And then wait for a scheduled backup with the backdoored client.
Though XZ says that's impossible, so I won't lose sleep over that scenario.
Honestly, I really wish the Tarsnap server was open source. I imagine it has not been released as such because that would probably hurt the business a lot, especially given that the costs per GB are currently approximately 50 times more than I would pay for simple object storage on B2.
I built our company's first backup solution on Tarsnap, but when I projected out what deploying that to our entire fleet would cost, I rebuilt on Restic. We currently pay something like $250/mo for our backups, as opposed to the approximately $12,500/mo they would cost on Tarsnap.
By the way, I absolutely love spiped. It beats the pants off stunnel in both stability and performance. Maybe Colin should close-source that and start charging $0.25/GB for traffic that flows through there too? :P
He's been doing this long enough, I'm not even prepared to dunk on him for picodollar pricing anymore.
That is to say, it's entirely possible that you were already tortured and the backdoor is already there by using the same logic - no time machine needed
Like already said unfortunately the only safety would be reading the code
But I can't be coerced into adding a backdoor into past versions of Tarsnap, because I don't have a time machine.