News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nvidia PR Responds To Torvalds' Harsh Words by mhurron on Tuesday June 19, 2012 @02:06PM (#4133240)
RandR is a Xorg extension, it's not a Linux kernel thing. To continue to provide graphics options for their customers that use OS's with recent Xorg installs (they make a FreeBSD driver available too) they had to support RandR.

This is right in line with 'we support our customers/users' not whatever the Linux kernel guys feel like doing today.

Re:Nvidia PR Responds To Torvalds' Harsh Words by ajross on Tuesday June 19, 2012 @02:17PM (#4133295)
That's spun and unfair. Booting with a working framebuffer isn't something that tickles only the "kernel guys" interest. Running the GPU on your hybrid laptop likewise. You realize that, with just a handful of exceptions, the NVIDIA part on most Optimus laptops simply doesn't work under linux, right? And that NVIDIA hasn't so much as lifted a finger to fix this?

So sure, if "customers/users" includes the only handful of 3D content shops out there running linux toolchains, and not the millions of people buying NVIDIA-enabled laptops, I guess it makes sense. But for everyone else it kinda sucks.

Re:Nvidia PR Responds To Torvalds' Harsh Words by mhurron on Tuesday June 19, 2012 @02:31PM (#4133389)
> That's spun and unfair.

Hardly. NVIDIA says they "made a decision to support Linux on our GPUs by leveraging NVIDIA common code, rather than the Linux common infrastructure." HN responder says that's bullshit since they finally support RandR. I point out RandR is not 'Linux common infrastructure' but a Xorg technology and supporting that is very literally "supporting Linux ... by leveraging NVIDIA common code" because the NVIDIA common code is targeting Xorg technologies and not Linux specific ones.

Then you move the point to something completely different.

NVIDIA is clearly not interested in providing any Linux only support. Don't expect them to support anything under Linux that isn't also common to other platforms they support.

Re:Nvidia PR Responds To Torvalds' Harsh Words by ajross on Tuesday June 19, 2012 @02:43PM (#4133444)
You're just making things up, stop it. DRI2 and KMS are no more "linux kernel" things than "X" things; all you have to do is check the domain hosting the specs. These are well established, well-supported APIs that have been very well received in the Linux world. And yet NVIDIA wants nothing to do with either, for silly internal reasons with poor justification.

(FreeBSD has commited to support for both, btw).

Re:Nvidia PR Responds To Torvalds' Harsh Words by Arelius on Thursday June 21, 2012 @01:52PM (#4143281)
To be fair, KMS does stand for "Kernel mode switching" and is useful for things unrelated to X, such as Wayland.
Re:Nvidia PR Responds To Torvalds' Harsh Words by daeken on Tuesday June 19, 2012 @03:03PM (#4133544)
> You realize that, with just a handful of exceptions, the NVIDIA part on most Optimus laptops simply doesn't work under linux, right? And that NVIDIA hasn't so much as lifted a finger to fix this?

I have an Optimus laptop (Thinkpad W520) and that's not really true. The problem is that you can't run both the Intel and NVidia chips at the same time without it being a PITA. If I want to use my internal display while I'm on the road, I move my NVidia Xorg.conf out of the way and it's fine. I'm not saying it's optimal, but it definitely works.

Re:Nvidia PR Responds To Torvalds' Harsh Words by vrodic on Tuesday June 19, 2012 @05:25PM (#4134262)
There's not just one Optimus implementation, there are many ways to wire Optimus. My colleague bought an Optimus laptop (can't remember which one now) that absolutely doesn't have the nVidia part of Optimus working. See here for details: http://nouveau.freedesktop.org/wiki/Optimus
Re:Nvidia PR Responds To Torvalds' Harsh Words by TylerE on Tuesday June 19, 2012 @02:30PM (#4133382)
> Booting with a working framebuffer isn't something that tickles only the "kernel guys" interest

Is it? If my computer boots up directly to X anyway, why do I care about a framebuffer beyond the standard vesa stuff?

PS: If Linus would get off his high horse about closed source drivers, and commit to have at least a somewhat stable ABI, that would do more for hardware support on linux than 1000 years of ranting and moaning, which if anything, will only alienate the hardware makers even more.

Re:Nvidia PR Responds To Torvalds' Harsh Words by muhfuhkuh on Tuesday June 19, 2012 @03:28PM (#4133649)
"If Linus would get off his high horse about closed source drivers"

... then he would be Microsoft and Apple, and not an Open Source operating system developer, maintainer, producer, and evangelist. All his years of working openly and freely will be squandered and his life's work beholden to closed-source, closed spec device manufacturers.

Re:Nvidia PR Responds To Torvalds' Harsh Words by TylerE on Tuesday June 19, 2012 @03:36PM (#4133693)
But his stance actually makes us much MORE beholden to the 3rd parties. If every minor kernel version didn't require the vendors to recompiled drivers, and quite possible change code because Linus changed the ABI again, that would result in more hardware working better for more people.

Live the open source dream if it makes you feel good. I live in a world where if it doesn't work, I couldn't care less about it.

Pragmatism > Dogma

Re:Nvidia PR Responds To Torvalds' Harsh Words by ajross on Tuesday June 19, 2012 @03:59PM (#4133821)
I don't think reality bears this out. Now that Broadcom has come to their senses, NVIDIA is pretty much the only major consumer device vendor in the PC space with binary blob drivers. Everyone else has, ultimately, folded in the face of pressure from the dogmatists. I think Linus is pretty much winning, and the fact that NVIDIA is feeling pressure here is a good thing.

Do you have any examples of situations where this is making us "MORE" beholden to third parties? I honestly don't see many (though in the SoC space, the PVR drivers are a very similar situation).

Re:Nvidia PR Responds To Torvalds' Harsh Words by LeonidasXIV on Tuesday June 19, 2012 @08:23PM (#4134988)
Broadcom OTOH still has crappy ARM SoCs that require binary blobs. Just like most ARM GPUs that run on Linux.
Re:Nvidia PR Responds To Torvalds' Harsh Words by TylerE on Tuesday June 19, 2012 @06:58PM (#4134649)
What about ATI?
Re:Nvidia PR Responds To Torvalds' Harsh Words by jlgreco on Tuesday June 19, 2012 @08:09PM (#4134935)
Didn't AMD release a ton of documentation for their GPUs specifically so that the open source radeon drivers could become a realistic option when using their GPUs?

Nobody I know with an AMD GPU uses the propriety fglrx drivers.

Re:Nvidia PR Responds To Torvalds' Harsh Words by TylerE on Tuesday June 19, 2012 @09:18PM (#4135161)
Open source 3D drivers will have a hard time EVER being useable for anything beyond glgears... everything in that space is going to be really patent encumbered.
Re:Nvidia PR Responds To Torvalds' Harsh Words by jlgreco on Wednesday June 20, 2012 @01:04AM (#4135705)
Frankly, if you are looking to play games than you are wasting your time with any of the available GPU/driver combinations on Linux.

If that's not what you are after, then I don't know what more than working KMS and enough "umph" to run a compositing window manager you could need.

Re:Nvidia PR Responds To Torvalds' Harsh Words by tadfisher on Monday June 25, 2012 @12:54PM (#4157355)
> working KMS

Something that NVIDIA refuses to support :)

Re:Nvidia PR Responds To Torvalds' Harsh Words by ajuc on Wednesday June 20, 2012 @05:34AM (#4136242)
Fortunately most of the world don't care about software patents :)
Re:Nvidia PR Responds To Torvalds' Harsh Words by LeonidasXIV on Tuesday June 19, 2012 @08:22PM (#4134983)
Pragmatism is running Windows. Or Mac OS X. There's people that prefer it this way on Linux.
Re:Nvidia PR Responds To Torvalds' Harsh Words by TylerE on Tuesday June 19, 2012 @09:09PM (#4135137)
Which is what I mostly do these days.
Re:Nvidia PR Responds To Torvalds' Harsh Words by adestefan on Tuesday June 19, 2012 @04:12PM (#4133883)
Having an unstable, internal kernel interface has nothing to do with being opposed to closed source drivers. Linus' problem is when people bitch and moan when things change and it breaks closed source drivers. He's repeatedly said that anything internal is fair game to change. If your driver is in the kernel it will be fixed if the interface changes; if it's closed then you better keep up on your own.