I don't like it when people assume perfect descriptions of reality are possible, but I also don't like it when people baselessly assume they're impossible.
Maybe one day we'll have a theory of everything and a solar system sized computer capable of perfectly simulating a bouncing ball at all levels, with no reduction.
Or maybe it's impossible.
We just don't know, and I don't know if it's possible to know you have the full picture.
Thought experiment:
I live on a planet near Star A and you live 6 trillion miles away on a planet near Star B. Each of us can see each other's host star as a bright star in our respective skies. Suddenly, both of our host stars supernova and burn out at the exact same time.
However, survivors on my planet observe that Star A supernova'd, and then about 1 year later Star B supernova'd (due to how long the light takes to reach Star A from Star B). And survivors on your planet observe the opposite: That Star B blew up first, and 1 year later Star A followed.
Only an observer precisely equidistant from both stars would have observed the stars burn out simultaneously. But there's nothing special about this vantage point - this vantage point isn't "the truth" either.
This means that a concept like the order of events is not an absolute measurement. To come up with a new function that explains what "really happened" here, accounting for relativity and lightspeed, would be to leave out at least that detail. Each additional function that answers new mysteries abstracts further and leaves out other details by necessity.
I think of it like fine-tuning a model to increase accuracy, it necessarily de-tunes it in other ways.
> simulating a bouncing ball at all levels, with no reduction
It wouldn't fully be the same thing (although could be a very good approximation).
2. Time as a linear description is the same, a way of sorting the physical world into a series of events.
Both have generalizations. Topos Theory generalizes Set Theory with different notions of what is "true." There are several variations on temporal logic with Linear Temporal Logic being only one such idea.
With all that in mind, your thought experiment does not cause any issues because you can say that the framework for reasoning about the example is _itself_ the problem. Hence, it fails as a counterexample for our inability to potentially understand reality without flaw.
In both comments I assert that phenomena cannot be wholly modeled (or replicated). The gist is that descriptions and replicas are always lossy to some extent.
The second comment just expands on why, relating it ultimately to physical limitations (features) of physical reality.
You can get uncannily precise and predictive with some knowledge - engineering, manufacturing, math - that any lossiness is truly negligible. Especially the smaller the scope and more "medium sized" the object or idea in question. But compounded, and at extreme scales, the incompleteness of our understanding of reality shows.
I agree with your 1 & 2.
You have it backwards. Events not having a globally consistent order is reality. Events seeming like they do is your intuition and leaves out details.
- A happened before B
- B happened before A
- A & B happened at the exact same time
- Neither / there is no "before"/"after"
Considering this is the case with anything measured, what explanatory "truth" would be left when you consider a perfect description of reality? One that accounts for the global reference frames of every possible metric (not just order of events)?
There's no absolute "truth" to any of the mainstays:
Where things are
When they happened
In what order they happened
Even whether or not they happened (there is a perspective where all the values of a measured thing can be zero - like mirroring the velocity of a speeding object to reduce its speed to zero, or rotating a plane to make its height zero - and the different physical implications therein).
We correlate observed "locations in space" and the "passage of time" to heuristical approximations that work (as scientific theories) for our intents and purposes on a hyper local level (a tiny fraction of just our galaxy), but they break down on macro levels because they aren't really accurate descriptions of reality. Our physics doesn't work at scale - not smaller than atoms, nor larger than ~solar systems, without theories falling apart.
Space
The XYZ coordinate system we understand as "3D space" works great for locating and measuring the size of objects locally, we could perfectly track a tiny marble bouncing down a huge mountain with a granular enough XYZ coordinate system and telemetry. But that wouldn't work on larger scales like comparing the movement of subatomic particles with the movement of stars in the same graph. The graph couldn't accurately chart that without normalizing data or adjusting the reference frame toward one bias or the other (see scale invariance, vacuum catastrophe). We can only neatly slap a fixed reference frame over a scoped area, invent units and call it a "field", if we expect any predictive utility.
Time
There's not really an absolute "arrow of time" with a past and future, where A happened, then B happened, etc. in an absolute sense. As shown in the star example, it completely depends on the orientation and velocity of the observer, and other factors. No one perspective is more true than the other.
We all happen to hang out in the same frames, so it seems like some of these are rigid laws - they effectively are, for us - but they aren't really, ultimately. When you eliminate the heuristics that give value to science there's nothing left - which as mentioned above is a possible and potential state.
Instead of living in a 3D universe with an absolute time, we are living in a 4D universe where time is a relative direction in the space-time. That doesn't mean we can't model things in principle, it just means we need to model them as things existing in 4D space-time.
True, really just meant "not absolute".
> such that C happened before D in every reference frame
If that's possible, considering the seemingly infinite number of instances where it'd have to both happen and in that way/order, I would consider those kinds of events to be the fundamental/baseline "forces" or asymmetries.
For example, the distance between Earth and Moon is about 1.3 light-seconds. That means that is A happens on Earth now, and B happens on Moon 1 second later (from our perspective), it is possible that from someone else's perspective B happened before A.
(Note that "someone else" in this example does not refer to the Moon, because its perspective is very similar to the perspective of the Earth. It refers to a hypothetical alien spaceship flying at an extremely high speed in a line parallel to the line between the Earth and the Moon.)
However, if C happens on Earth now, and D happens on Moon 2 seconds later (from our perspective), then C happened before D from everyone's perspective. Individual aliens would disagree on the exact time interval between C and D, where 0.7 would be the smallest possible value, but it could be any larger value. (You get the smallest possible value when you are not moving relatively to the Earth and the Moon.)
This is because a hypothetical light particle emitted at A couldn't reach B in time, but a hypothetical light particle emitted at C could reach D in time. The speed of light is the speed of causality, kind of. Events A and B couldn't possibly have caused each other (they could have a common cause X, but that's different), but C hypothetically could have caused D, which is why C happened before D from everyone's perspective.
Fascinating insights - it can be seen as causality, or at scale that there is a multi-dimensional reality where some timelines are inaccessible/impossible to each other (yet exist in their own right).
Perhaps in our neural net, we are also approximating functions that deal the approximated objects.
I think we know the brain doesn't just call an api. But it is doing some 'function' like things.
Not really true, our minds create approximate models of reality and in doing so divides the world into discrete objects that we can play with, but there's no reason to believe those discrete objects actually exist "out there" independent of our senses.
In this regard, even something as seemingly fundamental as arithmetic is just language. There's not really "two" "oranges".
I can write a function that explains what happens when a ball bounces off concrete, but nothing about that function is the ball bouncing off the concrete - the bouncing ball is not made of the function, nor is the function even a part of it. It's a totally outside replica that isn't even fully 1:1. Any attempt to completely model the ball or the concrete or the bouncing will fall short - they'll always be reductions.
So we're not made of functions. We don't know what we are. We use functions to model what's happening, but they're approximations or reductions of what it really is.