That’s a bit misleading, considering RSA is only used for certificate verification. Key exchange and symmetric encryption is handled by somewhat more recent algorithms (ECDH / AES-GCM).
You should consider these "right answers" as if the question were, "I want to develop a new product today. What cryptographic primitive should I use?"
RSAES-2048-PKCS#1v1.5 has implementation-dependent security; implementations keep getting broken due to padding oracle attacks. RSA-KEM-2048 is fine, though slower than ECDH.
If you drill into the details a lot of things haven't changed. Eg, the key size and HMAC recommendations go back to the original version (among others).
They also have a consulting product to sell you. When you build your entire society on "greed as a virtue", it is reasonable to assume it as a primary motivation for a profit seeking entity.
The Ellis, Cocks and Williamson algorithm has existed since at least 1973.
You may not need to jump to the next best thing every 3 years, but as certain constructs are proven weak, you’ll need to start migrating systems and data off of them to modern equivalents.
Yes, but for heaven’s sake don’t design something with “cipher suite negotiation” which has been an endless source of vulnerability over the years in SSL/TLS, IPsec, PGP…
Instead one should advance the version of the entire protocol or file format when you need to upgrade the cryptography. Then you deprecate old versions as quickly as possible. WireGuard and age have no algorithm negotiation at all.
If you are only trying to prevent your ISP from seeing your traffic, which they are not trying particularly hard to do, then that level of protection would be overkill.
It's supposed to protect my users' data for two full generations, but the advice is only good for 3 years?
Nobody has deliberately included bad advice. That's not what I'm saying.
This is what, a fourth or fifth version since 2009?
Meanwhile everything from ubuntu's apt-get to my connection to HN is secured with 2048-bit RSA - an algorithm invented in 1977 and in widespread use since at least 1995.
Am I getting crypto advice that will keep my data safe for 30+ years, if the advice changes every 3 years?