News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Anarchy in Sudan has spawned the world’s worst famine in ... by crop_rotation on Sunday September 01, 2024 @08:49AM (#41416583)
Central planning has a very good record in countries like China/South Korea. Non central social changes are just very very slow.
Re:Anarchy in Sudan has spawned the world’s worst famine in ... by yorwba on Sunday September 01, 2024 @10:25AM (#41417214)
Central planning has an extremely bad record in China, especially when it comes to famine.

During the Great Leap forward, the central planners demanded the implementation of new Lysenkoist farming practices that were reportedly a great success and on track to deliver a record harvest. The central planners then dispensed generous daily rations from the granaries, so that everyone could eat their fill, causing farmers to spend less effort on the side crops they had been growing in addition to working on the state farms. The central planners decided that they didn't need quite so many agricultural workers, so they redirected the labor surplus to increasing steel production in order to catch up with the British Empire and overtake the United States. And they also increased food exports to other countries.

Then it all came crashing down: the reports of huge productivity increases were made up, the record harvest was a record low, the surplus was a deficit, tens of millions of people starved. (Steel production did not meaningfully increase either.)

You could argue that it was just a very expensive beginner's mistake because they'd only been doing the central planning thing for about a decade at that point, but then after Mao's death less than two decades later, the first big economic reform was the Household Responsibility System where farmers would decide for themselves what to grow, and the state would just buy it from them.

So I think the verdict from the world's greatest experts in agricultural central planning is clear: don't do it.

Re:Anarchy in Sudan has spawned the world’s worst famine in ... by crop_rotation on Sunday September 01, 2024 @10:38AM (#41417316)
I have mentioned this elsewhere as well, no kind of planning saves one from bad economic policy. Post Deng China has a very very good record of bringing prosperity (and China still central planning).
Re:Anarchy in Sudan has spawned the world’s worst famine in ... by Jensson on Sunday September 01, 2024 @10:45AM (#41417372)
> and China still central planning

Every country has some central planning, China doesn't have much more central planning today than your average European country. Or do you believe some CCP central planner decided to put in scantily clad anime girls in games from China?

China today is very capitalist, they lack democracy, not capitalism.

Re:Anarchy in Sudan has spawned the world’s worst famine in ... by lazyasciiart on Sunday September 01, 2024 @11:52AM (#41417893)
I would probably focus on the government-mandated construction of new cities and control over which citizens go to university and where they can live, and that there is a wide spectrum of control between the USA and central planners managing the graphics in video game production.
Re:Anarchy in Sudan has spawned the world’s worst famine in ... by Jensson on Sunday September 01, 2024 @12:06PM (#41418001)
> control over which citizens go to university and where they can live

I am pretty sure Chinese citizens are allowed to live where they can afford and they are allowed to go to university if they score well enough on the public tests. Just like in Europe.

If you are talking about the random arrests that happens in China, that is due to the undemocratic authoritarian regime and corruption, not due to central planning.

Re:Anarchy in Sudan has spawned the world’s worst famine in ... by lazyasciiart on Sunday September 01, 2024 @12:09PM (#41418020)
No, they aren’t. Look up the hukou residence permit system.
Re:Anarchy in Sudan has spawned the world’s worst famine in ... by Jensson on Sunday September 01, 2024 @12:20PM (#41418093)
That has already ended, there is no such discrimination any longer, the Hokou now is just a way to track people. Loosening that up is a big contributor to the Chinese miracle.

Edit: Also class based societies are typically not called central planning, it is lack of human rights.

Western nations do similar levels of planning just by deciding how many new houses are allowed to be built, you need a permit for every business to ensure you don't take too much electricity etc, tons of central planning everywhere.

Re:Anarchy in Sudan has spawned the world’s worst famine in ... by thaumasiotes on Sunday September 01, 2024 @01:02PM (#41418448)
Having worked at a school in China in which a large number of the students were there because their nonlocal hukou didn't entitle them to attend local public schools, it's pretty surreal to see someone claiming that the hukou controls where people are allowed to live. How are you imagining that happens?
Re:Anarchy in Sudan has spawned the world’s worst famine in ... by thaumasiotes on Sunday September 01, 2024 @01:37PM (#41418691)
> I am pretty sure Chinese citizens are allowed to [...] go to university if they score well enough on the public tests. Just like in Europe.

China implements a comprehensive system of geographic affirmative action to prevent universities from being taken over by southerners. A school participating in this system will publish a plan stating how many students it will enroll on a province-by-province basis. (It's also divided by whether the students will major in science or humanities.)

Once the tests are scored, the students in a particular province are assigned in top-down order of score to the school of their choice, as long as that school's quota for accepting students from that province is not yet full. If your school of choice has filled its quota, technically you can have listed a second-choice school, but this is widely viewed as a disaster for the student. You need to get in to your first-choice school, or take a year off and try again next year.

What's happening in admissions cells for other provinces at the school you apply to is not relevant to you. You can outscore 90% of students who get admitted that way and it won't matter.

And this is not an especially unlikely scenario, because Chinese policy is that schools have much larger quotas for local students than otherwise. I think you need to score at about the 1 in 60 level, top 1.66%, to get into a top Shanghai university from Shanghai; you need to do a lot better than that to get in from outside Shanghai.

Sanity checking that, the admission table for Fudan University in 2018 is here: https://ao.fudan.edu.cn/a7/19/c36333a435993/page.htm . This contains some annotations that I don't understand, but let's say you want to be admitted as a math major. The score threshold if you're coming from Shanghai appears to be 586 ("选考科目999"?); 586 on the Shanghai 2017 gaokao is top 1.1%, or in perfect detail the top 473 people out of 43,103 who took the test. ( https://news.koolearn.com/20170623/1127786.html )

The score threshold if you're coming from Fujian appears to be 680 on the science test. A 680 on the 2017 science test in Fujian means you were one of the top 72 scorers out of 86,368 people who took the test, or the top 0.00083%. ( https://max.book118.com/html/2021/0817/8104004033003135.shtm )

That admissions table for Fudan is divided into two categories, 提前批 ("advance admission"?) and 本一批 ("freshman admission"??). I'm not sure what they mean; I used the 本一批 numbers, which are stricter.

Relevant here, I knew someone who attended a high school affiliated with Fudan (a lot of Chinese universities have these), and she informed me that before taking the gaokao, she had an interview with someone at Fudan, and their approval of her meant that she needed a lower score for admission to Fudan than would otherwise have been necessary. I suspect that this may be related to the difference between "advance admission" and "freshman admission".

(There is also affirmative action given for non-geographic reasons. Sometimes they combine in interesting ways. A friend of mine who was admitted to 上海财经大学 benefited from a program for minorities. She was a Mongol, and would have been given a direct bonus to her gaokao score for that reason, but this program additionally involved (1) attending a special high school in Beijing, and (2) counting as a resident of Beijing, and therefore also benefiting from the geographic scheme, for admissions purposes.)

Re:Anarchy in Sudan has spawned the world’s worst famine in ... by Jensson on Monday September 02, 2024 @09:16AM (#41425153)
You do know that Europe and USA has similar systems, just more spots? Local students are prioritized almost everywhere, in Europe it is by country, in USA it is by state.
Re:Anarchy in Sudan has spawned the world’s worst famine in ... by thaumasiotes on Monday September 02, 2024 @01:35PM (#41427293)
More spots? The threshold for attending college in general tends to be a score at the 40th percentile.
Re:Anarchy in Sudan has spawned the world’s worst famine in ... by giantg2 on Sunday September 01, 2024 @10:06AM (#41417075)
I'm not sure China is a good example of it working, unless you limit it to the past couple decades and ignore the human rights issues. South Korea may be a decent example, but also has some possible indirect negative effects, given all the protests, urban/rural divide, and social/birthrate issues. Sure they have the whole not starving thing handled, but so do the majority of countries regardless of central planning or not.
Re:Anarchy in Sudan has spawned the world’s worst famine in ... by crop_rotation on Sunday September 01, 2024 @10:40AM (#41417336)
Do you realise you are commenting in the context of a massive famine and millions of lives lost? All the countries in Africa and almost any non developed country will gladly take post Mao Chinese leadership and there current status quo over their current lives.

Human rights don't come before people have a certain dignity to live. Trying to preach human rights to a starving population is just .....

Re:Anarchy in Sudan has spawned the world’s worst famine in ... by giantg2 on Sunday September 01, 2024 @11:18AM (#41417667)
Do you realize we're talking about approaches that work? What stages did China and South Korea go through to get to today? The 40s and 50s were pretty bad in either country. Show me a prosperous centralized government that didn't have some ethnic or political cleansing at it's roots.

Or you could not red herring me and supply a proposed solution that could work instead of painting my opposition to central planning as an opposition to fixing famine in an emotional appeal.

Re:Anarchy in Sudan has spawned the world’s worst famine in ... by albertopv on Sunday September 01, 2024 @10:17AM (#41417153)
China had an empire lasting about 2000 years, truly something different
Re:Anarchy in Sudan has spawned the world’s worst famine in ... by logicchains on Sunday September 01, 2024 @10:07AM (#41417088)
>Central planning has a very good record in countries like China

It's got a very terrible track record in China; the government caused tens of millions of its own people to starve to death, and set the economic development back decades. The GDP per capita in Taiwan is more than double that of China currently, but both started at a similar position. If China had had a similar political system to Taiwan, its people's standard of living would be much better.

Re:Anarchy in Sudan has spawned the world’s worst famine in ... by crop_rotation on Sunday September 01, 2024 @10:43AM (#41417353)
> If China had had a similar political system to Taiwan, its people's standard of living would be much better.

This is just absurd. Taiwan's entire economy is TSMC + some small things. Copying political systems doesn't get you per capita standard of living.

Yes Mao's China did stupid things but post Mao China has done well economically atleast. They had an enviable job of bringing so many people out of extreme poverty and have done well.

Re:Anarchy in Sudan has spawned the world’s worst famine in ... by Ray20 on Sunday September 01, 2024 @01:11PM (#41418509)
>They had an enviable job of bringing so many people out of extreme poverty and have done well.

Literally zero work is required for this. You just need to stop keeping people in extreme poverty - and that's it.

Re:Anarchy in Sudan has spawned the world’s worst famine in ... by jajko on Sunday September 01, 2024 @09:01AM (#41416669)
Maybe but its doesn't work in democracies well. Main reason why EU won't ever compete with US economically, while being also very rich and actually more populous.

You should also compare it to situation where those countries wouldn't be centrally planned. Not so possible without time machine, so let's leave out measuring of efficiency of such systems. Ie when in Eastern Europe communism and central planning failed and fell down overnight, literally all those economies experienced massive boosts. I know I've lived through such transition there, hard to describe with words.

Re:Anarchy in Sudan has spawned the world’s worst famine in ... by joker99 on Sunday September 01, 2024 @09:13AM (#41416749)
That is not the main reason. Not even close. Here’s a list of main reasons, in no particular order:

- 8 different currencies across EU member states - 24 languages - 27 sovereign countries with wildly different economic, social, foreign, military … policies - laws and regulations are only slowly harmonised across the board - deep seating historic prejudices (which lead to major wars in the past) - unfriendly and downright hostile neighbours - a smaller amount of natural resources to exploit - etc etc

Re:Anarchy in Sudan has spawned the world’s worst famine in ... by walthamstow on Sunday September 01, 2024 @09:42AM (#41416911)
The EU has existed for less than a lifetime. Before that we were competing against each other, with bloody consequences.

How many wars were fought on European soil between 1776 and today? I couldn't even begin to answer that.

Re:Anarchy in Sudan has spawned the world’s worst famine in ... by feedforward on Sunday September 01, 2024 @09:26AM (#41416828)
With regards to central planning, neither China nor the US is fully in or out of it.

China still has Five Year Plans and some central planning, but Deng Xioping took steps away from it in the 1980s.

There's a mythology the US has no central planning, but it has had a lot of central planning since 1932 and certainly since 1941. Market makers watch for the presidentially nominated Powell to come out and announce the fed funds rate for our fiat currency, and the economy either speeds up or slows down in response. We are typing on a network the government paid BBN and other companies to create, on chips descended from the Fairchild chips that Air Force contracts funded. For various historical reasons, much of the central planning in the US is done via its very well funded military (then well funded military contractors pay think tanks and politicians to go out and say they're not so well funded)

Re:Anarchy in Sudan has spawned the world’s worst famine in ... by crop_rotation on Sunday September 01, 2024 @09:07AM (#41416715)
> Ie when in Eastern Europe communism and central planning failed

I am not saying central planning is a cure all. Trying a bad economic system with any kind of planning will fail.

> Maybe but its doesn't work in democracies well.

Correct, in the absence of strong top down rule (whether democracy or not), social changes are just going to be very slow (this doesn't mean strong top down rule will result in good changes, just that otherwise it is slow). The US needed a civil war to abolish slavery and two world wars for many other social changes (similar to most of western Europe).

I am not saying A or B is better. But without central planning the chances of any big cultural changes in Sudan type countries happening in the next 50 or even 100 years is very remote.