News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Alphabet Second Quarter 2024 Results by fragmede on Tuesday July 23, 2024 @05:09PM (#41050902)
> All without spending a single dollar on content creation.

YouTube paid out $70 billion to "creators, artists, and media companies" over the past three years.

https://blog.youtube/inside-youtube/2024-letter-from-neal/

Re:Alphabet Second Quarter 2024 Results by Workaccount2 on Tuesday July 23, 2024 @05:18PM (#41051014)
I don't think people are aware that the majority of a yt premium subscription goes to creators. Premium views also pay more than ad views to creators.

Not that I want to shill yt premium, but youtube overall would be dramatically better if google was beholden to users rather than advertisers.

Re:Alphabet Second Quarter 2024 Results by doe_eyes on Tuesday July 23, 2024 @05:37PM (#41051214)
> I don't think people are aware that the majority of a yt premium subscription goes to creators

Huh? Maybe Google can claim this through some very creative accounting, but the bottom line is that Google retains the vast majority of YouTube revenue; and that the vast majority of content creators on YouTube are not getting paid at all, because the requirements for monetization are pretty steep.

That last part is deliberate, by the way: it allows them to keep a larger slice of the pie while running ads on all videos and showering a small sliver of celebrity content creators with piles cash. For me as a content consumer, YouTube is fantastic. For the average content creator, it's a miserable experience largely built on a lie.

Re:Alphabet Second Quarter 2024 Results by Workaccount2 on Tuesday July 23, 2024 @05:50PM (#41051329)
I'm not a partner, so I don't have an original copy, but the 55% figure is regularly stated by creators online.

https://imgur.com/YjOHAAr

A verge article states this too: https://www.theverge.com/2024/3/28/24114031/youtube-shorts-p...

(shorts pay 45%, longform 55%)

Re:Alphabet Second Quarter 2024 Results by creato on Tuesday July 23, 2024 @05:49PM (#41051321)
In this thread, the numbers cited (I didn't verify) are: - $50B/year revenue - $70B/3 years in payments to creators

Youtube paying out ~50% of revenue to creators seems almost too good to be true to me. That isn't their only cost, the infrastructure of youtube must be insanely expensive. They're almost certainly taking far less in profit than they are paying to creators.

edit: I read the numbers in the thread wrong, $15B/year in subscriptions not $15B/quarter.

Re:Alphabet Second Quarter 2024 Results by samspenc on Tuesday July 23, 2024 @07:48PM (#41052254)
Ah that seems more reasonable, with $8.7B a quarter in advertising revenue, that's about $35B a year, so for Youtube annually:

  - $35B in ad revenue
  - $15B in subscriptions
  - (minus) $23B paid out to creators ($70B / 3 years)
Which seems to line up with around 50% paid out to creators ($23-24B out of $50B revenue).

I don't know how many employees work on Youtube specifically, but even with salaries and infra / CapEx / OpEx costs, they are probably making a decent profit on the remaining $25B they keep annually after payouts.

Re:Alphabet Second Quarter 2024 Results by paxys on Tuesday July 23, 2024 @05:39PM (#41051233)
> but the bottom line is that Google retains the vast majority of YouTube revenue

Do you have a source for that "bottom line"?

Re:Alphabet Second Quarter 2024 Results by mrkramer on Tuesday July 23, 2024 @06:04PM (#41051452)
The most scammy and evil move from them was monetization of content from non-partenered channels[0].

[0] https://www.cnbc.com/2020/11/19/youtube-will-put-ads-on-non-...

Re:Alphabet Second Quarter 2024 Results by sourcecodeplz on Tuesday July 23, 2024 @06:23PM (#41051614)
I don't get it. They host the videos for you, why shouldn't they recoup their hosting/traffic costs somehow?

Scammy? Evil? Damn...

Re:Alphabet Second Quarter 2024 Results by mrkramer on Tuesday July 23, 2024 @06:33PM (#41051690)
I didn't agree to have ads from X or Y company roll before my video/s. If they don't want freeloaders then make it subscribe only service. They leech data from us freeloaders why wouldn't we leech hosting resources from them?
Re:Alphabet Second Quarter 2024 Results by geodel on Tuesday July 23, 2024 @06:51PM (#41051840)
> I didn't agree to have ads from X or Y company roll before my video/s

Maybe read terms and condition before loading videos on youtube?

Re:Alphabet Second Quarter 2024 Results by mrkramer on Wednesday July 24, 2024 @07:36AM (#41055867)
Guess what? They change their TOS constantly meaning; I agreed to the initial TOS but I didn't agree to the subsequent ones. You can argue, "Yes you did, you clicked that agree button and you kept using it". Yes I did but only because they have the biggest video community on the internet, which means the biggest content offering and the biggest reach. If there was decent competitor, I would move immediately.
Re:Alphabet Second Quarter 2024 Results by Workaccount2 on Wednesday July 24, 2024 @09:19AM (#41056803)
Spoiler: A competitor would be just as shitty to you. No one wants to cater to people who think showing ads to support the costs is "evil and scammy".

Actually, vid.me did want to cater to people to you. And guess what happened? They went bankrupt once their VC cash was all burned up.

Re:Alphabet Second Quarter 2024 Results by mrkramer on Wednesday July 24, 2024 @11:40AM (#41058168)
Read my op; I said showing ads on non-partnered channels is evil and scammy not ads overall. As a matter of fact I watch ads on my YouTube mobile native Android app.

All I want to say is; if I a have small channel and if I am a small/hobbyist content creator, please don't show ads on my content because I didn't explicitly agree to it.

Re:Alphabet Second Quarter 2024 Results by Workaccount2 on Wednesday July 24, 2024 @12:05PM (#41058448)
Well you can go ahead an make a video host that provides free bandwidth and service to people who "don't explicitly agree to show ads".

It will be extremely popular, and you will become very...broke.

Re:Alphabet Second Quarter 2024 Results by paxys on Tuesday July 23, 2024 @05:22PM (#41051043)
That's the creators' share of ad revenue, and Google pays it out only after it has earned the money. If the video doesn't get views, the creators get nothing. It's the same as Google putting ads on your website. You get a share of the revenue, but that doesn't mean Google paid for the site.
Re:Alphabet Second Quarter 2024 Results by dagmx on Tuesday July 23, 2024 @05:28PM (#41051117)
The point still stands that YouTube does pay for content, it just does so in a semi unique way.

I say semi unique because revenue share is common in traditional content creation as well. So it’s not like YouTube is completely alone here , though it is rare for someone to go purely revenue share.

That said, YouTube has funded content creation directly as well in the past https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/YouTube_Original_Channel_Initi...

Re:Alphabet Second Quarter 2024 Results by paxys on Tuesday July 23, 2024 @08:23PM (#41052455)
I disagree. Paying for content, whether directly or indirectly, and being a platform that connects users/advertisers with content owners and takes a cut of all transactions are two very different business models. YouTube is very clearly the latter.
Re:Alphabet Second Quarter 2024 Results by nemothekid on Tuesday July 23, 2024 @05:30PM (#41051143)
I think it's more accruate to say that Google has done all of this without investing in content