News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Iranian writer is sentenced to 12 years after tweeting a ... by throw10920 on Monday September 02, 2024 @07:15PM (#41429576)
It's worth pointing out that similar stuff (although not quite as egregious) is happening in Belarus, Brazil, and even the UK.
Re:Iranian writer is sentenced to 12 years after tweeting a ... by eigenket on Monday September 02, 2024 @07:42PM (#41429720)
Could you point to something happening in the UK you think is similar to this?

Edit: I guess there's this [1] which free-speach maximalists would probably disagree with. Personally I think there's a line between free speech and calls to violence at which point its reasonable to prosecute people. She tweeted calling for people to set fire to buildings where migrants were being housed.

[1] https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cx2910vrrygo

Re:Iranian writer is sentenced to 12 years after tweeting a ... by throw10920 on Monday September 02, 2024 @07:53PM (#41429793)
A guy got 3 years in prison a few weeks ago for tweeting that people should go out and protest.
Re:Iranian writer is sentenced to 12 years after tweeting a ... by eigenket on Monday September 02, 2024 @07:59PM (#41429818)
Are you lying or misinformed?

He didn't get 3 years in prison for telling people to go out and protest, he told people to “set fire to all the fucking hotels full of the bastards”.

Setting fire to a building full of people isn't a protest, it's attempted murder.

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/crime/northampton-bbc-...

Re:Iranian writer is sentenced to 12 years after tweeting a ... by emmet on Monday September 02, 2024 @08:28PM (#41429987)
They always try to be vague when the truth is difficult to defend.
Re:Iranian writer is sentenced to 12 years after tweeting a ... by throw10920 on Monday September 02, 2024 @08:39PM (#41430054)
You both are actively lying. I'm not talking about Tyler Kay, I'm talking about Wayne O’Rourke, whose tweets did not advocate for murder at all, let alone “set fire to all the fucking hotels full of the bastards”. Not once did I mention Tyler. That's something you fabricated to deceive and mislead.

It's people like you that enable authoritarianism around the world by gaslighting others and justifying suppression of speech.

Re:Iranian writer is sentenced to 12 years after tweeting a ... by eigenket on Tuesday September 03, 2024 @02:41AM (#41431961)
Oh, that guy posted "Today was a terror attack by a Muslim...heads must roll" which again sounds like a call to violence to me.

Sorry I picked the wrong guy calling for racial violence, my mistake.

Re:Iranian writer is sentenced to 12 years after tweeting a ... by throw10920 on Tuesday September 03, 2024 @08:51AM (#41434473)
You actively lied about the person that was jailed to further a political agenda of suppressing free speech, protest, and democracy. That's not a mistake, that's malice. Your bad indeed.

Moreover, it's pretty clear that "heads must roll" is a euphemism used for people being punished or losing their job, and is almost always used in a non-violent context: https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/heads%20will%20ro...

There's no clear call to violence here. You are actively trying to justify tyranny.

Re:Iranian writer is sentenced to 12 years after tweeting a ... by eigenket on Tuesday September 03, 2024 @09:32AM (#41434776)
I didn't lie, I got the wrong guy because you weren't specific. In the context of his tweet I think it was clearly a call to violence. Almost always is not the same as always.
Re:Iranian writer is sentenced to 12 years after tweeting a ... by throw10920 on Tuesday September 03, 2024 @09:55AM (#41434989)
> I got the wrong guy because you weren't specific

That doesn't make it any less of a lie - you said something factually false about the person I was referring to. You also made an assumption that you knew could be false in order to push a political agenda and deceive others.

> Almost always is not the same as always.

This is grasping for straws, and has the tyrannical premise of "guilty until proven innocent" behind it. I really hope that you're not in a position of power in my country, or any one for that matter.

Re:Iranian writer is sentenced to 12 years after tweeting a ... by eigenket on Tuesday September 03, 2024 @10:27AM (#41435308)
> and has the tyrannical premise of "guilty until proven innocent" behind it

No it doesn't, for three reasons.

1. This is an internet forum not a court of law

2. He already plead guilty to his crime and been convicted, hes no longer in the "innocent until proven guilty" phase

3. Calling for violence wasn't even the crime he was convicted of. That was "publishing written material to stir up racial hate" [1].

Now you can reasonably say (and I expect you would) that you don't think that publishing written material to stir up racial hate should be a crime. Personally I think it should, because stirring up racial hatred is pretty damaging.

[1] https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1986/64/part/III/crossh...

Re:Iranian writer is sentenced to 12 years after tweeting a ... by throw10920 on Saturday September 07, 2024 @05:32PM (#41476614)
> 1. This is an internet forum not a court of law

This doesn't matter. "Guilty until proven innocent" is not exclusively a legal concept. Furthermore, you're making this opinion about a legal case, so even if it was exclusively a legal concept, you'd still be making an opinion about what should happen in a court of law.

> 2. He already plead guilty to his crime and been convicted, hes no longer in the "innocent until proven guilty" phase

This demonstrates a lack of experience with the real world, as it's very common for innocent people to plead guilty. This is trivially verifiable with quick internet searches[1]. Ergo, this claim is false - guilty plea status is irrelevant, especially if we're discussing the merits of the case or verdict.

> 3. Calling for violence wasn't even the crime he was convicted of. That was "publishing written material to stir up racial hate" [1].

That's even worse. If you read the definition of the law:

> A person who uses threatening, abusive or insulting words or behaviour, or displays any written material which is threatening, abusive or insulting, is guilty of an offence if—

> (a)he intends thereby to stir up racial hatred, or

> (b)having regard to all the circumstances racial hatred is likely to be stirred up thereby.

...you'd see that it's far less clear and more subjective than calling for violence.

> Personally I think it should, because stirring up racial hatred is pretty damaging.

This is a non-argument because "Stirring up racial hatred" doesn't mean anything. The law is written so broadly that it can be interpreted to mean almost anything. It's also a concept almost exclusively used by the UK government that is used to prosecute political opponents with zero clear harm identified. And, the concept is exclusively legal, not moral/ethical - if you ask a random person on the street of any country what "stirring up racial hatred" means, you'll get wildly different answers, and more than a few confused looks. This also means that "stirring up racial hatred is pretty damaging" doesn't mean anything, because you can't even quantify the meaning of the phrase, which makes assessing effects/damage completely impossible.

Even if you're acting in genuinely good faith (which is not the case in the UK) and only personally intend to use this law to prosecute people who are calling for violence (which is already illegal), it's extremely clear that the law is so broadly-written that it can be used against your political opponents (or, you, in case the party in power changes).

Not-so-ironically, you can see the exact same situation in the HN submission article - "Shanbehzadeh was sentenced to five years for alleged pro-Israel propaganda activity, four years for insulting Islamic sanctities, two years for spreading lies online and an additional year for anti-regime propaganda."

Like "stirring up racial hate", none of those terms mean anything (except what the state wants them to mean when it wants them to mean it in a legal context to persecute opponents), all of them are extremely broadly applicable, and all of them are actively being used by the state to suppress speech it doesn't like. You can take your statement "Personally I think [publishing written material to stir up racial hate] should [be illegal], because stirring up racial hatred is pretty damaging." and swap out the nouns and get "Personally I think spreading lies online should be illegal, because lies are pretty damaging" and you've just justified what the state of Iran did with exactly the same logic.

[1] https://www.criminallegalnews.org/news/2021/may/15/study-sho...

Re:Iranian writer is sentenced to 12 years after tweeting a ... by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday September 03, 2024 @10:07AM (#41435117)
Dude, cool your jets. The site guidelines call for you to assume good faith; you are failing at that.

While you're at it, look up the definition of "lie". It doesn't mean "made a mistake out of confusion".

Re:Iranian writer is sentenced to 12 years after tweeting a ... by throw10920 on Tuesday September 03, 2024 @06:56PM (#41440158)
You're right, I should be better about assuming good faith - I'd say that at this point there's at least some evidence that the user is not acting in good faith, but it's still pretty tenuous, and I wasn't acting that way to begin with. Thank you for calling that out.
Re:Iranian writer is sentenced to 12 years after tweeting a ... by AnimalMuppet on Wednesday September 04, 2024 @08:23AM (#41444816)
Well, see, I've never assumed bad faith... um... at least not today... so far...

Thanks for listening when called out. That's not easy.

Re:Iranian writer is sentenced to 12 years after tweeting a ... by nec4b on Tuesday September 03, 2024 @02:34PM (#41437720)
I'm curious, what do you think "heads must roll" means? Is English your first language?
Re:Iranian writer is sentenced to 12 years after tweeting a ... by eigenket on Tuesday September 03, 2024 @06:14PM (#41439858)
Heads must roll has two meanings to me

1. The original meaning is that people must be killed.

2. The more common meaning these days is that people must be punished in some less dramatic way (usually fired).

It is typical of racists to use phrases with double meanings like this. The idea ia that when their words are quoted back at them they can attempt to avoid consequences by claiming they intended the other meaning.

I am a native English speaker.

Re:Iranian writer is sentenced to 12 years after tweeting a ... by nec4b on Wednesday September 04, 2024 @09:14AM (#41445351)
>> It is typical of racists to use phrases with double meanings like this.

Using phrases with double meaning (euphemisms) is a sign of people who read a book or two and have the intelligence to understand the play on words. Some people unfortunately don't have this ability and they take everything as literal.

Re:Iranian writer is sentenced to 12 years after tweeting a ... by AlexSW on Monday September 02, 2024 @08:18PM (#41429932)
Could you link to the particular case you're referring to?
Re:Iranian writer is sentenced to 12 years after tweeting a ... by ClumsyPilot on Monday September 02, 2024 @08:39PM (#41430052)
Well we are working it.

In these riots we have charged a 12 year old orphan, sentenced 13 year old girl, jailed a guy for being “a curious observer”, and some woman for throwing water.

Previously, we have sentenced a teenager for reposting a rap song, some guy for filming his pug doing nazi salute, and charged two guys for possession of a book ‘Anarchist cookbook’

Also we have charged a woman for silent prayer.

So now I understand why a book about ‘thoughtcrime’ was written in Britain, it’s a local idea that was in the air for some time

Re:Iranian writer is sentenced to 12 years after tweeting a ... by throw10920 on Monday September 02, 2024 @08:41PM (#41430075)
The UK judges have stated that they will jail passive observers of the riots as a matter of policy, so it's not just that one guy:

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2024/08/09/judge-refuses-ba...

Re:Iranian writer is sentenced to 12 years after tweeting a ... by eigenket on Tuesday September 03, 2024 @03:59AM (#41432445)
More specifically they're jailing people who were at the riots but who claim they were only passive observers.

This is standard pre-trial detention because pretty serious crimes were committed. Obviously if its found at their trial that they didn't commit any crime then they won't be going to prison.

Re:Iranian writer is sentenced to 12 years after tweeting a ... by eigenket on Tuesday September 03, 2024 @04:33AM (#41432640)
I don't know the details of the other cases but the UK didn't jail anyone for being a "curious observer". They jailed him in advance of his trial where it is alleged he took part in criminal acts (setting fire to shops and other standard riot stuff).

He claims he was a curious observer, but frankly he can claim whatever he likes. Like everyone in pre-trial detention he is innocent until proven guilty so his claim doesn't really change anything.

Re:Iranian writer is sentenced to 12 years after tweeting a ... by snehk on Tuesday September 03, 2024 @02:31AM (#41431906)
Add Germany to that list. A girl was sentenced to actual jail for insulting a rapist who was spared jail. Absolute madness.
Re:Iranian writer is sentenced to 12 years after tweeting a ... by eigenket on Tuesday September 03, 2024 @04:12AM (#41432517)
Ok, there's some stuff that you seem confused about here.

Firstly she wasn't sentenced for insulting him, she was sentenced for threats of violence against him, specifically she wrote something like "you won't be able to go anywhere without having your face kicked in" and leaked his personal information.

Secondly she was in jail for 2 days, this was Freizeitarrest which is legally distinct from an actual prison sentence, with the aim of showing someone how unpleasant prison can be. You're not in a normal cell, don't have contact with regular prisoners, it doesn't leave a police record, doesn't have the same probation or anything.

Finally he wasn't sentenced to jail because he was a minor. He did get sentenced to 60 hours of labor with the proceeds going to her. I don't know whether 60 hours of unpaid (presumably) unpleasant labor is harsher than the very short "jail" sentence she got, personally I would say so but it probably depends on the person.

Personally I would agree that his sentence wasn't harsh enough, but German law doesn't really like giving minors harsh sentences. I think her punishment for the threats of violence were completely reasonable.

Re:Iranian writer is sentenced to 12 years after tweeting a ... by throw10920 on Tuesday September 03, 2024 @09:29AM (#41434747)
> she wasn't sentenced for insulting him, she was sentenced for threats of violence against him

This is a lie. Her sentence was in part for "defaming" him... in direct messages, that contained personal insults like “disgraceful rapist pig”[1]. She was not jailed solely for the threats of violence.

> leaked his personal information

Of a violent criminal that the state refused to confine for the safety of others? That's entirely reasonable. The rapist is an active threat to those around him, especially because "The judge overseeing the case noted that none of the defendants expressed remorse over the attack"[2], and Germany doesn't have a sex offender registry like some other states, so others around the rapist don't have a way to know about his presence, which is kind of in the public interest.

You also missed the part about the fact that she got a harsher sentence for her speech than the rapist himself. So when you say "I think her punishment for the threats of violence were completely reasonable." it sure sounds like you're saying that you think that threats of violence should be punished more heavily than actual violence.

I wonder why you're lying so much (here, and in other comments in this thread) to try to justify tyranny and oppression and violence against the vulnerable.

[1] https://news.yahoo.com/news/german-woman-given-harsher-sente...

[2] https://humanevents.com/2024/06/25/german-woman-sent-to-pris...

Re:Iranian writer is sentenced to 12 years after tweeting a ... by eigenket on Tuesday September 03, 2024 @09:41AM (#41434856)
> She was not jailed solely for the threats of violence.

As far as I understand, yeah she was. I'm not an expert in the German legal system but while the defamation was also a crime my understanding is she wouldn't have been sent to jail for that.

As far as the rest of your comment goes, I already said in the comment you're replying to that in my opinion the sentence he was given was significantly too light. Thats a specific weird thing about the German legal system, they are (in my opinion) very light on people who are being tried as juveniles.

> You also missed the part about the fact that she got a harsher sentence for her speech than the rapist himself

I literally mentioned that in the comment you're replying too and as I've now said three times, in my opinion his sentence was not harsh enough.

I haven't lied anywhere on this thread.

Re:Iranian writer is sentenced to 12 years after tweeting a ... by throw10920 on Tuesday September 03, 2024 @09:50AM (#41434932)
> my understanding is she wouldn't have been sent to jail for that.

Your "understanding" directly contradicts the links I posted saying that she was jailed for her insulting/offensive remarks.

> I haven't lied anywhere on this thread.

> He didn't get 3 years in prison for telling people to go out and protest, he told people to “set fire to all the fucking hotels full of the bastards”.

That's a lie, right there. I was not referring to that person.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41429818

Re:Iranian writer is sentenced to 12 years after tweeting a ... by eigenket on Tuesday September 03, 2024 @09:55AM (#41434972)
Copying and pasting from literally the third sentence of the link you posted

> The young woman was convicted last week of sending "insulting and threatening" messages

The threatening is important

I didn't lie in the comment you linked, I just didn't magically guess which guy you were talking about. I apologise for that.

Re:Iranian writer is sentenced to 12 years after tweeting a ... by throw10920 on Tuesday September 03, 2024 @10:02AM (#41435064)
You said above:

>> she wasn't sentenced for insulting him

...which is the falsehood that I pointed out with those links. I never claimed that the threat of violence didn't factor into it - you're the one who claimed that the insults didn't.

> I didn't lie in the comment you linked

You said something factually false about someone while knowing it could be false. That's epsilon away from lying, and it's certainly deceitful and deceptive, as are your statements above.

> didn't magically guess

So you magically guessed in the most malicious way possible instead of asking who I was talking about.

You also said:

> Are you lying or misinformed?

So you extremely confidently and aggressively projected your assumptions onto me.

Re:Iranian writer is sentenced to 12 years after tweeting a ... by eigenket on Tuesday September 03, 2024 @10:13AM (#41435180)
>> my understanding is she wouldn't have been sent to jail for that.

> Your "understanding" directly contradicts the links I posted saying that she was jailed for her insulting/offensive remarks.

My copy and paste of the third sentence of your link was to point out that this is false.

As far as the lying goes, if I was trying to lie I wouldn't have linked an article naming the guy in my message. What I said was completely correct about a guy who matches the description you gave as much as the person you intended did (both told people to protest, both called for violence against migrants (in my opinion)). I made a mistake in that I didn't know there was a second one of these scumbags in the news currently. That mistake is on me but its not a lie.

[dead]
Re:Iranian writer is sentenced to 12 years after tweeting a ... by tasuki on Tuesday September 03, 2024 @12:39PM (#41436634)
> in which she actively lived and participated.

Yes... ? She participated... on the side of the Nazis who murdered Jews? She even threatened Jews with "a new pogrom"? I'd imprison her all right!