News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US Judge Strikes Down Ban on Worker 'Noncompete' Agreements by deathanatos on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @07:27PM (#41305138)
> "The Commission’s lack of evidence as to why they chose to impose such a sweeping prohibition ... instead of targeting specific, harmful non-competes, renders the Rule arbitrary and capricious," wrote Brown

All non-competes are harmful, end of story.

Link to the ruling: https://assets.bwbx.io/documents/users/iqjWHBFdfxIU/rj8_52.B... (…though this PDF is kinda horrible, since it seems to somehow not be searchable at all, but it's the only one I've found in like 7 different news sites, all but one of which can't cite their sources…)

Re:US Judge Strikes Down Ban on Worker 'Noncompete' Agreements by fishtoaster on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @08:03PM (#41305376)
I'm inclined to support well-compensated non-competes, eg "you can't work in this industry for 1 year, but we'll pay you 100% of your salary for that year." That would allow non-competes for people where it really matters to a company (eg where they're willing to throw a lot of money after it), but ban it the rest of the time.

It's still harmful, but you're at least able to get compensated for the harm.

Re:US Judge Strikes Down Ban on Worker 'Noncompete' Agreements by Xelbair on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @08:09PM (#41305414)
>but we'll pay you 100% of your salary for that year.

if you can't work in the industry, and you get just 100% of your salary that's completely not worth it as you waste time not becoming a more competitive hire in the market - unless you aren't that specialized, but then why bind you with non-compete anyways?

Re:US Judge Strikes Down Ban on Worker 'Noncompete' Agreements by jncfhnb on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @08:16PM (#41305453)
What if you had a life that you wanted to enjoy
Re:US Judge Strikes Down Ban on Worker 'Noncompete' Agreements by meepmorp on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @08:41PM (#41305604)
But they're not paying you to enjoy your life, they're paying you to not work for their competitors, which has impact on your career in the longer term. So they should compensate you based on that, not you wanting to take up pottery or whatever.
Re:US Judge Strikes Down Ban on Worker 'Noncompete' Agreements by jncfhnb on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @09:06PM (#41305744)
Yeah, it’s 100% of salary in a competitive market

Y’all need to go outside if you think that’s not a fantastic deal

Re:US Judge Strikes Down Ban on Worker 'Noncompete' Agreements by radley on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @11:58PM (#41306649)
What if the competitor offers 150% or more? Then is 100% a fair deal?
Re:US Judge Strikes Down Ban on Worker 'Noncompete' Agreements by jncfhnb on Wednesday August 21, 2024 @07:24AM (#41309166)
Yeah
Re:US Judge Strikes Down Ban on Worker 'Noncompete' Agreements by pitterpatter on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @10:34PM (#41306247)
Sure, maybe we could have that conversation if noncompetes actually required that...but they don't
Re:US Judge Strikes Down Ban on Worker 'Noncompete' Agreements by hervature on Wednesday August 21, 2024 @12:24AM (#41306772)
While I agree that they should go outside, I will point out that the common tactic is to make salary than less than 1/2 of the total compensation. In tech, they issue RDUs and then they can claim that those were always bonus and never part of salary. In finance, they give big bonuses depending on performance. This is a little more legit but usually takes recessions for bonuses to actually disappear.
Re:US Judge Strikes Down Ban on Worker 'Noncompete' Agreements by OJFord on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @08:44PM (#41305628)
How much more competitive are you going to get in one year (/what's your discount rate) that you wouldn't take a paid year off?!
Re:US Judge Strikes Down Ban on Worker 'Noncompete' Agreements by Kirby64 on Wednesday August 21, 2024 @11:18PM (#41316497)
Gardening leave typically is only salary, and doesn’t include extremely lucrative bonuses (that can exceed salary, sometimes by some multiples) in certain investment industries. So, it’s a pretty big hit to your income.
Re:US Judge Strikes Down Ban on Worker 'Noncompete' Agreements by OJFord on Thursday August 22, 2024 @11:24AM (#41321339)
That's a good point, but an entirely different one to 'you waste time not becoming a more competitive hire in the market', which is what I was responding to.
Re:US Judge Strikes Down Ban on Worker 'Noncompete' Agreements by erik_seaberg on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @08:16PM (#41305454)
Base salary isn't as much as I would be vesting at a new employer.
Re:US Judge Strikes Down Ban on Worker 'Noncompete' Agreements by darby_nine on Wednesday August 21, 2024 @12:54AM (#41306897)
Oh come on nobody gives a shit about this bullshit except new employers. Even if you bought into it there's no reason to broadcast your weaknesses like they're public entertainment. Without the pressure of new employers this just comes off as histrionic simping.
Re:US Judge Strikes Down Ban on Worker 'Noncompete' Agreements by darby_nine on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @08:11PM (#41305425)
Eh, this has literally no upside for humanity. It's just a straight negative for everyone. Even compared to wage-fixing—at least wage-fixing results in lower wages for corporations! This implies no such effect.
Re:US Judge Strikes Down Ban on Worker 'Noncompete' Agreements by __loam on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @08:27PM (#41305522)
There is absolutely no reason to allow this kind of strict anti-labor bullshit in almost any case barring high level leadership positions. Giving you 100% of your salary for a year doesn't cover the damages incurred by foregoing potential career advancement and skill acquisition.
Re:US Judge Strikes Down Ban on Worker 'Noncompete' Agreements by IdiocyInAction on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @08:18PM (#41305463)
At least in my industry non-competes seem to be a tool to reduce worker mobility and a way for competitors to collude and keep costs down.

It's a highly-paid industry FWIW.

I think it makes sense to ban them.

Re:US Judge Strikes Down Ban on Worker 'Noncompete' Agreements by diab0lic on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @07:41PM (#41305220)
> All non-competes are harmful, end of story.

Ah. How could I be so foolish as to think there might be some nuance to the situation! For what it’s worth a lot of friends in finance are/were bummed about how this law might affect gardening leave. [0]

[0] https://finance.yahoo.com/news/whether-wall-street-garden-le...

Re:US Judge Strikes Down Ban on Worker 'Noncompete' Agreements by threatofrain on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @07:45PM (#41305258)
That does sound anti-competitive. Imagine if Google poaches hot people in industry and then just sits on them during a critical market time, doing nothing, because they don't have any particular work for them, they just don't want them working for the competition.

Those garden contracts sound like a variation of the same idea.

Anyways, if I understand FCC's position right, they also had nuance for specific non-competes.

Re:US Judge Strikes Down Ban on Worker 'Noncompete' Agreements by bobthepanda on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @07:53PM (#41305308)
at least with garden leave the person is at least getting compensated. it's substantially better than a minimum wage worker at ~~Subway~~ Jimmy John's being told they're not getting paid and they also can't make sandwiches for six months.
Re:US Judge Strikes Down Ban on Worker 'Noncompete' Agreements by threatofrain on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @08:01PM (#41305359)
That's one scenario I'm afraid of... that businesses have rational incentive to push boundaries for workers that aren't ultra high value, and that terms like these basically force you to stay at Subways.
Re:US Judge Strikes Down Ban on Worker 'Noncompete' Agreements by mikestew on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @08:04PM (#41305382)
GP’s comment was not a hypothetical, the names were just changed to protect the guilty:

https://www.cnbc.com/2016/06/22/jimmy-johns-drops-non-compet...

Re:US Judge Strikes Down Ban on Worker 'Noncompete' Agreements by bobthepanda on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @08:11PM (#41305423)
well, i mixed up which sandwich chain it was. but yeah.
Re:US Judge Strikes Down Ban on Worker 'Noncompete' Agreements by bobthepanda on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @08:12PM (#41305427)
they already do this.

we may as well force companies to pay up or shut up when it comes to noncompetes.

Re:US Judge Strikes Down Ban on Worker 'Noncompete' Agreements by johnnyanmac on Wednesday August 21, 2024 @04:38PM (#41314019)
I'm not on the "100% of non-competes are harmful". But definitely 98-99%. I agree with California's exceptions:

>The only exceptions are non-compete or restrictive covenants that fall within one of the narrow exemptions authorized by statute, all of which relate to the sale of the goodwill of a business, or of a substantial ownership stake in the business. Courts interpret these statutory exceptions very narrowly.

If you have enough skin in the game that you can make life or death decisions for a company (or take out money in stock that can sink the company), you probably have enough money that a non-compete won't put you on the streets.

Re:US Judge Strikes Down Ban on Worker 'Noncompete' Agreements by GeneralMayhem on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @08:29PM (#41305530)
That level of "argument" from a federal judge should be grounds for instant removal. It's bafflingly stupid, and nakedly partisan and outcome-motivated. Some ideas are just categorically bad, and the regulator needs to be able to say that, rather than pretend that the answer is always "halfway in between".

For his next decision, will he forbid the SEC from regulating all insider trading, since they didn't find a way to target "specific, harmful" patterns? And yet somehow I suspect he wouldn't bat an eye if the FDA were to decide that all abortifacients were disallowed, instead of looking at each one individually...

And of course, all of that is ignoring that he's flagrantly lying about the facts of the case, in at least two ways:

1. The summary is misstated. The FTC did not find that all non-competes were invalid. It specifically carved out cases where the balance leans toward non-regulation - namely, non-competes for executives.

2. Some of the "arbitrary and capricious" reasoning claims that no states have passed non-compete bans as broad as what the FTC did, and therefore none of their quantitative evidence can matter. That is, again, blindingly stupid on the face of it - but it's also factually false, because California has had just as broad a ban on non-competes for many decades.

Re:US Judge Strikes Down Ban on Worker 'Noncompete' Agreements by rahimnathwani on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @09:58PM (#41306067)

  It specifically carved out cases where the balance leans toward non-regulation - namely, non-competes for executives.
This is false. The FTC tried to ban for all workers and senior executives. The only difference for senior executives is that the FTC didn't retroactively invalidate existing non-competes. Under the FTC's rule, no new non-competes could be signed.
Re:US Judge Strikes Down Ban on Worker 'Noncompete' Agreements by rahimnathwani on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @09:37PM (#41305940)

  For his next decision, will he forbid the SEC from regulating all insider trading, since they didn't find a way to target "specific, harmful" patterns?
Insider trading is prohibited by federal statute. Non-competes are not.
Re:US Judge Strikes Down Ban on Worker 'Noncompete' Agreements by jellicle on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @08:35PM (#41305571)
Yes, the SEC and FDA and EPA and all similar regulatory agencies are headed for the chopping block too. You only need one judge to say so.

And yes, the quality of the reasoning is going to be just as bad. Sure, Congress passed a law which says in so many words "the agency has the power to do...", but here I am a duly appointed judge, and I can write a decision saying "Congress never gave the agency the power to...", with impunity, and so I shall.

Re:US Judge Strikes Down Ban on Worker 'Noncompete' Agreements by FireBeyond on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @09:51PM (#41306030)
Well, it's even worse. In this case the judge said that even if the agency had the power, she didn't feel sufficiently convinced by their argument (to act within their power) and would block it anyway.
Re:US Judge Strikes Down Ban on Worker 'Noncompete' Agreements by 1vuio0pswjnm7 on Wednesday August 21, 2024 @02:18AM (#41307303)
"For his next decision, ..."

The judge is female.

Re:US Judge Strikes Down Ban on Worker 'Noncompete' Agreements by gruez on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @08:54PM (#41305683)
>though this PDF is kinda horrible, since it seems to somehow not be searchable at all, but it's the only one I've found in like 7 different news sites, all but one of which can't cite their sources

Here's the original from recap: https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/68463428/212/ryan-llc-v...

Based on the metadata for the pdf you posted, it looks like for whatever reason they ran the original pdf through microsoft print to pdf, which stripped off all the OCR/text metadata.

Re:US Judge Strikes Down Ban on Worker 'Noncompete' Agreements by Xen9 on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @09:02PM (#41305724)
I don't see harm in non-compete agreements between non-natural legal persons.

In fact, were IP developed by a person tied to a personal proxy body, it would be possible for them to recieve payments for the IP from past employer, who could have sort of right to buy exclusive license for limited time. Probably better structures exist; the idea remains same.

Re:US Judge Strikes Down Ban on Worker 'Noncompete' Agreements by 1vuio0pswjnm7 on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @09:54PM (#41306046)
"Link to the ruling ... (...though this PDF is kinda horrible, since it seems to somehow not be searchable at all, but it's the only one I've found in like 7 different news sites, all but one of which can't cite their sources...)"

https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/68463428/211/ryan-llc-v...

https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/68463428/212/ryan-llc-v...