News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Why Is Pave Legal? by mcntsh on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @07:02AM (#41510161)
Wage fixing is when multiple companies agree to set wages at a certain amount.

Sharing compensation data across companies doesn't necessarily mean wage fixing. Company A can use the compensation data from Company B to try and compete better for talent.

Not saying thats what it will be used for, but it's technically not wage fixing.

Re:Ask HN: Why Is Pave Legal? by the_mitsuhiko on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @07:19AM (#41510255)
> Wage fixing is when multiple companies agree to set wages at a certain amount.

I am not an expert on wage fixing laws in the US, but I came across a class action on wage fixing a few days ago (Ron Brown et al v JBS USA Food Company et al) where part of what was aledged was the illegal exchange of salary data via surveys [1].

> The Red Meat Industry Compensation Survey conducted by WMS on behalf of the Defendant Processors violated the Safe Harbor Guidelines in at least three ways. First, the Defendant Processors, not WMS, collectively managed and controlled the annual Red Meat Industry Compensation Surveys. Second, those Surveys often contained information about the Defendant Processors’ future compensation plans and practices. Third, Defendant Processors had extensive discussions about the Survey results, including at in-person meetings, during which they disclosed their respective compensation rates, practices, and plans

[1]: https://www.classaction.org/media/brown-et-al-v-jbs-usa-food...

Re:Ask HN: Why Is Pave Legal? by SideQuark on Friday September 13, 2024 @02:03PM (#41533564)
>part of what was aledged was the illegal exchange of salary data via surveys

Alleged doesn't mean illegal. In this case this point never saw court; the sides settled.

And what this claimed to have happened is not what is happening here.

Re:Ask HN: Why Is Pave Legal? by the_mitsuhiko on Monday September 16, 2024 @10:06AM (#41556210)
> Alleged doesn't mean illegal

What is alledged is that they did that. And if they did, they would have violated the law from my understanding.

> And what this claimed to have happened is not what is happening here.

That might be, but that's not entirely clear to me. I don't know if what Pave is doing is legal or not, but it seems to me that the line is quite fine and it would be fascinating to see this play out at court.

Re:Ask HN: Why Is Pave Legal? by chipgap98 on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @07:18AM (#41510250)
Stochastic wage fixing is still wage fixing
Re:Ask HN: Why Is Pave Legal? by sameoldtune on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @07:20AM (#41510259)
Your honor, the algorithm made me do it!
Re:Ask HN: Why Is Pave Legal? by jskrablin on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @07:30AM (#41510326)
ChatGPT did it!
Re:Ask HN: Why Is Pave Legal? by toomuchtodo on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @10:29AM (#41511722)
Re:Ask HN: Why Is Pave Legal? by econcon on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @07:24AM (#41510284)
unless you collude with other companies, doesn't seem like it is.
Re:Ask HN: Why Is Pave Legal? by theGnuMe on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @07:52AM (#41510437)
unless disclosed to employees and applicants this seems like de facto colluding.

I always ask myself, as to the legality or ethics, would this survive review by a jury of my peers...

Re:Ask HN: Why Is Pave Legal? by fastball on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @10:26AM (#41511703)
You think it is more ethical for wage data to be kept secret? Why? Rarely is requiring secrecy the more ethical option.
Re:Ask HN: Why Is Pave Legal? by cryptonym on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @10:51AM (#41511931)
What would be the least ethical would be keeping it secret to one party and having the other party sharing data... Oh wait!
Re:Ask HN: Why Is Pave Legal? by HeyLaughingBoy on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @11:53AM (#41512540)
Glassdoor exists.
Re:Ask HN: Why Is Pave Legal? by simion314 on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @12:40PM (#41513011)
>Glassdoor exists.

you are not allowed to tell anyone how much you make so you might be in trouble if your found out but the companies share this info without your consent. From my POV make it all transparent.

Re:Ask HN: Why Is Pave Legal? by HeyLaughingBoy on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @02:14PM (#41513887)
I have had a career spanning over 30 years at this point. I've worked in businesses with 6 employees and F500 corporations. No one has ever told me that I can't tell anyone else how much I make.
Re:Ask HN: Why Is Pave Legal? by cryptonym on Thursday September 12, 2024 @06:08AM (#41519217)
So... Pave shouldn't exists as "Glassdoor exists" and is already providing data?
Re:Ask HN: Why Is Pave Legal? by fastball on Thursday September 12, 2024 @04:40PM (#41525296)
Eh? Glassdoor is for the other party, which you were implying was being kept in the dark.
Re:Ask HN: Why Is Pave Legal? by cryptonym on Friday September 13, 2024 @09:26AM (#41531067)
If Glassdoor data are sufficient, why would employers pay for Pave?

It's not like Glassdoor is restricted to employees, they even offer specific services to employers.

Re:Ask HN: Why Is Pave Legal? by theGnuMe on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @01:19PM (#41513406)
I never said that.
Re:Ask HN: Why Is Pave Legal? by willseth on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @10:27AM (#41511708)
That is the entire basis for the RealPage lawsuit. The point is that if the effect on pricing is indistinguishable from price fixing, it doesn't matter if the act of colluding is abstracted into and laundered through a 3rd party with an algorithmic system responsible for setting prices.
Re:Ask HN: Why Is Pave Legal? by ambicapter on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @11:18AM (#41512178)
Honestly, I think it does still matter. The basis for the RealPage lawsuit seems to be that people inside and outside the company glibly considered it price-fixing, and said it out loud to each other. The didn't really seem to make the case that it was "algorithmic price-fixing" (Disclaimer: not a lawyer). You can only argue in court about existing laws, so until algorithmic price-fixing is written in the law books (or settled case law) you're gonna have a tough time bringing that up to a judge.
Re:Ask HN: Why Is Pave Legal? by willseth on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @11:43AM (#41512446)
It seems you don't understand the lawsuit. Most of the claims are based on the actual mechanics of how algorithmic price fixing does violate existing laws.
Re:Ask HN: Why Is Pave Legal? by CRConrad on Thursday September 19, 2024 @03:23AM (#41589411)
As this guy argues, that this is also price fixing by algorithm: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xFk8V7mU0Wo .

(Got the link from a comment on another recent HN post, IIRC.)

Re:Ask HN: Why Is Pave Legal? by nowyoudont on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @07:05AM (#41510179)
I'm asking this as someone with 0 legal knowledge: doesn't the context matter? If every company takes this data and is like "we want to pay at the 95th percentile" (which is what they all do), that seems like wage fixing even if they're not all agreeing to it together.
Re:Ask HN: Why Is Pave Legal? by aikinai on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @07:16AM (#41510238)
If they’re all shooting for the 95th percentile and have up-to-date data then you certainly won’t have fixing; rather you’ll get insanely rapid wage inflation!
Re:Ask HN: Why Is Pave Legal? by michaelt on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @07:56AM (#41510462)
There's also a more cynical explanation.

It's possible the purpose of wage benchmarking companies is to allow bosses to say they pay the 95th percentile - which is useful to be able to say, when someone at an all-hands Q&A asks about raises and bonuses.

Then the benchmarking company simply has to define 'comparable roles' broadly enough to give the customer the result they want.

Re:Ask HN: Why Is Pave Legal? by wccrawford on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @07:41AM (#41510395)
Yeah, it seems more like they'd all shoot for 45th percentile and say "We pay competitive wages" instead, slowly driving the wages down.
Re:Ask HN: Why Is Pave Legal? by throwway120385 on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @10:27AM (#41511714)
That's what my employer does. The head of our HR team got in front of the entire company and said that they aim for 50th percentile for everyone in every pay band. It instantly made me want to job hop, tempered only by the million things I have going on in my personal life that have a better expected value than a 5 or 10k pay bump.
Re:Ask HN: Why Is Pave Legal? by hobs on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @10:49AM (#41511913)
That's... hilarious. We all know they are thinking that but to say it loudly and proudly to the employees is a self own on a level that makes me Cheshire Cat.
Re:Ask HN: Why Is Pave Legal? by itronitron on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @10:57AM (#41511991)
Not necessarily, if everyone's wages (except 5%) were set at minimum wage then the 95th percentile would be the minimum wage.
Re:Ask HN: Why Is Pave Legal? by bradleybuda on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @03:07PM (#41514383)
Which is... exactly what the software industry has seen over the past 30 years?
Re:Ask HN: Why Is Pave Legal? by mcntsh on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @07:19AM (#41510254)
If you opened up a business selling water bottles, you'd probably check what price water sells at across brands, then decide in which segment to price it.

"I want to sell my water at the upper end and market it as a gourmet brand"

Re:Ask HN: Why Is Pave Legal? by drw85 on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @10:56AM (#41511978)
But in this case you're not selling, you're buying.
Re:Ask HN: Why Is Pave Legal? by dctoedt on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @07:29AM (#41510319)
> If every company takes this data and is like "we want to pay at the 95th percentile"

It's thought by some that this is how CEO compensation has gone up so much: Corporate boards of directors have compensation committees, which are fed survey data about comp ranges; a comp committee will say, "We want our CEO's comp to be in the top quartile" — which, as time goes on, leads to an inexorable upward ratchet effect.

Re:Ask HN: Why Is Pave Legal? by vishnugupta on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @07:15AM (#41510224)
That’s how pricing works in a market?

In fact if every company did pay at 95th percentile then I’d say it’s a good outcome. There’s a 5 percentile slack which is not too bad?

Re:Ask HN: Why Is Pave Legal? by tensor on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @11:15AM (#41512156)
I think some basic math knowledge would help more, if every company paid at the 95th percentile then it wouldn't be the 95th percentile, it would in fact be the average. But no, these distributions are not flat like that, there is a large spread and "by definition" of the 95th percentile only a few companies pay at that rate.
Re:Ask HN: Why Is Pave Legal? by Suppafly on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @11:23AM (#41512235)
>Company A can use the compensation data from Company B to try and compete better for talent.

My company has done this in the past sorta indirectly, we were losing a lot of people to competitors and data like this is how they justified paying a bunch of us better so we wouldn't leave. I agree that it could be used to fix wages, but companies will always have to pay their best talent more if they want to retain them, whether that means paying them above what the data says or if it means inventing new job titles for them to progress into.

Re:Ask HN: Why Is Pave Legal? by neilv on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @02:09PM (#41513839)
> Company A can use the compensation data from Company B to try and compete better for talent.

Company A could make offers and negotiate with prospective hires based on the value they can get out of the hire. Rather than secretly leverage surveillance capitalism against the prospective hire, to base their offer on what the person is currently making (and, hey, if lots of employers do that by convention, you pretty much have collusion).