You know that every time you use the card, American Express charges a fee?
All the perks and cashbacks etc come more or less out of that fee.
Of course, that fee doesn't show up directly on your bill. But you still pay ultimately it. (Just like you as an individual bear most of the brunt of a VAT, even if officially the shop hands the money to the government.)
Until that happens card users will not care
There’s an analogous situation with tariffs - it seems the manufacturer pays the cost of the tariffs since it is coming out of their bank accounts. But it’s actually consumers paying the tariffs.
The problem is the govt wants to get rid of cash all together so I guess this will never happen
Unless I’m charged a lower cash price vs a higher credit card price, no, I’m not really ultimately paying it. You may be correct at a macro level but I’m looking at it from a practical standpoint.
When a merchant does charge a lower cash price, I make a real time judgement call to pay in cash or use card.
It's typically the more expensive merchants with higher margins who accept American Express.
So you are right that staying with the same merchant, you seldom get an explicit discount for not using American Express. The non-AmEx discount is more hidden, in the form of being able to shop at not-so-overpriced merchants.
The protection that Amex has given me, when it comes to chargebacks for purchases that didn't work out has easily justified the annual fee.
And that's before any perks like miles or cashback or anything else.