as top secret, just because it has been viewed by people without requisite clearance. Here, the order was secret and due to being a secret order, the public was not aware of it until X released documentation of the order. Documentation being released on the order does not mean that it was not a secret order.
Re:Brazil Supreme Court unfreezes X, Starlink's bank account... by oliv5900 on Saturday September 14, 2024 @02:48AM (#41537974)
The fact that twitter revealed the (supposed to be secret) order is the exact reason why they got banned.

Imagine if Clarence Thomas orders Facebook that they have to censor any negative posts about him, and they cannot reveal the reason the reason for censoring, with the threat of getting shut down.

Re:Brazil Supreme Court unfreezes X, Starlink's bank account... by sschueller on Saturday September 14, 2024 @02:00AM (#41537784)
I wonder if Elon would also not comply with a secret FBI warrant. I highly doubt it.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Foreign_Intell...

Re:Brazil Supreme Court unfreezes X, Starlink's bank account... by TeaBrain on Saturday September 14, 2024 @04:01AM (#41538267)
What do you think you're saying here? If Elon's companies were ever served a US warrant, it wouldn't be a FISA warrant. Telecommunications providers are compelled to provide information under FISA, but this has nothing to do with FISA warrants. FISA warrants are simply a method for government agencies to obtain permission to perform surveillance on the entity specified by the warrant. They aren't served to domestic companies. The idea doesn't even make sense.
Re:Brazil Supreme Court unfreezes X, Starlink's bank account... by 7e on Saturday September 14, 2024 @10:55AM (#41540199)
FISA only applies to domestic companies, it’s not enforceable anywhere else. According to https://www.zdnet.com/article/when-the-feds-come-knocking-th... the orders (warrants?) are served to ISPs but they’re too secret to be kept by them.
Re:Brazil Supreme Court unfreezes X, Starlink's bank account... by wakawaka28 on Saturday September 14, 2024 @03:10AM (#41538058)
Would you even have a way to know if he fought a secret order or not without someone breaking the law? Also, a Brazilian judge can't do much harm to him personally. On the other hand, even a lower court in your own country can put you in jail (for at least a little while) for essentially nothing.
Re:Brazil Supreme Court unfreezes X, Starlink's bank account... by piva00 on Saturday September 14, 2024 @06:06AM (#41538744)
Then why does he comply with Indian or Turkish orders?
Re:Brazil Supreme Court unfreezes X, Starlink's bank account... by wakawaka28 on Saturday September 14, 2024 @09:09AM (#41539583)
Because those are lawful orders that he can't fight, I assume. Or maybe it's an issue of money. Who knows. Let's hope he means what he says.

Is there any similarly-sized tech company doing as much for free speech as X, including not complying with court orders?

Re:Brazil Supreme Court unfreezes X, Starlink's bank account... by hungie on Saturday September 14, 2024 @03:01AM (#41538026)
He's complied with Indian and Turkish authorities, choosing to censor. I'm sure he'd comply if asked by the trump admin and fight if asked by the Harris admin.
Re:Brazil Supreme Court unfreezes X, Starlink's bank account... by wakawaka28 on Saturday September 14, 2024 @03:19AM (#41538089)
The dude burned a huge pile of money and fought a lot of opposition just to end censorship on Twitter, at least in the US. He does have his pet issues that face very minor censorship but I think he would fight any further attempts for illegal and unconstitutional government censorship. If he censors now, it will defeat his stated purpose and be just as bland as other establishment-run social media.
Re:Brazil Supreme Court unfreezes X, Starlink's bank account... by blackeyeblitzar on Saturday September 14, 2024 @04:42PM (#41542694)
I think all instances of censorship are bad, personally. However, it isn’t as simple as comparing cases in different countries. Twitter/X has a policy of abiding by local laws. So if they feel government ordered censorship is legal, they’ll comply. Otherwise, they’ll refuse and challenge it. If there is no way to challenge an illegal order, they’ll refuse it and go public as they have in Brazil.

One difference in India is that the orders are not secret - they don’t come with gag orders to hide censorship from the public. Another difference is that they are legal, due to a number of regulations their government passed over the last several years. That doesn’t mean Twitter accepted these censorship demands because they (or Musk) are friendly with that government, which is a conspiracy theory I’ve seen spreading in recent times. Twitter/X literally sued the Indian government over these orders and lost back in 2023 (note Musk acquired the company in 2022), at which point they had to pay fines and comply. It’s not just Twitter/X either - Google also complies with the same orders in India and other countries, for example removing content from YouTube.

Re:Brazil Supreme Court unfreezes X, Starlink's bank account... by inemesitaffia on Sunday September 15, 2024 @01:21AM (#41545397)
It's not the same
Re:Brazil Supreme Court unfreezes X, Starlink's bank account... by locallost on Saturday September 14, 2024 @01:38AM (#41537707)
Their right to free speech was not taken away. Their access was blocked for failure to comply with the law. E.g. it wouldn't be the first time if I tried to visit a website and see the domain was seized by the US government for breaking a US law, which is even more egregious because it blocks a page from the whole world and not just US. I have yet to hear Musk complain about this being the man of strong principles he tries to make himself to be. Twitter under Musk routinely bans users that mock Musk, see e.g. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Junlper
Re:Brazil Supreme Court unfreezes X, Starlink's bank account... by andrei_says_ on Saturday September 14, 2024 @02:00AM (#41537787)
Musk seems to want to own speech for the sake of controlling it much more than what we were seeing from the publicly owned Twitter.

Him screaming “free speech”, through the mega-megaphone of his own platform is PR. Let’s not confuse PR with reality.

Re:Brazil Supreme Court unfreezes X, Starlink's bank account... by blackeyeblitzar on Saturday September 14, 2024 @02:27AM (#41537896)
You’re mixing different unrelated issues and making this about Musk, which I don’t think is on topic. I’ll just say that Brazil has local laws that make secret censorship orders unconstitutional. Twitter complies with government orders to censor if it is legal, for example in Australia. But it isn’t legal in Brazil. Elsewhere they’ve even fought such orders - for example shortly after Musk acquired Twitter they had a legal battle with the government of India, which they lost and ended up complying, in part because laws were passed that made those censorship orders legal. No law has been passed in Brazil to give any court the power that Moraes assumed.
Re:Brazil Supreme Court unfreezes X, Starlink's bank account... by locallost on Saturday September 14, 2024 @03:53AM (#41538227)
Twitter doesn't get to decide what is legal or what isn't in Brazil. If they feel something is illegal, Brazil has a judicial system they can use, but until then they are expected to comply with court orders like in any other country in the world. Instead Musk announced they will not comply, pulled the representatives of Twitter in Brazil and now has his service banned. So it very much is about Musk because it was his decision to defy the court on the basis of protecting free speech, although again he routinely bans users from Twitter that mock him.
Re:Brazil Supreme Court unfreezes X, Starlink's bank account... by FranzFerdiNaN on Saturday September 14, 2024 @03:05AM (#41538043)
Lets not pretend Musk understands Brazilian law. He looked for a fight and lost again, so he left the country.
Re:Brazil Supreme Court unfreezes X, Starlink's bank account... by FranzFerdiNaN on Saturday September 14, 2024 @03:04AM (#41538038)
But X doesn’t stand up for free speech? Musk loves nothing more than groveling for rightwing strongmen like Trump or Erdogan or Modi. He only had a problem with Brazil because it’s led by a leftist government.