> People who put their ideals above pragmatic self-interest self-select out of positions of power and influence. That is likely to be the case here as well.
It’s also possible that this co-founder realizes he has more than enough eggs saved up in the “OpenAI” basket, and that it’s rational to de-risk by getting a lot of eggs in another basket to better guarantee his ability to provide a huge amount of wealth to his family.
Even if OpenAI is clearly in the lead to him, he’s still looking at a lot of risk with most of his wealth being tied up in non-public shares of a single company.
Also, OpenAI has some of the most expensive people in the world, which is why they're burning so much money. Presumably they're so expensive because they're some of the smartest people in the world. Some are likely smarter than Schulman.
I don't want to dissuade you from this belief, but maybe you should pay less attention to the boastful marketing of these AI companies. :-)
Seriously: from what I know about the life of insanely smart people, I'd guess that OpenAI (and most other companies that in their marketing claim to hire insanely smart people) doesn't have any idea how to actually make use of such people. Such companies rather hire for other specific personality traits.
I was really surprised when OpenAI started providing most of their good features for free. I am not a business person, but it seems crazy to me to not try for profitability, of at least being close to profitability. I would like to know what the competitors’ burn rates are also.
For API use, I think OpenAI’s big competition is Groq, serving open models like Llama 3.1.
Because I’ve seen a lot of questions about how to use these models, I recorded a quick video showing how I use them on MacOS.
Local is not where the money is, it’s in cloud services and api usage fees.
They all tout OpenAI compatible APIs because OAI was the first mover. No real threat for incompatibility with OAI.
Plus these LLMs don’t have any kind of interface moat. It’s text in and text out.
> Plus these LLMs don't have any kind of interface moat.
The interface really has very little influence. Nobody in the enterprise world cares about the ChatGPT interface because they're all building features into their own products. The UI for ChatGPT has been copied ad nauseam - so if anyone really wanted something to look and feel the same it's already out there. Chat and visual modals are already there, so I'm curious how you think ChatGPT has an "interface moat"?
> Local private models are not a threat to openai.
There are lots of threats to AI. One of them being local models. Because if the OpenAI approach is to continue at their burn rate and hope that they will be the one and only I think they're very wrong. Small, targeted models provide for many more use cases than a bloated, expensive, generalized model. I would gather long term OpenAI either becomes a replacement for Google search or they, ultimately, fail. When I look around me I don't see many great implementations of any of this - mostly because many of them look and feel like bolt-ons to a foundational model that tries to do something slightly product specific. But even in those cases the confidence with which I'd put in these products today is of relatively low quality.
There is no interface moat. No reason for a happy openai user to ever leave openai, because they can enjoy all the local model tools with GPT.
I should’ve been more clear.
A business is worth the sum of future profits, discounted for time (because making money today is better than making money tomorrow). Negative profits today are fine as long as they are offset by future profits tomorrow. This should make intuitive sense.
And this is still true when the investment won't pay off for a long time. For example, governments worldwide provide free (or highly subsidized) schooling to all children. Only when the children become taxpaying adults, 20 years or so later, does the government get a return on their investment.
Most good things in life require a long time horizon. In healthy societies people plant trees that won't bear fruit or provide shade for many years.
I'm reminded of the Silicon Valley bit about no revenue https://youtu.be/BzAdXyPYKQo
It probably looks better to be not really trying for profitability and losing $5bn a year than trying hard and losing $4bn
I would also assume that he earns enough money to be rich. You are not a co-founder of OpenAI if you are not playing with the big boys.
So he definitly wants to be in this AI future but not with OpenAI. So i would argue it has to do with something which is important to him so important that the others disagree with him.
OpenAI will be better off without this crowd and just focus on building good products.
> OpenAI will be better off without this crowd and just focus on building good products.
Ah yes, "focus on building good products" without safety. Except a "good product" is safe.
Otherwise you're getting stuff like an infinite range plane powered by nuclear jet engine that has fallout for exhaust [1].
[1] IIRC, nuclear-powered cruise missiles were contemplated: their attack would have consisted on dropping bombs on their targets, then flying around in circles spreading radioactive fallout over the land.
Depends on how you define "safe". The kind of "safe" we get from OpenAI today seems to be mostly censorship, I don't think we need more of that.
there is an effort by AI-doomer groups to try and regulate/monopolize the technology, but fortunately it looks like open source has put a wrench in this.
Yep. The writing was already on the wall for GPT-5 when they teased a new model for months and let the media believe it was GPT-5, before finally released GPT-4o and admitting they hadn't even started on 5 yet (they quietly announced they were starting a new foundation model a few weeks after 4o).
Don't get me wrong, the cost savings for 4o are great, but it was pretty obvious at that point that they didn't have a clue how they were going to move past 4 in terms of capabilities. If they had a path they wouldn't have intentionally burned the hype for 5 on 4o.
This departure just further cements what I was already sure was the case—OpenAI has lost the lead and doesn't know how they're going to get it back.
I hope not, because Claude is much better, especially at programming.
Maybe I've been using it for the wrong things—it certainly never helps unblock me when I'm stuck like it sounds like it does for some (I suspect it's because when I get stuck it's deep in undocumented rabbit holes), but it sounds like it might be decent at large-scale rote refactoring? Aside from specialized editors, how do people use it for things like that?
You take Claude, you create a new Project, in your Project you explain the context of what you are doing and what you are programming (you have to explain it only once!).
If you have specific technical documentation (e.g. rare programming language, your own framework, etc), you can put it there in the project.
Then you create a conversation, and copy-paste the source-code for your file, and ask for your refactoring or improvement.
If you are lazy just say: "give me the full code"
and then
"continue the code" few times in a row
and you're done :)
When you say this, you mean typing out some text somewhere? Where do you do this? In a giant comment? In which file?
Don't ask short one-off questions and expect it to work (it might just, depending on what you ask, but probably not if you're deep on some proprietary code base with no traces in the LLMs pretraining).
I'm trying to figure out if I'm using it wrong or using it on the wrong types of problems. How do people with 10+ years of experience use it effectively?
Then when I have a bunch of wrong answers, I can give those as context as well to the model and make it avoid those pitfalls. At that point my constraints for the problem are so rigorous that the LLMs lands at the correct solution and frankly writes out the code 100x faster than I would. And I’m an advanced vim user who types at 155 wpm.
See, it's comments like this that make me suspect that I'm working on a completely different class of problem than the people who find value in interacting with LLMs.
I'm a very fast typer, but I've never bothered to find out how fast because the speed of my typing has never been the bottleneck for my work. The bottleneck is invariably thinking through the problem that I'm facing, trying to understand API docs, and figuring out how best to organize my work to communicate to future developers what's going on.
Copilot is great at saving me large amounts of keystrokes here and there, which is nice for avoiding RSI and occasionally (with very repetitive code like unit tests) actually a legit time saver. But try as I might I can't get useful output out of the chat models that actually speeds up my workflow.
If you're an experienced dev, having a peer that enthusiastically suggests a bunch of plausible but subtly wrong things probably net-net slows you down and annoys you. If you're more junior, it's more like being shown a world of possibilities that opens your mind and seems much more useful.
Anyway, I think the reason we see so much enthusiasm for LLM coding assistants right now is the overall skew of developers to being more junior. I'm sure these tools will eventually get better, at least I hope they do because there's going to be a whole lot of enthusiastically written but questionable code out there soon that will need to be fixed and there probably won't be enough human capacity to fix it all.
He still needs instructions on what to do next, he lacks a bit of "initiative", but from a pure coding skills it's amazing (aka, we will get replaced over time, and it's already the case, I don't need help of contractors, I prefer to ask Claude).
But I agree that for some creative tasks, like writing or explaining a joke, or some novel algorithms, it's very bad.
(I am not a paid shiller, just in awe of what Sonnet 3.5 + Opus can do)
Is it better than using GitHub Copilot in VSCode?
If you compare to Claude Sonnet, just the context window considerably improves the answers as well.
Of course there is no objective metrics, but from a user perspective I can see the coding skills are much better in Anthropic (and it's funny, because in theory, according to benchmarks it is Google Gemini the best, but in reality is absolutely terrible).
FWIW according to LMSYS this is not the case. In coding, current GPT-4o (and mini, for that matter) beat GPT-4-Turbo handily, by a margin of 32 points.
By contrast Sonnet 3.5 is #1, 4 score points ahead of GPT-4o.
I don't know what world you live in, but my experience has been 100% the opposite. Most people will not do what is ethical or principled. When you try to discuss it with them, they will DARVO and congrats, you have now been targeted for public retribution by the sociopathic child in the drivers seat.
The thing that upsets me most is the survivorship bias you express, and how everybody thinks that people are "nice and kind" they are not. The world is an awful terrible place full of liars, cheats and bad people that WE NEED TO STOP CELEBRATING.
One more time WE NEED TO STOP CELEBRATING BAD PEOPLE WHO DO BAD THINGS TO OTHERS.
(Also, I think you misread what I wrote.)
P(ethical_and_principled) < P(ethical_and_principled|stands_to_gain)
Or in plain language people are more likely to do the right thing when they stand to gain, rather than just because it’s the right thing.
I'll play devil's advocate. People leave bad bosses all the time, even when everything else is near-perfect. Additionally, cofounders sometimes get pushed out - even Steve Jobs went through this.
OpenAI has a burn rate of about 5 billion a year and they need to raise ASAP. If the fundraising isn't going well or if OpenAI is forced to accept money from questionable investors that would also be a good reason to jump ship.
In situations like these it's good to remember that people are much more likely to take the ethical and principled road when they also stand to gain from that choice. People who put their ideals above pragmatic self-interest self-select out of positions of power and influence. That is likely to be the case here as well.