Alternatively, maybe practically everyone uses credit cards, so the "subsidy" is negligible, and everyone loses slightly on average. But then you'd lose even more if you didn't use a credit card and subsidised everyone else.
It's basically a big version of the Prisoner's Dilemma.
I mostly don't shop at places that accept American Express, exactly because their prices are higher to pay for this cross-subsidy. Thus I don't pay for this cross subsidy.
I see a few explicit discounts (or surcharges) for different payment methods here and there, but mostly the system works by segregation: the cheaper suppliers with lower margins don't tend to accept the more expensive payment providers.
So, to be clear for anyone else with the same problem I had:
Merchants in all US states can legally give cash discounts.
In Connecticut and Massachusetts, it's illegal to add a surcharge for credit purchases.
The protection that Amex has given me, when it comes to chargebacks for purchases that didn't work out has easily justified the annual fee.
And that's before any perks like miles or cashback or anything else.
You know that every time you use the card, American Express charges a fee?
All the perks and cashbacks etc come more or less out of that fee.
Of course, that fee doesn't show up directly on your bill. But you still pay ultimately it. (Just like you as an individual bear most of the brunt of a VAT, even if officially the shop hands the money to the government.)
Until that happens card users will not care
There’s an analogous situation with tariffs - it seems the manufacturer pays the cost of the tariffs since it is coming out of their bank accounts. But it’s actually consumers paying the tariffs.
The problem is the govt wants to get rid of cash all together so I guess this will never happen
Unless I’m charged a lower cash price vs a higher credit card price, no, I’m not really ultimately paying it. You may be correct at a macro level but I’m looking at it from a practical standpoint.
When a merchant does charge a lower cash price, I make a real time judgement call to pay in cash or use card.
It's typically the more expensive merchants with higher margins who accept American Express.
So you are right that staying with the same merchant, you seldom get an explicit discount for not using American Express. The non-AmEx discount is more hidden, in the form of being able to shop at not-so-overpriced merchants.
Ya, what’s up with that? It is totally true, but I’ve never been able to figure out why it’s true like that, given its huge unfairness. Is it just punishing people who get laid off from their job and have to go on Cobra? Likewise, are independent contractors just SOL?
These high income taxes were politically popular, but companies still wanted to compete for workers. So they found all kinds of loopholes for extra benefits they could give employees at a lower tax rate (or at no taxes at all). Sometimes they even lobbied for those loopholes, too.
See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Health_insurance_in_the_United... for a brief overview, and perhaps follow references from there.
Employers were not allowed _by law_ to pay their employees competitive wages, so they offered benefits which weren't restricted.
Even after the war, this was still a benefit to employers: the cost of benefits paid by the employers could be deducted from their taxes, but employees didn't have to pay taxes on it (unlike wages), so it was more efficient; also, changing jobs meant changing health insurance plans, which complicated job switching for employees.
(BTW, the supposed "high tax rates" were paid by almost no one, in part because they only applied to the highest tax brackets but also because of numerous tax deductions.)
Of course, both what you said and what I said still doesn't explain why benefits weren't taxed (or at least not as heavily).
Btw, I remember growing up in the 1990s in Germany that having a company car used to be a big deal as a perk. I don't hear about that as much anymore, I suspect it's because the relative tax attractiveness of benefits vs straight up cash changed over time; I remember some loopholes being tightened (if not closed).
Normally for insurance the suggestion is that you should 'self-insure' smaller risks, and only purchase third-party insurance for catastrophic risks. The theory being that insurance has extra overheads and on average has to cost you more money than you get out. But that for catastrophic risks, you can't rely on averages.
(Of course, that only applies in the absence of tax or regulatory arbitrage. Eg I hear in the US your employer can buy health insurance from pre-tax money, but you'd have to use post-tax money for paying out-of-pocket.)
Similar for a company like AmEx you have to weigh whether the occasional wins you describe are worth the constant drain. Or whether you should just put the winnings in a piggy bank, and use a small part of that to finance the replacement for the never-arriving fancy new sofa.