News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by dralley on Friday July 26, 2024 @08:01AM (#41077877)
Yesterday a Russian "chef" was arrested after drunkenly bragging about a sabotage operation to disrupt the Olympic opening ceremony.

https://theins.press/en/politics/273350

> On May 7, he was in Russia and due to fly from Moscow to Istanbul, where he’d catch a connecting flight back to Paris the next day. Except he couldn't. He got so fall-down drunk at Istanbul Airport that he was barred from boarding his plane. Instead Griaznov took a taxi to the Bulgarian border, where another car delivered him to St. Vlas, a resort town on the Black Sea coast of Bulgaria, where Griaznov owns property.

> Griaznov stayed at his apartment for a few days before moving on to Varna, a Bulgarian city 60 miles north of St. Vlas. From there he flew on to Paris. During one of his beach-side dinners he got drunk again and let slip to the neighbors that he had a special assignment this summer in Paris to disrupt the opening ceremony of the Olympics. At first the neighbors were incredulous. That’s when Griaznov brandished his FSB ID, witnesses told The Insider. A few days later, Griaznov made his way to Varna and took a flight from there. Before flying to Paris, Griaznov made a call to his FSB boss and informed him that the operation was on track. Griaznov even said he’d recruited “one more Moldovan from Chisinau.”

It would be humorous if it weren't so serious.

Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by CoastalCoder on Friday July 26, 2024 @08:07AM (#41077916)
If this is true, I don't understand the actions of Russia's government in recent years.

I doubt their goal is to be universally reviled, so what's their real objective?

As much as I'm tempted to think they're just being full-on assholes, I assume they're being more strategic than that.

Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by baq on Friday July 26, 2024 @08:12AM (#41077940)
They sow chaos and then unleash the bots criticizing whoever is currently in office; then they unleash bots criticizing those bots and hope to drag in normal people.

Basically the idea is to erode trust in the western system. They don't try to hide it anymore and seems it doesn't matter - it's quite effective anyway.

Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by netcan on Friday July 26, 2024 @08:22AM (#41078004)
Yeah but this is more like "plan a minor disturbance of a high profile event. Get caught and galvanize the public to arm your enemies."

It doesn't erode trust in the western system.

Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by baq on Friday July 26, 2024 @08:32AM (#41078079)
This one was exceptional in every way. There are tens if not hundreds of examples in which they managed to not be so completely drunk to fail multiple times.
Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by mistermann on Friday July 26, 2024 @03:44PM (#41081636)
How do you distinguish between ones that are actually Russia and ones that are only asserted or implied to be Russia?

Or do you?

Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by baq on Friday July 26, 2024 @03:58PM (#41081733)
Sometimes the authorities find out, especially if it's a big fire of an ammo depot or a nerve agent wet job. Sometimes there is only circumstantial evidence. Sometimes you get used to it and you know it's them again.
Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by mistermann on Friday July 26, 2024 @04:23PM (#41081937)
> Sometimes you get used to it and you know it's them again.

You are using the colloquial versions of "know", and "is".

Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by baq on Friday July 26, 2024 @04:52PM (#41082187)
Yes, of course. You're taking what I've written out of context.
Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by mistermann on Friday July 26, 2024 @05:55PM (#41082667)
The context: I asked you a precise question about your claim, you answered it in the way you chose to.

You are welcome to clarify if you'd like.

Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by baq on Friday July 26, 2024 @06:12PM (#41082780)
Won’t be doing your googling for you today, I’m very sorry.
Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by mistermann on Saturday July 27, 2024 @02:13PM (#41088332)
I believe this is in play:

https://www.logicallyfallacious.com/logicalfallacies/Shiftin...

Do you disagree?

Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by lesuorac on Friday July 26, 2024 @09:38AM (#41078543)
I mean if you gave an American the option between say NK and USA they'll probably chose USA. However, if you just omit a comparison and ask them if they trust the USA they'll probably say no.

That's the cleverness of this. You aren't trying to convince them that Russia is better. You're just trying to convince them that USA is failing compared to its previous self.

https://news.gallup.com/poll/508169/historically-low-faith-i...

Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by netcan on Friday July 26, 2024 @09:49AM (#41078655)
This was in France.
Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by lesuorac on Friday July 26, 2024 @10:15AM (#41078842)
Well, the French never had confidence in their government but it is down.

Slide 22 - https://www.sciencespo.fr/cevipof/sites/sciencespo.fr.cevipo...

Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by toyg on Friday July 26, 2024 @08:49AM (#41078186)
The "get caught" part often doesn't happen. And even if they do get caught, as long as the main objective is achieved, it can be promoted as a show of strength so that next time the victims will play ball even before force is applied.

It's the mafia style, everyone knows who whacked whom.

Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by netcan on Friday July 26, 2024 @09:49AM (#41078659)
I don't see how this shows strength.
Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by toyg on Friday July 26, 2024 @11:15AM (#41079302)
Not everyone can pull off "a massive attack on a large scale to paralyse the TGV network" (literal quote from the rail operator). It's brutish, but it's a form of strength - like a mafia bully burning down your flower shop because you refused to pay.
Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by Modified3019 on Saturday July 27, 2024 @06:37AM (#41085652)
Which is fine and expected, the goal here isn’t to impress you.

You have to look at this from the perspective of deeply broken people, full of malice and hardcore narcissism. Even if sabotage fails, they pat themselves on the back, rejoicing that they’ve increased paranoia and confusion, and start planning the next attack.

And if it provokes a response from their would be victims that results in Russian goals somewhere being ruined, they cry crocodile tears for pity and make themselves out to be martyrs, and plan the next attack.

There are many humans in this world with thoughts and motivations that are completely alien to others.

Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by consumer451 on Friday July 26, 2024 @06:06PM (#41082740)
According to their history of attacks on individuals, grand strategic logic often lags behind their desire for petty revenge. The government of France denied Russia's standing in this Olympics. This is simple reprisal.
Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by anonym29 on Friday July 26, 2024 @08:56AM (#41078232)
Counterpoint: as someone with zero trust in the U.S. system, Russia's actions and influence have done nothing to contribute. Our own politicians have that covered, for me.

The US government is the world's pre-eminent pirveyor of global terrorism, and the world leader of assassinating and overthrowing legitimately elected Democratic leaders. When American soliders murder unarmed Reuters journalists, the American government conceals it. When that (and evidence that the American government spies on it's "allies") gets leaked by a whistleblower anyway, instead of giving either the American people or our allies a sincere apology for it's wrongdoing, the American government persecutes and slanders the whistleblower. The American media conglomerates are complicit. Back when America was still an even more authoritarian regime than it is today, the military was often deployed to suppress peaceful anti-war protests at college campuses. Recall that in the Kent State Massacre, it was the American government that opened fire on unarmed 18, 19, 20, and 21 year olds who were exercising their constitutionally protected rights to assemble and petition the government to demand a redress of grievances. Several students died, none of the American soldiers faced meaningful disciplinary action (e.g. imprisonment for murdering unarmed civilians). The American government freaked out and treated Soviet warheads on Cuba, 1100 miles from DC, as an existential threat and directly accused Moscow of provoking WW3, yet after breaking the verbal promise that we made to Russia in the early 90s to expand NATO "not one inch east", we instead began placing nuclear weapons of our own in the Baltics and Eastern Europe, a mere few hundred miles from Moscow. For all the good of the American people, the American government contrasts with profound hypocrisy, ugliness, deceit, hate, a callous disregard for human life, disrespect for actual democracy, and a seemingly endless appetite for murdering unarmed civilian populations, both foreign and domestic. This hasn't stopped in recent years, the targets have merely changed. The American government now routinely harms and murders people of color, minorities, and women both directly and through inaction of national legislature cracking down on racist policing, and failing to uphold reproductive rights.

Russia didn't need to lift a finger for me to lose all faith and trust in the American government, they've got many generations of evildoing that suffice fine on their own. That 'senator' is an anagram for 'treason' is no coincidence.

Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by jcranmer on Friday July 26, 2024 @09:27AM (#41078478)
> That 'senator' is an anagram for 'treason' is no coincidence.

One is a Latin word, the other is a French word?

And when you say it's "no coincidence", that means that someone intentionally made it so. Which word do you think was designed to be the anagram? Given that 'senator' is the direct Latin word that predates 'treason' (in its modern English spelling) by thousands of years, it has to be the latter, so do you think some philologist is sitting around going "ah yes, we should spell traïson as treason so that it's a perfect anagram to use as a pun for an office that won't exist for another few hundred years"?

Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by laughingcurve on Friday July 26, 2024 @09:33AM (#41078512)
>That 'senator' is an anagram for 'treason' is no coincidence.

That is literally the definition of a coincidence. Get off Hacker News and go to Reddit. Low information comments like this belong there.

Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by anonym29 on Friday July 26, 2024 @10:46AM (#41079050)
A paragraph of accurate historical details about government atrocities is undone by a single rhetorical remark at the botttom to drive the point home? TIL.
Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by jcranmer on Friday July 26, 2024 @11:01AM (#41079173)
There's a lot of details that aren't accurate. For starters, no nuclear weapons have been placed by the US in any country of the former Warsaw Pact or USSR.
Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by colingoodman on Friday July 26, 2024 @12:50PM (#41080129)
It’s an ethos thing. Don’t make ridiculous claims if you want to convince people of your argument; by nature people will assume everything else is nonsense, too.
Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by ljlolel on Friday July 26, 2024 @09:11AM (#41078341)
Found the anonymous bot account
Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by anonym29 on Friday July 26, 2024 @10:44AM (#41079031)
I'm not a bot, but nothing I say can convince someone who isn't open to new information or critical thinking.
Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by dvfjsdhgfv on Friday July 26, 2024 @11:37AM (#41079506)
Yeah, the anagram part almost got me convinced.
Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by neoromantique on Friday July 26, 2024 @09:44AM (#41078607)
Hello Ivan.
Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by anonym29 on Friday July 26, 2024 @10:45AM (#41079033)
Hello Reagan administration admirer.
Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by neoromantique on Friday July 26, 2024 @05:58PM (#41082684)
Не, я тебя вижу ;)
Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by worldsayshi on Friday July 26, 2024 @08:15AM (#41077964)
I'm a bit puzzled by this as well but I assume that the goal here is to project power and scare people into submission. Making themselves seem more powerful than they are by attacking an event that is in the public spotlight.
Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by dotancohen on Friday July 26, 2024 @08:20AM (#41077986)
Different cultures, this seems a very Russian way of projecting power. Though I personally can think of at least two other actors who are just as likely to blame. At least this wasn't a "hurt people" power projection.

Western civilization, including most of the infrastructure, assumes good intentions of those around. How many times have teenagers independently realized the chassis they could cause just by pushing a waiting pedestrian into traffic? Trains have always been noted as an easy target.

Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by rjzzleep on Friday July 26, 2024 @08:23AM (#41078010)
You should be puzzled. You should always be puzzled when people say "witnesses told us", "anonymous intelligence officials said". It's what got us into plenty of wars we didn't need to be in. Especially when the authors are known to be in collusion with said intelligence agencies.

> An extraordinary email uncovered under freedom of information laws raises serious questions about whether Bellingcat, the “open source” collective widely cited by mainstream journalists and loved by the CIA, collaborates directly with Western intelligence agencies.

https://thegrayzone.com/2023/11/30/bellingcat-collusion-west...

Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by r721 on Friday July 26, 2024 @08:57AM (#41078233)
Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by jdietrich on Friday July 26, 2024 @08:31AM (#41078068)
Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by rjzzleep on Friday July 26, 2024 @08:38AM (#41078117)
Did you even read the article you linked? Wyatt Reed worked as a Freelance journalist, like so many other journalists. It was always public knowledge. There was no "hacked email" here. The WaPo issued a tiny correction on this smear piece at least:

> correction > A previous version of this article incorrectly said that leaders of the online news site Grayzone had received payments from Iranian media, according to recently unearthed documents. The documents show that only one of the site’s editors received such payments. The article has been corrected.

Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by baq on Friday July 26, 2024 @03:05PM (#41081314)
You should also assume Russia would very much prefer the USA to keep to themselves so Putin et al. can steal the rest of the world.
Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by mrguyorama on Friday July 26, 2024 @05:14PM (#41082325)
Calling everything a conspiracy is the exact lack of skepticism you should not have.

If you want to paint bellingcat as a tool of the CIA, you have to prove their claims to be false. If the CIA pays bellingcat to produce only factually correct information, that is still useful.

Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by rjzzleep on Saturday July 27, 2024 @12:52PM (#41087801)
No. People like YOU should provide proof. Until then YOUR claims are the conspiracy. Relying purely on hearsay makes YOU the conspiracy theorist. It's absurd that I even have to say this.
Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by surfingdino on Friday July 26, 2024 @08:25AM (#41078027)
Terrorism is the weapon of the powerless. Russians know they cannot match NATO, so they are trying to disrupt the event they essentially banned themselves from.
Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by surfingdino on Friday July 26, 2024 @08:21AM (#41077998)
There is no objective other than to destroy the West and democracy and then rule with as much brutality as the conquered nations will bear. If they cannot achieve that objective they want to go down in flames with the rest of the world.

If you want to know how the Russian peace looks like read up on the partitions of Poland (economic exploitation, violent anti-semitism, deportations to Siberia, confiscation of property and land, russification, etc.) or the history of countries in Eastern Europe who found themselves inside the borders of Soviet Union or the Warsaw Pact. Persecutions, mass deportations, mass murders, torture, economic exploitation.

I really pity the African nations who got convinced to kick out Americans and the French. They will now get a taste of Russia and it will not be pretty.

Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by insane_dreamer on Friday July 26, 2024 @09:45AM (#41078627)
Russia’s influence in Africa / Asia is greatly diminished since the Cold War era.

China is the primary threat to Western nations, not Russia. China savvily extended its influence in Africa in particular while the US was so caught up with its useless War on Terror in Iraq and Afghanistan, totally squandering its post Cold War opportunities in Africa.

Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by Jach on Friday July 26, 2024 @04:39PM (#41082085)
I'm sure Chinese intelligence loves how easily people attribute things to Russia.
Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by insane_dreamer on Friday July 26, 2024 @08:55PM (#41083706)
Yeah, it's a ridiculous Cold War era kneejerk reaction.
Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by throwaway290 on Friday July 26, 2024 @09:16AM (#41078386)
> I really pity the African nations who got convinced to kick out Americans and the French. They will now get a taste of Russia and it will not be pretty.

As a Russian I was with you until this part. Russia doesn't seem to have enough money/influence for that. They get a taste of China instead. Like https://x.com/mirab_clothiers/status/1782115456045728135

Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by surfingdino on Friday July 26, 2024 @09:42AM (#41078584)
Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by neom on Friday July 26, 2024 @09:27AM (#41078480)
At least the west knew what they were getting into when they enabled the Chinese extraction system (no objections here, seemed like a fine quid pro quo for a while). I don't expect we would see benevolence from China towards the west, I do hope they show it to the emerging countries, as they were not so long ago emerging themselves.
Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by insane_dreamer on Friday July 26, 2024 @09:46AM (#41078635)
> do hope they show it to the emerging countries, as they were not so long ago emerging themselves.

That’s not how it works.

Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by throwaway290 on Friday July 26, 2024 @09:32AM (#41078505)
Not sure I understand most of your comment, what extraction system?
Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by jcranmer on Friday July 26, 2024 @09:41AM (#41078577)
China tends to be even more narrowly focused than Western powers on mineral extraction in its African investment, and they also have a reputation for relying very heavily on imported Chinese labor in their projects, which means the benefits percolate less than they would with Western projects (itself a pretty meager benefit usually!).

Or it could be a reference to the Chinese tendency to invest in the form of giving countries loans that they are ill-equipped to pay back, and China playing very hardball on poorest country debt forgiveness.

Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by neom on Friday July 26, 2024 @10:09AM (#41078797)
China emerged by building and selling. Part of the rise of china has been the extraction of wealth, resource, and knowledge. I don't say this with any shade, any emotion or feeling, just very literally. A large component of the ability for china to move forward so quickly was the creation of funnels that allowed for exchange. The west mostly extracted the labour and china extracted a bunch of other stuff. I can't think of a better word to describe what literally happened, and again, I'm not saying it with an opinion (that would be another discussion).

Without any judgement, imo: China is good at creating extractive systems.

(I'll add, if you've not read it, "Dealing with China An Insider Unmasks the New Economic Superpower By Henry Paulson" is a fantastic book)

Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by throwaway290 on Friday July 26, 2024 @10:18AM (#41078857)
OK, makes sense.
Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by ClumsyPilot on Friday July 26, 2024 @08:48AM (#41078177)
> If they cannot achieve that objective they want to go down in flames with the rest of the world.

I think this level of unserious analysis is deeply unhelpful. You know people in Russia have their lives and goals, they are not suicidal maniacs. At least read some Russian media with google translate

Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by surfingdino on Friday July 26, 2024 @09:34AM (#41078521)
People in Russia are indoctrinated and their thinking and worldview is heavily influenced by Russian propaganda. They have never enjoyed freedom of thought or legal protection from the intrusive, corrupt, and murderous state. Their lives belong to the state just like their goals. The concept of personal freedom or privacy doesn't exist in Russia.

Even those who travel abroad don't seem to change their behaviour and thinking no matter how often and how long they visit other countries. They have become the scourge of the tourist resorts that will still take their money. Europeans don't want to go there anymore. It's all vodka, loud parties, and being absolute assholes to others. They are quickly becoming the Sentinelese of Europe.

I will not read Russian media, I had enough of it in my early years when it was compulsory. Russians pillaged my country of birth and continue to be an existential threat. Russians also lied to everybody after 1989 and used the time, the trust, and the money to arm themselves and start invading and killing neighbours. There is zero truth in what Russians say. They can keep their ballet and Dostoyevsky.

Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by immibis on Friday July 26, 2024 @08:59AM (#41078246)
They are talking about the Russian state, not people in Russia.
Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by dvfjsdhgfv on Friday July 26, 2024 @11:44AM (#41079547)
> You know people in Russia have their lives and goals, they are not suicidal maniacs.

There are many, many decent people in Russia who abhor this war. But people have zero influence on what is going on. If one day Putin decides to invade the Baltics, your statement about Russians not being suicidal maniacs will still hold true, but again with no relationship with the actual events.

Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by spywaregorilla on Friday July 26, 2024 @03:42PM (#41081611)
The "nations" in Africa courting Russian influence are largely militant groups that have claimed dominion over lands. Those particular people in charge will probably selfishly benefit a great deal.
Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by jltsiren on Friday July 26, 2024 @08:24AM (#41078023)
They could be embracing the North Korean model. You don't have to be competitive as long as you are untouchable. The elites get wealth and power, and the rest don't matter.
Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by surfingdino on Friday July 26, 2024 @08:28AM (#41078049)
What wealth? Their wealth comes from the natural resources, which they now cannot openly sell at market prices. Give it a few years and the next meeting of the Russian oligarchs will be held on a wooden bench behind the foreign currency exchange kiosk next to the Moscow's Luzniki stadium.
Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by hiatus on Friday July 26, 2024 @08:58AM (#41078244)
If terrorist organizations can sell their natural resource plunder on the black market at profit why can't the Russians? For instance https://www.brookings.edu/articles/how-isis-uses-oil-to-fund...
Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by grugagag on Friday July 26, 2024 @09:39AM (#41078555)
Too little and too slow for Russia’s current needs.
Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by surfingdino on Friday July 26, 2024 @09:40AM (#41078565)
Sure. But what is wealth without a chance to flex? You can park all your yachts in Vladivostok, but it's not exactly the Monaco Yacht Club is it?
Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by jltsiren on Friday July 26, 2024 @08:46AM (#41078169)
Private wealth, not national wealth. Despite the poverty of his country and decades of isolation, Kim Jong Un is a billionaire who lives an extremely comfortable life.

If you are untouchable, don't care about the people, and can keep the people in check, the economy doesn't matter. You can live in wealth and comfort, while your people face famine and poverty. And the situation can be stable for many decades.

Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by surfingdino on Friday July 26, 2024 @09:14AM (#41078369)
Kim is a billionaire who cannot enjoy his wealth in the same way western billionaires can.

He is untouchable because of the cost of removing him, not because he is so well protected.

Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by jackstraw14 on Friday July 26, 2024 @08:26AM (#41078037)
Destabilization. You can usually count on it if Russia is involved.
Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by energy123 on Friday July 26, 2024 @08:27AM (#41078040)
They didn't want to get caught. They want to create chaos, which leads to disillusionment, nihilism, infighting and isolationism and a breaking up of the West's unity. Relevant, from the CBS this week:

> The FBI announced it disrupted a Russian AI-enhanced social media bot farm, which was designed to be an influence operation. Some of the fake profiles from bots purported to be Americans.

Some other examples:

- https://www.technologyreview.com/2021/09/16/1035851/facebook...

- https://openai.com/index/disrupting-deceptive-uses-of-AI-by-...

- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russia_and_Black_Lives_Matter

It's probably quite effective, but we don't know how effective because it's impossible to re-run the last 10 years without this and see what would have happened.

Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by aga98mtl on Friday July 26, 2024 @08:30AM (#41078064)
Poisonings, people falling out of windows, arsons, it all make sense if you consider that it is a state captured by a mafia clan. John McCain famously said that Russia is ‘A Gas Station Run by a Mafia That Is Masquerading as a Country’
Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by ekianjo on Friday July 26, 2024 @08:34AM (#41078090)
> that it is a state captured by a mafia clan

most countries are captured by a mafia clan, this isn't a thing specific to Russia. When you have powerful intelligence services sooner or later they end up taking over.

Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by crabbone on Friday July 26, 2024 @09:04AM (#41078290)
But there are differences.

For example, Asian theocracies understand their mission as a state and its government as furthering whatever bizarre ideas they gleamed from the scripture. They are often clan-ish in organization, but this only reflects the history of how they came to be that way, that isn't the goal.

When it comes to the European politicians, they may be very corrupt lying scumbags, but in order to get elected they need to put on a show pretending to act in the interest of the country they want to rule.

When it comes to Russia: they are simply criminals. They don't need to pretend to want to make their country better off. Not in the sense the same corrupt lying European politician would. In prison terms, they try to prove themselves as the higher cast. As those who are allowed (and even required) to humiliate the lower cast.

It's highly unlikely that Russian intelligence service is anything special. But they aren't the ones calling the shots that's for sure. They are just a part of the country-sized prison.

Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by Modified3019 on Friday July 26, 2024 @05:48PM (#41082619)
The reality of living in Russia is the perfect example of the false equivalence of the sentiment that “a government is just a mafia”. Magnitude matters.
Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by ifyoubuildit on Friday July 26, 2024 @08:38AM (#41078120)
It's just like how the terrorists hated us for our freedoms and were hiding weapons of mass destruction. The war machine isn't just gonna keep itself running.
Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by crabbone on Friday July 26, 2024 @08:49AM (#41078185)
To understand anything Russian government does, you need to understand that they aren't a government in the way Western democracies / republics / monarchies understand the function of the government. For someone with largely humanistic outlook on life, the function of the government is to try to make sure that what's being governed prospers. Prosperity may be understood as "more riches for the rich" or "redistribution of wealth" or anywhere in between. But the basic idea is to make things better, at least for some sub-group of thus governed subjects.

Russia is operated by straight-up criminals. And I don't mean white-collar corrupt politicians. They are literally people who committed often very violent crimes. For instance, Putin is implicated in a number of "hits" on law enforcement officers, investigators etc. He was not the one executing the "hits", but he was likely directly involved in the crime. A lot of his associates have done often long time behind bars. For example, his puppet assigned to rule over Ukraine (the one who was deposed in the "revolution of dignity" which set in motion the present conflict) started his career as a gang robber: he, with his friends broke into an apartment, tortured the owners while taking their belongings.

These people have a mental model of the world defined by the prison lore. They have a bizarre set of rules which define what honor is: "honor" (the prison kind of) is the central value / virtue in this system. In this model, the world is divided into "suckers" and "men". "Men" are allowed to humiliate the "suckers" in whatever way they want. In fact, if they don't, they might as well join the "suckers". In this system, anyone who shows any kind of compassion to the "suckers" is him/herself a "sucker". Europeans or anyone who wants to live in a society that values any human life thus is automatically a "sucker".

This is why Russians think and treat Europeans with contempt and disdain. They don't think it to be immoral to steal from a European, or to assault one etc.

It's also "honorable" to accept the risks associated with humiliating the "suckers". To prove how much of a "man" someone is that is. It's actually better to die while proving your place is among "men" than to surrender and live like a "sucker". So, they don't care about international consequences of their sabotage in France today. At least not in the sense how another European country might've cared, should they engage in something similar.

Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by Mikhail_K on Friday August 09, 2024 @07:25AM (#41200764)
> For example, his puppet assigned to rule over Ukraine (the one who was deposed in the

> "revolution of dignity" which set in motion the present conflict) started his career as a

Deposed by the maidan's "revolution of dignity" president of the Ukraine Yanukovich had not been "assigned to rule over Ukraine", but elected in competitive voting, that OSCE certified as democratic and "organized in a transparent manner."

You are entitled to your own opinions, but not to your own facts.

Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by Tade0 on Friday July 26, 2024 @09:10AM (#41078328)
I think you have to be Russian to fully grasp the motivations behind this.

I've got a lot of mileage out of the assumption that every such act is supposed to send a message both to Russia's enemies and citizens.

The message being "we are everywhere".

Should anyone try to start working with the enemy, like the helicopter pilot Maxim Kuzminov, they will be found and executed.

EDIT: Navalny's return to Russia raised eyebrows in the west. I think he was aware that he would be targeted anyway, so might as well have it happen on his own terms.

Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by thriftwy on Friday July 26, 2024 @02:20PM (#41080918)
> the helicopter pilot Maxim Kuzmin

Made two of his fellows killed (perhaps killed them directly) to enjoy that Spanish beach via treason. May his soul roast in hell.

Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by cheyp on Friday July 26, 2024 @03:03PM (#41081301)
What's the problem of killing two Russian soldiers who participating in the war?
Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by thriftwy on Friday July 26, 2024 @03:36PM (#41081567)
The obvious problem is that you become a fair target in the war.
Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by imp0cat on Friday July 26, 2024 @03:25PM (#41081476)
What a weird spin. He prevented many more deaths of innocent people.
Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by thriftwy on Friday July 26, 2024 @03:49PM (#41081671)
Your claim is meaningless. It cannot be proved or disproved.

What is known is that domestic law is very harsh to traitors, and for good reason. International law has hard time defending them and in this case it has clearly failed.

If you decide to be a hard line traitor avoid defecting to Ukrainians, instead of putting you to a safe house with fake bio, they will congratulate you as their victory, in process filling the internet with your mug shots to the extent that random people start to recognize you on street. Then you get shot.

Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by koonsolo on Friday July 26, 2024 @03:19PM (#41081431)
Yes, all 3 of them.
Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by neom on Friday July 26, 2024 @09:11AM (#41078339)
I think about this quite a lot. I presume people at that level are at least TRYING to be strategic in some manner. The two thoughts I used to try and frame it are: the cold war never really ended, it just changed, and, begrudging-capitalist subscribing societies have highly intelligent people in them just like capitalist societies. If nation states are indeed competitive, then a relatively decent strategy would be presume automation is going to rapidly allow for an alternative systems in societies, and while that shift is happening, cause as much problem as you can for the folks unable/unwilling/unknowing, while you start shifting behind the scenes. Marx literally articulated deeply, the idea that socialism, and eventually communism, would arise as a natural progression from capitalism. We may or may not want to accept that, but Marx spelled it out, and lots of people follow Marx as their philosophy.

I try hard to avoid getting conspiratorial in my head, so I tend to leave the thought around that point, after all, it's just a thought. :)

Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by Juliate on Friday July 26, 2024 @09:14AM (#41078361)
Sowing chaos is always a good strategy, when you need/want to disguise your action behind or among distractions.

As to be reviled, some don't care, as long as they're feared.

Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by marcosdumay on Friday July 26, 2024 @09:49AM (#41078658)
The goal is to get some fact they can use in propaganda internally to show how the country is great or succeeding against its enemies. And yeah, everybody that complains about them is an enemy.
Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by mrguyorama on Friday July 26, 2024 @05:15PM (#41082339)
Remember that Russian citizens are explicitly told they are "At war with NATO".
Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by beretguy on Friday July 26, 2024 @11:52AM (#41079625)
russia’s ultimate goal is to spread misinformation to destroy democratic countries from within and then invade these countries’ land.

Because they stand no chance fighting fare and square.

Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by beretguy on Monday July 29, 2024 @05:36AM (#41099142)
I see some fascists downvoted this comment. It’s very unfortunate fascism is on the rise again. Even a hundred years since WW2 haven’t passed yet, and here we are again.
Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by racional on Friday July 26, 2024 @12:48PM (#41080094)
I doubt their goal is to be universally reviled, so what's their real objective?

Believe it or not -- their initial goal was simply to gain respect.

They actually thought the Ukraine invasion would be a walkthrough, and that of course Western countries would whine and moan about of a -- but ultimately they would respect Russia for its audacity and boldness, that Russia would emerge with greatly enhanced stature over its historic rivals, and a new era of Russian gravitas and self-assuredness would begin.

So yes - it was all definitely quite strategic, in theory. But things didn't go as they planned of course, so now they're fighting like a cornered animal.

Except now the fight isn't for "respect", and it certainly isn't about Ukraine -- but rather their own physical and political survival.

Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by tim333 on Friday July 26, 2024 @03:29PM (#41081505)
My take is they think they are a great power entitled to rule over their neighbours including the former soviet union and thus are entitled to attack all who oppose that by whatever ways including dumb things like disrupting the olympics and funding anti vaxxer and far right folk and the like. Not that I know that much - I'm kind of confused myself.

Here's Keir Giles, who wrote a related book, talking a bit. https://youtu.be/j8wVuHMAEHg?t=688

Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by jetrink on Friday July 26, 2024 @08:13AM (#41077952)
That reads like an extract from a John le Carré novel.
Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by nindalf on Friday July 26, 2024 @08:18AM (#41077979)
Are any le Carré characters so flagrantly incompetent? Even the ones who like to drink (like Connie Sachs) manage to keep it under control and function reasonably well.
Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by surfingdino on Friday July 26, 2024 @08:40AM (#41078130)
I always had the feeling that Le Carré's portrayal of Eastern European adversaries was too kind. He clearly underestimated the influence of alcohol over private and professional lives in those lands.
Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by rjzzleep on Friday July 26, 2024 @08:15AM (#41077961)
In case someone else is wondering the author of this article is an MI6 agent that has been posing as a "British journalist", and has been cheering on war and has posted so many debunked lies that it's actually disgusting to watch. Can we stop posting junk like that on HN?
Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by tokai on Friday July 26, 2024 @08:17AM (#41077976)
Which of the authors? There are three.
Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by rjzzleep on Friday July 26, 2024 @08:21AM (#41077999)
Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by tokai on Friday July 26, 2024 @08:29AM (#41078057)
Just answer the question.
Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by jojobas on Friday July 26, 2024 @08:04AM (#41077897)
Carrying FSB ID on assignment abroad?

It has to be a decoy of sorts right?

Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by surfingdino on Friday July 26, 2024 @08:08AM (#41077922)
Nope, they operate more or less in plain sight and don't care. They know that they worst thing that can happen to them in the west is expulsion or a jail sentence.
Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by dralley on Friday July 26, 2024 @08:14AM (#41077959)
Jan Marsalek reportedly bragged multiple times to business associates about his connections to Russian intelligence services
Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by BoingBoomTschak on Friday July 26, 2024 @09:43AM (#41078603)
Anyone capable of critical thinking would suspect false flag attack with this ostentatious lack of forethought.

But well, as we all know, false flag attacks is something only The Enemy does.

Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by surfingdino on Friday July 26, 2024 @09:54AM (#41078691)
It's a pattern. Russian and Belarusian agents attacked rail infrastructure across Europe on several occasions over the last year or so. Not a false flag, but yet another terrorist attack against the European rail transportation infrastructure.
Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by finikytou on Friday July 26, 2024 @08:08AM (#41077925)
yeah sounds about true. french newspaper also said hamas was russian yesterday. I guess I got a power outage yesterday too. must be putin.
Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by simion314 on Friday July 26, 2024 @08:27AM (#41078046)
Until RT or Putin confirms it was Ruzzia then you won't believe it.

For other real skeptics, there were 100% clear Ruzzian attacks in France before, there were people that drawn Swasticas, some people that put some coffins , soem Chechen guy with a grenade/bomb. We do not have video or written proof that Putin signed the orders so we need to use our brains and ignore the bots and trolls that defend terrorists.

Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by surfingdino on Friday July 26, 2024 @08:33AM (#41078083)
There has been at least one dangerous fire in a factory or a warehouse per week in Europe for over a year now. Most suspects caught are Russian agents, Russians or people paid by Russia or Belarus.
Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by mardifoufs on Saturday July 27, 2024 @12:06AM (#41084382)
Do you have a source on that?
Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by lesuorac on Friday July 26, 2024 @10:24AM (#41078895)
I mean they probably won't read it anyways. Usually with comments like "french newspapers said hamas is russian" end up being strictly factually false.

Perhaps a french newspaper said hamas received russian funding or weapons or some other nuance that they completely glossed over. Perhaps it wasn't even a french newspaper or one not well regarded for accuracy (look at what the Onion prints in the US!). Or possibly it's even worse and the article is just posting a quote of somebody who said "hamas is russian" and so it's not even the french newspaper saying it.

This blindness is also commonly seen in the US. i.e. people saying polls had trump at a 0% chance to win the election despite literally a week before the election even CNN had articles saying it's a tight race -- https://www.cnn.com/2016/11/01/politics/presidential-poll-do...

Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by finikytou on Wednesday July 31, 2024 @12:29PM (#41120652)
https://www.lefigaro.fr/international/des-rivieres-de-sang-v... here you go about hamas.

and then here you go about left wing being behind the train attack: https://www.wsj.com/world/europe/france-sees-hand-of-far-lef...

this is the problem when having a political bias. you stop being factual. it was not the russian you were wrong and you wont even acknowledge it. before the russian it was the arabs for decades and before that it was the serbs. we know how the hive mind operates.

Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by lesuorac on Monday August 05, 2024 @07:53AM (#41160389)
lefigaro is behind a paywall so not much to read there. Judging from the articles title it sounds _at best_ like the article will claim that "Russia created a photo of a Palestinian soldier" and not that "Russia is Hamas".

> here you go about left wing being behind the train attack

> France’s top cop said Monday he suspects far-left saboteurs [1] [2]

The article you're using as support doesn't support the claim you're making; the guy _suspects_ the far left but going around posted about it as settled matter is inaccurate. We got tons of people on this forum that _suspect_ Russia should I go make a post saying Russia did it and link to them as proof?

[1]: https://archive.ph/TcBBx

[2]: https://www.wsj.com/world/europe/france-sees-hand-of-far-lef...

Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by finikytou on Wednesday July 31, 2024 @12:24PM (#41120600)
coming back to this https://www.ft.com/content/9efa3343-e97e-40ed-b7d7-e2b6a6a58...

it was indeed the russian far left from france. you were right I apologize. putin owns even our left wing I wonder how France is even still a nation

Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by finikytou on Wednesday July 31, 2024 @12:26PM (#41120619)
got downvoted to -4 while it was revealed that french far left was behind the attack.https://www.wsj.com/world/europe/france-sees-hand-of-far-lef...

nice to see the political wokeness affecting hnews.

Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by anonym29 on Friday July 26, 2024 @08:37AM (#41078113)
When your culture's drinking problem is so bad that it starts causing information leaks that disrupt clandestine overseas sabotage operations, maybe that's the clue it's time to get a better grip on the culture of alcohol consumption.

I've read that it's not quite as simple or easy as banning vodka or alcohol, as strangely enough, the highest individual source of Russian tax revenue is from excise taxes on the vodka, and revenue from the excise taxes on beer make up 75% as much as the excise taxes on vodka.

Further reading: https://warontherocks.com/2015/07/little-water-vodka-and-the...

Re:French rail network hit by 'malicious acts' ahead of Pari... by nradov on Friday July 26, 2024 @05:32PM (#41082487)
They tried an anti-alcohol campaign. It failed.

https://soviethistory.msu.edu/1985-2/anti-alcohol-campaign/