News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Red Herring of Red Flags: Why Resumes Are a Relic of ... by addaon on Saturday August 10, 2024 @02:12AM (#41207673)
"Resumes are a poor proxy for talent."

Resumes are not intended to be a proxy for (assessing) talent. They're intended to be a proxy for (assessing) experience. Portfolios, references, and interviews are intended to be a proxy for assessing talent.

Re:The Red Herring of Red Flags: Why Resumes Are a Relic of ... by abhas9 on Saturday August 10, 2024 @02:39AM (#41207758)
IMO, resumes, while ideally intended as experience summaries, often function as gatekeeper proxies, filtering candidates based on arbitrary criteria rather than actual potential. Unfortunately, I too can't think of a good alternative solution that can scale well.
Re:The Red Herring of Red Flags: Why Resumes Are a Relic of ... by jahewson on Saturday August 10, 2024 @02:44AM (#41207777)
Hiring on potential isn’t a great strategy though. It’s important to compare candidates on something objectively displayed during in the hiring process, rather than some “potential” that’s a figment of one’s imagination.
Re:The Red Herring of Red Flags: Why Resumes Are a Relic of ... by atq2119 on Saturday August 10, 2024 @03:26AM (#41207921)
It's not exactly potential. The way I've heard it phrased is: hire for slope, not y-intercept. The trouble is that slope is even harder to judge than y-intercept.
Re:The Red Herring of Red Flags: Why Resumes Are a Relic of ... by abhas9 on Saturday August 10, 2024 @03:28AM (#41207925)
IMO, Resumes attempt to solve a problem that precedes what some consider the actual hiring process: the need to quickly screen thousands of candidates.

Unfortunately, this approach has flaws. The person doing the initial screening may not have a deep understanding of the role and is often working with secondary information. This can sometimes lead to them becoming gatekeepers, filtering based on superficial criteria (like career gaps, job switches, etc)

Re:The Red Herring of Red Flags: Why Resumes Are a Relic of ... by tlarkworthy on Saturday August 10, 2024 @02:18AM (#41207690)
In my mind resumes are the trust part of "trust but verify". The resume is evidence the candidate meets the needs of the role description. The job interview verifies the resume is not a work of fiction.
Re:The Red Herring of Red Flags: Why Resumes Are a Relic of ... by katzinsky on Saturday August 10, 2024 @07:58AM (#41208864)
Yup. Resumes tell you what's in the box but you should actually open the box and check to make sure the label is accurate.
Re:The Red Herring of Red Flags: Why Resumes Are a Relic of ... by duck on Saturday August 10, 2024 @02:45AM (#41207779)
> They’re often polished, curated, and tailored to tick boxes rather than showcase genuine skills.

I look at a lot of resumes and would say most aren't well polished or curated. They often don't showcase skills either, but it is surprising how bad resumes still are today.

Re:The Red Herring of Red Flags: Why Resumes Are a Relic of ... by baxtr on Saturday August 10, 2024 @03:43AM (#41207973)
That’s exactly why I believe they are still a good indicator for assessing people.

How much effort did they put it? That’s at least a first indicator how much they care about to get the job.

Re:The Red Herring of Red Flags: Why Resumes Are a Relic of ... by johnisgood on Saturday August 10, 2024 @05:03AM (#41208241)
Mine is written in LaTeX, and converted to PDF with pdflatex. Does that work? :D
Re:The Red Herring of Red Flags: Why Resumes Are a Relic of ... by deng on Saturday August 10, 2024 @06:51AM (#41208635)
As someone who gets a ton of resumes from academia, I see these very often. The problem here is that they all look the same because everyone is using the 'moderncv' package. If you want to stand out, invest some time to create your own template (but otherwise, it's perfectly fine, at least you'll have the basic structure correct).
Re:The Red Herring of Red Flags: Why Resumes Are a Relic of ... by johnisgood on Saturday August 10, 2024 @07:45AM (#41208813)
Well, I am not using "moderncv" at all. I use three packages: "geometry", "inputenc", and "graphicx". That said, it does not look as appealing as these "creative" resumes (made using HTML & CSS or Adobe Illustrator, etc)
Re:The Red Herring of Red Flags: Why Resumes Are a Relic of ... by LtWorf on Saturday August 10, 2024 @12:04PM (#41210398)
Then you know where to look for things. Imagine if papers started to put the abstract somewhere else
Re:The Red Herring of Red Flags: Why Resumes Are a Relic of ... by katzinsky on Saturday August 10, 2024 @07:56AM (#41208849)
Meh. My "resume.html.pdf" has gotten me multiple jobs.
Re:The Red Herring of Red Flags: Why Resumes Are a Relic of ... by baxtr on Saturday August 10, 2024 @08:18AM (#41208962)
That doesn’t say anything, really.

It might very well be that you html.pdf thingy is great.

Re:The Red Herring of Red Flags: Why Resumes Are a Relic of ... by Cwizard on Saturday August 10, 2024 @04:18AM (#41208100)
This matches my experience as well.
Re:The Red Herring of Red Flags: Why Resumes Are a Relic of ... by deng on Saturday August 10, 2024 @04:18AM (#41208104)
Haha, exactly this! The resume is the first work sample you receive from an applicant, and it's absolutely baffling that even nowadays with all the tools available, a LOT of them still have glaring typos, poor grammar, confusing formatting, wrong length, you-name-it. It is absolutely correct that a perfect resume might not mean much in terms of skills, however, it's been very rare that someone with a poorly made resume even made it through the first screening interview.
Re:The Red Herring of Red Flags: Why Resumes Are a Relic of ... by _nalply on Saturday August 10, 2024 @07:51AM (#41208834)
If a company excludes bad resumes they are possibly just optimizing for good resume writers just by assuming that good resume writers are good workers.
Re:The Red Herring of Red Flags: Why Resumes Are a Relic of ... by tmcdos on Friday August 16, 2024 @08:54AM (#41265966)
It's like handwriting - good handwriting does not necessarily mean good worker but bad handwriting quite often means bad worker.
Re:The Red Herring of Red Flags: Why Resumes Are a Relic of ... by Cocktail on Saturday August 10, 2024 @04:41AM (#41208160)
I am one of those who made through the hoop of first and second rounds with the most horrid of CVs, still cant believe I got the job. Extremely happy that I did, I was told later that the resume I submitted was the worst one by far, but the person (ie. Me) was the best applicant, which I still consider funny yet depressing.
Re:The Red Herring of Red Flags: Why Resumes Are a Relic of ... by packetlost on Saturday August 10, 2024 @12:42PM (#41210649)
What are the things you generally look for? I've looked at a lot of resumes myself, but I still struggle with my own. I'd really love to see an example of one of the best resumes you've seen!
Re:The Red Herring of Red Flags: Why Resumes Are a Relic of ... by astura on Saturday August 10, 2024 @03:16PM (#41211567)
Just pay a professional to write it for you.
Re:The Red Herring of Red Flags: Why Resumes Are a Relic of ... by DSingularity on Saturday August 10, 2024 @03:43AM (#41207977)
For me I understood resumes when I interviewed.

It’s a pipeline. People are filtering the resume and you show up late in the process to interview. The resume is giving you material. You study it before the interview and based on what’s on it you look for opportunities to casually measure the candidate in a manner most favorable to the candidate himself. If the candidate can’t answer questions which probe the things his resume claims as expertise then it doesn’t bode well.

Re:The Red Herring of Red Flags: Why Resumes Are a Relic of ... by spicyusername on Saturday August 10, 2024 @08:32AM (#41209014)
They're simple, easy to make, easy to read, and perfectly solve the problem of quickly communicating your background to someone in in less than a minute.

I have a hard time imagining an alternative.

Re:The Red Herring of Red Flags: Why Resumes Are a Relic of ... by JohnFen on Saturday August 10, 2024 @09:02AM (#41209157)
Considering the amount of time and attention I put into crafting my resume, I don't consider them to be simple or easy to make.
Re:The Red Herring of Red Flags: Why Resumes Are a Relic of ... by from-nibly on Saturday August 10, 2024 @09:24AM (#41209293)
The root of the problem is that hiring doesn't scale. If you try to scale, it falls apart. It doesn't matter if you use resumes or some "objective" coding interview. Hiring is getting to know a lot of people and finding those that align greatly with what you are doing and who is doing it. You can't know that quickly. It sucks but it's the reality.