News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google is a monopoly. Breakup may be coming; what comes a... by is_true on Thursday August 15, 2024 @08:28AM (#41255109)
I think Google can win this easily by using the public opinion against the regulators.

They just need to say that they are gonna start charging for all their services because without the level of integration they have it doesn't make sense to keep running businesses that otherwise would lose money.

Re:Google is a monopoly. Breakup may be coming; what comes a... by blitzar on Thursday August 15, 2024 @08:48AM (#41255314)
Google would need to get public opinion on their side first.
Re:Google is a monopoly. Breakup may be coming; what comes a... by is_true on Thursday August 15, 2024 @07:04PM (#41261414)
They already have that.
Re:Google is a monopoly. Breakup may be coming; what comes a... by snapcaster on Thursday August 15, 2024 @08:53AM (#41255370)
I don't see this succeeding. Not only is tech extremely hateable as a demographic, not everyone is a corporate bootlicker (outside of this forum)
Re:Google is a monopoly. Breakup may be coming; what comes a... by miki123211 on Thursday August 15, 2024 @09:07AM (#41255537)
> Not only is tech extremely hateable as a demographic

Oh boy is this incorrect.

Outside the Silicon Valley / well-educated upper middle class / tech worker bubble, tech companies are more trusted than most political parties and government and religious institutions, and this is true across the world as polls show. People who are not into tech have no idea about Google's business deals or App Store anti-steering provisions. They use Google as long as it delivers great results, and switch to searching on Tiktok or asking Chat GPT if it doesn't. HN is probably one of the most anti-tech places on the internet, maybe outside of Mastodon.

Re:Google is a monopoly. Breakup may be coming; what comes a... by JKCalhoun on Thursday August 15, 2024 @09:22AM (#41255733)
I'm not so sure. You sound like you're describing the older generations and their tech swoon. What I am hearing lately, and from coming-up generations, is very much anti-tech.

I think HN is more the bellwether.

Re:Google is a monopoly. Breakup may be coming; what comes a... by wildrhythms on Thursday August 15, 2024 @07:19PM (#41261539)
>tech companies are more trusted than most political parties

The bar is that low huh?

Re:Google is a monopoly. Breakup may be coming; what comes a... by viraptor on Thursday August 15, 2024 @08:34AM (#41255178)
Do you honestly think that would have any effect beyond Gmail users? (those would really hurt)

But otherwise I don't think an average non-tech person would be likely to notice a difference between Bing and Google. And ms, ddg, Kagi and perplexity would love to see lots of people actually looking for alternatives.

Docs/sheets/pages/whatever wouldn't change since they're supported by the paying users. The rest, Google is going to kill at some point anyway like they did with hundred other projects.

They only one I really don't know how it would be affected is Android.

Re:Google is a monopoly. Breakup may be coming; what comes a... by stogot on Thursday August 15, 2024 @08:38AM (#41255220)
I’d pay for consumer tier (which we’ll pretend was the former free tier) if I got proper customer service number I could call. I don’t use it enough to pay for a business tier
Re:Google is a monopoly. Breakup may be coming; what comes a... by vel0city on Thursday August 15, 2024 @08:51AM (#41255355)
Google One includes phone support.
Re:Google is a monopoly. Breakup may be coming; what comes a... by ajcoll5 on Thursday August 15, 2024 @09:11AM (#41255588)
It does, but they're useless for anything that isn't already a Google search away. They can't help with actual account/service issues, and don't seem to have a way to escalate to the right teams that can.
Re:Google is a monopoly. Breakup may be coming; what comes a... by s_dev on Thursday August 15, 2024 @08:51AM (#41255354)
>I think Google can win this easily by using the public opinion against the regulators.

Apple levels of arrogance.

Apple tried the same approach when the EU was slapping them down with DMA and few were having it, calling Apple out for their immature responses delusionally thinking that because people were glued to their phones they would some how value that above their representative government.

Re:Google is a monopoly. Breakup may be coming; what comes a... by 2OEH8eoCRo0 on Thursday August 15, 2024 @08:39AM (#41255230)
The public would have been against breaking up Standard Oil because they kept oil cheap.
Re:Google is a monopoly. Breakup may be coming; what comes a... by newsclues on Thursday August 15, 2024 @08:43AM (#41255260)
Standard oil lacks the ability to shape the narrative that google has.

If standard oil had control of the information space history would be very different. Not even Ma Bell had the power that google has

Re:Google is a monopoly. Breakup may be coming; what comes a... by vel0city on Thursday August 15, 2024 @08:54AM (#41255387)
You couldn't even own a phone under Ma Bell.

Meanwhile just about every product Google has I can use someone else.

Re:Google is a monopoly. Breakup may be coming; what comes a... by newsclues on Thursday August 15, 2024 @08:59AM (#41255440)
Ma Bell didn’t have the power to cut off advertising revenue to YouTubers who say things the company does like, nor the power to shape the global access to information with search, nor did they scan people’s communications
Re:Google is a monopoly. Breakup may be coming; what comes a... by ApolloFortyNine on Thursday August 15, 2024 @09:11AM (#41255583)
>Ma Bell didn’t have the power to cut off advertising revenue to YouTubers who say things the company does like

They don't even ban you (it's very hard to get banned on youtube) and it's the advertisers themselves who decide this.

>nor did they scan people’s communications They don't scan emails and never have.

And you could move to an alternative browser/search/youtube (if someone could host one profitably) by the end of the day.

Re:Google is a monopoly. Breakup may be coming; what comes a... by vel0city on Thursday August 15, 2024 @09:15AM (#41255637)
Ma Bell had the power to make it so you couldn't talk on a wire, at all. They owned all the wires. They owned all the phones.

But sure, being de-monetized on a website, that's way worse.

And yes, Ma Bell had the ability to listen in to every conversation had on a wire. Not just some, all. Meanwhile most conversations I have on the internet don't involve Google in the slightest.

Re:Google is a monopoly. Breakup may be coming; what comes a... by newsclues on Thursday August 15, 2024 @12:12PM (#41257622)
More control over a narrower aspect of life, vs control over many parts of your life.

Google can be your email, your phone, your ISP, own your health data, control what you watch, listen, search for, it can control your ability to make money or even control access to your data and documents.

Re:Google is a monopoly. Breakup may be coming; what comes a... by vel0city on Thursday August 15, 2024 @12:31PM (#41257818)
> Google can be

Can be.

Google doesn't control what I watch. Google doesn't control what I listen to. Google doesn't control my email. Google doesn't own my health data. Google isn't my ISP. Google doesn't control my data and documents. Google doesn't control my ability to make money. Google doesn't control what I search for.

Meanwhile with Ma Bell, it was Ma Bell or just don't have telecommunications.

Re:Google is a monopoly. Breakup may be coming; what comes a... by 2OEH8eoCRo0 on Thursday August 15, 2024 @12:39PM (#41257891)
That's a good point but my point was more that if we listened to public opinion we may not have broken up Standard Oil!
Re:Google is a monopoly. Breakup may be coming; what comes a... by bell-cot on Thursday August 15, 2024 @08:33AM (#41255173)
"...gonna start charging..."

In a world where the competition's price for most of those services is "free", charging for used-to-be-free stuff sounds like a sure-fire suicidal business strategy.

Re:Google is a monopoly. Breakup may be coming; what comes a... by StrauXX on Thursday August 15, 2024 @08:37AM (#41255217)
They don't have to actually do that should Google bbebroken up. They can still use that as an argument to rouse public support against a breakup.
Re:Google is a monopoly. Breakup may be coming; what comes a... by bell-cot on Thursday August 15, 2024 @09:21AM (#41255717)
They can try. But in a world full of free on-line stuff, the public may think the "you'll go bust if you try" counter-argument is obviously correct.
Re:Google is a monopoly. Breakup may be coming; what comes a... by pydry on Thursday August 15, 2024 @08:33AM (#41255165)
"If you break us up we will start such an epic tantrum that we will end up shooting ourselves in the head"