If Acadia is engaged in insurance fraud, the insurance companies have every incentive to stop that.
Clearly falls into mandatory coverage (if claims are accurate), so all companies are going to have to pay it. Raises costs. Insurance gets to have overhead (profit) based on claims paid.
There's more incentive to deny marginal claims, because some insurance companies won't and then you may attract more customers with a lower price and maybe you get more money that way.
Patients are unlikely to complain to insurance to tell them the treatment/confinement was unjustified... because the patient will then need to pay the bill.
Honestly, you buried the lede here. This is the horrifying and broken part. Under no circumstances should someone have to be afraid of paying for their involuntary commitment.
Like is Acadia really going to sue so they can have the insurance company and the patient testify under oath that Acadia management is guilty of kidnapping at scale, and in this particular case?
This is one of the prime examples of the utter failure of the US for-profit healthcare model.
If they actually kidnapped you (as is apparently common practice there), I doubt they’d be dumb enough to sue you.
If they were, you can countersue in California, and the civil damages they owe you for kidnapping you will be deducted from whatever court judgement they win (probably making it negative).
> Acadia was founded in 2005 by Reeve B. Waud, a financier, and grew slowly at first. But in 2011, the company went public and embarked on a major expansion.
> The timing was ideal. Over the next several years, Acadia got a lift from Obamacare, which required insurers to cover mental health. Today Acadia has 54 inpatient psychiatric hospitals with a total of 5,900 beds.
I'm not trying to imply that the ACA is bad here - just that the incentive provided by the requirement for insurance companies to cover this form of treatment inadvertently incentivized the kind of fraud described in the article.
This is why legislation needs to be iterated on - to correct for unexpected consequences like this. Ideally the abuse described in this article would be prevented by further legislation - though there's always a chance that could open up further loopholes.
The affordable care act mandated that insurance companies cover mental health. Psychiatric hospitals can charge insurers $2,200/day for holding patients who "pose an imminent threat to themselves or others".
So now you get this:
> Once Acadia gets patients in the door, it often tries to hold them until their insurance runs out.
> Acadia goes to great lengths to convince insurers that the patients should stay as long as possible, often around five days.
> To do that, Acadia needs to show that patients are unstable and require ongoing intensive care. Former Acadia executives and staff in 10 states said employees were coached to use certain buzzwords, like “combative,” in patients’ charts to make that case.