In the EU, every company is responsible for what their users post on their service. There's a reason you won't find any (or very few) comment sections on the website of EU media and news companies. No one wanted to pay for the moderators needed, so when the law came around most comment sections were shuttered.
The law professor bit is shocking, given the article basically revolves around it making “zero sense for Durov to do any of these things,” as if criminality is always rational. But crypto has broadly come out in support of Durov [2].
[2] https://www.nytimes.com/2024/08/27/technology/telegram-crypt...
In this case "crypto" in the title is confusing, since it could be also/instead about the cryptography industry...
I mean, he got French citizenship despite not fitting any legal requirements, and nobody in the French government has given any explanation on why he got it.
This is pure conjecture, btw.
>If Telegram receives a court order that confirms you're a terror suspect, we may disclose your IP address and phone number to the relevant authorities. So far, this has never happened. When it does, we will include it in a semiannual transparency report published at: https://t.me/transparency.
A legal request comes from a legal authority: a judge.
>Cooperating with law enforcement
Law Enforcement (that's the police, right?) are not judges and are not authorised to rule on legal matters.
Hate has not logic.
So you are trying to cover the whole spectrum of things to ensure your belief that Durov is being legally detained.
Sorry for editing instead of answering. Reddit says I "post too fast".
It's a pretty straightforward logic.
What if it wasn't even encrypted, and was just so many gigabytes of data that the government doesn't have the skill or manhours themselves to wade through it? Can they demand big data tools tailor made per company?
Why can't companies submit software and data to these requests so covered in "cookie consent style popups" that nobody could ever get through it in multiple lifetimes?
It looks like the author failed to grab that Durov asked for the French nationality and therefore is a French citizen who must comply to French law.
> Telegram is not the only company in the world which has a social media platform used for unlawful purposes
Except Telegram is the only one of those companies which intentionally doesn’t answers to legal requests. All other social networks are cooperating with law enforcers in the countries they operate.
Even Signal is cooperating when asked too. The difference is that unlike Signal, Telegram owns its users data in plaintext.
Also the author fails to understand that the complicity here doesn’t mean that companies in Europe are responsible for their users content. Like in the US, they are responsible if they fail to comply to laws in a reasonable time. Telegram doesn’t comply in a reasonable time since they voluntarily don’t comply at all. That’s a huge difference.