News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The expected value of the game is positive regardless of ... by qarl on Friday September 06, 2024 @02:27AM (#41463414)
And this, friends, is the perfect example of why the modern tech interview process is pure insanity.
Re:The expected value of the game is positive regardless of ... by Jalad on Friday September 06, 2024 @02:38AM (#41463479)
Is this a perfect example of broken modern tech interviews?

Balmer's question seems fair for the complexity of the answer he was expecting.

As the interviewee you would presumably provide the (mathematically) wrong answer, but you'd show your thinking along the way, including a small demonstration of CS principles.

Keep in mind that Balmer had a long career, so if he ever asked this question, it was probably back in the 80s when no one expected you to come up with the complex solution outlined in the post.

If you did outline the correct answer, that would be amazing, and you'd be an instant hire. But the question doesn't fundamentally seem broken to me because either answer (taking the bet or not) needs to be well justified.

Re:The expected value of the game is positive regardless of ... by rustybolt on Friday September 06, 2024 @03:00AM (#41463615)
The question seems like a mathematical one.

What you're saying sounds to me like "your answer doesn't need to be correct, it just needs to sound reasonable". What you're filtering on with this question is good bullshitters.

To me, the only reasonable to this question is "I don't know". I think even a mathematical genius like Terrence Tao would not be able to give you the answer to this on the spot. (Although I can also totally believe that he would instantly see this from some obscure theorem that only like 5 people on the planet know.)

Re:The expected value of the game is positive regardless of ... by ywvcbk on Friday September 06, 2024 @03:27AM (#41463808)
> "I don't know"

Which is exactly the same as “no” in this situation. If you were capable of proving the opposite I assume he would have been willing to hear you out.

> not be able to give you the answer to this on the spot

Realizing the most obvious strategy would be suboptimal if the game is adversarial is the first step of the correct answer though. If you didn’t know what to do next obviously the correct answer is “no, because I don’t know”.

Someone who is trying to absolve himself from making any decision ls is presumably not the sort of a person they were looking for.

Also would Balmer have been hiring for engineers to begin with?

Re:The expected value of the game is positive regardless of ... by roenxi on Friday September 06, 2024 @03:11AM (#41463693)
In fairness, if someone proposes a complex and contrived game which cannot be easily analysed but is potentially adversarial... you shouldn't play them.
Re:The expected value of the game is positive regardless of ... by randomdata on Friday September 06, 2024 @03:15AM (#41463721)
Are you talking about Balmer's question or the aforementioned job being interviewed for?
Re:The expected value of the game is positive regardless of ... by IanCal on Friday September 06, 2024 @03:09AM (#41463683)
No, it's about understanding what an interview is for. They're not trying to get the answer. They're trying to find out what you know, how you think and how you communicate.

Do you spot that it's different with one Vs many plays? Do you spot the binary search? Do you spot that an adversarial opponent can push things? Can you clearly communicate these?

If you just say "I don't know" and that's it you are showing you don't know how to communicate important information and miss soft skills about understanding the context of an interview.

If you say "I don't know" and talk through your thoughts then great. The point is talking things through, even if you have gotten the wrong answer.

Maybe you'd be able to say "and here's how I'd code a simulation to check"

Re:The expected value of the game is positive regardless of ... by rustybolt on Friday September 06, 2024 @03:18AM (#41463745)
That seems reasonable, and in that context I would think it's actually a good interview question.

But it seems that Steve Ballmer used this question as if it has a single right answer, and that answer is "no". Unless it's more about the question "do you want to play this game, right here, right now?", then it becomes more about heuristics and quick reasoning.

It's all about context I guess.

Re:The expected value of the game is positive regardless of ... by randomdata on Friday September 06, 2024 @03:01AM (#41463620)
Seems so. The broken tech interview idea stems from the idea that interview questions that do not pertain to the job will lead to hiring the wrong people.

And, indeed, what Microsoft really needed in the 80s was people who truly understood memory management in C, not gamblers left to hack their way into something that kind of worked sometimes. Microsoft's need to correct that hiring mistake later set them back significantly. Had they asked about the intricacies of C as it directly pertained to the job instead of unrelated trivia, they would be in a much stronger position now.

Re:The expected value of the game is positive regardless of ... by ywvcbk on Friday September 06, 2024 @03:30AM (#41463831)
> Had they asked about the intricacies of C

Presumably it wasn’t Ballmer who was asking questions like that?

If he was running the “business”, sales etc. part of the company.

All of the things you listed would have been less than worthless if they weren’t able to convince anyone to buy their products.

Re:The expected value of the game is positive regardless of ... by randomdata on Friday September 06, 2024 @03:41AM (#41463893)
Thanks for playing along. This is a perfect example of why pointless trivia does well in an interview. It reveals the psuedo-intellectuals who will overanalyze the situation in an effort to try and sound intelligent. Exactly who you want to steer clear of.

The candidate you actually want to hire will respond with something to effect of "That's dumb. Let's instead talk about X, which will be a far more appealing topic to both of us."

Re:The expected value of the game is positive regardless of ... by ywvcbk on Saturday September 07, 2024 @02:52AM (#41472037)
Well.. most people generally don’t like working with annoying, self-entitled know-it-alls. So I guess the question serves its purpose if it filters such people out.

> effort to try and sound intelligent. Exactly who you want to steer clear of.

I wouldn’t be reading your comments if I wanted to stay clear of stuff like that, would I?

Re:The expected value of the game is positive regardless of ... by qarl on Friday September 06, 2024 @08:07AM (#41465396)
I think you're missing my point. The problem isn't the question - it's the fact that Balmer was objectively wrong about the answer - and he never changed that determination after having conversations about it however many times. ("I asked this question all the time.")

It doesn't matter that it was difficult to prove he was wrong. The issue is that it was impossible to prove he was right. And if anyone ever tried to bring that up to him, he never once heard them.

I believe an interviewer who is wrong and does not listen to you is a perfect example of the broken process. Especially given that he was an industry leader - in this interview he was providing a historical example of the process' merits - all while being entirely incorrect.

Re:The expected value of the game is positive regardless of ... by lupire on Friday September 06, 2024 @10:04AM (#41466331)
You are claiming things that are absent from and contradicted by the interview.
Re:The expected value of the game is positive regardless of ... by qarl on Friday September 06, 2024 @10:15AM (#41466448)
You need to explain what you think those things are.
Re:The expected value of the game is positive regardless of ... by qarl on Saturday September 07, 2024 @05:02PM (#41476473)
I'd love to address your point, but unless you further articulate your position I won't be able. I see nothing in my statements that isn't directly said or implied from the linked video.
Re:The expected value of the game is positive regardless of ... by langcss on Friday September 06, 2024 @02:44AM (#41463525)
Yes because it is a question for a quant.
Re:The expected value of the game is positive regardless of ... by noname120 on Friday September 06, 2024 @02:46AM (#41463542)
Well to be fair Steve Ballmer is a terrible leader and if he had to take the tech interviews he wouldn't have passed and Microsoft wouldn't have stagnated for 10 years, before Satya Nadella took over and brought the company back on its feet.
Re:The expected value of the game is positive regardless of ... by ywvcbk on Friday September 06, 2024 @03:33AM (#41463853)
He’s probably a decent leader just not a very good CEO for a company that needs to develop new products and enter new markets to continue growing rather than to try and squeeze every remaining penny from their current customers.
Re:The expected value of the game is positive regardless of ... by smolder on Friday September 06, 2024 @03:57AM (#41463981)
Satya Nadella has been good for the stock price and is probably a better leader than Ballmer, but hasn't made MS into a respectable company.
Re:The expected value of the game is positive regardless of ... by high_na_euv on Friday September 06, 2024 @04:05AM (#41464028)
Many Satyas successes started under Ballmer.
Re:The expected value of the game is positive regardless of ... by noname120 on Friday September 06, 2024 @04:25AM (#41464110)
Could you give some examples?
Re:The expected value of the game is positive regardless of ... by high_na_euv on Friday September 06, 2024 @05:24AM (#41464431)
Re:The expected value of the game is positive regardless of ... by OmarShehata on Friday September 06, 2024 @02:34AM (#41463455)
is it? If I was forced to ask this question as an interviewer, and the candidate said, "actually, you're wrong, here's why" that's a very good signal. Do most people not do this?

(typically there's discussion with all the interviewers and it isn't just "did the candidate get the question right or not). I personally think a lot of big tech interview questions are dumb but I think the process isn't as broken as I thought, seeing it from both sides.

Re:The expected value of the game is positive regardless of ... by carlmr on Friday September 06, 2024 @03:11AM (#41463695)
>If I was forced to ask this question as an interviewer, and the candidate said, "actually, you're wrong, here's why" that's a very good signal. Do most people not do this?

The question is whether Ballmers ego would allow him this flexibility if it's his own question.

Some people might be very emotionally attached to the questions they created, but not so much to those they've been given as an interviewer.

I've fared well pointing out issues with questions in the past and gotten the job. I'd try to be diplomatic about it though and not outright say they're wrong. Instead pointing out how with a classical binary search the expected value is negative, but there are strategies from game theory to deal with adversarial picks and here you could reach a positive expected value.

Kind of a "yes, and..." approach. You acknowledge their view, and then you add a new perspective. But don't say they're wrong.

Funny enough in situations where I suspect the interviewer was given the question it probably wouldn't have helped, not due to emotional attachment, but because the interviewer had a tenuous grasp of the topic themselves and couldn't stray from the script they were given.

Re:The expected value of the game is positive regardless of ... by metabagel on Friday September 06, 2024 @02:39AM (#41463484)
I suppose that telling the interviewer that they're wrong is a good way for the interviewee to test culture fit.
Re:The expected value of the game is positive regardless of ... by rustybolt on Friday September 06, 2024 @03:05AM (#41463655)
> Do most people not do this?

I'd say it's impossible to answer this question conclusively within the time frame of an interview. That makes it, in my opinion, a bad interview question.

My answer to this question would be to show that I understand what it would take to answer this question correctly (you'd have to find a mixed strategy that has a positive expected value for every choice of number), I wouldn't be able to give a confident "yes" or "no" answer on the spot. I think that's the only correct answer.

In practice, I think this question is advantegeous for those who confidently blurt out an answer and then make up a heuristic argument for it. But a heuristic argument can be found for both "yes" and "no".

Re:The expected value of the game is positive regardless of ... by qarl on Friday September 06, 2024 @07:42AM (#41465227)
I think you're missing something.

Presumably Balmer did ask this question. At least a few times. And yet he never heard of the correct answer, and believed the incorrect answer to be correct.

That tells you that if anyone did say "actually, you're wrong" he never listened to them.

Re:The expected value of the game is positive regardless of ... by TheCondor on Friday September 06, 2024 @09:48AM (#41466178)
I think this is a good question, there are many veins of potential discussion which is what you want. It’s not likely a binary question.

Is it fair? Does he change his choice or pre-record it? Can you play multiple times?

Purely random distribution, totally fair? Sure play the game every time, the math pans out. It’s not that though.

It’s about showing your work

Re:The expected value of the game is positive regardless of ... by thih9 on Friday September 06, 2024 @03:08AM (#41463669)
As long as it's used to figure out if the two parties would enjoy working with each other, I guess it's fine. But yes, increasingly often this turns into a quiz or worse.

At least we get some quality fiction like https://aphyr.com/posts/340-reversing-the-technical-intervie... and its sequels.

Re:The expected value of the game is positive regardless of ... by beeflet on Friday September 06, 2024 @02:45AM (#41463530)
I don't work in the tech industry but I always assumed these questions were designed for you to demonstrate your problem-solving skills, regardless if you get the answer correct or not.

In this case, it would just be showing that you can reason about binary search and showing that the mean profit is 0.20 dollars

Re:The expected value of the game is positive regardless of ... by weinzierl on Friday September 06, 2024 @02:32AM (#41463436)
It is the perfect example, why you should pay attention in your math class too.
Re:The expected value of the game is positive regardless of ... by corimaith on Friday September 06, 2024 @02:37AM (#41463474)
I don't think the average CS curriculum is going to cover advanced game theory. And you certainly aren't going to doing most linear programming on the spot in a interview.
Re:The expected value of the game is positive regardless of ... by rustybolt on Friday September 06, 2024 @03:20AM (#41463763)
This is actually extremely basic game theory, but I agree that most CS programs would probably not cover it.