News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:State of emergency declared as Ukraine launches raid into... by jncfhnb on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @03:29PM (#41184529)
I’m struggling to understand what the plan is. Unless it’s just grab the nuclear power plant and force a trade. But would Russia agree to such a trade?

Maybe it’s just a panic button to force them to spend more manpower on defenses.

Re:State of emergency declared as Ukraine launches raid into... by SenHeng on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @03:44PM (#41184656)
A few guesses.

Disrupt supples into Donbas by taking over the train lines.

Capture large number of untrained and unmotivated conscripts that are currently surrendering in large numbers.

It's easier to travel in Russia than in the heavily mined occupied Ukraine. Maybe they're taking the long way round?

Force a buffer zone.

Russia has been using scorched earth tactics in occupied Ukraine, maybe they'll be less willing on their own land?

Additional chips to prevent Russia from insisting on freezing the borders along occupied lands (you take our land, we take yours) during rumoured ceasefire negotiations.

Land swap negotiations.

Re:State of emergency declared as Ukraine launches raid into... by jncfhnb on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @03:49PM (#41184689)
Like 40 guys have surrendered. Not meaningful.

It seems unlikely that they can hold any of this territory. They have no supply lines.

Re:State of emergency declared as Ukraine launches raid into... by jajag on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @05:27PM (#41185750)
It's quite a bit more than that. I've seen reports of 40-50 surrendering in just one location alone - smaller numbers in multiple reports from other locations.
Re:State of emergency declared as Ukraine launches raid into... by jncfhnb on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @06:43PM (#41186303)
I find that tricky to believe. This is a fast operation that is probably quite a bit smaller than the Russians are claiming (they claim 1000 guys). I don’t think Ukraine is going to have the manpower to collect a significant number of prisoners even if they are surrendering.
Re:State of emergency declared as Ukraine launches raid into... by jajag on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @08:13PM (#41186841)
For what it's worth:

https://x.com/Heroiam_Slava/status/1821274958879977633

https://x.com/Tendar/status/1821222650191982674

https://x.com/bayraktar_1love/status/1821219526668898710

https://x.com/Danspiun/status/1821218979811119558

Yes I agree, this has to be a limited Ukrainian operation, but the short term impact is still considerable. What the long term goal is, who knows.

Re:State of emergency declared as Ukraine launches raid into... by jncfhnb on Friday August 09, 2024 @05:48PM (#41205636)
The numbers I’m seeing now are about 300 prisoners, which seems believable now that Ukraine seems to be doing a ridiculous number of soldiers into Russia
Re:State of emergency declared as Ukraine launches raid into... by euroderf on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @05:31PM (#41185792)
> Additional chips to prevent Russia from insisting on freezing the borders along occupied lands (you take our land, we take yours) during rumoured ceasefire negotiations.

I like this one. Negate a freeze as a negotiating proposal.

Re:State of emergency declared as Ukraine launches raid into... by Arnt on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @04:08PM (#41184871)
I'd guess it's mostly about the gas pipeline. The Russians sell cheap gas to Hungary, right?
Re:State of emergency declared as Ukraine launches raid into... by jncfhnb on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @04:19PM (#41184992)
The lines run through Ukraine though. Seizing the station here is not necessary to stop the flow.
[dead]
Re:State of emergency declared as Ukraine launches raid into... by dang on Saturday August 10, 2024 @10:34PM (#41213638)
You're certainly welcome here but you're not going to get anywhere by attacking the mainstream/majority view. I'm not saying that the majority view is correct, just that group dynamics ensure that if you challenge it in a provocative way, you'll get rejected the same way an immune system rejects antibodies.

If you want to participate successfully, the only two ways I know are either (1) avoid contentious topics, and/or (2) be careful not to provoke. This may be unfair but there's nothing we can do about it and it's the only thing that has any chance of working.

I've written about this in the past in case any of it is of interest or somehow helpful: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...

Re:State of emergency declared as Ukraine launches raid into... by justsomehnguy on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @03:53PM (#41184731)
Olympic Games and the US President Race, along with Biden who can just vanish into thin air and nobody would even bother now, switched media attention in the US from UA and without such focus - no more money or weapons.

> Unless it’s just grab the nuclear power plant

Read the article, emphasis mine:

>> On Wednesday evening, Ukrainian MP Oleksiy Honcharenko said the Ukrainian army had established control over the Sudzha gas hub - a major gas facility involved in the transit of natural gas from Russia to the EU via Ukraine, which has continued despite the war. It is the only point of entry for Russian gas into the EU.

>> Although this has not been verified by the BBC, Mr Honcharenko's comment was the first confirmation of an incursion into Russian territory by a Ukrainian official. Kyiv had previously not commented on reports of a cross-border attack.

Ukrainians always insisted what they are fighting to protect the homeland. You can twist the history books all you want, but you would never find Kursk being a part of the Ukraine, ever.

So it's just a combo operation for the PR (to get attention again) and for the blackmail (it's evil russkies destroyed gas station! we were just passing by!)

>> But with Ukrainian forces already overstretched and outmanned, some military analysts are questioning the wisdom of such cross-border raids.

That's quite soft, better to hear it straight from the horse's mouth: https://imgur.com/a/kcxBzF5

EDIT: one more interesting detail: while Ukrainains love to show in the gruesome details what they do with any Russians, most of the videos from their side is extremely mangled and low resolution. My favourite part (if it can be described like that) is a video of 'FPV drone hitting Mi-28', except it's spliced video (with very poor quality) of Mi-17 then oh! interference! video of what looks like a close by of Mi-28 and then oh! interference again! of the drone recovering somehow. If you ever saw Mi-17 you would never mistake it for Mi-28. Full damage control.

Re:State of emergency declared as Ukraine launches raid into... by kcb on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @04:14PM (#41184937)
What an incoherent argument. Russia started a war and it doesn't just magically stop at their border.

It's like arguing against the allies capturing Berlin because they should've just been protecting their homeland.

Re:State of emergency declared as Ukraine launches raid into... by jajag on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @05:30PM (#41185778)
> Ukrainians always insisted what they are fighting to protect the homeland.

Just what do you think they're doing if not that?

Re:State of emergency declared as Ukraine launches raid into... by klyrs on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @07:48PM (#41186689)
> Ukrainians always insisted what they are fighting to protect the homeland.

Sorry, what do you think Russia has been up to these last two years? Just playing tiddlywinks along the border? They invaded a country with their army. And now that country has gotten sick of playing D this entire time.

So when I read your comment all I hear is "Mommmm, Jimmy hit me back, it's not faiiiiiruh!"

Re:State of emergency declared as Ukraine launches raid into... by ninininino on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @05:10PM (#41185565)
1. Disrupt logistics/resupply to the frontlines.

2. Force Russia to allocate some of its troops to defense, not just pure 100% towards frontlines in Luhansk and Donetsk.

Re:State of emergency declared as Ukraine launches raid into... by praptak on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @05:20PM (#41185666)
I read some experts (armchair or otherwise) and they seem to agree it's a standard military strategy - create an attack strong enough to force the enemy to reallocate troops from the main attack directions.

The details here is that Russia has no forces available quickly enough to react. The exception is their air force and AFU came prepared for that. Their AA defence is unusually strong and it shows in Russian aircraft losses.

The other (pretty obvious) detail is that it's the enemy home territory which just makes Putin look bad.

Re:State of emergency declared as Ukraine launches raid into... by derdi on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @05:58PM (#41186021)
The nuclear power plant is a Russian talking point. Ukraine is not into nuclear terrorism, not even as quid pro quo.

Setting the power plant up as a goal in people's minds just helps Russian propaganda. Ukraine doesn't go there = Ukraine didn't reach its goal = heroic Russian victory. Let's not proactively fall into this trap.

Re:State of emergency declared as Ukraine launches raid into... by jncfhnb on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @06:49PM (#41186333)
That doesn’t seem obvious to me at all. Seizing the plant and rigging it to explode as a quid pro quo demand for Russia to leave the Zaporizhia NPP seems perfectly reasonable.

It’s not like “nuclear terrorism” is morally superior to threatening nuclear annihilation via MAD

Its also one of the few exit plans for a raid deep into enemy territory with no logistics.

Re:State of emergency declared as Ukraine launches raid into... by jajag on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @08:20PM (#41186877)
> Seizing the plant and rigging it to explode as a quid pro quo demand for Russia to leave the Zaporizhia NPP

I honestly don't see that happening. There's a diplomatic game being played around Russia's nuclear threats, I don't see Ukraine being so dumb as to undermine that.

Re:State of emergency declared as Ukraine launches raid into... by bdjsiqoocwk on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @10:29PM (#41187559)
The west is supporting Ukraine. The west wouldn't like if Ukraine starts engaging in nuclear terrorism because that would remove legitimacy from West's support in the eyes of the rest of the world. So, regardless of whether Ukraine would like to do some terrorism, the west is asking it: don't.
Re:State of emergency declared as Ukraine launches raid into... by derdi on Thursday August 08, 2024 @02:45AM (#41188750)
This would not be a good bluff from Ukraine, even if it considered nuclear terrorism an option. The prevailing winds blow from the east, as we know all too well since Chornobyl. Blowing up the plant just east of the border would mostly terrorize Ukraine itself.
Re:State of emergency declared as Ukraine launches raid into... by protomolecule on Thursday August 08, 2024 @04:59AM (#41189455)
>Ukraine is not into nuclear terrorism

They are into helping Jama’a Nusrat ul-Islam wa al-Muslimin (JNIM), which is an al-Qaeda affiliate. [0] Two African countries stopped diplomatic relations with the Ukraine over that. [1]

[0] https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/2024/08/05/ukraine-mali...

[1] https://www.rferl.org/a/niger-mali-ukraine-rebels-wagner/330...

Re:State of emergency declared as Ukraine launches raid into... by derdi on Thursday August 08, 2024 @05:35AM (#41189640)
(Well done for quoting the word "nuclear" but choosing to ignore it.)

To be clear, the "two African countries" are both military dictatorships that depend on Russian military support. Which is the reason Ukraine might be involved in a proxy war there. Not out of love for al-Quaeda but because they have a common enemy.

Re:State of emergency declared as Ukraine launches raid into... by protomolecule on Thursday August 08, 2024 @05:42AM (#41189682)
I've shown that they are into helping terrorists. They are also into using terrorists' tactics themselves [0]. At the same time you have failed to provide any justification for your statement "Ukraine is not into nuclear terrorism, not even as quid pro quo."

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2022_Crimean_Bridge_explosion#...

Re:State of emergency declared as Ukraine launches raid into... by 0dayz on Thursday August 08, 2024 @08:24AM (#41190799)
You're flailing your arms around.

They are first of supporting the rebels which are also working with the al qaeda group.

Secondly we still don't know how the truck explosion was pulled off if it was Ukrainian driver or Russian.

Lastly even if you consider Ukraine has used an attack ONCE like terrorist do, then I wonder two things: what about Russia then and how do you even remotely draw parallell between nuclear terrorism and use "tactics" used by terrorists?

Re:State of emergency declared as Ukraine launches raid into... by klajhaF on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @06:42PM (#41186299)
Probably what the Ukrainian MP cited in the article said:

Mr Honcharenko said on Facebook that while he did not know what the "plan"behind the incursion was, it would show "Europeans and Americans that... Russia can and needs to be attacked".

Some forces in the U.S. indeed view this as "proof" that Russia can be successfully attacked on its own territory and are more likely to approve funding.

Re:State of emergency declared as Ukraine launches raid into... by rasz on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @07:09PM (#41186446)
>I’m struggling to understand what the plan is.

"avoid what is strong and strike at what is weak". russia doesnt defend its borders because putin believes nuclear blackmail is enough deterrence.