News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by lokar on Sunday August 18, 2024 @02:45PM (#41284392)
IANAL, but I don’t think they are supposed to. They decide the case in front of them: 14 months is too long. And give some insight as to why and what the might be in other cases, but that’s not authoritative.

We will have to wait for more cases to refine the time limit and other factors that impact it.

Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by lucianbr on Sunday August 18, 2024 @03:01PM (#41284500)
> We will have to wait

I seem to remember something about "justice delayed".

Sure these things are complicated. But coming to a just conclusion sooner rather than later should also be a goal, not just dotting Is and crossing Ts. Of course for law specialists such as lawyers and judges minutiae seem important. But to me it seems the overall goal of the entire concept has been forgotten. Or maybe is ignored on purpose.

Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by johnnyanmac on Sunday August 18, 2024 @03:52PM (#41284911)
More like "this is how you creep in justice". You set a date and politicians will spend months determining what's too long/too short. Or in this case, the judges may not get a unanimous ruling as easily. The article mentions that this is a DC appeals court that establishes this, and several other circuits have rules otherwise.

The fastest way is leaving it vague, waiting for some court case to set precedent on what is "too long" and use that as a reference for future court cases. Or in this case, it may in fact go to the supreme court who will be able to determine a more concrete time (or just throw it all away and doom us all).

Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by ethbr1 on Sunday August 18, 2024 @06:01PM (#41285885)
Given the prior majority of appeals courts deciding the other way, it seems like something of a waste of time to figure out a time period.

Better to say "you can't hold it for an unreasonable period, and 14 months was unreasonable"

It will have to be resolved at the Supreme Court level anyway, given the US Court of Appeals split.

Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by rodgerd on Sunday August 18, 2024 @06:37PM (#41286112)
I hope that you aren't expecting a court with a rampant Clarence Thomas to care about anything pertaining to your rights vis-a-vis the police.
Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by ethbr1 on Sunday August 18, 2024 @08:39PM (#41286793)
1 / 9
Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by autoexec on Sunday August 18, 2024 @06:29PM (#41286063)
> The fastest way is leaving it vague, waiting for some court case to set precedent on what is "too long" and use that as a reference for future court cases.

We're stuck with the courts because congress doesn't do their job, but leaving this to the courts to decide on a case by case basis could mean that only people who can afford to pay the lawyers and court fees and take the time off for a lengthy court battle against the police can expect to have their rights respected. Ideally, we'd have claws with specific limits that would then be used to set department policy. That way it'd be clear to everyone what the expectation is and when a violation occurred.

Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by BurningFrog on Sunday August 18, 2024 @04:05PM (#41284994)
A functioning congress could make laws regulating this.

But as things are, we have wait for some random court case to bubble up.

Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by giantg2 on Sunday August 18, 2024 @04:11PM (#41285059)
Congress has no reason to care. They certainly aren't subjected to any of the shady tactics. Most of their constituents aren't either. Just the edge cases, but nobody cares unless they find themselves in it.