News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Belenios: A Verifiable Online Voting System by maxdamantus on Sunday August 04, 2024 @07:57PM (#41157125)
As a software developer myself, if an "independent expert" comes out and says that some software system is fully verified, I might trust their allegiance, but I probably won't trust their competence.

I wouldn't expect the general population to trust them either.

Re:Belenios: A Verifiable Online Voting System by eru on Sunday August 04, 2024 @10:56PM (#41157773)
What if lots of experts come out that way, including people you already trust otherwise? Eg assume both Bill Gates and Linus Torvalds etc say they have reviewed the code?
Re:Belenios: A Verifiable Online Voting System by maxdamantus on Monday August 05, 2024 @12:23AM (#41158169)
Then I would ask why the system they're reviewing is different to any other which is meant to be guaranteed-secure (or check that others are asking those questions). We're told every year or so about some SecureBoot vulnerability, which presumably involves code that has been reviewed.

The system doesn't only include the code directly related to voting. It also includes OSes and everything involved in the infrastructure for hosting and communication (the Belenios system in particular involves sending private keys by email, and we're also relying on end user systems being uncompromised (who here likes browser extensions?)). It's not feasible to claim that such a system is secure from a remotely controlled attack (eg, by a lone external actor).

Most of the attack scenarios against an offline voting system are ones that the general population can at least reason about, and they probably involve multiple insiders that would face a serious risk of being ratted out by one another.

Re:Belenios: A Verifiable Online Voting System by eru on Monday August 05, 2024 @05:23AM (#41159448)
See https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41158861

Sending private keys (by mail or any other way) does sound bad, so the specific system mentioned in the article might not be worth bothering with.

Re:Belenios: A Verifiable Online Voting System by atoav on Monday August 05, 2024 @01:53AM (#41158468)
If we assume that:

- how do you know the code running on these machines on day X is actually the code they tested?

- how do you know the code running does the same thing the code they tested does, even if it is the same code (e.g. hardware instructions could be doing different things on the machine, the OS could provide different functionality, other programs could interfere)?

- how do you (and for that matter: every single voter) know their vote was counted towards the correct candidates in the whole process towards the end results, which likely involves transmitting data through the internet and/or people carrying USB thumb drives and sticking them into computers

I am not saying it can't be done, but I say you can tell appart who knows computers really well (hackers) from those who know it kinda (geeks), by how doable they think this is.

Re:Belenios: A Verifiable Online Voting System by baobabKoodaa on Monday August 05, 2024 @03:21AM (#41158861)
The voting system you described is not a verifiable voting system. If you have a verifiable voting system, you don't need to know what code is running on the election machines. That's the whole point of having a verifiable voting system.

You asked "how so you know your vote was counted". You can google for examples of how this works in verifiable voting systems.

Re:Belenios: A Verifiable Online Voting System by j16sdiz on Monday August 05, 2024 @10:34PM (#41167373)
In a verifiable voting system, voter usually get a recipe that he can verify, in later time, their vote have been counted. But what stop same recipe is handed out twice? Do you do transparent log? Second system to audit those? How general voters are supposed to understand this?

Just pick a voting station with lower computer literacy, and you can do whatever you want ..

Re:Belenios: A Verifiable Online Voting System by eru on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @01:16AM (#41167974)
> But what stop same recipe is handed out twice?

Cryptography. Your receipt is presumably only valid for yourself. So if you got someone else's receipt, it wouldn't be valid for you.

I support paper voting for political elections for most of the reasons you mentioned, but I don't think that automatically makes all arguments for paper voting good and valid, and all arguments for alternative voting systems null and void.

And even if political elections are better done on paper, there's plenty of other elections (eg in companies and clubs etc) with different requirements and threats, and they might benefit from the research and experimentation.

Re:Belenios: A Verifiable Online Voting System by baobabKoodaa on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @03:05AM (#41168474)
> In a verifiable voting system, voter usually get a recipe that he can verify, in later time, their vote have been counted. But what stop same recipe is handed out twice?

Different solutions exist for this problem, which is known as a "clash attack". For example, in the Floating Receipts voting scheme, those things that you call "recipes" are pre-printed on ballots and hidden under scratch strips. The scratch strip is removed at the time when the ballot is dropped into the ballot box. If the manufacturer of the ballots were to pre-print the same "recipe" on multiple ballots, it would be discovered during the verification phase, because you would in some cases have 2 different votes cast on 2 different ballots which would contain the same "recipe". So both voters look up the "recipe" online and they are supposed to discover only one vote corresponding to the "recipe".

Re:Belenios: A Verifiable Online Voting System by j16sdiz on Monday August 05, 2024 @10:27PM (#41167350)
Reviewed the code -- but did they inspect the machine? Check the network for reliability? Review the crypto for replayability? RNG that's is actually random?

How many expert do we need? Do we need cross-domain experts to check if any domain experts missing anything between the gaps?

For paper voting, it is literally just check the box is empty before voting and nobody get near the box unexpectedly

Re:Belenios: A Verifiable Online Voting System by eru on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @01:16AM (#41167977)
> For paper voting, it is literally just check the box is empty before voting and nobody get near the box unexpectedly

That depends on how complicated your voting system is. Have a look at the complications they have in Australia..