News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The future of Boeing's crewed spaceflight program muddy a... by bell-cot on Thursday September 12, 2024 @09:44AM (#41520896)
NASA obviously needs a new, reliable horse in this race.

If only the development of Sierra Space's Dream Chaser wasn't moving at a snail's pace. (That project started back in 2004; they're currently hoping for the first test flight, of an unmanned cargo version, to happen in 2025.)

Re:The future of Boeing's crewed spaceflight program muddy a... by dylan604 on Thursday September 12, 2024 @09:50AM (#41520973)
I love how Bezos' company is never mentioned in these discussions. Seriously, why is he not competing in this space?
Re:The future of Boeing's crewed spaceflight program muddy a... by Retric on Thursday September 12, 2024 @10:13AM (#41521243)
They skipped the small/midsized orbital rocket stage and went straight to a huge orbital launch system which has been in development for a long time and is still unproven.

New Shepard, their suborbital demonstrator, had it’s first flight 9 years ago. They could quickly prove themselves, but such a long period in development without successful orbital launches destroyed the hype.

Re:The future of Boeing's crewed spaceflight program muddy a... by dylan604 on Thursday September 12, 2024 @10:29AM (#41521431)
Right, but they've sued NASA over not receiving bids that SpaceX won, so they clearly "feel" like they should be in the running. Seems like if they were so desperate to win bids, they should be challenging Boeing. Clearly, I'm not privy to internal NASA discussions on awarding bids, but at this point, there has to be serious discussions on looking for another vendor as Boeing is just not reliable and shows no signs of improving. If I were part Bezos' entourage, I'd have a crew capsule design ready to go to approach NASA with. The time has never been more ripe for a spoiler to enter the discussion.
Re:The future of Boeing's crewed spaceflight program muddy a... by Retric on Thursday September 12, 2024 @11:05AM (#41521787)
They have won other government contracts so they are in the running, I’m just talking about how the public feels.

As to moon missions, building a capsule from scratch would take at least 5 years and more likely a decade plus a few billion dollars at this point. Putting another company in charge of Boeing’s operations could be viable, but having a 3rd party show up just doesn’t seem viable on any kind of reason timescale.

Re:The future of Boeing's crewed spaceflight program muddy a... by imtringued on Thursday September 12, 2024 @11:17AM (#41521907)
There isn't really a need for a competitor to Starliner or even Crew Dragon, because they were both designed for LEO re-entry.

Crew Dragon in particular was overbuilt for LEO so that it can be used multiple times. While lunar re-entry is indeed possible, the vehicle wasn't designed for more than a one off mission.

The missing link is a low cost reusable crew vehicle designed for carrying people between LEO and NRHO/LLO. Basically a competitor to Orion.

While it is true in theory that a Starship could carry people to the moon and land them directly on the surface, the return trip isn't that easy and basically boils down to a second starship picking up astronauts from NRHO.

Re:The future of Boeing's crewed spaceflight program muddy a... by m348e912 on Thursday September 12, 2024 @10:15AM (#41521269)
>I love how Bezos' company is never mentioned in these discussions.

This is a good point. Not much is said about Blue Origin. Perhaps because they're overshadowed by SpaceX? But Bezos is launching rockets.

* Their New Glenn rocket is reusable and can launch 45 tons, focusing on the commercial satellite launch market. First launch in Spring of '25.

* New Shepard is more like a tourist transport, delivering passengers to the edge of space. They have completed 26 missions so far.

* They're working on Blue Moon, which is a lunar lander designed to be part of Nasa's Artemis program.

Here's a video of Bezos talking about (and showing) the first New Glenn rocket being prepared for launch.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hu8SlfmpKM4

Disclaimer: I don't work for Bezos PR. I know very little about Blue Origin except what I learned from that video and what I got from ChatGPT.

Re:The future of Boeing's crewed spaceflight program muddy a... by marcosdumay on Thursday September 12, 2024 @10:21AM (#41521333)
Did Blue Origin manage to reach orbit already?

They are usually ignored because they seem to be at least a decade away from any practical application, and kept being that decade away for at least the last entire decade. But if this changed, than yeah, people should stop ignoring it.

Re:The future of Boeing's crewed spaceflight program muddy a... by m348e912 on Thursday September 12, 2024 @10:27AM (#41521409)
They have launched New Shepard 26 times, carrying passengers just above the Kármán line, which is about 62 miles above earth.

The rocket in the video I linked to is New Glenn (a heavy payload rocket) and its first launch will be in Spring 25

Re:The future of Boeing's crewed spaceflight program muddy a... by marcosdumay on Thursday September 12, 2024 @10:59AM (#41521721)
To be fair, they are working on a lot of the advanced problems before they get the basics. So they may be closer to a practical application than it looks.

But they didn't get the basics. Getting high up into space is much, much easier than reaching orbit. To the point it's a qualitatively different problem.

Re:The future of Boeing's crewed spaceflight program muddy a... by tempaway75647 on Thursday September 12, 2024 @10:44AM (#41521579)
which is about 62 miles above earth

But 'reaching orbit' isn't really about height, its more about speed

Re:The future of Boeing's crewed spaceflight program muddy a... by tekla on Thursday September 12, 2024 @11:15AM (#41521879)
Yes. The point being they don't have a orbital vehicle yet
Re:The future of Boeing's crewed spaceflight program muddy a... by imtringued on Thursday September 12, 2024 @11:23AM (#41521958)
Their pace significantly accelerated since the original tweet where they showed a fully assembled pathfinder vehicle on the launch pad. Before that tweet I thought Blue Origin was way behind. Now they are at most a year away from having a successful rocket and two years away from a moon landing with their prototype MK1 moon lander. At the current pace it is not unthinkable that Artemis 3 and 5 could happen a year apart.
Re:The future of Boeing's crewed spaceflight program muddy a... by rbanffy on Friday September 13, 2024 @05:29PM (#41535337)
Blue Origin is not building a crew launch system and New Glenn will not fly until next year, and won’t carry humans for the foreseeable future.
Re:The future of Boeing's crewed spaceflight program muddy a... by HarHarVeryFunny on Thursday September 12, 2024 @09:50AM (#41520967)
Why Sierra Space vs Blue Origin ?
Re:The future of Boeing's crewed spaceflight program muddy a... by imglorp on Thursday September 12, 2024 @10:48AM (#41521623)
Apples and oranges. Sierra is making a reuseable orbiter which needs a launcher and is pretty agnostic which one. Blue is making an orbital launcher but doesn't have a orbital spacecraft.
Re:The future of Boeing's crewed spaceflight program muddy a... by HarHarVeryFunny on Thursday September 12, 2024 @11:01AM (#41521740)
OK, but surely NASA would like multiple suppliers for all components, and the launcher is the hard part, so Blue Origin seem closer to being a (single vendor) alternative to SpaceX. They were also tendering for the Artemis moon landing vehicle.
Re:The future of Boeing's crewed spaceflight program muddy a... by imtringued on Thursday September 12, 2024 @11:38AM (#41522107)
I'm not sure the launcher is the hard part. Heat shield tiles and re-entry seem to be much harder problems.

Boeing Starliner had no trouble launching, returning on the other hand was risky.

SLS worked flawlessly, but the returning Orion capsule's heat shield was severely damaged and the heat shield does not appear to be safe enough for crewed missions.

Starship's super heavy booster landed as planned, but the upper stage got damaged during re-entry and just barely managed to perform a landing.

STS/The space shuttle disaster was caused by damage from the launch, but arrived safely in LEO. The catastrophic loss occured during re-entry.

Re:The future of Boeing's crewed spaceflight program muddy a... by bell-cot on Thursday September 12, 2024 @01:47PM (#41523492)
Pretty much.

With both more time and vastly more money than Sierra, BO has yet to reach orbit with anything. Medium lift rockets are not particularly scarce...vs. there's only one decent non-Russian, non-Chinese manned orbital vehicle. And it took even SpaceX almost a decade to go from Cargo Dragon to Crew Dragon.