News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Employers used return-to-office to make workers quit by teeray on Thursday August 08, 2024 @01:50PM (#41194288)
Constructive dismissal is apparently only legal if you do it at enormous scale.
Re:Employers used return-to-office to make workers quit by vehemenz on Thursday August 08, 2024 @02:01PM (#41194416)
Yes, but constructive dismissal is only relevant if returning to the office constitutes a hostile work environment, which it wouldn't if the original terms of employment included office attendance. Inconvenience isn't an argument.
Re:Employers used return-to-office to make workers quit by CptFribble on Thursday August 08, 2024 @02:16PM (#41194597)
If WFH was accepted corporate policy, and allowed for moving large distances away, then reversing back to RTO is not just an inconvenience, it's as much a life-upending disruption as moving for a new job.
Re:Employers used return-to-office to make workers quit by supriyo-biswas on Thursday August 08, 2024 @02:10PM (#41194526)
That may be the legal definition, but creating difficulties and hurdles for the employee so that they leave also looks very much like it, if you ask me.
Re:Employers used return-to-office to make workers quit by jihiggins on Thursday August 08, 2024 @03:19PM (#41195199)
RTO in and of itself is hostile. Especially when there is still a highly contagious disease running rampant. It might not _legally_ constitute a hostile work environment, but it is _literally_ hostile.
Re:Employers used return-to-office to make workers quit by Ferret7446 on Friday August 09, 2024 @03:40AM (#41199617)
Are you talking about covid, right now in August 2024? I wasn't aware that anyone was still living in fear of covid; my observation is that literally everyone, in every country has moved past it.
Re:Employers used return-to-office to make workers quit by jihiggins on Wednesday August 14, 2024 @07:20PM (#41251612)
Sorry, didn't see your reply till now.

It's not literally everyone.

Immunocompromised people who have managed to survive are often still afraid of catching Covid. How little most people care means that those who are worried have a difficult time existing in public spaces. Especially with the constant social pressure to act like Covid is over. You're not going to see people who are worried about Covid as often, because... they are worried about Covid.

This was the case early on, too, though! Covid is _much_ more likely to kill people in marginalized groups. And while marginalized deaths still show up statistically, they are going to be more hidden in the day to day.

New Covid variants still cause severe long-term effects. From what I’ve read, the consensus seems to be “we have no idea what all of the long-term consequences will be, but they’re looking worrisome.” Covid is not reported on as much now, but this information isn't from like, fringe sources or anything. There is less news about Covid now because nobody wants to think or read about Covid anymore.

e.g. a quick search gives me: https://www.cbc.ca/news/health/researchers-are-still-untangl...

So, while most people may have moved on, I think the RTO movement is still hostile and coercive. Honestly, imo most people having moved on is also largely due to coercive forces.

Re:Employers used return-to-office to make workers quit by Suppafly on Thursday August 08, 2024 @02:39PM (#41194799)
>but constructive dismissal is only relevant if returning to the office constitutes a hostile work environment

That's not true, constructive dismissal happens when any part of your job significantly changes and you are forced to accept it or quit. Changing a job from WFH to RTO is a very significant change, especially if you were hired directly to WFH and never worked in the office as part of the job. It won't stop them from firing you, but will stop them from blocking your unemployment claims.

Re:Employers used return-to-office to make workers quit by tux1968 on Thursday August 08, 2024 @02:44PM (#41194854)
RTO, means Return To Office, which means it's applying to people who started out working in the office. And by your definition, when jobs changed from the office to WFH, it constituted constructive dismissal, since it was a significant change; but that is just silly.
Re:Employers used return-to-office to make workers quit by petsfed on Thursday August 08, 2024 @03:22PM (#41195218)
RTO is often applied to an organization, even if elements of it were never in an office. Anecdotally, I've heard of quite a few people who were hired as remote, then their org did and RTO, and the HR response amounted to "tough shit, move on your own dime, or find work elsewhere".
Re:Employers used return-to-office to make workers quit by bravetraveler on Friday August 09, 2024 @05:50AM (#41200306)
Happened to me and at least two executives. One had just built a house. Insane.

The same people tried to tell me I could ignore it. I said, "Dude, both of you couldn't" and found work that works instead.

Happily remote and not wasting another productive second on this.

Re:Employers used return-to-office to make workers quit by Suppafly on Thursday August 08, 2024 @03:07PM (#41195075)
>RTO, means Return To Office, which means it's applying to people who started out working in the office.

Not necessarily. The company itself is moving it's workforce from home back to the office, but lots of people were hired during the WFH phase of these companies operations, so RTO is a new situation for them. We're what, 4 years into WFH now? A lot of companies have probably turned over half their staff in that time. Even the older employees might be 'returning' to a completely different building than they originally were hired to work in, since many companies gave up their leases or sold their buildings during the height of WFH.

Re:Employers used return-to-office to make workers quit by bravetraveler on Friday August 09, 2024 @04:59AM (#41200069)
Wrong. If only things were as honest as their labeling.

Source: me. Hired remote, was unfortunate to be within fifty miles of an office and placed in a new bucket. They tried to change the deal, I found new work and a higher salary instead.

I used to go on site to train people. I wasn't unreasonable, the business was. RTO proponents actually pushed me more remote.

Re:Employers used return-to-office to make workers quit by pwillia7 on Thursday August 08, 2024 @02:43PM (#41194837)
Is it not hostile that they wanted a significant % of those they asked to no longer be employed there, spurred by the deliberate intentional actions of the company?
Re:Employers used return-to-office to make workers quit by dingnuts on Thursday August 08, 2024 @02:09PM (#41194509)
WFH has been normal for almost half a decade now. I changed jobs and stipulated remaining remote in that time, and I suspect my employer doesn't care. They have begun talking about RTO.

Here's the thing: it's not JUST inconvenient. It's a pay cut, full stop. I have to pay to commute, one way or the other, in both time and money. Acting like this only has to do with convenience is some real bootlicker shit

Re:Employers used return-to-office to make workers quit by 0cf8612b2e1e on Thursday August 08, 2024 @02:18PM (#41194611)
It is also the most dangerous thing I do in a day. Nearly every single day, there is a traffic accident on my route. Through no fault of my own, someday that could be me smeared on the road.
Re:Employers used return-to-office to make workers quit by teeray on Thursday August 08, 2024 @02:22PM (#41194667)
> it's not JUST inconvenient. It's a pay cut, full stop.

Never mind the ongoing state income tax implications of being forced to work in a physical location, which can greatly impact the amount of take-home pay you have.

Re:Employers used return-to-office to make workers quit by vehemenz on Thursday August 08, 2024 @04:33PM (#41195920)
I'm considering the employer's position. If a bunch of my employees were working six-hour days and communication was suffering at the office, then I would feel justified to institute RTO. As long as it's not meant as an indirect layoff AND the employees were hired for on-site work originally, I genuinely do not see the problem.

Of course, one might argue that employers should "know" that employees will quit, but honestly, are employers supposed gauge the level of WFH cultishness before making a routine business decision? It's ridiculous.

Yes, one can argue that it's a "pay cut, full stop" just as the employer can argue that they are getting less effective employees during WFH, or that one's unearned "raise" during COVID is being rescinded. I'm not a cultist, so these are positions that need to be argued for and earned. No foot-stomping. The employers should get a say.

Re:Employers used return-to-office to make workers quit by lotsofpulp on Thursday August 08, 2024 @02:29PM (#41194706)
It’s still not constructive dismissal in any state I know of. Management is allowed to change strategy, and deciding that having people in office is better for the business is sufficiently good cover.

Using return to office as a way to make people quit is also not a new strategy. Even before Covid, it was an often used tactic to trim headcount. Another common tactic is moving the office to a different location entirely, and that also is not constructive dismissal.

Re:Employers used return-to-office to make workers quit by pton_xd on Thursday August 08, 2024 @02:03PM (#41194440)
Constructive dismissal should be met with malicious compliance. I wonder what the PFML / FMLA claims look like graphed year over year.
Re:Employers used return-to-office to make workers quit by duxup on Thursday August 08, 2024 @02:28PM (#41194701)
Better to just find a job you want to work at ...

Reward the places that do it right with your efforts.

Re:Employers used return-to-office to make workers quit by RandallBrown on Thursday August 08, 2024 @02:37PM (#41194776)
Well sure, but that takes time.
Re:Employers used return-to-office to make workers quit by giantg2 on Thursday August 08, 2024 @02:10PM (#41194532)
Most places would have unpaid leave for those options, so it would hurt the worker more than the employer in most cases.
Re:Employers used return-to-office to make workers quit by ozim on Thursday August 08, 2024 @02:25PM (#41194681)
Unfortunately we still live in legal environment where work from office is the norm, so if someone is just an employee not a contractor and not some b2b - all legal setup is that employer sets up where and how you work.

There is no way you can disagree and "expecting to work from the office" doesn't constitute "hostile work conditions" it is just the norm.

For full time employees all laws for remote work is quickly cobbled patchwork that employer can cut right away by saying now they expect RTO and I would be seriously surprised if any employee wins lawsuit.

Re:Employers used return-to-office to make workers quit by paranoidrobot on Thursday August 08, 2024 @02:39PM (#41194794)
If remote or hybrid work is important to you, put it in your contract.

If an employer is not willing to do that then it's not really a remote/hybrid role.

Once it's in your contract then it won't matter about RTO demands for the workforce, because they don't apply to you.

Re:Employers used return-to-office to make workers quit by pwillia7 on Thursday August 08, 2024 @02:42PM (#41194829)
The law can be whatever you want when money is speech