News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Non-computability of solutions of certain equations on di... by almostgotcaught on Saturday August 03, 2024 @07:44PM (#41150120)
Why do people upvote this stuff - an unremarkable paper on a niche topic in a niche area. How many hn readers would even be able to distinguish if this were LLM word salad or original work? How many would take the time to try? "We love science and learning!" Cool well then how there aren't arcane/abstruse biology/psychology/history papers posted here at the same frequency?
Re:Non-computability of solutions of certain equations on di... by lisper on Saturday August 03, 2024 @07:47PM (#41150131)
This paper is not unremarkable. It's actually quite a surprising result. The only question is whether it's earth-shattering, or just a parlor trick. My money is on parlor-trick, but I don't understand the math well enough to be confident of that. I posted this here hoping to find someone who could shed some light on this question.
Re:Non-computability of solutions of certain equations on di... by almostgotcaught on Saturday August 03, 2024 @07:50PM (#41150147)
It is unremarkable - it has 5 citations since May 2022. I have papers with more cites from this year.

Edit: it's a parlor trick because they invent a decision procedure (bounds on maxima) and then prove something based on that premise:

> It will be shown that non-computability of the first derivative is not detectable by a Turing machine for two concrete examples

I wonder if they rigged the game hmmm. In general people do this kind of thing all the time to get published (build both a technique and a foil for their technique) and it's always a weak paper.

Re:Non-computability of solutions of certain equations on di... by cscurmudgeon on Saturday August 03, 2024 @07:57PM (#41150171)
1. https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/37021/why-is-it...

2. > it has 5 citations since May 2022 ... I have papers with more cites from this year ... In general people do this kind of thing all the time to get published

People also play games to get citations.

Re:Non-computability of solutions of certain equations on di... by almostgotcaught on Saturday August 03, 2024 @08:12PM (#41150227)
This is an NPC response. We all already know citation count is flawed just like we all already know that all metrics are flawed in some way. Doesn't mean they're worthless such as in this case where we're not assessing some nuance of the paper but an already superficial quality ie whether the paper is remarkable. And if you think that you can't use citation count as at least a weak signal on that, I challenge you to provide me a counterexample.
Re:Non-computability of solutions of certain equations on di... by immibis on Saturday August 03, 2024 @08:43PM (#41150346)
Your original response of "it has few citations so it's unremarkable" was also an NPC response, which I wouldn't have commented on except that you're calling other people's responses NPC responses.
Re:Non-computability of solutions of certain equations on di... by almostgotcaught on Saturday August 03, 2024 @08:49PM (#41150368)
> Your original response of "it has few citations so it's unremarkable"

I'm befuddled. it's right there at the root of this string of comments: my original response was "it's unremarkable because it's niche in a niche area". it's only when someone asked why, i responded with citations and etc. so my original comment was not NPC according to your assessment, and it's only in response to someone reasserting that i had to cite something.

Re:Non-computability of solutions of certain equations on di... by pvg on Saturday August 03, 2024 @09:41PM (#41150583)
You should take a look at https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html for some suggestions re: "NPC response".
Re:Non-computability of solutions of certain equations on di... by almostgotcaught on Saturday August 03, 2024 @09:46PM (#41150601)
The false decorum/hypocrisy is palpable: I don't see how a dismissive/flippant link to a generic stack exchange post is any better in terms "quality response".
Re:Non-computability of solutions of certain equations on di... by pvg on Saturday August 03, 2024 @09:58PM (#41150662)
It's not a personal attack via crappy internet trope, that's the hopefully-now-obvious difference.
Re:Non-computability of solutions of certain equations on di... by almostgotcaught on Saturday August 03, 2024 @10:07PM (#41150711)
Sure but it's just as dismissive. At least my response included more reasoning in addition to the crappy Internet trope.
Re:Non-computability of solutions of certain equations on di... by pvg on Sunday August 04, 2024 @11:05AM (#41153997)
You can't escalate to edgelordery just because you read something as dismissive, at least not on HN. Or in npc-jargon terms, Snowflake Edgelord is not a valid alignment/class combo.
Re:Non-computability of solutions of certain equations on di... by refulgentis on Saturday August 03, 2024 @07:58PM (#41150174)
Sure, but rings off to the ear: this 2 year old paper saying it proved a Turing machine could say if a Turing machine could enter infinite loop given a very particular problem class could possibly be big news, earth-shattering news, I need someone else to tell me if bounds checking is involved. thank God it made it to the front page, I submitted it so I could get someone else to tell me
Re:Non-computability of solutions of certain equations on di... by fourier456 on Saturday August 03, 2024 @07:59PM (#41150178)
Tbf you can always ask an LLM to explain it /s