News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The CAP theorem Is Irrelevant for Cloud Systems by kstrauser on Thursday July 25, 2024 @02:31PM (#41071815)
That presumes you can only have 1 partition at a time. That is not the case. You can optimize for good behavior when you end up with 2 disconnected graphs. It’s absolutely the case that a graph with N nodes can end up with N separate groups. Conceptually, imagine a single switch that connects all of them together and that switch dies.

You can engineer cloud services to be resilient. AWS has done a great job of that in my personal experience. But worst cases can still happen.

If you have an algorithm that runs in n*log(n) most of the time but 2^n sometimes, it can still be super useful. You have to prepare for the bad case though. If you say it’s been running great so far and we don’t worry about it, fine, but that doesn’t mean it can’t still blow up when it’s most inconvenient. It only means it hasn’t yet.

Re:The CAP theorem Is Irrelevant for Cloud Systems by cryptonector on Thursday July 25, 2024 @02:33PM (#41071845)
Again, a partition that leaves you with no quorum anywhere is like the cloud being down.
Re:The CAP theorem Is Irrelevant for Cloud Systems by pessimizer on Thursday July 25, 2024 @03:26PM (#41072402)
A partition that leaves you with no quorum anywhere is like the cloud being down if you value consistency over availability.
Re:The CAP theorem Is Irrelevant for Cloud Systems by cryptonector on Thursday July 25, 2024 @03:45PM (#41072587)
Yes, but again, TFA says that you will trust the cloud will be up long enough that you would indeed prefer consistency.

My goodness. So many commenters here today are completely ignoring TFA and giving lessons on CAP -- lessons that are correct, but which completely ignore that TFA is really arguing that clouds move the needle hard in one direction when considering the CAP trade-offs, to the point that "the CAP theorem is irrelevant for cloud systems" (which was this post's original title, though not TFA's).

Re:The CAP theorem Is Irrelevant for Cloud Systems by pyrale on Friday July 26, 2024 @04:12AM (#41076763)
The issue people are pointing is that the author conflates "Cloud is good enough for my needs" with "CAP is no longer relevant".The point is especially annoying considering that the author works at a cloud vendor and not a cloud user.
Re:The CAP theorem Is Irrelevant for Cloud Systems by robertlagrant on Thursday July 25, 2024 @05:29PM (#41073618)
> Again, a partition that leaves you with no quorum anywhere is like the cloud being down.

What does this mean? What is the cloud being down? The cloud isn't a single thing; it's lots of computers in lots of data centres.

Re:The CAP theorem Is Irrelevant for Cloud Systems by NavinF on Thursday July 25, 2024 @06:00PM (#41073831)
It means there will be an article on the front page declaring the outage
Re:The CAP theorem Is Irrelevant for Cloud Systems by Spivak on Thursday July 25, 2024 @08:41PM (#41074937)
Huh? You can create partitions in ways other than issues with the underlying network. You can mess up firewall rules for example and find yourself with no quorum.