If this happening as frequently as the article suggests, and if Arcadia operates over 50 hospitals, you’d think there would be at least 1 law firm dedicated solely to prosecuting this specific hospital.
Skip the class action BS, and run those “mesothelioma” type commercials. Then have a boilerplate structure for a lawsuit that you can repeat successfully, hire your own doctors as expert witnesses to refute the hospital, etc.
If they are imprisoning people illegally, I imagine the settlements would be quite high per patient.
> But since it was just the doctor's word against theirs
When something is widespread and perpetrated by the same people, you have to establish a pattern of behavior to discredit the witness.
The narrative could be pretty straight forward: the doctor was lying to the insurance company, and they’re lying to the jury, too.
Seems they already settled a couple suits, which could potentially be used to discredit the hospital as well.
But again, you really need a specialized firm willing to take them down by taking on a bunch of similar cases to make it worthwhile to do all of the background/evidence/research to make a case.
This is also the type of case that could get heavy PR / public support which the right law firms can leverage in their favor.
…or we embrace better regulation and trust the government to fix this. But the government also has a terrible track record when it comes to caring for the mentally ill.
That depends on whether or not anyone cares about the patient.
Many, many psych patients have basically been disowned by their families, they have no friends, and don't have the ability to live on their own in society. Maybe the lawyers would care enough about them, if they could win a suit, but I'd not bet on that.
I'd suspect that a huge number of homeless folks were ones that would have been "lifers" in mental hospitals. The enormous homeless problem in the US is actually relatively new. I remember when it was much, much less of a problem (We have always had them, but nowhere near the scale we have them, now).
We live in a nation, where it is easier for mentally ill people to get weapons, than help[0].
That said, in MD, where I lived for a while, we had The Patuxent Institution[1]. It may still be around. Charming place. It inspired this movie[2].
[0] https://www.npr.org/sections/shots-health-news/2024/08/24/nx...
What after winning the suit? I mean, if they dont have the ability to live on their own, what happens with them?
They'll probably get cheated out of whatever winnings they get, and end up back on the street.
Thank god for Ken Kasey and thank god for desinsitutionalization and the anti-psychiatry movement.
The effects of medications will encourage patients to act out, decompensate, commit acts of self-harm and violence upon others. The strategy is to get them jailed or cause serious bodily harm/death, because... Well let's just say that the incentives are perverse.
Whereas lunatics of old wore visible chains and straitjackets, and were mercifully housed, fed, and clothed, now they are largely on their own, sink or swim; hope some other human family member cares enough to pick up the pieces.
Of course, you can point to some centrist flyover states, but in anywhere worth living, it’s either extreme blue team or extreme red team policies.
These types of abuses happen with all the "institutional" civil laws - involuntary commitment, civil asset forfeiture, guardianship, red flag, and especially protection from abuse orders (weaponized in divorces fairly commonly). It will continue to increase as we, as a society, continue to favor quick and easy "fixes" to overcome the protections found on the criminal side.
They helped more than 1 friend of mine when they when they needed the help.
The real issue is the 100k+ bill they got at the end, but politics so I digress.
This kind of thing used to scare me - once you're booked into the system, they can literally stab you with an injection to make you behave in whatever way they want to portray you in court. And that's just if they're outright malicious.
Worse, they might instead be entirely earnest in their belief that you need to take that particular pill, that makes your misdiagnosed condition worse.
then its not patient vs doctor, it's doctor vs doctor
I know someone who was threatened with having their children taken away, and prison if they tried to leave the hospital, or stopped taking medication that was making them feel worse.
But since it was just the doctor's word against theirs, they were told there was very little chance of winning in court.