Submitters: "Please submit the original source. If a post reports on something found on another site, submit the latter." - https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
This isn't a random aggregator, Freight Waves is a well-known industry specific site.
A world where this wasn't rehashed by Freight Waves is a world where you have to read every Reddit board to gain knowledge.
> unrelated to listening to the radio in itself
None of the links you mention, nor any comment or headline, includes the word listening.
I don't see how any of the headlines, on HN, Freight Waves, or Reddit, or content, on HN, Freight Waves, or Reddit, could be read as related to listening.
> but a lot easier to talk about it directly than via rehashes.
What does this mean, exactly?
EDIT: Can't reply due to HN timeout, maybe the HN link was originally to Jalopnik saying they can't listen to the radio, and it's cached in your browser? On my end, it's always been a link to Freight Waves with the headline "Amazon bans its drivers from moving their own lips...(something something, can't see, I'm on mobile)"
To be clear, I'm not saying the sites themselves are useless or not - just the wrong thing to post as a source for discussion here. From the HN guidelines: "Please submit the original source. If a post reports on something found on another site, submit the latter". Freight Waves would probably be acceptable enough for that, Jalopnik is pretty poor in this particular case.
> None of the links you mention, nor any comment or headline I see, mentions listening.
Apologies, that is a slip on my part - meant singing along to the radio. A great example of why you should look at the original instead of commentary :p.
> What does this mean, exactly?
When you talk about what an article which talks about what another article talks about what people talk about what someone said it becomes a lot less clear than staging a conversation around what was originally said instead.
> instead of talking about things like "That’s an opinion shared by many Freight Waves readers".
It should read more like:
> instead of things like the Jalopnik reporting "That’s an opinion shared by many Freight Waves readers".
I.e. obviously it's not a rehashing problem for Freight Wave to report what its own user polls say.
Still, with the source being one “we were told” I guess we’re not sure if this is this official; this could be a manager’s threat or someone’s inaccurate understanding of what the camera is actually monitoring.
Ventriloquism, face masks or humming in the meantime then. Or quitting, like the author of the linked post - perhaps best for now.
I'm not saying some of this kind of thing can't be better served by some different laws, just it's probably not as easy to solve with a "quick" law or these other approaches as it might seem.
This is not true.
It makes me very itchy to see 2 comments in a row using innuendo and deconstructing sourcing in an erroneous way.
The other handwaves about "rehashing" to wave away Freight Waves, while linking to comments on Reddit. You imply there's only one comment that says "we were told"
The other also implies the claim is they cannot listen to the radio.
As noted elsewhere, I did make a grave error in saying listen instead of sing to when writing the comment and by the time someone mentioned it it was too late to edit the comment. A great example of why you want to base discussion off of sources closer to the original first :).
The version of the story (straight to Freight Waves instead of Jalopnik) the link was changed to at the time you made your comment was much better about getting to this point (one less layer of indirection).
Just reading the original quoted mid article without the extra commentary it's clear the story is unrelated to listening to the radio in itself and to do with the camera mechanism monitoring for other forms of distracted driving not being able to tell the difference:
> we were told that "a lot of mouth movement will set off the camera" and that we "needed to keep mouth movement to a minimum".
Still a shitty system by all counts... but a lot easier to talk about it directly than via rehashes.